False Prophets the most used comeback!

  • Thread starter Thread starter tonyfish58
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Can you give an example of a thoughtless use of the term false prophet? Or is that you just don’t like your prophet being called false when you cannot retaliate and say any of the actual prophets are false?
Every time it is used against a True Prophet.

False Prophet has connotations of the lowest form of Person a Deceiver a Dishonest Person

One can make that of any person form anything they wish.

A False Prophet will not endure the Bible says it will be cut down.

Muhammad Endured, so should we go back and see why? ETC

Regards Tony
 
Every time it is used against a True Prophet.
Joseph Smith Jr. was a True Prophet? WHY?
False Prophet has connotations of the lowest form of Person a Deceiver a Dishonest Person
Yeah . . .
One can make that of any person form anything they wish.
So the idea is to call no one a false prophet.
A False Prophet will not endure the Bible says it will be cut down.

Muhammad Endured, so should we go back and see why? ETC
Jim Jones fought to the end, so did Marshal Applewhite,
Joseph Smith too, his successors Brigham Young and
Joseph Smith III as well, so they are too True Prophets.
 
The Love of God is not a game, I appreciate you do not want to explore this, so yes we will leave it at that.

In all this conversation there is only one result that we should consider, that is to Know and to Love God. May we all find this, God willing.

God Bless 👍

Regards Tony
 
I would not have thought so until reading some of the posts of members of the Baha’i faith on this thread. The idea of trying to prove the divinity of the Baha-u-llah on a Catholic Forum is, to me, as futile as a Jew, Muslim, or Hindu trying to prove the truth of their faith. One might discuss different perspectives, which is something I have done mainly in response to others’ questions, but not for the purpose of, as you say, “advancing an agenda.”
 
Jim Jones fought to the end, so did Marshal Applewhite, Joseph Smith too, his successors Brigham Young and Joseph Smith III as well, so they are too True Prophets.
That is for you to decide 😉

What Fruits did they have and leave behind. Did they live their lives as they preached? Do they have a book attributed to their revelation?

This is all for you to decide as by their fruits you shall know them!

I would like to make this point in making a Judgement re Faith, One must a personal Choice with what they find, no one else can make up their mind.

If I was to determine a claim as False, I would leave them to God. God will sort it out!

Regards Tony
 
That is for you to decide 😉
What Fruits did they have and leave behind. Did they live their lives as they preached? Do they have a book attributed to their revelation?
This is all for you to decide as by their fruits you shall know them!
I would like to make this point in making a Judgement re Faith, One must a personal Choice with what they find, no one else can make up their mind.
If I was to determine a claim as False, I would leave them to God. God will sort it out!
Regards Tony
I’ve decided, what about you? You proclaim them as True Prophets?
 
Thank you for all the responses to this post.

I can see that it may be perceived that it is all about “advancing an agenda.” But my friends I have no agenda except for the Love of God.

This at times may require provocative thoughts. But in providing these there is no intent to call or impute any one or anything as bad. That is not for me to decide, that is all answerable to God.

May your decisions and replies be made with Love and Justice, God Bless you all and it is time for me to say good bye to CAF.

May life and Faith be kind to you all. 👋 😉 :blushing:

Regards Tony
 
Then Mohammed, even from the Baha’l perspective it seems suspect. How come Mohammed is allowed a different set of guidelines and measuring stick?
Cause the rules change everyone 1000 years or whenever God feels like it. The Bahai God could apparently make homosexuality good in the next revelation, who knows.
Every time it is used against a True Prophet.

False Prophet has connotations of the lowest form of Person a Deceiver a Dishonest Person

One can make that of any person form anything they wish.

A False Prophet will not endure the Bible says it will be cut down.

Muhammad Endured, so should we go back and see why? ETC

Regards Tony
I didn’t ask for your personal opinion I asked for an example of thoughtless use of the term. When I call your prophet say, a false prophet on the level of Joseph Smith a representative of satan masquarading as an angel of light do you think I am doing it thoughtlessly?

Where in the bible are we promised every false prophet will be cut down? Everyone of them will die yes and be judged yes, but not all of them will be punished on earth for doing so. Consider the Mormons and all their prophets, you think all of them were cut down? By your understanding you would have to accept mormonism and their God of flesh and bone.

So when I call your prophet a false prophet how am I doing thoughtlessly? Do you know my reasons? Or are you just a little too offended? I would expect jews to call Jesus the false Christ and its not on me to demand they not call him that. Its on me to present the gospel and for them to either accept or reject. If we are unconvinced we are unconvinced and he will remain a false prophet.
 
Thank you for the list. 👍 ;)!
Least I could do to help. 😛
Go through the List and one can soon conclude what has prevailed and Had Fruits and what has not.!
I seen a documentary on a couple of them. There’s a couple on there just as plausible I would venture to say.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vissarion
From this list it is easy to see who was Not possibly the Return of Christ ond after a bit more research, Who may have been!
Perhaps, but its leaves more than one who are possible as I just showed you also. Add to this the dilemma that I “never” knew the apostolic church’s to teach Jesus Christ would return as a man at the Second Coming. That’s not apostolic teaching. The Kingdom of Heaven, will be established through the Resurrection of the dead.

To me your entire teaching is no surprise since I have to assume the understanding arrived by sola scriptura reading. Not a bad thing but it indicates how a false conclusion was arrived at.

In “orthodox” Christianity they recite …“He ascended into heaven and is seated at the right hand of the Father. He will come again in glory to judge the living and the dead, and his kingdom will have no end. … We look for the resurrection of the dead, and the life of the world to come. Amen.”

Matthew 24 “For just as the lightning comes from the east and flashes even to the west, so will the coming of the Son of Man be.”

Acts 1:10 "They were looking intently up into the sky as he was going, when suddenly two men dressed in white stood beside them. “Men of Galilee,” they said, “why do you stand here looking into the sky? This same Jesus, who has been taken from you into heaven, will come back in the same way you have seen him go into heaven.”

“Some have concluded Christ is to come down in person to strike His great adversary, and that this will be the day when He will appear in His great glory and majesty. The interpretation is incorrect. St Thomas and St John Chrysostom explain the words (quem Jesus destruet illustration adversus sui”) is “Who the Lord will destroy with the brightness of His coming”

St Paul (spiritu oris sui) “With the Spirit of His mouth”

Here, Revelation 11- But after the three and a half days “the breath of life from God” entered them, and they stood on their feet, and terror struck those who saw them. Then they heard a loud voice from heaven saying to them, “Come up here.” And they went up to heaven in a cloud, while their enemies looked on.

This is what I was saying earlier, many take it on faith they will have time to repent, nothing indicates that to be the case, and certainly not from my own experience here. More than likely in a flash of a moment you will be at the end of the line and you will “then” surely realize your life is truly in the hands of Jesus Christ. Perhaps a few moments of perfect contrition will be enough. I would discourage this path and stick to the teachings of the Church as you may not have even a few moments.
 
Of course

What does it have to do with two separate paradigms? If the Pope for example stated with Bab the jury is out, I would agree that’s the truth and we would all be agreement that’s Gods truth? Yes or no?
this totally depends on if the Pope’s decisions and words are Truth or not. There are 5 billion people on earth who would so “no” they are not…

Which then puts the fate of your soul squarely on your own hands. The Pope has been known to even be unable to salvage His own souls’ fate in the past, so why would you allow him to be the decision maker for your souls fate?
And you mention this as to suggest what? How I should view Bab? :But he wrote the Pope who I follow.
I write this because Peter, Paul, John etc etc did not consult the Jewish Rabbinic order in order to make a decision for them on whether they should follow Jesus or not.

The Bab did not write to the Pope, Baha’u’llah did.

I think you are getting confused, the Bab and Baha’u’llah are two separate Individuals.

The Pope was written to so that the entirety of Catholicism can be notified “through” him that Jesus had Returned. He ignored it…to quote Fulton Sheen “The truth is the truth even if nobody believes it, and a lie is still a lie, even if everybody believes it.”

So what is the Truth, and how do you know it through proper investigation?
Your have to elaborate clearly on the “IN HIMSELF” part, sounds like that tough language area. Its a red flag to me as its foreign to my Christian ears.
“IN HIMSELF” here means without the need to go check through other avenues. You are waiting for the Pope to give you verification about the Divinity of the Bab. this is like Peter going to the local Rabbis to check on the Divinity of Jesus.

If Peter wouldn’t do that, and John wouldn’t do that, then why would you?
I’m stretched out attempting to. I think finally I’m really starting to get it with Paul and Peter. I’m feeling it more now that I use to. Sacraments of their Church is a “must”. Its a tough one wrapping the mind around the RP?
Not sure what RP stands for here?
I speed read through it. That said I think you guys are polite and somewhat balanced.
I guess thats a complement 🙂
But no I believe nothing about Bab. Not feeling it, it could be me. I’m reading a story not feeling the movement of the Wind, the Holy Spirit rushing over me. That’s why I recommend the Sacraments of the Church. Jaw dropping miracle. That’s why when new 200 yo revelations appear I check with the Pope.
Again, did St. Ignatius of Antioch check with Jewish authorities before he converted to Christianity? Did St. Teresa Benedicta ask the Rabbis about Jesus before becoming a Catholic?

You say you did not feel the Holy Spirit rushing over you when reading about the life of the Bab. That is fine and well and if you have done yourself justice by giving it your best shot to test the Spirit of the Bab and Baha’u’llah then you have done your duty before God 👍
The same who gave him the Keys to the Kingdom and which He built His Church upon.
I’m glad you agree here. But what we don’t agree on, at least I, is that the Bab is anything divine whatsoever. Like I said, you guys are cool, but I don’t see anything divine. I could be Christian brainwashed but I believe God is Jesus Christ. The Living God, no other, no more to come, who came back for the lost sheep. And that I will live eternally divinized with Him, Jesus Christ in His Kingdom. Shocking as it may be He instituted a Church, thus the Pope.
This is very honest and worthy of attention Gary.

If you have personally tested the Spirit of the Bab and Baha’u’llah, as I have said already, you have fulfilled your duty towards God and carried out the admonitions of 1 John.

I commend you dear friend 🙂

👍
I notice its mentioned here and there, but no I don’t see that either. “Return of John the Baptist (without ever having met Him)”
What is it you are looking for Gary?

Was John the Baptist the return of the Prophet Elijah? Jesus declared it, then others recognized its truth. The question you could ask is what are the spiritual qualities necessary to be shown forth in order that a “spiritual return” can be established?
Come-on that’s a bit of a stretch? That’s up there with ancient aliens now. How, show me how you see that. Lets go through it word for word.
I geneuinely see that Gary. Maybe you are blinded by Christian thinking. Maybe I am blinded by Baha’i thinking.

But all I know is that I have done a very thorough and extensive research into Biblical Christianity AND the Baha’i Faith. Can you claim to have done the same?

What would you like to go through “word for word”?
I’m glad you feel this way, but we have to test that spirit and maybe think about it and be silent as the Pope is silent?
Christ is risen. Jesus is God. Bab is under review by the Pope and Christs Bishops.
Is testing something a silent act. How long does it take to test something. The Revelations of the Bab and Baha’u’llah have been around for over 150 years. It cant take that long for testing to take place. I have a feeling that there is no testing going on at all, but I hope I am wrong…

.
 
How is it blasphemy to point out that Abraham was a sinner like anybody else?

And can you make that last part more clear?
Because in todays standards He may have been a sinner, but in His time He was the Light of God for humanity.

 
So your actions are a sign of your Divinity?

Sinner - not Divine
Not sinner - Divine.

Is that your conclusion?

.
 
Why today’s standards?
Because moral and ethical truths are relative.

Are women supposed to be subordinate to men, and silent in the assembly as Paul suggested?

You don’t know what was moral and what was immoral during Abraham’s time and social circumstance…

.
 
I can sense you don’t like the Baha’is Jharek…

…may I ask if we have offended you?

I am trying to sincerely understand…

.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top