Feminisms effect on women

  • Thread starter Thread starter Pope_Gregory
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Huh?

Could you give a citation or two of when the Church has condemned feminism?
Pius XI in his Encyclical *Casti connubii *

*“Neither this emancipation of the woman is real, nor is it the reasonable and worthy liberty convenient to the Christian and noble mission of the woman and wife. It is the corruption of the feminine nature and maternal dignity, as well as the perversion of all the family, since the husband lacks his wife, the children their mother, and the entire family her vigilant guard.

"On the contrary, this false liberty and unnatural equality with man is harmful for the woman herself, because at the moment that she steps down from the royal domestic throne to which she was raised by the Gospel, quickly she will fall into the ancient slavery of Paganism, becoming a mere instrument of man” (n. 76). *

And of course HUman Vitae and also the churches condemnation of Modernism, which is a component of feminism.

And VATICAN ANNOUNCES LETHAL EFFECTS OF FEMINISM

washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A30761-2004Jul31.html
news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/3940719.stm

The pope approved the document, titled “Letter to the Bishops of the Catholic Church on the Collaboration of Men and Women in the Church and the World.”

vis.pcn.net/doc/040731x_en.htm
 
No worries…just thought I would point out the irony of it.

As for a solution…what’s wrong with simply letting women be women and men be men? I mean, what was wrong with a mother staying at home to raise her family? She was given that role because females are naturally more nurturing…why must women think they have to work out of the home to compete with their husbands?

You know…basically…the solution is pretty simple…we should follow the example of the Holy Family…period.
Ok I understand the importance of being a mother b/c of those wonderful gifts…but I think we can also use those gifts to bring compassion to the medical field as nurses/doctors and as teachers/counselors. All careers that women do well in. I do not have a job to compete with my husband b/c I’m not married yet. Nor do I have a job to compete with my fiance. I have a job b/c I feel God has called me to be a teacher/counselor. I love my students as if they were my own and show them compassion when they have difficulty with the material. Some students just need someone to listen to them. They are college freshmen so it is a rough transition to be living away from home. I am excited to be able to use my God given gifts! Some women don’t have to be in the work field and are happy at home. So be it. Let them. But don’t expect me to.
 
juliamajor;3617012]

I know a handful who have. Well, at least they have claimed to be, like it was some sort of “look at me” medal to be worn and told to anyone who will listen. Hell, my own sister claimed that she was, but, she really wasn’t. Regret for having sex, is not rape.

But of course, real rape does happen, I am not doubting that one bit. But with false accusations flying around?? You want equality? Then let’s be equal. I want just as aggressive men’s protection laws.
Medal? most of the women I know have hidden it from everyone. After my daughter starting acting out of character-and it took a couple of years of family suffering- she finally told us what had happened to her. She told me first-she was afraid to tell her dad-afraid she’d be rejected by him like her best friend had been. It was only after she told her dad that things started to improve and real therapy and healing could happen. It’s still a very deep dark secret that she doesn’t voice to anyone- so as far as a medal-nonsense.
 
That;s great that you had the courage to report it really is. However you have to understand why many people donlt. The thought of having to go into court and face the man or woman that raped them is very frightening for many people. Not to mention I imagine humilating in some ways. I mean there is going to be a defence you know? which is going to try to discredit their experience in everyway they can.

As for guilt people feel a whole slew of emotions after rape. And guilt is just one of them. One reason a person might feel guilt for instance is because they might be wondering if something they did lead to the rape. Like oh was it because I wore that somewhat revealing? Was it because I went to that one place? So on and so forth.
Well, in many cases…you don’t have to go to court to face the person…you file the report and the state takes care of the rest…that’s how it was in my case. I didn’t have to do anything other than report the incident the night it occurred…sure I was distraught and upset, but I did report it because I wasn’t about to let another female become a victim.

I agree, many deal with guilt…don’t think I didn’t, but fact of the matter is…none of that makes up for not reporting a crime, especially when one is going to go around “citing” it later on…which many women I have met, have done.

It doesn’t mean I am not sympathetic, I just wonder if they throw the word rape around, sort of like when liberals call conservatives “nazi’s”…if you truly understand the meaning of the word, you would never so casually “drop” it or easily call someone such.
 
Male-female relationships should be based on mutual respect. Feminism, or Women’s Lib, as presented by the National Organization for Women was divisive, victimizing and not solution oriented. It was anti-family and healing was not the goal, only an eternal struggle against the eternal enemy - men.

The primary issues of our time revolve around human sexuality. One in four girls in the United States have an STD. Artificial contraception. Cohabitation and a turn away from committed, lifelong relationships. Embryonic stem cell research. Abortion. Gay marriage. All of these things things have been identified as a threat to the family by the Catholic Church.

The feminism espoused by NOW in the 1970s was just another revolution - a form of class warfare. It was and is unBiblical. And it was an attempt at social engineering.

Calling prostitution an industry gives it an inappropriate normalcy.

God bless,
Ed
Ah ,yes it’s all the women’s fault society is the way it is!
 
Medal? most of the women I know have hidden it from everyone. After my daughter starting acting out of character-and it took a couple of years of family suffering- she finally told us what had happened to her. She told me first-she was afraid to tell her dad-afraid she’d be rejected by him like her best friend had been. It was only after she told her dad that things started to improve and real therapy and healing could happen. It’s still a very deep dark secret that she doesn’t voice to anyone- so as far as a medal-nonsense.
Actually, I am sorry to say, its does occur. I know several women, who sadly, casually throw the word around trying to justify their behavior and beliefs…sorry about your daughter…hope she has been able to leave it all behind her now.
 
Ok I understand the importance of being a mother b/c of those wonderful gifts…but I think we can also use those gifts to bring compassion to the medical field as nurses/doctors and as teachers/counselors. All careers that women do well in. I do not have a job to compete with my husband b/c I’m not married yet. Nor do I have a job to compete with my fiance. I have a job b/c I feel God has called me to be a teacher/counselor. I love my students as if they were my own and show them compassion when they have difficulty with the material. Some students just need someone to listen to them. They are college freshmen so it is a rough transition to be living away from home. I am excited to be able to use my God given gifts! Some women don’t have to be in the work field and are happy at home. So be it. Let them. But don’t expect me to.
You are right…but let me remind you that long before the feminist movement, it was women who were teachers and nurses. We didn’t need a “movement” to allow us access to those positions in life…as they were generally consider “female” work for the reasons you state above…women are more nurturing.

The problems I find with those who so ardently support the feminist movement is that when someone mentions that they are a “stay at home mom” they are treated as if they are something “less” than the rest. They are degraded and looked upon as if they are either 1) spoiled 2) dominated by their husbands

And as far as I know…the whole point of the “feminist movement” was supposed to be allow for CHOICE in life…yet…today, unless you emphatically agree and support the feminist movement work outside the home, you are not allow that choice…at least not with any respect given to you! Sorry to say, but even your last sentence above shows a bit of the condescension given to those who choose to stay at home.
 
Naztakuan;3617264]

If they are demanding that the Church adapt to them, their wants, or society, then yes, they should be free to leave. And the point of Church, is to praise God. And by praising God, we accept His Word and Laws. We do not tell Him that we will only practice what we want to. And we are not making it sound like a club, that is how you take it. We are just fed up with these…new, Catholics, who condone abortion and such by lobbying for it or voting for people who sustain it. There is a difference between sinning, and not accepting or “picking” which doctrine to practice. ** A sin is a mistake or weakness, the other is deliberate./**QUOTE]
Wait…what? So if an abortion is deliberate it’s not a sin?
LOL No! Having an abortion is a sin. Being a pro choice Catholic is deliberate. It is thought out, rationalized, and accepted. Abortion is a sin, supporting it as a right, is deliberate.
Sin hasn’t necessarily increased in our society but when you make it acceptable, it is planned in advance to mitigate any consequences.
Sure it has. And the frequency of those consequences, proves it.
I know what you are trying to say which is that now people are planning to sin long before they commit it, as opposed to commiting it within a brief moment of weakness.
While that may very well be true(and it is), that was not my point. EX: A person who has premarital sex has sinned. Was weak. A Catholic who chooses to willingly engage in premarital sex, is deliberate. Basically, a Cafiteria Catholic, is what I meant.
Many women who actually grew up in the pre-feminist era admitted to having sex before marriage contrary to popular belief.
That is not contrary to popular belief. When we talk about the past, we mean that it was not accepted, as you have pointed out here somewhere. And it was not anywhere near as rampandt as it is today. (Same with drugs, for that matter.)
HOWEVER,The difference was that the person you fornicated with would usually end up being your spouse within a short period of time. But now the person you fornicate with, you will probably never see again and definetly not marry. Premarital sex was frowned upon by society true, but it doesn’t mean teenagers didn’t sneak and fool around ever. It was just more shameful to talk about. Also, it’s frequency was probably even lower. As opposed to engaging in planned fornication every week, young people may have engaged in such behavior on rare unplanned occassions like just one time the year before they got married.
LOL Ok, so we are parroting each other! LOL Cool. And many of us who have something to say about topics on these forums, actually do research before we spout out. We are well aware that “stuff” went on in the past, but we are also aware that it was nothing like today, and THAT, is what we are fighting. Me personally, compare then to today. See the differences, and try to bring some of the past back into society.
I think that’s what modern sex education actually means when they say “abstinence doesn’t work”. *Of course *it works BUT people are weak so if a person firmly decides not to have sex and they happen to experience a severe moment of weakness, they haven’t planned for it so the result ispregnancy
.

That is what they mean, I agree. But where the sex ed people screw up, is that they do not realize that they are telling kids that it is ok, and even worse, that it is acceptable. With all the sex ed that has been going on, STD’s among teens is rising at a nasty rate. So apparently their method has failed. Girls fear a baby, more than an STD. AND, it is because that is what they are taught today.
 
Originally Posted by Dale_M
Huh?
Could you give a citation or two of when the Church has condemned feminism?
Pius XI in his Encyclical Casti connubii

“Neither this emancipation of the woman is real, nor is it the reasonable and worthy liberty convenient to the Christian and noble mission of the woman and wife. It is the corruption of the feminine nature and maternal dignity, as well as the perversion of all the family, since the husband lacks his wife, the children their mother, and the entire family her vigilant guard.

"On the contrary, this false liberty and unnatural equality with man is harmful for the woman herself, because at the moment that she steps down from the royal domestic throne to which she was raised by the Gospel, quickly she will fall into the ancient slavery of Paganism, becoming a mere instrument of man” (n. 76).

And of course HUman Vitae and also the churches condemnation of Modernism, which is a component of feminism.

And VATICAN ANNOUNCES LETHAL EFFECTS OF FEMINISM

washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn…2004Jul31.html
news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/3940719.stm

The pope approved the document, titled “Letter to the Bishops of the Catholic Church on the Collaboration of Men and Women in the Church and the World.”

vis.pcn.net/doc/040731x_en.htm
 
Well, in many cases…you don’t have to go to court to face the person…you file the report and the state takes care of the rest…that’s how it was in my case. I didn’t have to do anything other than report the incident the night it occurred…sure I was distraught and upset, but I did report it because I wasn’t about to let another female become a victim.

I agree, many deal with guilt…don’t think I didn’t, but fact of the matter is…none of that makes up for not reporting a crime, especially when one is going to go around “citing” it later on…which many women I have met, have done.

It doesn’t mean I am not sympathetic, I just wonder if they throw the word rape around, sort of like when liberals call conservatives “nazi’s”…if you truly understand the meaning of the word, you would never so casually “drop” it or easily call someone such.
Yeah- my kid’s rape is just a cover for my nefarious liberal ways- I’ve encouraged my daughter to be more open about it- difficult for her- just as I’ve been open about my depression-I used to hide the fact -but why should I - I’ve done nothing Wrong- My kid did nothing wrong.
 
Yeah- my kid’s rape is just a cover for my nefarious liberal ways- I’ve encouraged my daughter to be more open about it- difficult for her- just as I’ve been open about my depression-I used to hide the fact -but why should I - I’ve done nothing Wrong- My kid did nothing wrong.
I didn’t call you a liberal…I love the selective reading…sigh…

I stated that many women do throw around the word “rape” just as liberals throw around the word “nazi”…when you truly know the horror of both…as I am sure you do from your daughter’s experience, you WOULDN’T do so.
 
And as far as I know…the whole point of the “feminist movement” was supposed to be allow for CHOICE in life…yet…today, unless you emphatically agree and support the feminist movement work outside the home, you are not allow that choice…at least not with any respect given to you! Sorry to say, but even your last sentence above shows a bit of the condescension given to those who choose to stay at home.
I have said in previous statements that stay at home moms have a talent and patience that I do not possess. Due to my personality characteristics I would go absolutely crazy if I had to be one. I think they have it harder than women who work do and the fact that they enjoy it is even more commendable. I never meant to put down women who stay at home I just know that I could not mentally/physically do it and would never want to be expected to. This is my personal choice and thankfully I have that choice.

I only consider myself a feminist in that women have the right to hold a job, vote, be paid same wage for talent/education/experience. making sure we have the basic unalienable rights. I do not approve of the crazy fanatical women who say we don’t need men. We do. We were made Adam and Eve Male and Female for a reason. I just don’t like men telling me that I am inferior b/c I have certain body parts or that I am less intelligent or less morally capable than they are based on my gender.

And yes I have been told point blank these things
 
Dale_M;3617370]
I don’t think the verse has anything to do with feminism. It was an explanation of why things were as they were, not a statement of how things should be for all times.
No, but back to post# 210, you said:

" Its not like most of history when housework and obtaining food were full-time occupations which necessitated strict sex roles/division of labor. We have advanced beyond that, and there is no reason to continue the submission of women to men."

You consider that submission of women to men, but it you also made it sound as if the roles were out of neccessity, rather than men oppressing women. You even said that it was like most of history. LOL well, yeah, historically speaking, it was ALL of history thus far, minus the last 40 years or so.

My point is that, the breakdown of those roles today, have had negative consequences on society as a whole. And that there is ample reason to place men and women back, into those roles.

The verse actually seems to suggest, that that was how it should be. And I agree, for society’s sake.
 
Ah ,yes it’s all the women’s fault society is the way it is!
???/

Or to put it another way ???

A small group of radicals, supported by the media, have subverted male-female relationships, and lowered women to a “permanent victim” class.

Peace,
Ed
 
I didn’t call you a liberal…I love the selective reading…sigh…

I stated that many women do throw around the word “rape” just as liberals throw around the word “nazi”…when you truly know the horror of both…as I am sure you do from your daughter’s experience, you WOULDN’T do so.
apparently selective reading is rampant here:)
 
???/

Or to put it another way ???

A small group of radicals, supported by the media, have subverted male-female relationships, and lowered women to a “permanent victim” class.

Peace,
Ed
yep- just the reaction i expected
 
My point is that, the breakdown of those roles today, have had negative consequences on society as a whole. And that there is ample reason to place men and women back, into those roles.
Okay. I don’t agree with the point about restoring traditional male and female roles, but I respect your opinion.
The verse actually seems to suggest, that that was how it should be.
Again, I disagree, but your opinion is equally as valid as mine.
 
There’s no excuse for false rape accusations or not protecting the rights of the accused in rape cases. If you think there is, then you’re the one with the problem.

Always nice to argue against a straw man. Unfortunately it’s just a little intellectually dishonest.

I accept zero blame for that. There is absolutely nothing wrong with my attitude. And I absolutely refuse to kowtow to the typical female emotional-manipulative tactics you are attempting to use here.

You have selective outrage. What about men whose lives are ruined by false accusations? Do they count? Where’s your outrage towards all these women who, apparently, are making false claims of rape.

Yeah well I could say the same thing about being falsely accused of a crime. Women don’t have a monopoly on suffering and claims of compassion. Men are human too and deserving of just as considerations as such. I have nothing but contempt for “womenfirsters”.
You never mention fathers who unjustly accuse their daughters’ lovers of rape. This was a common occurance in more racially tense times(like30 years ago or less). It was not uncommon for a black young man to be either jailed or lynched for engaging in consenual sex with a white woman. This was an act of pride on the fathers part. These men thought themselves superior to black men in every way so the idea that their daughter willingly had lain with one was too much . So such men were often accused falsly of rape. That’s where those stereotypes that black men and their supposed feral sexual nature come from. These rape charges were instigated by the parents out of racism not by the girl/woman herself. So of course I understand the whole falsley accused thing. Our fathers, brothers, and cousins have dealt with racial profiling since like…forever .

All of these myths politicized the issue of black on white rape in the South. White southern bigots used rape fears to rationalize oppression; white southern race liberals, and their northern allies, used Freudian analysis to debunk rape myths as mere projection and denial of white men’s sexual guilt and fear. Both sides agreed, however, that any white woman in the South could get any black man killed simply by “crying rape,” whether any crime had occurred or not…

have you ever been randomly pulled over by the cops because you “fit the description”? My father has. Even when he was driving his children around in a mini van with his wife. Apparently the African American male is the most feared out of all the other men. So Dale, if you’re white, be happy you don’t “fit the description” Sometimes when the a white male commits a rape, the woman…for some reason STILL claims the perpetrator was black. I have no idea why.
It’s gone on for so long that we just laugh about it. We’ve all been followed around the store being expected to steal things. even me. And I’m a black female.
You feel that all men are always accused unjustly of rape. I have to disagree. The Duke men were falsley accused because they were athletes and they were well to do. The young woman had expected some sort of pay out to keep quiet just like Kobe. The type of woman that just runs around accusing women on rape isn’t most women. Those women are in the same category as prostitutes. Except hookers usually demand the money before hand instead of after the fact. Maybe less women would claim rape if they were licensed to recieve payment for their “services”.lol…I’m kidding!
 
I have said in previous statements that stay at home moms have a talent and patience that I do not possess. Due to my personality characteristics I would go absolutely crazy if I had to be one. I think they have it harder than women who work do and the fact that they enjoy it is even more commendable. I never meant to put down women who stay at home I just know that I could not mentally/physically do it and would never want to be expected to. This is my personal choice and thankfully I have that choice.

I only consider myself a feminist in that women have the right to hold a job, vote, be paid same wage for talent/education/experience. making sure we have the basic unalienable rights. I do not approve of the crazy fanatical women who say we don’t need men. We do. We were made Adam and Eve Male and Female for a reason. I just don’t like men telling me that I am inferior b/c I have certain body parts or that I am less intelligent or less morally capable than they are based on my gender.

And yes I have been told point blank these things
Good for you! 😉 Myself…I refuse to associate with the “feminist” movement in all ways…because I believe that we could simply call what you describe above as simply human rights. I don’t believe anyone should given priviledges or be ridiculed and denied access to education because they are male or female, color of their skin, ethnicity, etc.

And I don’t believe that most men today want to “dominate” and “rule” over their spouse…they simply want a wife who will be nurturing and loving, rather than one who wants to compete constantly.

I do believe men get a bad rap today and I do believe that one of the reasons that so many are becoming “gay” is because we have been drilling into their brains for so many years now…1) we are the “same” as you 2) you need to get in “touch” with your femine side…sigh…

🙂 😉
 
Carolinagirl411;3617378]
Ok Leftdestroyer and Seeking Catholic
You guys seem to be the main male voices in this discussion arguing against the women and how they aren’t considering the damages done by feminism.
That’s dominant males.😉
If you don’t mind…Outline how you would like women to be.
Anyway prior to the 60’s.
I say a woman should hold a job, you guys argue with that but you also argue against a woman mooching money off of a man…so what is the deal?
I did not go there with the mooching part. I say it is the job of the man to be the supporter and the protector.
Are there any positive effects of feminism for women/men? Or do you prefer the victorian society where women are covered from neck to toe, and stay at home to have as many children as possible, are not allowed to say no to their husbands if they don’t feel like sex due to illness or just lack of interest, and aren’t allowed to leave the house without male escorts. Also they aren’t even allowed to vote!
You love going to the extremes don’t you? Yes, having children(plural) is a good thing. She does housework, and I do outside work. She raises the kids while I work, and at night, we both do it. We get a babysitter on Friday night, for our alone time. If she wants to work a part timer when the kids are not around or at night, just to get away, then I have no problem with that. Choosing school or career over family, I do not like. HOWEVER, I wouldn’t have a problem with college so much, if more women would have chose to be moms. My issue is that they are taught(told) not to! That college is the ONLY option for them. I have no issue with a smart woman, as a matter of fact, I require it. But a swwet, nice, airhead is not a bad person either, contrary to what the feminists say. I have everthing I want in poster Neat62. She is my girlfriend. A masters degree, wants children, wants to be a stay at home, wants to cook, wants to be a housewife. Ironically, feminism has kept us single for too long, BUT, it has actually allowed us to meet. (I called her a feminist on another Catholic blog lol) She acts girly, not arrogant, not overeducated, and does not ACT, overly confident. Sometimes she does in certain situations, but not with me. If she attacks my ego, then we will have problems. She knows when and how to let me win. That may seem subserviant to you, but try it sometime. You may find a little…power, in it.
and also how would you like society to be in your perfect world in regard to rape laws or whatever laws you seem to have problems with!
Well, I cannot respond to that. I only know that stuff happens on both sides. I also know that the courts favor women, suiting as feminism has been mainstreamed in society, as I have mentioned before. Want proof? The Duke players were tried in the media even before the trial. DO NOT deny that! You KNOW they were. What happend to the “victim”? NOTHING! I want justice. Put her in jail.

I have no specifics I would like to see done about rape, cause I don’t spend too much time on that subject.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top