How do you ascertain God sees only one? Even if you imagine God is only at the end of all time looking back, He would be able to see that I had a decision to make and what my decision was. But that doesn’t negate the fact that He would know I had a choice.
From my point of view, I choose X. But we established the very fact that I could have chosen X or Y makes them both real. The fact that a choice existed makes it real for both myself and for God.
Yes I can. The other choice is not a choice -it was a thought (which God of course also knows). It is the road not taken -the flavor not chosen.
Good. So the other choice is an illusion. Now it is your turn to show that fatalism is not real when only one choice is always real.
No.
Future cannot be possibly two.
We are talking about choice, what you perceive and think you can perform.
Your still trying to think of God like we think of you or me in time. God is outside of time…
Good then no question remains. God sees me with a choice to make (chocolate or vanilla) and God sees that I choose chocolate not vanilla. The vanilla still exists -I simply do not choose it but chocolate.
Now, we have two roads to go. Your road or my road.
I have already explained all above.
Your choice, the mental one. It is either illusion or real. Pick one.
It is a real choice. Choices are made interiorly. And then carried out - exteriorly. God sees all - both the real options before me, the real thoughts in my mind, the real choice in my will and the carrying out of that choice (chocolate) in action outside of my mind - though heading towards my mind via my stomach
No you didn’t. You have two options X and Y. One is real, lets call it X, because you can choose it and another one is an illusion, Y. It is always like this. All options, mental one are illusions but one.
No both are real.
Ok. You choose X and then you rewind time. Can you choose Y this time or you only choose X always no matter how many times you rewind time?
And future implies linear time, which is not for God.