well since you are a âphd scientistâ (whatever that means) I guess we are all wrong and must convert to mormonism or face eternity in hellâŚ
Wow. I thought it would be clear that a PhD scientist is a scientist with a PhD⌠in a science. I know enough not to reveal a lot of personal info on a forum like this, but since you asked Iâll just say that my PhD is not in population genetics, but it is in a field that required me to study some evolutionary biology (a related subject.) Iâm a university professor, and an active researcher with federal grants. So, as I said, I can read the arguments and make my own evaluation of how conclusive they are. And they arenât very conclusive.
And no majick, thatâs not why youâre going to spend an eternity in hell.
you choose a strange red herring in the DNA subject but okay, what non-LDS accredited scholar has done any peer reviewed work that shows that native americans are descended from israelites?
Why is it a red herring? One of the ex-Mormons here posted something about it in this very threadâsee post #104 by xmormon. (I see you didnât object to it being a red herring back then, though.
I see you have also chosen to ignore the supposedly âdivineâ revelations of early LDS prophets and apostles to ârewriteâ the BoM as some kind of LGT that was secluded from any other indigenous peoples. narrow reading indeed. (principal ancestors, land kept hidden from all others, millions of warriors, no mention of any common atributes of pre-columbian cultures) whatâs your degree in? multilevel marketing?
I donât ignore those revelations. I do think that pretty much all the native americans around now are descended from the Lehi colony. I just think that they have lots of other ancestors, as well.
And FYI, do you have any idea how âLimited Geography Theoriesâ of the Book of Mormon came about? By reading the Book of Mormon. If you pay attention to descriptions of distances and travel times, it is clear that the whole civilization was in an area around a ânarrow neck of land,â and a few hundred miles from North to South. So do you really mean ârewrite,â or have you just not read the Book of Mormon carefully? As for all the other objections you mention, some of them are somewhat reasonable, but not conclusive by any means. See Jeff Lindsayâs LDS FAQ website if you really want information about what Mormons typically say about them.
nice rabbit trail on the trinity as well. do you think that will mask the original trinitarian view of JS that is STILL in the BoM? or do you really hope to reconcile theosis with eternal progression?
Wait a minute. âXmormonâ also previously mentioned that ârabbit trailâ on this thread. So once again, you didnât give a peep when he said it, but now youâre acting like your the ever-so-patient martyr who has to stop the Mormon trolls from changing the subject. Nice try.
In any case, I understand that the Book of Mormon says that the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost are âone God.â I understand that Jesus is called âthe Father of Heaven and Earthâ several times. But I also know that the Book of Mormon depicts Jesus praying to the Father in Heaven (3 Ne. 17:15). I also know that the BofM has Jesus saying the he was âwithâ the Father in the beginning (3 Ne. 9:15), and ascended up to be with the Father after his resurrection (3 Ne. 26:15). And 600 years earlier, Nephi reported hearing the voices of both the Father and the pre-incarnate Son (2 Ne. 31:11-15). I also know that Joseph Smithâs Book of Moses, written a few months after the Book of Mormon, reports a 3-way conversation between the Father, Jesus, and Satan.
So the truth is that from the Book of Mormon, we get the idea that in some way the Trinity is âOne,â and in some way they are âmore than one.â Gee, thatâs the same thing you can get by quoting similar passages in the Bible. And yet, the real issue between Catholics and Mormons is not âwhetherâ they are âone,â but âhowâ they are âone.â The only biblical passage I can find that seems to address this question is in John 17, where Jesus prayed to the Father that his disciples would be one together, and one in Jesus and the Father âasâ (meaning âin the same wayâ) Jesus and the Father are one. Ok, so however the Trinity is âone,â we can be âoneâ with God in the same way.
Can you find another passage that says âhowâ the Trinity is âoneâ?
Iâm just wondering which LDS missionary board whyme pulled you off of.
Donât know him, and I donât actually participate in any LDS boards of any type.