How would you fix the U.S health care system?

  • Thread starter Thread starter RCIAGraduate
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
One comment I’d like to make in general is paying attention to the “incidental” costs of healthcare. There’s a lot of stuff that isn’t strictly healthcare but can still be financially crippling. For example, if you need care that’s far away, you have to pay the costs of getting there and back. It’s even worse if it’s your child; a parent may need to be there but they can’t stay in the hospital. They need a hotel nearby. If you need regular care and are hourly, you’re also losing pay every time you go to the doctor. If you have a special diet that can cost a lot more money (and prevent you from using existing resources). If you need a modified shower, that’s more money out of your pocket to adjust it. All sorts of things.
That’s why being referred to a far away specialist probably wouldn’t work for many people. But more and more specialists are interacting with some patients electronically and not in person, face to face.
 
Last edited:
I went to a walk-in clinic a few days ago. I had a bad cold. The nurse asked me at check-in if I would want a chest x-ray.
How in the wide, wide world of sports would I know that?
 
Last edited:
Sometime you should read about the legal system of bribery, extortion, and kickbacks called PBMs—pharmacy benefits managers.

That’ll be a kick in the crisper for ya. The extraordinary levels of corruption that the PBMs engage in is astonishing. And all entirely legal ways to make a buck at others’ expense.
 
Last edited:
John Stossel maintains that an all-cash system would be far more affordable than what we have. Thus, medical savings accounts +
 
John Stossel maintains that an all-cash system would be far more affordable than what we have. Thus, medical savings accounts +
How does that work for people who don’t make enough money to have any left over at the end of the month to put some of it into a medical savings account?
 
A million and one municipal, county, parish, state and federal assistance programs. The Church. The UN. You and I.

In my own small way, I’m doing that right now by sending money to Africa so that priests and Catholic missionaries there can dig wells and give penicillin to parishioners so that they won’t die of dehydration and common infection.

That is not a dream. It is not a suggestion or plan. That is concrete.
 
Denied, how? Approval is based on need, which is primarily certified by submitting the most recent tax return. Do you mean their tax return would be kicked back?

I THINK you’re imagining there is an insurance company involved – it this system, the only insurance company is the catastrophic health insurance company. The “help” people get is from the government.
While it’s a relief to hear it won’t end up like insurers who might give a surprise denial (horror stories that are too real though I don’t recall any myself (Michael Moore’s Sicko does give its share of stories of people not being helped well by today’s health care system)), what about the people who don’t neatly fit into income guidelines, like a working-class family or individual who barely misses the eligibility cut-offs.
 
I would just note that the existence of insurance always drives up prices. When a third party is paying the bill, demand increases, and when demand increases, so do prices.
For most, for some, yes but doesn’t the insurance system (or probably even a universal or single-payer system so long as you’re not the one being denied) help those who have the most expensive issues and needs like someone with chronic conditions and/or multiple medical needs; for mental health, wouldn’t it be much easier if someone’s plan covered all their fees for weekly counseling, seeing a psychiatrist and paying for prescription, for people especially on the lower ends of the spectrum, self-pay or paying for a therapist every week seems to be challenging, what do you think can be done there?
 
Somebody will be paying the therapist. If it’s the patient, demand will tend to be lower, as will prices. If prices are high, more therapists will be drawn to the field, thereby increasing supply.
 
Well, I would note that many US counties have public health departments with free or reduced price counseling. But most importantly, I would recommend not living paycheck to paycheck.
 
Somebody will be paying the therapist. If it’s the patient, demand will tend to be lower, as will prices. If prices are high, more therapists will be drawn to the field, thereby increasing supply.
Do you think that most patients could pay for a psychiatrist out of pocket? According to statistics online, they usually charge about $500 for an initial consultation and $100 per hour after that. And would it be good for demand to be lower since that would probably mean that someone with possibly serious mental health problems isn’t getting treated. And for psychiatrists to get paid more to increase supply would make their charges even more exorbitant.
 
As others have pointed out the “problem” is the elephant in the room that no one wants to address ie the enormous insurance liability expense doctors, nurses and hospitals need to pay.
Try suing for medical malpractice in the “free healthcare heaven” that is supposed to be Europe. Good luck with that!
I have a very close friend of mine who lives over there that was given a tainted blood transfusion with Hepatitis C.
She almost died and is now living with RA as the side effect of the experimental drugs she had to take to survive the Hep C. Many died, she sued as well as many others none has seen a cent of compensation. Considering that the transfusion was given at a hospital owned and operated by the government over there.
Here if that happened how much money would the lawyers make on each side? Oh and by the way she did have to pay the lawyers over there, they won the case but no pay yet…
Believe me I have survived they “Free healthcare” and found out that A is not free and when is free is rubish.
I will rather pay and take my chances with our healthcare here any day of the week.
 
The question seems to be: How can we have socialism but not call it socialism? We know that socialism works until other people’s money runs out and that socialism is in contradiction to Church teaching - being a form of collectivism which ultimately violates human dignity.

Yet, we are a very generous and charitable nation. Lawrence Kudlow, not that it matters, but he is a Jewish convert to Catholicism, proposed a system that would be far better than O****Care.

To dismiss such informed proposals out of hand, I think, is intellectually dishonest.
 
Well, I would note that many US counties have public health departments with free or reduced price counseling.
I like this. Thank you Mr.Jim. My concern here is that local governments can only expend so much resources (plus there’s an incentive of a “race to zero” since counties and states compete with each other which seems safety nets and the people in need lose out); in this case, I’d like the federal government to help, maybe with funding community health centers or state subsidies to institutions like free clinics or safety net hospitals (I believe they already do the latter with uncompensated care but at a larger scale, maybe to accommodate more basic forms of care like preventative and primary).
But most importantly, I would recommend not living paycheck to paycheck.
I don’t think most people who are living, like seriously living “paycheck to paycheck” do so out of thier own volition: perhaps they’re stuck at a dead-end career or job, they’re struggling with living costs, especially housing, maybe even going without insurance and they’re people doing what they can, you know your definition of the working class?
 
We know that socialism works until other people’s money runs out
If I had a dime for every time this saying was trotted out and flogged, I could afford a good health care plan!
 
Last edited:
While it’s a relief to hear it won’t end up like insurers who might give a surprise denial (horror stories that are too real though I don’t recall any myself (Michael Moore’s Sicko does give its share of stories of people not being helped well by today’s health care system)
I thought I had explained it. Under my proposal, YOU are your own insurer. You make your own decisions and pay with your own money – until you reach the deductible and your catastrophic insurance policy kicks in.
what about the people who don’t neatly fit into income guidelines, like a working-class family or individual who barely misses the eligibility cut-offs.
I thought I had explained that, too. When you apply for help, you submit your tax return. The help you receive will be based on your declared income.
 
I grew up in a pretty small rural town and although I moved away, my parents still live there. There aren’t enough primary care doctors there and most of them are semi-retired and work only a few days a week. A lot of people have to settle for a Nurse Practitioner. The doctor my Dad was seeing for a while was almost as old as he was and he was over 80 then. When that old doctor suddenly retired, both of my parents had a difficult time even finding a primary care doctor to accept them as patients.
It is the responsibility of the retiring doctor to find doctors for his patients. Not doing so is called Patient Abandonment.
I noticed he was having memory problems. His primary care doctor doesn’t seem to have noticed.
No system of insurance will guarantee competence in doctors.
 
Usually, the answer to this is “by letting the insurance network handle it.”
And we can see by escalating medical costs how well they do that. 🙂
Because you have a fixed cost for what you pay and it’s not too hard to pick someone off your provider list. Basically every plan has an out of pocket maximum too, so after a certain point you stop having to pay more money for the year.
But do you get your unspent premiums back? Under my proposal, it’s YOUR money and you keep any unspent money and roll it over into your IRA.

Let’s imagine you pay $1,000 a month, and I save $1,000 month. Let’s suppose we both consume $6,000 of medical care during the year. At the end of the year, I put $6,000 in my IRA – and you have nothing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top