Do Protestants Really Hate Catholicism?

  • Thread starter Thread starter gookykookypig
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Could any one enlighten me if there is any problems for a Catholic to marry a Protestant or Vice-versa?
My dad was Lutheran (LCMS) my mom is Catholic. It was not a problem for them. They respected each others faiths, and my dad was a very devout Christian. We kids were raised Catholic, and I learned a lot about love for Christ from my dad. When I was growing up, '60’s, Catholics kept their mouths shut about their faith.
I have this problem as my elder sister who is a protestant married a Catholic. My borther in law does not like my niece to attend Protestant Church and in the contrary, my sister does not like her daughter to attend the Roman Catholic Church. As such, my niece aged 18 now knows almost nothing about Jesus Christ even though she has been brought up in LA, the US.
This is just very sad.
Both my wife and I are protestants but these days, I start to attene Roman Catholic Church for the mass. My wife does not mind me taking my daughter to Roman Catholic Church as she accepts the Catholic Church just like any other christian bodies. Is that ok?

wlychan64
I hope your are being welcomed! You just cannot take Communion until you become Confirmed in the CC.
 
you need to go to RCIA classes, i think those are the right initials, and as j. grodi would say, ‘welcome to the journey home’
OK Jerry, you know way to much about EWTN and RCIA-are you on the Journey Home?😛
 
:)Hello Jerry,I hope you dont mind if i ask you this do you beleive that once you are saved you cannot loose your salvation? I studied with the Baptist but i dont remember that. Please get back Love of Christ Nancy
Being saved(Greek:sozo) is also described in the Bible as aFuture Event that will be experenced by those who are found faithful to Christ at the very end of their lives,(Salvation can be lost if one is found unfaithful at the end of his life,)Yes I have been saved when Jesus died on the Cross for me 2,000 years ago on Cavary and, thus, redeemed all of humanity(Acts 4:12;Eph 1:7)
 
Could any one enlighten me if there is any problems for a Catholic to marry a Protestant or Vice-versa?

I have this problem as my elder sister who is a protestant married a Catholic. My borther in law does not like my niece to attend Protestant Church and in the contrary, my sister does not like her daughter to attend the Roman Catholic Church. As such, my niece aged 18 now knows almost nothing about Jesus Christ even though she has been brought up in LA, the US.

Both my wife and I are protestants but these days, I start to attene Roman Catholic Church for the mass. My wife does not mind me taking my daughter to Roman Catholic Church as she accepts the Catholic Church just like any other christian bodies. Is that ok?

wlychan64
For a Catholic to marry a Protestant, it should be ensured that proper Catholic form is followed. So, it’s not a problem per se, but there are issues that should be resolved between the couple.

There’s no problem of your going to Catholic Mass. You should not receive Communion, though, unless you are Catholic.
 
Could any one enlighten me if there is any problems for a Catholic to marry a Protestant or Vice-versa?

I have this problem as my elder sister who is a protestant married a Catholic. My borther in law does not like my niece to attend Protestant Church and in the contrary, my sister does not like her daughter to attend the Roman Catholic Church. As such, my niece aged 18 now knows almost nothing about Jesus Christ even though she has been brought up in LA, the US.

Both my wife and I are protestants but these days, I start to attene Roman Catholic Church for the mass. My wife does not mind me taking my daughter to Roman Catholic Church as she accepts the Catholic Church just like any other christian bodies. Is that ok?

wlychan64
Dear wlychan,

How wonderful that you are loving God through the Mass at a Catholic Church. As a child I learned about the Mass with the word “ACTS.” A stood for “adoring” Jesus Christ which is really easy to do. C stood for “contrition” since we need to be sorry for our sins. T stood for “thanksgiving” and there was always something to be grateful for. S stood for “supplication” because there is always something we need and Holy Mass is a great place to ask God for help. This word “acts” made so much sense to me that I never forgot it.

You asked if there are any problems for a Catholic to marry a Protestant or Vice-versa?

The only question which comes up at the time of marriage is whether the Catholic wants to be married in the Catholic Church or outside of the Catholic Church. A while back, I posted the different possibilities. Since your sister has been married for a long time, my guess is that everything was taken care of. If not, I will be glad to answer other questions.

The current problem is that your niece does not know Jesus. I’m sure that you pray to God about this, asking Him to help your niece get to know Jesus. You have to be the judge of what you can do. Maybe you could share your love for Jesus with her.
Maybe you could give her a bible or some kind of book. Maybe take her to a Christian movie.

You also asked if it was o.k. to go to Mass. Of course it is o.k. to go. Jesus has His arms open wide to receive you and love you and your family. I noticed that someone told you that you cannot receive Holy Communion until you are a Catholic. I hope you understand that it is important to be a member of the Church.

The other thing I would like to share with you is a letter from a Bishop which tells about Holy Mass. Please read it slowly in sections. Think about it. Pray about it. Let our Lord Jesus Christ speak to you in your heart

This is the website.


Please go to the left column and click “Meet Bishop Doran.” Then click Bishop Doran’s “Pastoral Letter on the Eucharist”, 1997.

Or try

Blessings,
granny

All human life is meant for eternal life.
 
OK Jerry, you know way to much about EWTN and RCIA-are you on the Journey Home?😛
i’m on my journey home but not as you might think my friend, i’m running, running towards the Cross of Jesus Christ cause i know that without Him in my life i am doomed, this is the race i am running like paul writes.
 
being saved(greek:sozo) is also described in the bible as afuture event that will be experenced by those who are found faithful to christ at the very end of their lives,(salvation can be lost if one is found unfaithful at the end of his life,)yes i have been saved when jesus died on the cross for me 2,000 years ago on cavary and, thus, redeemed all of humanity(acts 4:12;eph 1:7)
:dhi boxcar,what do you mean by at the end of your life? I thought you could loose your salvation any time in your life because of murder or other bad things. Yes Jesus saved us but we can unsave ourselfs through sin. I;m writing big because i just went to the eye doctors and he diolated my eyes. Get back to me as i just started learning your way. ;)hay Jerry come on in the waters fine love of Christ Nancy
 
Dear wlychan,

How wonderful that you are loving God through the Mass at a Catholic Church. As a child I learned about the Mass with the word “ACTS.” A stood for “adoring” Jesus Christ which is really easy to do. C stood for “contrition” since we need to be sorry for our sins. T stood for “thanksgiving” and there was always something to be grateful for. S stood for “supplication” because there is always something we need and Holy Mass is a great place to ask God for help. This word “acts” made so much sense to me that I never forgot it.

You asked if there are any problems for a Catholic to marry a Protestant or Vice-versa?

The only question which comes up at the time of marriage is whether the Catholic wants to be married in the Catholic Church or outside of the Catholic Church. A while back, I posted the different possibilities. Since your sister has been married for a long time, my guess is that everything was taken care of. If not, I will be glad to answer other questions.

The current problem is that your niece does not know Jesus. I’m sure that you pray to God about this, asking Him to help your niece get to know Jesus. You have to be the judge of what you can do. Maybe you could share your love for Jesus with her.
Maybe you could give her a bible or some kind of book. Maybe take her to a Christian movie.

You also asked if it was o.k. to go to Mass. Of course it is o.k. to go. Jesus has His arms open wide to receive you and love you and your family. I noticed that someone told you that you cannot receive Holy Communion until you are a Catholic. I hope you understand that it is important to be a member of the Church.

The other thing I would like to share with you is a letter from a Bishop which tells about Holy Mass. Please read it slowly in sections. Think about it. Pray about it. Let our Lord Jesus Christ speak to you in your heart

This is the website.


Please go to the left column and click “Meet Bishop Doran.” Then click Bishop Doran’s “Pastoral Letter on the Eucharist”, 1997.

Or try

Blessings,
granny

All human life is meant for eternal life.
Thanks for the mail. I understand that I cannot take Holy Communion until I have become a member of the church. Anyway, at the very least, I can attend the mass happily

wlychan64
 
For a Catholic to marry a Protestant, it should be ensured that proper Catholic form is followed. So, it’s not a problem per se, but there are issues that should be resolved between the couple.

There’s no problem of your going to Catholic Mass. You should not receive Communion, though, unless you are Catholic.
Dear sir,
Thank you for the reminder that I cannot take the holy communion

wlychan64
 
Thanks for the mail. I understand that I cannot take Holy Communion until I have become a member of the church. Anyway, at the very least, I can attend the mass happily

wlychan64
I bet your love for Jesus is so strong that even if you can’t touch Him, you know He is in your heart loving you back.
 
I bet your love for Jesus is so strong that even if you can’t touch Him, you know He is in your heart loving you back.
Dear madam,
Thank you for your good words. I will love Jesus Christ more and more.
wlychan64
 
i’m on my journey home but not as you might think my friend, i’m running, running towards the Cross of Jesus Christ cause i know that without Him in my life i am doomed, this is the race i am running like paul writes.
:clapping:

And when you come to that fork in the road, watch which way St. Paul runs.:yup:
 
i’m on my journey home but not as you might think my friend, i’m running, running towards the Cross of Jesus Christ cause i know that without Him in my life i am doomed, this is the race i am running like paul writes.
Good for you Jerry, The dark night of the soul , is a state of one’s being, just before entering the everlasting light of Christ, that is why I practice the ladder of accent,or the Ladder Prayer…Peace be with you…
 
:)i HAVE A BOOK AT HOME IT IS CALLED ELEMENTS OF HISTORY BY JOHN W BARBER.IT HAS ALOT OF HISTORY INFORMATION AND THE BOOK WAS WRITTEN 1844 IN NEW HAVEN CONN. THE BOOK WAS USED TO TEACH HISTORY WAY BACK THEN AND IT TALKS ABOUT HOW THINGS STARTED 350 YEARS BEFORE CHRIST EVER CAME. IF YOU WANT TO BORROW IT LET ME KNOW BUT DO BE CAREFUL AS IT IS OLD.LOVE OF CHRIST NANCY:)
JL: Thanks Nancy, I have about twenty new books on the shelf. That I need to read before anyothers. By the way your book may be a collectors item. Here is a link on the author, you might be interested in reading. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Warner_Barber
 
JL: Thanks Nancy, I have about twenty new books on the shelf. That I need to read before anyothers. By the way your book may be a collectors item. Here is a link on the author, you might be interested in reading. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Warner_Barber
:thumbsup:I just looked up the site and ended going to the Conn: historical society the title of his works were there and that book title was one of them but i couldn’t find the book to look at> I wrote a note to the archives and we’ll see if they get in touchThank You I have alot of old books and i know they were not changed or added or subtracted to. jlhargus,take care of your self God speed love of Christ Nancy PS I was brought up Roman Catholic what is the difference? There is alot of differnt kinds of Catholics I dont remember that when i was a kid?😉
 
It would surprise you how many do, at least in the UK. There is still a law on the books, they are talking about it now, which does not allow the heir to the throne marry a Catholic. He can marry someone from any other Christian denomination and from any other non-Christian religion, or an atheist, or whatever. I had thought it was one of those laws which simply got overlooked once the UK decided that Catholics were human beings again. But not so! There are still people opposed. They say that the monarch cannot be “Head of the Church of England” if his father married a Catholic and he, then, becomes Catholic. I don’t know why the trouble - the Church of England is not state-supported. Most people, though, think the law is stupid and want to scrap it. Some even want to scrap the monarchy.

One guy was interviewed by a news anchor, and he said that the Catholic Church was backward, discriminatory and in no way should the monarchy be linked with us at all, that it sends a bad message. The anchor finally asked him whether he (the interviewee) had some Catholic skeletons of his own in the closet.

But there are still some people… they say things like we’re discriminatory because we do not accept homosexual activity and do not ordain women. They ignore the fact that many other religions and Christian denominations have the same stipulations. In fact, it might tear the Church of England asunder. Most British feel that the Anglican Church is very progressive. They already ordain women - they lost people due to that (and gained some) but now there is a debate over serving under a female bishop - some priests are not willing. The homosexual issue is a hot debate in the Anglican church. Especially among the developing nations - it is just not recognized as being a natural phenomenon in their culture. Rather they view it as aberrant. So Anglicans will talk about how progressive they are with half of the church up and arms about the so-called progressiveness on which they pride themselves.

But any chance some people get, they knock us and ignore the fact that the very church which symbolizes the UK (and other churches) are grappling with the same thing.

A new Catholic bishop was just questioned on the news about that. The anchor said “Well, then, only abstaining gays in the Catholic church are welcome,” after the bishop had explained that any extramarital sex was considered wrong. The bishop’s answer was beautiful. He said everyone was welcome and that we all struggle, we’re all sinners and we all fail. He said that if you are striving to do what is right, no matter who you are or what you are, you’re welcome. His whole stance was that people need to be in the Church because of our sinfulness, not because we are doing just fine. The anchor could not keep pinging on him - he had nothing to say to that answer.

It’s taken getting used to. Well, not really. I grew up in an area of the US which used to be very anti-Catholic. Things are much better now. And, luckily, not all British feel this way. It’s worse in the media, but not all the media feels this way.

I have a lot of Protestant friends, here and back home in the States. My beliefs are not a problem. I am married to a self-professed non-Christian and we have no problems. I have more problems with one of my siblings. He left the Church during the excesses of Vatican II and absolutely hates it. If I mention anything ‘Catholic’ in an email to him, he addresses everything else but that. Then my mom, she doesn’t recognize Vatican II. So if I say too much to her, she gets all upset as well.

I have learned not to worry about it because there’s nothing I can do and I figure that if we’re so highly criticized then we must be doing something right. After all, we were told we’d be persecuted (although I hesitate to use that word considering what some Christians are going through across the world).

Rock on!

byrdele
 
I have learned not to worry about it because there’s nothing I can do and I figure that if we’re so highly criticized then we must be doing something right. After all, we were told we’d be persecuted (although I hesitate to use that word considering what some Christians are going through across the world).
Amen to that. Thanks for the excellent report and your comments.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top