Does God call people to be separate from Catholic Eucharist

  • Thread starter Thread starter rcwitness
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Friend, before I address anything else I’m going to say it again; there’s no need to be insulting. I’ve told you I’ll Christian and if you keep, essentially, calling me a liar I don’t see why I should keep talking to you.
 
I had my revelation while I was Catholic and it led me away from that church to a different one. I remain Christian and would appreciate an apology for an the insult you keep throwing at me.

I don’t believe my belief system is relativism. And I believe I’ve also explained to you exactly how that passage may not mean what you think it does. While you may think Jesus spoke in nonsequiturs I think he likely practiced better speaking practices.
 
How have I insulted You? Please explain.

You do realize you are professing things that are against the Catholic faith, right? And you are doing so on the premise that God reveals these things to you privately!

Is it fair for you to call our Teachings false, and then criticize me for doubting that it is the Lord Jesus Christ speaking to you?
 
Last edited:
The Quaker religion is not considered Christian by the rest of Christianity. Am I wrong that you neither participate in the Lord’s Eucharist or Baptism?
 
That would be why I’m not Catholic, friend. But I am Christian and Quakers are considered Christian. So are you going to keep ignoring what I say? Because that it quite insulting.
 
Oh, you’ll also notice I never called your beliefs false. I said I was happy for you. Because I’m not rude.
 
Alex337 said:
Oh, you’ll also notice I never called your beliefs false. I said I was happy for you. Because I’m not rude.
Click to expand...
You don’t have to specifically say the Catholic beliefs are false to convey your sentiments about them.

The Catholic faith is NOT compatible with the Quaker religion! You do realize this, right?

You have stated that Scripture is “fallible”. As a Quaker, you do not participate in Baptism or Holy Communion. You also deny that Scripture is the Written Word of God.

I am not insulting you at all! I wish you peace. But you cannot subscribe to the Quaker religion and expect it to be compatible with the Teachings of the Catholic faith. By joining the Quaker religion, you actually reject the Catholic faith which you were Baptized into.
 
Last edited:
Dude, why did you keep calling me a liar? This is getting beyond a joke. I never called your beliefs false; I specifically said I was happy for you.

You admitted that translation also makes some Bibles false, which is all I said.

I also never said I didn’t believe in scripture. At this point I will return the favour and insinuate that you’re lying.

And yes; I left Catholicism. I opened with that :roll_eyes: because God led me away from it 💙
 
Alex337 said:
Dude, why did you keep calling me a liar? This is getting beyond a joke. I never called your beliefs false; I specifically said I was happy for you.

You admitted that translation also makes some Bibles false, which is all I said.

I also never said I didn’t believe in scripture. At this point I will return the favour and insinuate that you’re lying.

And yes; I left Catholicism. I opened with that :roll_eyes: because God led me away from it 💙
Click to expand...
Where did I say you are a liar?

I believe you are the one being deceived.

Quakers do not profess Scripture as the Word of God.

Translations are translations. This does not make the Holy manuscripts false. It merely means that some translators have sometimes chosen words that are not always representative of the original message of the words. This is why the Catholic faith is NOT a “religion of a book” but of a living God who is a Father, a Son and Holy Spirit. This God has given us a revelation of who He is and what He Teaches by way of Sacred Scripture, Sacred Tradition, and a Magisterium to interpret universal faith and morals.
 
Okay, you’re gonna keep saying I’m a liar. It’s not worth talking with you.
 
Sorry, I don’t see a clarity beyond clarity–I’m quite pedestrian, you know.

Maran atha!

Angel
 
Alex337 said:
Otherwise we accept that God sees incest as a valid marriage, if even only for a time. Which could also be forever if they don’t divorce.
Click to expand...
I don’t think that you are following Scriptures close enough… did Jesus say God accepted divorce because Moses came up of a decree for it or did Jesus say, "it was not so from the Beginning: one man, one woman, united by God?’ (paraphrased)

Maran atha!

Angel
 
And the exception is “a case of porneia”. A Christian marriage is not porneia.
 
Alex337 said:
But you said they could get divorced. You can’t get divorced without being married, friend.
Click to expand...
Again you are confusing terms.

Did St. Paul not Teach that those who came into the Faith not get divorced from their un-Believing spouses?

A joining, even as the social experiment of cohabitation is a marriage (marital bond); an illicit marriage must be annul before a genuine Sacramental Marriage must take effect.

Maran atha!

Angel
 
We went over this already and you’re still insulting.

So, over all; yes, God can lead people away from Catholicism. There are many translations and interpretations of the scripture. I’m glad you two found one that works for you but frankly you kind of don’t listen to people and go in circles, and get pretty darn insulting.

I’m more happy than ever that God led me away from that. But glad it helps you feel closer to Him. Blessings.
 
rcwitness said:
The faith was preached before Scripture was penned… so Scripture is not the only source of the revelation of Jesus.
Click to expand...
And is preaching a source of the faith and revelations of Jesus today?

Plenty of Scripture was penned way before Jesus to verify His preaching.
 
Alex337 said:
It’s even in the same passage where he talks about marriages being something in the eyes of God. It goes from Jesus explaining that God joins people together into the exception for when to split then apart.
Click to expand...
Yet, the practice, then as now, is that two people (more in some cultures) come together as a married union even and in spite of God.

So you must give in to reason–less you are intimating that it is God who brings together that which He considers illicit.

Maran atha!

Angel
 
[quote="rcwitness,

Is it fair for you to call our Teachings false, and then criticize me for doubting that it is the Lord Jesus Christ speaking to you?
[/quote]

Rc, my advice to you is to slow down a bit. I also have been told a couple of times in my life that someone questions whether I am a Christian or not. It is not a pleasant thing to be told. Really, that is God’s judgement.

You asked the quote above, which is quite interesting, for if you reverse it and apply it to me, you have to admit that both you and the CC call the teaching of my church false.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top