Are you 10? Were you alive on September 11, 2001? Do you concede that America is facing a very real sophisticated radical Islam terrorist threat - with cells all through the USA and abroad? What is your take on the Boston Marathon Bomber? And I am the one who doesn’t care about America???
I was an adult in 2001. I saw (in person, I mean, not on TV) the smoke billowing up from the Pentagon, and like millions of others, I cried for hours watching the coverage of New York.
That does not mean that I think it is OK for the government to know the content of my e-mails or phone calls or texts, even if I don’t think there is anything that should interest them in that. It’s not like the government has a right to all information about me unless I can prove they don’t need it. And in fact, we’re not given the opportunity to prove it even if we could.
What if they collect all of this information and later decide that devout Catholics are a danger to the state? Do you know what they’re looking for? Does anyone? Is there any accountability for what they search for? Once they’ve collected it, is there any guarantee that they delete the information that is not related to terrorism? When they’ve indicated that Christians and conservatives and those who are suspicious of centralized federal authority are dangerous, even if they deleted information that they feel is not related to terrorism, they will still have information that I feel is not related to terrorism.
The interesting thing about that episode in the debate is that I found I didn’t agree with either Christie or Paul. In time-sensitive situations, I think law enforcement could have information without waiting for a warrant. However, they should still have to show (at least afterwards) that they had a good reason for collecting all of the information they collected, reasons having to do with suspicious behavior, information received, etc., and also that they had good reason to believe the situation was really time-sensitive. You can’t just say, “It’s OK to spy on everyone, because anyone might be a terrorist.” Or rather, you can say it, but I will certainly argue with you about it, and I will have to think long and hard before voting for anyone who says it. (I won’t think you don’t care about America, just that you’re wrong.

)
The fact that my life is boring and crime-free (well, maybe except speeding

) doesn’t mean that I am willing to have my every communication known by the government. Even if I trusted what they would do with it (which I don’t), it is my private life and I deserve, as a human being who has not committed or even contemplated any serious crime, to keep it private. The hundreds of millions of other Americans whom the government has no reason to believe are involved in terrorism deserve it too.
–Jen