Evolution and Creation: What to Teach Students?

  • Thread starter Thread starter lucille5
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Except that evolution is a matter of science, not faith. Non-theistic gravity and plate tectonics would be against our faith as well, if faith had anything to do with those theories.
I have faith that God is responsible for gravity, and plate tectonics (however accurate our models of them may or may not be).
 
I am lousy at all the pasting needed for those windows so forgive me.
  1. God created everything. We have some insights into how that was done, and we can create models of how it was done, but we’ll never know for sure because we’re not God.
    Point two is a direct rebuttal against point 1. While it is true that man will never be able to duplicate God’s creation he has both intellect and reason to be able to fully apprehend and appreciate it. These are the gifts of God that should be used in that effort.
  2. Science is a tool that God gave us (part of intellect and reason). It is one more way that we can come to know God, as we do through Art, Music, and other ways in which we exercise our intellect.
  3. Scientific evidence points to an earth that was created about 13 billion years ago, and an earth that was created 4.5 billion years ago.
    hopefully you were referring to the universe (13.5 BP
  4. Scientific evidence also points to the fact that complex life forms exist today, and much simpler ones billions of years ago. There is a transition in the fossil record that shows a gradual increase of complexity over time.
    Science has shown that organisms change over time, increasing complexity is not a given
  5. Scientific evidence shows that natural selection plays a part in ensuring the survival of species which are more fit than others.
    *natural selection involves individuals with better fitness out competing the lesser fit for breeding and gene passage *
  6. Scientific evidence shows that genetic mutations are responsible for providing the increased complexity on which natural selection operates.
    Science shows that genes are responsible for change. Again complexity is not a given
  7. Science cannot determine exactly what mutations occurred and over what time period to cause this increasing complexity.
    DNA research is providing evidence which alleles were fixed and is providing a time table
  8. Catholics must believe that God is responsible for both the creation of the universe, as well as the creation of man.
    Joyfully given
  9. Catholics must believe that we originated from a single set of human parents.
  10. Catholics can believe that God created our human bodies via evolutionary processes as described above, but that these human “bodies” did not become fully human until infused with souls from God.
  11. Catholics must believe that our souls are directly created by God, and did not evolve. (since they consist of only 1 part, it is impossible for it to evolve).
    Given by doctrinal statement
For the sake of specificity.
 
I am lousy at all the pasting needed for those windows so forgive me.
  1. God created everything. We have some insights into how that was done, and we can create models of how it was done, but we’ll never know for sure because we’re not God.
    Point two is a direct rebuttal against point 1. While it is true that man will never be able to duplicate God’s creation he has both intellect and reason to be able to fully apprehend and appreciate it. These are the gifts of God that should be used in that effort.
No, point 2 is not a direct rebuttal of point 1. Science leads to models of reality, not actual perfect knowledge of reality. Those models of reality can help us know God (in the sense of appreciate and stand in awe of…).
quoting ricmat:
2. Science is a tool that God gave us (part of intellect and reason). It is one more way that we can come to know God, as we do through Art, Music, and other ways in which we exercise our intellect.
  1. Scientific evidence points to an earth that was created about 13 billion years ago, and an earth that was created 4.5 billion years ago.
    hopefully you were referring to the universe (13.5 BP
Oops…yes, I meant universe in the first phrase…
Thanks for catching that. I was typing at warp 9 and was only thinking at warp 8 at the time…
quoting ricmat:
4. Scientific evidence also points to the fact that complex life forms exist today, and much simpler ones billions of years ago. There is a transition in the fossil record that shows a gradual increase of complexity over time.
Science has shown that organisms change over time, increasing complexity is not a given
I guess I was thinking in terms of simple life evolving into man, rather than a generic definition.
quoting ricmat:
5. Scientific evidence shows that natural selection plays a part in ensuring the survival of species which are more fit than others.
*natural selection involves individuals with better fitness out competing the lesser fit for breeding and gene passage *
Right. I agree.
quoting ricmat:
6. Scientific evidence shows that genetic mutations are responsible for providing the increased complexity on which natural selection operates.
Science shows that genes are responsible for change. Again complexity is not a given.
OK - I mentioned complexity again because it came up on a previous evolution thread…and I guess it stuck in my mind as a better term with which to describe evolution going in a positive direction.
quoting ricmat:
7. Science cannot determine exactly what mutations occurred and over what time period to cause this increasing complexity.
DNA research is providing evidence which alleles were fixed and is providing a time table.
I meant this statement in the most general sense of…will never determine each and every mutation from e.g. slime, to modern humans. And when they occurred. (And as a separate note, the probability of such mutations occurring at the right time without some sort of intelligent guidance.)
quoting ricmat:
8. Catholics must believe that God is responsible for both the creation of the universe, as well as the creation of man.
Joyfully given
9. Catholics must believe that we originated from a single set of human parents.
  1. Catholics can believe that God created our human bodies via evolutionary processes as described above, but that these human “bodies” did not become fully human until infused with souls from God.
  2. Catholics must believe that our souls are directly created by God, and did not evolve. (since they consist of only 1 part, it is impossible for it to evolve).
    Given by doctrinal statement
For the sake of specificity.
Not sure what you mean by your last sentence…???
 
(taken out for brevity)

Not sure what you mean by your last sentence…???
I was referring to the comments. changes suggested for specificity of the points.

We will have to agree to disagree on point one. Knowledge is increasing geometrically and shows no slowing so for the natural world, the sky is the limit to me. Not because of some sense of Ubermann(sp?). I just think God made it possible for us to know.
 
Oops…yes, I meant universe in the first phrase…
Thanks for catching that. I was typing at warp 9 and was only thinking at warp 8 at the time…
Interestingly, brain science says you were thinking at warp 9 and typing at warp 8. Ever notice how many times you write the wrong letter in a word? The science of ballistic behaviors explains that. writing a letter (a, b, c) is programmed into your Medulla so you won’t have to spend time thinking through the formation. (remember all those Aa, Bb exercises in kindergarten and first grade?). When we write or type our cerebellum is ahead of our medulla and bits of old ballistic behaviors get caught in the loops. If you are a good typist this is a minor problem. If you are a hunt and peck typist (like me) it is a HUGE problem.
 
What is the incorrect assumption about Christianity you refer to?
Well for example

That Christianity teaches that dinosaurs and humans co-existed
or that a literal interpretation of Genesis is required for Christian faith
 
That Christianity teaches that dinosaurs and humans co-existed or that a literal interpretation of Genesis is required for Christian faith
In a delicious irony, the makers of Ben Stein’s new creationist film, Expelled!, today had police kick P. Z, Myers out of a cinema where it was being screened, but they didn’t even recognize Myers’ guest – Richard Dawkins, who was allowed to go in and watch the film!
 
I have faith that God is responsible for gravity, and plate tectonics (however accurate our models of them may or may not be).
I don’t know, ricmat – it takes a lot of faith to believe that plates just move themselves along the earth’s molten surface, rather than God’s little finger doing it.
 
Well for example

That Christianity teaches that dinosaurs and humans co-existed
or that a literal interpretation of Genesis is required for Christian faith
Yes, there are Christians who believe that humans and dinosaurs coexisted. If anyone wants to look at the evidence presented at places like the Creation Museum, they can.

Catholics are taught that the Genesis account is actual history. The Church also refers to Adam and Eve as distinct persons who sinned, necessitating the birth, life and death of Jesus Christ. This is a key teaching. Although the Bible is not a science book as we understand science today, it does record actual events. As Catholics, we believe that a literal, real person who was true God and true man, lived and died for us. The saints and martyrs throughout history have given us the tangible witness of this reality. Today, the Church requires 2 miracles of every person being considered for sainthood.

Being Catholic, I am not required to believe in evolution. My Church is not promoting it. I can’t help it that a few are making a big deal about it in the outside world.

Ask yourself, why is it such a big deal? Is it because of the science? Because a person can go their entire life without knowing about it. They need Jesus Christ, first and foremost. Personally, based on everything I’ve read, a few people want science to dictate to the Church what it believes.

If truth cannot contradict truth, remember that truth does not flow in one direction only - from science to the Church. It also does flow in the opposite direction. The Church judges science and interprets it in light of divine revelation all the time.

God bless,
Ed
 
I don’t know, ricmat – it takes a lot of faith to believe that plates just move themselves along the earth’s molten surface, rather than God’s little finger doing it.
I don’t pretend to know if God uses his little finger or not. Perhaps it is his little finger that is responsible for wonderfully designed natural laws that we have.

But God is involved. Really.
 
In a delicious irony, the makers of Ben Stein’s new creationist film, Expelled!, today had police kick P. Z, Myers out of a cinema where it was being screened, but they didn’t even recognize Myers’ guest – Richard Dawkins, who was allowed to go in and watch the film!
And for those interested in both sides of the story about this private showing, by invitation only:

from: evolutionnews.org/2008/03/richard_dawkins_worlds_most_fa.html
Amazingly, the best selling Oxford scientist/author Richard Dawkins also **crashed a showing of *Expelled ***in Minnesota last night and he not only *was *let in, but introduced at the end of the showing.

Dawkins apparently acknowledged that he had not been invited and did not have a ticket. A sophomoric side to his ideological campaign is thus revealed.

Dawkins, understandably is nervous about this film, among other reasons because Ben Stein has him on camera acknowledging that life on Earth may, indeed, have been intelligently designed, but that it had to have been accomplished by space aliens! This is hilarious, of course, because Dawkins is death on intelligent design. But it turns out that that view applies only if it includes the possibility that the designer might be God.
Dawkins Introduced at the end of the showing. And answering questions.
 
In a delicious irony, the makers of Ben Stein’s new creationist film, Expelled!, today had police kick P. Z, Myers out of a cinema where it was being screened, but they didn’t even recognize Myers’ guest – Richard Dawkins, who was allowed to go in and watch the film!
And as a follow up to my last post, but this one about Myers, from this source:

blog.christianitytoday.com/ctliveblog/archives/2008/03/dawkins_crashes_1.html
I just happened to be standing directly in line behind Dawkins’ academic colleague. Management of the movie theatre saw a man apparently hustling and bothering several invited attendees, apparently trying to disrupt the viewing or sneak in. Management then approached the man, asked him if he had a ticket, and when he confirmed that he didn’t, they then escorted him off the premises.

snip…

And since I was literally 3 feet away from Myers when he was “expelled,” I heard every word. It was obvious he was being kicked out by theatre management because he was not invited nor was he on the pre-submitted list. He didn’t cause a disruption per se; he was kindly escorted out.
In fact, Dawkins himself acted as a perfect gentleman during the Q&A. He was respectful of everyone present, even though he was a little upset about Myers and his own role in the film.
This doesn’t sound like Myers was thrown out by the police at the request of the filmmakers. It sounds like he was trying to sneak in without an invitation. But even when Dawkins managed to do that, he was treated with respect.
 
I don’t pretend to know if God uses his little finger or not. Perhaps it is his little finger that is responsible for wonderfully designed natural laws that we have.

But God is involved. Really.
Don’t let a gentle ribbing get your goat ricmat. I am sure that everyone here ultimately depends on God for all of physical being.

The debate, as I see it, revolves around perspective rather than cause. For the creationist their perspective is a shorter term. The absolute literalist sees a young earth with spontaneous acts of creation. The ID sees a slightly older earth with God dropping in to introduce design here and there to direct His creation along a defined path. The evolutionist (Christian) sees a creation that is made independent of the Creator (given free will) and God enters it when it is ready for a relationship. The purist sees a moment of creation where the laws of matter (defined by God at the instant of creation) define the parameters of atoms and molecules such that the universe has no choice but to be fertile. The plasma must make stars. The stars must make atoms. The atoms must have defined characters so they must form certain molecules which are destined to result in bios. Bios must be mutable because the planet it is on must have volcanoes and geology to maintain the environment for Bios. Bios must at some point lead to a creature who is then ready to receive the gift of the soul.

So we have competing hypotheses. If Richard Dawkins was part of this thread, there would be another view; pure random chance which we have eliminated at once. Even for a staunch evolutionist like me, the dice may be thrown, but the table, the house is owned by God so I bow to the last, the purist, and allow that the whole game may be rigged by the first laws of God written not on clay tablets but the very fabric of creation itself. One could say that I am defeated but by bowing I actually become free to study the beauty and rightness of a mutable Bios that can meet any temporal challenge but remain faithful to the mission given by God. To say one is favor of the evolutionary hypothesis and the final purist hypothesis ultimately makes one the ultimate intelligent design advocate even though the hypothesis argues forcefully against the ID proposal of Behe and others. If I have a criticism of Behe, it is that he didn’t think big enough, go far enough, let logic lead him to the correct point of design. If I argue against the creationists it is because they let an explanation of creation calculated to fit the level of science and thinking of a scientifically ignorant Hebraic people be the be all-end all of any explanation. The kernel of truth is there. Baal didn’t create the world. Shiva didn’t do it either. God is the source, the “from nothing” creator. He leaves it at that so they can understand. At the time He makes the explanation He knows that man will progress mentally, scientifically and find the whole of the story that is only beginning to be suggested in Genesis. I think too many have let people like Dawkins and Watson hijack the science both for an against evolution. Letting them do that sets us against each other and that is such a clever ruse by satan. Screwtape would be proud of that nephew. Keep them at each other throats and you will keep confusion alive. This is one reason why I keep begging people to read Kenneth Miller. (running out of character allowance =(

Does any of this make sense?
 
In a delicious irony, the makers of Ben Stein’s new creationist film, Expelled!, today had police kick P. Z, Myers out of a cinema where it was being screened, but they didn’t even recognize Myers’ guest – Richard Dawkins, who was allowed to go in and watch the film!
I don’t know why anyone is surprised; they did say “no intelligence allowed.” 😃
 
I don’t guess IAmEd is ever going to tell us about those missing transitionals. Too bad. I was looking forward to it.
You guessed correctly.

How does the saying go?.. cast no pearls before…

Well… I guess I’m not much for being attacked in a discussion, or having my ability as a teacher insulted. I’ll leave you 2 to yourselves… hoe you have a long discussion together. Sorry to have bothered with a different opinion. ;]

God Bless… Happy Easter… Darwin rules… yadda yadda. ;]

🤷

LOL
 
Barbarian observes:
I don’t guess IAmEd is ever going to tell us about those missing transitionals. Too bad. I was looking forward to it.
You guessed correctly.
It wasn’t hard. The guys who say “there are no transitional fossils” almost always fold when challenged.
How does the saying go?
“Talk is cheap; evidence is harder to come by.”
Well… I guess I’m not much for being attacked in a discussion, or having my ability as a teacher insulted.
Or for backing up your claims with evidence. I can see you’re upset and frustrated. But things go badly for people who make claims they can’t support with facts.
 
Does any of this make sense?
[Note: I needed to cut your post above out or this post would have been rejected by the system as too long.]

Yes, it does, thank you.

On a thread a long time ago, and far far away, there was much confusion about terms. “Creationist”. “Creationist in disguise”. Etc. So I proposed 4 different very brief “summaries” of belief about evolution that we could publicly identify with (so the other posters knew where we were coming from). Without using pejorative terms. I’m too lazy to try to find the thread…

I thought it was a great idea. As it turned out, Barbarian and I both self identified as the same “type”. And we argue with each other more than (possibly) anybody else. So that idea didn’t work too well.

I see the whole evolution question from the perspective of “it’s interesting from the perspective of curiosity, but doesn’t really matter in the long run.” Some day I’ll be dead, and the question of “evolution, how?” becomes irrelevant. Some day, we’ll all be dead and the question of “evolution, how?” will not matter to anybody reading this post. Some day, this universe will cease to exist, it will be as though it never existed, and the question really won’t make any difference to anyone.

What will matter will be where we are when we realize that the question is irrelevant.

From my above post stating “what should we teach”, it should be obvious that I’m not a YEC (and it’s not just a matter of being a “bit” older than 6000 years.) And I don’t think that the bible is a science textbook. But I DO think that the bible is a reliable textbook regarding human nature and our ultimate path to God.

There are several science / religion divides going on here. One is evolution / creation debate itself. The others have to do with salvation. Despite what many think, I usually align myself with the pro-evolution folks on the evolution debate when talking about evidence. But frankly, when it comes to things like “certainty of knowledge”, this has salvific(sp?) implications beyond the knowledge itself. And I align myself with those who say “Don’t be so sure of yourself that you puff up your pride to immense proportions.”

There are many biblical passages in the Wisdom books (related to human nature, not science) which speak of many things beyond our understanding…and “don’t go there.” And in the Book of Job, last 3(?) chapters, God tells Job of his might and asks Job basically, can you do this, can you understand all this? Of course Job’s answer is “no.” And Job’s answer should not be “But eventually Science will figure it all out, and then we WILL know!” God is telling us that we have limits, and to deny this is hubris.

Adam and Eve’s sin. The devil’s pride, Adam and Eve’s pride, a search for knowledge to be like God.

The tower of Babel incident. Another demonstration of mankind’s pride, and God’s reaction to it.

I’m an engineer. I love science, especially where it has direct application to solving a particular problem. We can use science for many wonderful things, building bridges and dams, inventing medical cures, etc. And in a cosmological sense (including things which we can’t duplicate, like evolution) I think that science is still a gift by which we can understand the beauty and glory (and even things like efficiency) of God’s design. But when we decide that we can actually know everything (eventually) then we make ourselves equal to God, and that can never happen.

When we pursue knowledge, we need to remember that ultimately the first will be last and the last will be first. He will scatter the proud in their conceit. We must be like children to enter the kingdom of Heaven. God will fill us with good things only if we are “empty” of bad things.

A final note on “creationism”. Creationism, going to the extreme says that “God did it, and I don’t care how he did it.” Science going to the extreme says that we have no need of God and/or We Know Everything. Balance is nice, but if one falls off the fence, one extreme leads to heaven and the other does not.
 
" I collect old cameras, and so I often visited antique shops and the like in small towns. Once, near Greenville, Texas, a lady asked me if I’d be interested in a “Baptist Bookshelf.”

I admitted I didn’t know what that was. She showed me a perfectly-normal looking bookcase. But then she showed me the hidden space just big enough to hold a fifth of whiskey."

Is this bookshelf used by Hardshell Baptists, Softshell Baptists, or Southern Fried Baptists?
 
Chuck H wrote:

“It is involved more than can be typed here, but briefly. Homo sapiens was a biological reality but not yet ready for sharing the life of God through the soul or grace. Having the natural body was not sufficient until the brain could perceive what difference the soul could make. There is a computer modeling experiment that uses genes for brain size and collection of what are termed memes. Homo sapiens sapiens underwent a gradual increase in brain size to the point where the birth process could no longer accommodate the increase in infant skull size. During that time period of natural development homo sapiens was gaining brain capacity but was not yet capable of perceiving or acting on having a soul. The geological record shows a period of time where we had a larger brain but skeleton data was “strewn” across the landscape. Suddenly we see graves with personal effects and sometimes flowers and decorations placed in the graves with the body. Aha! now we see the effect of the soul. Not yet ready for the ten commandments yet but getting closer and close enough to perceive the afterlife. One can easily come to the conclusion that God would judge this people not by the commandments or by Paul’s epistles but exactly where they were at in that time frame and at stage of development.
Suddenly archeology begins to see graves that demonstrate a care for the infirm and arthritic elders. That is altruism beyond biological necessity and we see it both in homo sapiens sapiens and in homo sapiens neanderthalis. I can see the work of God here and evidence that in this period God considers us ready to give us a share of His life and grace however humble the beginnings”

?? Homo Sapiens (I guess that means people) were alive, but not yet ready to share the life of God? Where did you get that information? What happened to these Homo Sapiens when they died? How do you know?

I’m glad that I don’t put my trust in computer models. Computers are handy devices, but their output is totally dependent on the quality of their (name removed by moderator)ut.

So, I guess it all boils down to this: Either the first man was created by God with all his faculties, or the first man (men?) evolved millions of years ago, but were unable to be considered to be in the image of God. Now which is it?
 
"Quote:
Originally Posted by abu kamoon
I know how we can solve this argument. Let’s all contribute come money in the interest of science and purchase a brand new car. We’ll leave the car parked in a field for let’s say, twenty five years. Hopefully, the weather and other environmental conditions can induce a few random mutations in the car. Then we can all see how the car evolves into a more advanvced model.

That is just nonsensical. The car is not organic and has absolutely no capacity to respond to anything. You are just planning on driving it away and claiming it went extinct. "

Of course it’s nonsense, Chuck. But it is no more ridiculous than the idea that one species can “evolve” into another because of random mutations. Non bacterial maladies that afflict the human race like the sickle cell are the result of mutation. We don’t evolve from these mutations, we devolve.

What happens to the human body as it ages? Cells continue to reproduce, but mutations cause degeneration. It’s the same situation in the reproduction of offspring, but much slower. It involves errors caused by mutations in the genetic code. These errors do not create superior beings, the cause weaker offspring, more prone to disease and even extinction.

Why do evolutionists cling to this theory when what we can observe shows just the opposite?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top