T
Of course I can’t judge God or know whether his rewards and punishments are deserved. I take it as axiomatic. However, everlasting torment is the kind of punishment that can never be just, reasonable, loving, beautiful, etc. I think if an angel appeared to me and told me that God wanted me to worship an idol or go kill dozens of children, I would rightfully argue that God wouldn’t want me to do something like that, and therefore the angel can’t possibly represent God. I think eternal hell is like that. If a man/church appears teaching that eternal hell awaits most of humanity, or even one person, that man/church does not represent God.
I admire your compassion and mercy for the fallen angels and the people and Hitlers of the world who may be in hell all of whom are hell-bent on your destruction. But, I’m sure glad you are not God. You have probably never met one of these malicious beings in person but if you did, you may come to a different frame of mind. The fallen angels and the human beings in hell are all unrepentant sinners. It’s like if you had say a 8 year old daughter who was kidnapped, tortured, beaten, raped, and murdered, and you met this criminal in court and he says to your face “I’m glad I did it, I’d do it again.” Are you going to feel sorry for this criminal? I would hope you would think for your daughter’s sake that this person needs to be punished, locked up for a lifetime behind bars or strung up and hung. And then you meet this same person after death in the next life and he says to you the same thing “I’m glad I did it, I’d do it again if I could.” Again, are you going to have compassion or feel sorry for this person? I would hope not unless you want your daughter to go through the same ordeal.
Thankfully, there is an after life where perfect justice will prevail and you can hope while still living on earth that your daughter who was maliciously murdered on earth is in heaven. The murderer took your daughter’s one chance at life on earth for all eternity. In a sense, the murderer committed an eternal damage for we live one time on earth and that’s it. How can the murderer compensate for this crime? It appears to me to be impossible for once we die we do not come back to earth. The only just sentence for such a criminal is to be punished for eternity, everlasting, forever. Why for eternity? Because there is never going to be a time even after a zillion years to compensate for the crime. The victim, the daughter, is not going to come back to earth to live no matter how long the criminal is punished for. The criminal does not necessarily have to end up in hell. He/she can while still living on earth, repent of his/her crime, ask forgiveness from God and God will forgive him/her and this person can end up in heaven. Consider the repentant thief on the cross next to Jesus. It is not God’s will that any should perish but that all should come to repentance. Unfortunately, not all repent but are happy to live in sin. But, living in sin is not true happiness but an apparent happiness. And as the Scripture says whatever a person chooses will be given them:
“Set before you are fire and water;
to whatever you choose, stretch out your hand.
Before everyone are life and death,
whichever they choose will be given them” (Sirach 15: 16-17).
Now, thankfully, God values life and the things He made much more than we do and so there is a heaven and a hell. Jesus, the God-Man who speaks the words of God, has told us there is an eternal punishment awaiting evil people. Catholics, who are followers of Christ, believe in the words of Christ as well as the words in other parts of Holy Scripture which is the word of God that tells of an eternal punishment awaiting the evil people. Since we believe God is perfectly just, an eternal punishment of hell must be just. We may not fully comprehend this in this life but we will see the justice of it in the next life.
In my view, pumpkin cookie, you have way to much compassion and mercy for those beings in hell, again, who are hell-bent on your destruction. These beings are our enemies. I would not worry about trying to understand fully the eternal punishment of hell in this life, we will see the perfect justice of this in the next life, or worry about your enemies in hell. Instead, do all you can in this life so you don’t end up in hell. Leave the rest to God and believe with absolute certainty that God is perfectly just and that an eternal punishment of hell is perfectly just. I honestly do not understand your compassion, mercy, and worry over our enemies who are hell-bent on our own destruction.
Another thought that has occurred to me is this. Since you do not believe that an eternal punishment is just according to your finite mind, maybe we ought to eliminate the other part of Jesus’ teaching about the good people entering eternal life. Maybe the bad people ought to be punished for, lets say, a thousand years; and the good people rewarded for a thousand years. After this, they both can cease to exist. How does this sound?
My apologies, although I’m afraid I have landed myself on the “naughty” list by alleging that he doesn’t exist. 
