Did Jesus Really Son of God/God or The Prophet

  • Thread starter Thread starter tomshaikh
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I now believe that the “cross” that Jesus (pbuh) meant in this verse probably looked like the following ancient crossbow:
doesnt this prove muslim malice? a christian mentions the cross and they think christians are pointing crossbows at them. and such misinterpretations give them the excuse to yell out their favorite jihadic slogan: ALLAH AKHBAR! 😛
 
from the gospel written by St.John9:35-38…Jesus had heard they turned him out,and when He had found him,said to him"Dost thou believe in the Son of God?"he answered and said"who is he Lord that i may believe in him?“and Jesus said to him"thou hast both seen Him,and He it is who speaks with thee” and he said “i believe Lord”.and falling down he whorshipped Him.this quote comes as part of the section where Jesus healed a man who was born blind, by making mud and placing it on the blind man’s eyes.if Jesus were merely a prophet He would not have allowed this man to whorship Him,if he was only a man of God then Jesus would have been allowing the xblind man to commit the sin of idoldtry by letting him (blind man)worship Him.
I am your God you shall have no other God’s before me.
 
I have devoted a whole thread to the subject of Prophet Jesus (pbuh) calling his followers to ‘Jihad’.
And you have been soundly refuted by Rebecca’s first post there:

You have your interpretation of the Matthew 10:34 quote backwards. If you read all in that chapter before it, you will see that Jesus is telling the disciples that because of what they will teach, the sword will be turned against those who believe them.
 
You only believe this baloney because your parents indoctrinated you by baptism when you were 4 months old. You were brain cleansed by your parents into only believing this ****, Growing up thats all you knew. Kind of narrow minded ignorance. Bill Maher and George Carlin are right. Check them out on youtube.
Your public profile claims you are Catholic; perhaps you should update your profile. George Carlin and Bill Maher are entertaining, but hardly more than that. They are clever without actually being deep. Somehow, I doubt that either of them will ever be listed with Sartre, Russell and Camus as being effective critics of the concept of religious faith.


Bill
 
Lets see, John 1 claims that the Word was both with God and was God. Later it is made clear that Jesus is the Word. So that would show that Jesus is God.

Also, Matthew 16, when Jesus asks the Apostles who do they think he is and Peter answers, “You are the Christ, the son of the living God”. Far from rebuking him, Jesus praises him and tells him that his Father in heaven (implicitly God the Father) revealed this information to him.

There are other places in the New Testament where Jesus is specifically equated with God or is stated to be God’s son. How much scriptural evidence do you really need?


Bill
Bill, lets not forget it also says in the bible that jews are the chosen people, not catholics as you seem to arrogantly believe. Jesus lived his whole life a Jew. Spent his saturdays in the synagogue. Bill why not visit a synagogue and experience what Jesus did throughout his life as a practicing Jew? It also says in the bible its ok to own a slave but after 6 years he must be let go. If he has a wife and children they become property of the slave owner. Do you believe that? Its in the bible. You can’t pick and choose bill, if its in the bible it must be true right? Just as I thought.

Where does it say in the bible that mary died a virgin and went to heaven?. More BS from the catholic church. It was only 2 popes back that the vatican taught and believed the sun rotated around the earth. Unbelievable. Unbelievable.

Please no more quotes from the bible. its a fairytale book with fables and kiddies stories that we were taught in grade 3.

John a lapsed catholic like most are today and growing in numbers
 
Bill, lets not forget it also says in the bible that jews are the chosen people, not catholics as you seem to arrogantly believe. Jesus lived his whole life a Jew. Spent his saturdays in the synagogue. Bill why not visit a synagogue and experience what Jesus did throughout his life as a practicing Jew? It also says in the bible its ok to own a slave but after 6 years he must be let go. If he has a wife and children they become property of the slave owner. Do you believe that? Its in the bible. You can’t pick and choose bill, if its in the bible it must be true right? Just as I thought.
Well, lets take this a point at a time.
  1. Jew as the chosen people. I never denied that the Jews were the Chosen people, and remain the chosen people. However, It is clear in the New Testament, that Christians are not bound to Jewish Law; though it was never lifted from the Jews. Christians, not being Jews were never bound by that law.
  2. I have been to Synagogue thank you very much. However, I think you will find if you do your research that modern Jewish practice diverges considerably from the practice of Jews before the destruction of the temple.
  3. The law on slaves, and other laws (for example divorce) were written into the law to appease the stubbornness of the Israelites. The law as written was probably a moderation of existing practice. Ultimately, we have come to understand that if we focus on the true root of the law (love of God and love of neighbor), that slavery is not compatible with our beliefs.
Where does it say in the bible that mary died a virgin and went to heaven?. More BS from the catholic church. It was only 2 popes back that the vatican taught and believed the sun rotated around the earth. Unbelievable. Unbelievable.
You are right, it is unbelievable because it is not true! The conviction of Galileo was rescinded relatively recently, but the bans on the belief in heliocentrism ended in 1757, and books supporting this model of the Solar System were specifically allowed in 1822.

It is also Unbelievable to believe your claims because of the significant role that Catholic Clergy has played in the science in the last 2 centuries. Both Genetics and Cosmology look to Catholic Clergy as significant figures.
Please no more quotes from the bible. its a fairytale book with fables and kiddies stories that we were taught in grade 3.
John a lapsed catholic like most are today and growing in numbers
If you do not wish to read quotations from the Bible, or other religious works, I suggest you probably should not participate in a forum dedicated to religious discussion.


Bill
 
Your public profile claims you are Catholic; perhaps you should update your profile. George Carlin and Bill Maher are entertaining, but hardly more than that. They are clever without actually being deep. Somehow, I doubt that either of them will ever be listed with Sartre, Russell and Camus as being effective critics of the concept of religious faith.


Bill
Bill I can’t change my profile as being listed a catholic. The church teaches once your parents have you baptized you are a catholic forever like it or not. You can call me lapsed. Thats what your parents wanted you to be and thats all you were allowed to learn growing up. The church teaches ignorance of others…its sad.

I can’t believe the churchgoers here are not writing their bishops about the thousands of priests that have committed grave sins by having sex with our children. [Moderator removed indecent comments.] Shame on the catholic church and the ones who belong and afraid to show their disgust. Catholics like to criticize others but when it comes to the church and its sinful deeds fear over takes common sense and reality. The church instills fear among the believers. UNBELIEVABLE!
 
Bill I can’t change my profile as being listed a catholic. The church teaches once your parents have you baptized you are a catholic forever like it or not. You can call me lapsed. Thats what your parents wanted you to be and thats all you were allowed to learn growing up. The church teaches ignorance of others…its sad.
I don’t quite recall ever being told I was not allowed to switch religions. Certainly there are members of this forum who are Orthodox, Muslim and Jewish who started as Catholics and now no longer consider themselves so.
I can’t believe the churchgoers here are not writing their bishops about the thousands of priests that have committed grave sins by having sex with our children. [Moderator removed indecent comments.] Shame on the catholic church and the ones who belong and afraid to show their disgust. Catholics like to criticize others but when it comes to the church and its sinful deeds fear over takes common sense and reality. The church instills fear among the believers. UNBELIEVABLE!
With respect, this is completely off topic, and out of line. Yes, there are those who have completely abused the position of priest in a thousand different ways (sexual immorality being only one way). I doubt you will find anyone here who is anything but disgusted with such betrayals of faith. That being said, the Church has never taught that any man is capable of perfection in this life. Further, what outrages me is the fact that the Church is the only group being singled out for such attention when like numbers of ministers in other faith traditions, teachers in schools, doctors, coaches, etc. are all abusing children in this way.

I don’t excuse the Church for the sins of its members, but then again, I will not hold them to a level of perfection that no human can obtain. Sin is sin; some sins harm their victims more, but it doesn’t change the fact that all sin is to be opposed.


Bill
 
Well, lets take this a point at a time.
  1. Jew as the chosen people. I never denied that the Jews were the Chosen people, and remain the chosen people. However, It is clear in the New Testament, that Christians are not bound to Jewish Law; though it was never lifted from the Jews. Christians, not being Jews were never bound by that law.
  2. I have been to Synagogue thank you very much. However, I think you will find if you do your research that modern Jewish practice diverges considerably from the practice of Jews before the destruction of the temple.
  3. The law on slaves, and other laws (for example divorce) were written into the law to appease the stubbornness of the Israelites. The law as written was probably a moderation of existing practice. Ultimately, we have come to understand that if we focus on the true root of the law (love of God and love of neighbor), that slavery is not compatible with our beliefs.
You are right, it is unbelievable because it is not true! The conviction of Galileo was rescinded relatively recently, but the bans on the belief in heliocentrism ended in 1757, and books supporting this model of the Solar System were specifically allowed in 1822.

It is also Unbelievable to believe your claims because of the significant role that Catholic Clergy has played in the science in the last 2 centuries. Both Genetics and Cosmology look to Catholic Clergy as significant figures.

If you do not wish to read quotations from the Bible, or other religious works, I suggest you probably should not participate in a forum dedicated to religious discussion.


Bill
Bill are you a catholic by choice or were you indoctrinated into the faith because of family tradition like most catholics?
 
I don’t quite recall ever being told I was not allowed to switch religions. Certainly there are members of this forum who are Orthodox, Muslim and Jewish who started as Catholics and now no longer consider themselves so.

With respect, this is completely off topic, and out of line. Yes, there are those who have completely abused the position of priest in a thousand different ways (sexual immorality being only one way). I doubt you will find anyone here who is anything but disgusted with such betrayals of faith. That being said, the Church has never taught that any man is capable of perfection in this life. Further, what outrages me is the fact that the Church is the only group being singled out for such attention when like numbers of ministers in other faith traditions, teachers in schools, doctors, coaches, etc. are all abusing children in this way.

I don’t excuse the Church for the sins of its members, but then again, I will not hold them to a level of perfection that no human can obtain. Sin is sin; some sins harm their victims more, but it doesn’t change the fact that all sin is to be opposed.


Bill
Code:
Bill, (off topic) yes there are others in other faiths who have molested children.  When you look at current numbers where protestants out number catholics in the USA   2 to 1   latest statistics show that the catholic church (insurance and other assets have paid out over $2 billion dollars in settlements and thousands of priests have been charged since 1950 with these crimes and the numbers are still growing.   Lets not forget the bishops/cardinals that LIED and covered up these crimes, and they are crimes/felonies  and the thousands of so called good priests who were aware of other priests molesting and did nothing to save their own behind and cushy job.   Disgusting!   When you mention other groups and other faiths you are shifting  the blame/issue away from the catholic church and not accepting what the hell is going on in the catholic church.   If you google priest molests you will see this is a world wide epidemic.  Don't give me this baloney  that we are only human and we make mistakes. Having sex with a minor is not a mistake.  Its a felony.  Stealing a chocolate bar from a store  is a mistake.  I grew up in the church in the 1950s/60s  and no one then or up until these brave boys came forward would ever believe a priest could EVER commit such  heinous crimes.   Google priest steals,  Google priest grows marijuana and you will see many  they are not the squeaky clean group that catholics want them to be.   Its time for  serious accountability in the church.
Lets not forget. The only reason this issue is being dealt with is because the church got caught and had no choice but to come forward when these crimes started rolling in. Crimes that have been probably been going on for centuries.

Question? If you knew first hand that a priest was molesting a child would you go to the police? Would you notify his bishop?
 
I now believe that the “cross” that Jesus (pbuh) meant in this verse probably looked like the following ancient crossbow:

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2247/1811580719_ede07e74fe.jpg
Shame on you for bringing up this nonsense topic again.
However, if there is evidence which points to the disciples started to carry crucifixes after the alleged crucifixion of Jesus (pbuh), then I would be interested to see this evidence.
And shame on you for suggesting that the disciples weren’t crucified for their faith.
 
Hello Everyone Again, I guess no body has the answer or verses from bible explaining who is he really was. I have verses from The Last Book i.e, The Quran Kareem which is as follows:

An-Nisa

And because of their saying (in boast), “We killed Messiah 'Īsā (Jesus), son of Maryam (Mary), the Messenger of Allâh,” - but they killed him not, nor crucified him, but the resemblance of 'Īsā (Jesus) was put over another man (and they killed that man), and those who differ therein are full of doubts. They have no (certain) knowledge, they follow nothing but conjecture. For surely; they killed him not *: (157) But Allâh raised him 'Īsā (Jesus)] up (with his body and soul) unto Himself (and he A.S. is in the heavens). And Allâh is Ever All-Powerful, All-Wise. (158)

The Quran: Surah 4, Ayat 157-158 or Chapter 4, Verses 157-158

By this Ayat its mentioning Isa(Jesus) as Messenger or Prophet. Hope i prove by this who Jesus was.*

Any comments feel free to answer back.
emphasis mine]
You only proved that you have read the Qur’an. But you haven’t proved that the Qur’an is truth. The Qur’an has no match to fulfilled prophecy.

I’m convinced that Jesus did die on Friday 3rd April, 33 AD.
 
How does any of that answer my question?
" So are you saying God “created” a greater evil (Muslims) to fix an evil(Christians)? If that were so why wouldn’t he just turn the earth over to the direct control of Satan and cut out the middle man (Mohamed)?
Well I said Ishmael still had to have his promise of a great nation of God fulfilled with Islam, as Isaac has his. But Satan has taken control of both Christianity and Islam quite a bit anyway.
 
Bill are you a catholic by choice or were you indoctrinated into the faith because of family tradition like most catholics?
I am a Catholic both by birth and by choice. I was raised in the faith, but I would hold that there is a huge difference between being raised in one’s faith and being indoctrinated. Indoctrination suggests you ultimately don’t critically examine the faith. I have critically examined my faith at many times in my life.


Bill
 
Bill, (off topic) yes there are others in other faiths who have molested children. When you look at current numbers where protestants out number catholics in the USA 2 to 1 latest statistics show that the catholic church (insurance and other assets have paid out over $2 billion dollars in settlements and thousands of priests have been charged since 1950 with these crimes and the numbers are still growing. Lets not forget the bishops/cardinals that LIED and covered up these crimes, and they are crimes/felonies and the thousands of so called good priests who were aware of other priests molesting and did nothing to save their own behind and cushy job. Disgusting! When you mention other groups and other faiths you are shifting the blame/issue away from the catholic church and not accepting what the hell is going on in the catholic church. If you google priest molests you will see this is a world wide epidemic. Don’t give me this baloney that we are only human and we make mistakes. Having sex with a minor is not a mistake. Its a felony. Stealing a chocolate bar from a store is a mistake. I grew up in the church in the 1950s/60s and no one then or up until these brave boys came forward would ever believe a priest could EVER commit such heinous crimes. Google priest steals, Google priest grows marijuana and you will see many they are not the squeaky clean group that catholics want them to be. Its time for serious accountability in the church.

Lets not forget. The only reason this issue is being dealt with is because the church got caught and had no choice but to come forward when these crimes started rolling in. Crimes that have been probably been going on for centuries.

Question? If you knew first hand that a priest was molesting a child would you go to the police? Would you notify his bishop?
Sigh… I will answer your question first. Yes and yes, I would report the priest both to the police and to his bishop.

Now, I am not denying that the leaders of the Church made a mistake, but I think we need to be very careful in over reaching into areas where we have no knowledge (i.e. where we start claiming to know the motives behind their actions).

In any case, all of the evidence I have seen suggests that the rate of abuse by Catholic Clergy is approximately the same as those in non Catholic Clergy, or amongst teachers. Much of the attention that the Church has received is primarily built around the fact that the Church has a celebate Clergy.

BTW, if you want to claim stealing a chocolate bar is simply a mistake and having sex is not, keep in mind that more than a few stores have gone under because of losses due to shop lifting.


Bill
 
emphasis mine]
You only proved that you have read the Qur’an. But you haven’t proved that the Qur’an is truth. The Qur’an has no match to fulfilled prophecy.

I’m convinced that Jesus did die on Friday 3rd April, 33 AD.
Hi There,

I didn’t read The Quran whole by translation in my primary language. But i finished 2 times in my whole life by reading it in Arabic thou i donot know Arabic language.But i know one verses which i donot want to quote wrong coz i donot know where to find the verses in The Quran. But it says in The Quran somewhere about the development of a baby child in her mother womb.Which is now proved in todays life science. No one know how child was developed in 1400 years ago coz they donot have the required equipment.And many other verses which proved about in science today.I have to read with my primary language and English translation.It is very good to know about it.And Prophet Muhammad PBUH told in his hadith about the future thing happened till 1500,After that he didn’t tell. Allah knows why?. Right now its islamic calendar 1429 which is 2008.Allah help me to read my Holy Quran.So i will get more and more knowledge out of it.I am not the punctuale Muslim,i didn’t pray five time even though i didn’t go on my friday prayers now thou i did before i came to USA.May Allah help me to become a practical muslim.Coz first question for us to be asked in grave is about Prayer(Naamaz). And life in this world is about maximum 100 or 150 now-a-days but not more than that we have to written to Allah so why don’t we spend our whole time in remembalance and prayer of Allah which he told us to do in this life and he do not need our prayers its for our own sake…Coz everything living thing is in his preaching mode wheather its angel, spark our others birds.Where angle is praying for him 24 hours i donot know heaven time but they are praying all around time.And remember there is stages in heaven like now a days some people lives in apartment some people live in house and some people live in mansion like this we have stages for every humanbeing who is faithfull to him.May Allah guide me to the right path.Ameen
 
Quote:
Islam and Christianity have the same God, so we are brothers. We just see him differently.

Hi There,

The difference between Islam and Christianity is Jesus PBUH exsistance.Wheather he is The Prophet or Son Of God.I am tired of proving you guyz and know i am fade up.This is my last post about this title.I have did my correction infront of Allah/God.May Allah/God shows us the right path.End with Quran Surah/Chapter

Al-Ikhlas
In the name of Allah, the Beneficent, the Merciful

Say (O Muhammad (SAW)): "He is Allâh, (the) One.] (1) "Allâh-us-Samad (السيد الذي يصمد إليه في الحاجات) [Allâh the Self-Sufficient Master, Whom all creatures need, (He neither eats nor drinks)]. (2) "He begets not, nor was He begotten;] (3) “And there is none co-equal or comparable unto Him.” (4)

Quran:Surah 112, Ayat 1-4 or Chapter 112, Verses 1-4
Peace be with you!
 
You have just thrown a great deal of ancient scholarship into the garbage by twisting the cross into a weapon. No, I don’t think you would be interested in the Roman method of crucifixion or in the meaning of the word “metaphor”.

Why are you posting on here, anyway? Isn’t there some 17-year old girl in Iraq that you need to stone to death?
Was Jesus really the son of God? There should be no double standard when it comes to morals. Lets see, from a young age we were all taught that Mary conceived Jesus at 12 or 13 years of age and married to a much older man Joseph. How old was mary when she was married 10 or 11? How do moral christians justify that story? That goes against all our MORAL teachings and beliefs throughout history. We have laws that we instituted abut minimum age. Morals are the same no matter what part of the world you come from. If a neigbor or relative had a daughter that was pregnant at 12 or 13 by a much older man everyone on this forum would be outraged, but again the old double standard. If the bible says so it must be true and it must be OK. Right? WRONG! I believe the son of god story was made up to justify mary getting pregnant when she was just a child. I am a lapsed catholic like most are today. UNBELIEVABLE!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top