Does any of this make sense?
[Note: I needed to cut your post above out or this post would have been rejected by the system as too long.]
Yes, it does, thank you.
On a thread a long time ago, and far far away, there was much confusion about terms. “Creationist”. “Creationist in disguise”. Etc. So I proposed 4 different very brief “summaries” of belief about evolution that we could publicly identify with (so the other posters knew where we were coming from). Without using pejorative terms. I’m too lazy to try to find the thread…
I thought it was a great idea. As it turned out, Barbarian and I both self identified as the same “type”. And we argue with each other more than (possibly) anybody else. So that idea didn’t work too well.
I see the whole evolution question from the perspective of “it’s interesting from the perspective of curiosity, but doesn’t really matter in the long run.” Some day I’ll be dead, and the question of “evolution, how?” becomes irrelevant. Some day, we’ll all be dead and the question of “evolution, how?” will not matter to anybody reading this post. Some day, this universe will cease to exist, it will be as though it never existed, and the question really won’t make any difference to anyone.
What will matter will be where we are when we realize that the question is irrelevant.
From my above post stating “what should we teach”, it should be obvious that I’m not a YEC (and it’s not just a matter of being a “bit” older than 6000 years.) And I don’t think that the bible is a science textbook. But I DO think that the bible is a reliable textbook regarding human nature and our ultimate path to God.
There are several science / religion divides going on here. One is evolution / creation debate itself. The others have to do with salvation. Despite what many think, I usually align myself with the pro-evolution folks on the evolution debate when talking about evidence. But frankly, when it comes to things like “certainty of knowledge”, this has salvific(sp?) implications beyond the knowledge itself. And I align myself with those who say “Don’t be so sure of yourself that you puff up your pride to immense proportions.”
There are many biblical passages in the Wisdom books (related to human nature, not science) which speak of many things beyond our understanding…and “don’t go there.” And in the Book of Job, last 3(?) chapters, God tells Job of his might and asks Job basically, can you do this, can you understand all this? Of course Job’s answer is “no.” And Job’s answer should not be “But eventually Science will figure it all out, and then we WILL know!” God is telling us that we have limits, and to deny this is hubris.
Adam and Eve’s sin. The devil’s pride, Adam and Eve’s pride, a search for knowledge to be like God.
The tower of Babel incident. Another demonstration of mankind’s pride, and God’s reaction to it.
I’m an engineer. I love science, especially where it has direct application to solving a particular problem. We can use science for many wonderful things, building bridges and dams, inventing medical cures, etc. And in a cosmological sense (including things which we can’t duplicate, like evolution) I think that science is still a gift by which we can understand the beauty and glory (and even things like efficiency) of God’s design. But when we decide that we can actually know everything (eventually) then we make ourselves equal to God, and that can never happen.
When we pursue knowledge, we need to remember that ultimately the first will be last and the last will be first. He will scatter the proud in their conceit. We must be like children to enter the kingdom of Heaven. God will fill us with good things only if we are “empty” of bad things.
A final note on “creationism”. Creationism, going to the extreme says that “God did it, and I don’t care how he did it.” Science going to the extreme says that we have no need of God and/or We Know Everything. Balance is nice, but if one falls off the fence, one extreme leads to heaven and the other does not.