Free Will when God ‘Wills’ you to marry someone

  • Thread starter Thread starter angel83
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
No, no, no. Do not set him up with a spiritual advisor. He should make his own decision on that.

Are you telling me where you are located, residentially, there is not a priest or other disinterested party, and nobody can provide you advice on this, other than your mom (not that she’s not a good person, just that she might be too close to the situation)?

And what does your mom say about all this?
 
Oh of course… I would let him decide and pick. I’m just saying it does scare me because I know even the best spiritual directors are ‘off’ sometimes. I’ve heard too many stories. I guess maybe I’d just have to trust…
My mom said based on EVERYTHING that I’m not supposed to be with him and that I need to stop losing sleep over this. She brought up EVERY SINGLE point here that has been made.
She actually wanted to show me that her opinions were’t the way they were because she was close to me and the situation and she encouraged me to post here and to let ‘the body of christ’ confirm it. Which you guys have confirmed her points exactly.
 
40.png
angel83:
cause there is 0 physical attraction. The personality thing, although he has all Christ like qualities I love, isn’t really there either.
I knew it 😃

I can understand the “neutral” feeling later growing into something else. It is possible but unlikely. For a guy the neutral feelings are bad news. Usually the neutral feeling from the woman ends up leading to the dreaded “friend zone” where no man wants to be. There is no escaping the friend zone. I once heard of a man who did, but it turned out to be an urban legend 😉 .

Nope, doesn’t happen. And that is why this guy is desperate. He is trapped in the friend zone. (Insert Twilight Zone music here).

The neutral feelings can grow into something as long as they don’t get sidetracked into the friend zone.
 
HaHa SemperJase, you’re too funny! And I agree often times the neutral feelings don’t develop… so then the ‘God please no/I’m crying myself to sleep’ feelings woudn’t either. That combined with ‘free will’, knowing my heart is a gift to give to whomever I choose… and I’m beginning to feel relieved and safe!
 
40.png
angel83:
Oh of course… I would let him decide and pick. I’m just saying it does scare me because I know even the best spiritual directors are ‘off’ sometimes. I’ve heard too many stories. I guess maybe I’d just have to trust…
My mom said based on EVERYTHING that I’m not supposed to be with him and that I need to stop losing sleep over this. She brought up EVERY SINGLE point here that has been made.
She actually wanted to show me that her opinions were’t the way they were because she was close to me and the situation and she encouraged me to post here and to let ‘the body of christ’ confirm it. Which you guys have confirmed her points exactly.
Recently I heard an audio recording from a seminar where a man was actually training other men to seduce women.

Your friend could stand to hear one of the points he made, that men don’t understand. Maybe this is ridiculously obvious to a woman, but I doubt most men understand it.

That is, if a woman forms an impression is not attracted to a man, there is nothing the man can do to change it. However, if she is attracted to him, there is nothing SHE can do about it to convince herself otherwise.

The point I see here is this guy can’t logically convince you that you are supposed to be with him. If you don’t believe it, then don’t fall for word games. Either that or this guy lecturing is all washed up…

Alan
 
To help maybe calm thing down at bit, you might want to pray to st. joseph [patron of workers] and start praying to his guardian angel to soften his ‘want’.

Ewwww, the evil friend zone :eek: :). I think he is pushing for the timetable [and wants] to be on his terms and not God’s (more of a fear thing).
Oh, if you need help with those pesky demons… keep holy water by your bedside [bless yourself and room]. pray to st. michael or st. harvey… you are in my prayers.
 
40.png
Bulldog:
Ewwww, the evil friend zone :eek: :). I think he is pushing for the timetable [and wants] to be on his terms and not God’s (more of a fear thing).
That’s a great point! I didn’t even think of it from that way, but from his view the “friend zone” can be very troubling indeed. One might then wonder what proportion of his motivation comes from a) her, b) the project, and c) some synergistic combination.

If he’s committed to her and not the project, and she does not reciprocate, that doesn’t bode well for him, her, or the project having any part of each other. I know from experience and a brief engagement that one can easily be mesmerized into thinking one is in support of a woman’s project when it’s really the woman they are interested in.

Alan
 
40.png
angel83:
Oh of course… I would let him decide and pick. I’m just saying it does scare me because I know even the best spiritual directors are ‘off’ sometimes. I’ve heard too many stories. I guess maybe I’d just have to trust…
My mom said based on EVERYTHING that I’m not supposed to be with him and that I need to stop losing sleep over this. She brought up EVERY SINGLE point here that has been made.
She actually wanted to show me that her opinions were’t the way they were because she was close to me and the situation and she encouraged me to post here and to let ‘the body of christ’ confirm it. Which you guys have confirmed her points exactly.
Your mother sounds like a very wise woman.
 
40.png
AlanFromWichita:
I didn’t even think of it from that way, but from his view the “friend zone” can be very troubling indeed.
Yep. In Dante terms, it is the fifth circle of hell for a guy. :yup:
 
40.png
Reepicheep:
Here’s a question, Angel83:
Have you ever before heard someone say to someone else “You have to do what I want, because God told me so”? If you have, did you believe or trust the person who said that?

What you describe sounds to me like this:
Him: I want to marry you.
You: No.
(A little later)
Him: GOD wants me to marry you. He told me so.

.
Update! You guys are going to love this.
Him: I want to end up marrying you.
You: No.
(A little later)
Him: GOD wants me to marry you. He told me so.

Me: No. (Brought to him all of the points given to me by my revelation, my mom, and the rest of the body of Christ)

Him: Well I’ve been praying about this really hard. I now see that I don’t have physical attraction for you and the chemistry isn’t there. But God is still telling me you are ‘the one’ and I have to trust that he will bring it.

Can you believe the games the devil is bringing on me???

I’m so happy because I feel like I have been given this trust that God would never shoot me with cupid’s arrow unwillingly.

A big part of his point now though is that there are people who are like “I don’t like you… no way ever” and they do develop feelings down the line. But I don’t feel this isn’t the case for ‘repulsed ewwww’ feelings towards somone. God forcing love potion feelings when I’m against it would take away my free will. How can I convince him when he brings me stories of people who dislike each other but eventually fall for each other?

(Edit to say that he isn’t pushing this on me. This is simply his one and only response to what I shared with him. He wants to drop it)
 
Drop it. He doesn’t want to be convinced. If he brings it up again, TELL SOMEBODY IN CHARGE. Whether you want to admit or not, he is pushing toward harassment.

Listen to your mom!!! Ask her advice for a priest for YOU. Don’t give him any encouragement or hope by even finding him a priest. except for work, leave him alone.
 
What “Outin” said. This is certainly on the border of harassment - if it isn’t already there. Such a mindset as he has developed could become quite dangerous, so please speak to your pastor, your mother, and anyone else who could deal with him. I repeat, who could deal with him - NOT you. Stay away, and if need be, remove yourself from the work that puts you in his company.
 
40.png
angel83:
A big part of his point now though is that there are people who are like “I don’t like you… no way ever” and they do develop feelings down the line. But I don’t feel this isn’t the case for ‘repulsed ewwww’ feelings towards somone. God forcing love potion feelings when I’m against it would take away my free will. How can I convince him when he brings me stories of people who dislike each other but eventually fall for each other?
Come on Angel, haven’t you ever read Harlequinn Romances? :eek: That is the driving force and underlying principle for all 58,000 of their books. 😉
 
Loren 1of6:
Come on Angel, haven’t you ever read Harlequinn Romances? :eek: That is the driving force and underlying principle for all 58,000 of their books. 😉
…That and descriptions of maritial acts generally right before a marriage is entered that flirt with, and sometimes cross into, pornography of words…
 
40.png
angel83:
A big part of his point now though is that there are people who are like “I don’t like you… no way ever” and they do develop feelings down the line. But I don’t feel this isn’t the case for ‘repulsed ewwww’ feelings towards somone. God forcing love potion feelings when I’m against it would take away my free will. How can I convince him when he brings me stories of people who dislike each other but eventually fall for each other?

(Edit to say that he isn’t pushing this on me. This is simply his one and only response to what I shared with him. He wants to drop it)
You don’t have to convince him. You have the right and even the obligation to say “no” because he obviously has no clue what the word “no” means. Your life with this guy will be a living hell. There may be a distant chance in the future but if you go into business with him most likely he will take that as some sort of halfway-to-a-promise.

In more crude terms, he is letting his “biology” do the talking for him, and it is causing him to be rude, imposing, and basically I certainly cannot tell but I would be astonished if he didn’t also routinely sin with you in his mind… after all he seems to respect no limits on what he can get away with.

He isn’t pushing this on you, but he threw it out there for you to consider which is basically the same thing although I believe him in that he has likely fooled himself.

Trust me, young men aren’t all that sophisticated as you’re giving this guy credit for. He’s a snake oil salesman. Maybe he will turn out to be honest and true, but one thing he doesn’t seem to understand is respect for your feelings. It isn’t that he doesn’t care about your feelings; more likely he is completelyi clueless even though he pretends to be all knowing and caring. Yeesh. When I was on haitus from the Church, I found myself playing some of these mind games. It can get women into bed sometimes even as they think they have to “make sure” that they have no feelings. I’m not buying it, but then again I’m just a voice on the Internet.

Alan
 
40.png
AlanFromWichita:
You don’t have to convince him. You have the right and even the obligation to say “no” because he obviously has no clue what the word “no” means. Your life with this guy will be a living hell. There may be a distant chance in the future but if you go into business with him most likely he will take that as some sort of halfway-to-a-promise.

In more crude terms, he is letting his “biology” do the talking for him, and it is causing him to be rude, imposing, and basically I certainly cannot tell but I would be astonished if he didn’t also routinely sin with you in his mind… after all he seems to respect no limits on what he can get away with.

He isn’t pushing this on you, but he threw it out there for you to consider which is basically the same thing although I believe him in that he has likely fooled himself.

Trust me, young men aren’t all that sophisticated as you’re giving this guy credit for. He’s a snake oil salesman. Maybe he will turn out to be honest and true, but one thing he doesn’t seem to understand is respect for your feelings. It isn’t that he doesn’t care about your feelings; more likely he is completelyi clueless even though he pretends to be all knowing and caring. Yeesh. When I was on haitus from the Church, I found myself playing some of these mind games. It can get women into bed sometimes even as they think they have to “make sure” that they have no feelings. I’m not buying it, but then again I’m just a voice on the Internet.

Alan
The amount of vicious lies and hatred towards this person is appaling in this forum. How the truth can get so truely distorted and and blown out of proportion is amazing sometimes.

I don’t know how so many people here went down on so many tangents, but it is a real eye opener.

How do I know? Because apparently I am that snakeoil, I’m the one she talks of in this huge string of hatred here.

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=105435

Would any of you actually ever try and give objective advice, or maybe take what was presented to ya, and not add your own BS biasness or taints on it.
Most of you seem to think this guy is a louse, evil, had hidden motives… and not nearlly one of you actually tried to place yourselves in that persons shoes, and give objective advice.

We had to resort to name calling, picking apart, tearing down and thinking the absolute worst in the situtation. I appaled by the display of “advice” here in a Catholic Forum.

I never told this girl i loved her, or I wanted to Marry her. I have no clue how it esclated to this? I said, and would go on the record for this:

I told her I had feelings for her… never once that I loved her.

I told her when I searched the bottom of my heart, I felt she was the one, and I kept praying about it, in hopes it would go away or maybe I was wrong. It did not.

I told her I feel really called to be there for her, whatever happens in the long run, as I feel she may need it. And I LEFT IT AT THAT.

I’ve absolutely tried to push aside and avoid talking bout this issue from that moment forward, because I ddid not wish to hurt her anymore, nor did I ever want to.

The most important thing to me is trying to get this Ministry off the ground, and its **** like this from half you people here, that deflates people, makes them feel worthless and places serious doubt on all good things they try and do.

I wish I had no feelings for her, they have been the absolute bane of my existance and the means to tear me apart. And I try to be open about it, and tell her whats wrong… and I find an entire massive thread with hatred and lack of understanding or sympathy running amuck in it, half of you truely should be ashamed.

I have been under non stop attack for weeks, and its unbeleivable how something I said to someone that conversation lasted 15 minutes, and a few email exchanges, which I told in confidence because I was trying to be absolutely open with her, has blow up into this massive mess I find before me here.

I guess from all of this, I’ve truely learned two things.

The first is to keep your feelings inside and DO NOT share them with other people, else you may find them on forums and discussion groups with people calling you vicous names and ripping you apart. Exactly like we have here.

The other is the new lows the devil goes to in attempts to tear a person and a ministry down.

And we are supposed to be Catholics here. This is not Salem, and I am not a witch. A lack of compassion from half you people here makes me ponder, who truely are my friends, and more importantly, who can you trust?
 
HFNB06- Wow when I came back to this thread my jaw dropped to the floor. I would have never thought in a million years you would think to go on these forums as well. I didn’t think you knew about them. I hardly know what to say.

I can see how you would be upset about what people are saying and that’s why I was never going to take you here, but rather take the basic points and relay them back to you. They are saying this not knowing you as a person and please don’t take anything personally. I would have never wanted you to read all of this especially because I am very blunt here. And I still feel the same way… even after reading your thread that you linked up to I feel horrified at what you feel God is telling you- not about continuing the ministry- or about supporting me in every way possible- but that in the vision you saw yourself with me. You feel God has told you “I’m the ONE”

I know we only talked about this a few times and exchanged a few e-mails and that’s why I have kept saying on here that you are not pressuring me. I know you have not ‘proposed marriage’ but you saying distinctly that you felt God telling you I was ‘the one’ implies just that… we’ll one day end up married. Thus I titled it so and fit into the Family Life forum.

Nothing was said ‘in confidence’. I told you that I discuss EVERYTHING with my mom and she told me to take it to the body of Christ.

I AM GLAD that you brought it up and told me. I was suspicious if that’s what you thought was going to happen with us- and it was already starting to tear the ministry down. I’m glad it was brought to the light so it could be dealt with.

Just wanted to respond here but if you wish we can stop our posts on line and get spiritual direction. I do feel it’s very important that we take a break from the ministry until this gets straightened out. I know I can’t go on thinking that God might let your vision happen.

To everyone else – NFBH06 is truly a very deep self-sacrificial and caring person. I just want to make my stance known again.
 
40.png
HFNB06:
And we are supposed to be Catholics here. This is not Salem, and I am not a witch. A lack of compassion from half you people here makes me ponder, who truely are my friends, and more importantly, who can you trust?
Sorry, but your post confirms my suspicions.

You first say you didn’t tell her you love her, then in the same post said you wish you didn’t have feelings for her.

Who can you trust? People who give you an honest assessment of the situation even if it isn’t the answer you want to hear.

The assessment remains, I doubt God told you she is “the one”. I also do not think it is wise, in fact it is dangerous for two single people of the opposite sex to work in a ministry together.

Hatred here? Nope. Rather we are concerned for a young woman who is feeling pressured into something she doesn’t want. I am also a man who knows the feelings that men have and the way men approach relationships. You’re going about it the wrong way. Sorry, but you were definitely in the “friend zone”. It is disappointing if you have feelings. I know because I’ve been there. I had a street named after me there.

Don’t share your feelings? I’d say don’t pressure people. It only pushes them away. You lash out in your post like this admittedly embarrassing situation is all the fault of everyone else. Maybe you don’t like the response you got, but it is time for you to consider how your actions led to this point.

I suggest you widen your circle of friends. Get more involved in group activities. I hope you find the peace you are looking for.
 
i had a guy like that in my life. wait - no - two. they both were convinced that God was telling them i was their future spouse and that i’d be happiest with them. the first i bought the “story” even though i was NOT attracted to the guy at all. it was a miserable relationship. even after i broke up with him, he was still trying to convince me that God was telling him in prayer that i was the one. nice try, buddy, but if it was so important that God told you then He’d have told me too.

the second guy i saw it coming and just broke off the acquaintance immediately.

Angel - if this is truly God’s will, you would have peace about it, and you don’t.
 
HfN,

If it is any consolation, we are all strangers here. Even if we met you on the street we would not know you. Cyber space is a bit different then real life(thankfully).

We can only go by what we are told. There is no way on the internet that we can get both sides of the story. Based solely on what we have been told…you sound like a confused man.

Angel seeks advice here on this board, on the advice of her mom, and then shares the information with you. You then come to the board in question and do a little bit of bashing of her yourself. Perhaps you don’t realize that you are doing that but you stated that what she said happened was not true. You then continue on to basically say what she claimed you did.

I don’t know the history of your relationship. Did you ask Angel out for a date before you announced that God put your feelings about her on your heart? If you had then the young woman could have been honest with you up front or have developed emotions for you slowly and naturally. It sounds as though you came on to strong, too fast. This is very frightening to the other person.

By the way, far from bashing you, Angel has defended you several times against the charge of being manipulative. She obviously respects you and that is why it is bothering her so greatly that she might be hurting you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top