Interdenominational Relationships

  • Thread starter Thread starter SomeBaptsitGuy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Cast, I think I get the gist of it.

Basically, as long as you are a Christian, even if things aren’t perfect, you get salvation? If you never heard of Christ, if you did what Christ would have wanted you to do, you also get salvation?
 
I think that goes both ways. I am sure there are some who have posted in this thread who do not consider me a Christian because I am not Catholic.
Despite what individual Catholics may believe about Baptists, the Catechism of the Catholic Church makes it clear that denominations are Christian and that even those who have never heard the gospel can be saved.

Can you show me in the Catechism of the Baptist Church where non-Protestants are Christians?
 
Despite what individual Catholics may believe about Baptists, the Catechism of the Catholic Church makes it clear that denominations are Christian and that even those who have never heard the gospel can be saved.

Can you show me in the Catechism of the Baptist Church where non-Protestants are Christians?
The Baptist churches are structured too independently to have any catechism that would apply universally.
 
Cast, I think I get the gist of it.

Basically, as long as you are a Christian, even if things aren’t perfect, you get salvation? If you never heard of Christ, if you did what Christ would have wanted you to do, you also get salvation?
More like, the Church is the only means of salvation. There are some people who are imperfectly joined to the Church (validly Baptised) who have not rejected the Church. They may attain salvation (not WILL, none of us are guaranteed salvation).

Those who have never heard of Christ, we believe that God provides a way for them to accept Him.
 
Cast, I have heard it said before that those who never heard of Christ would be given a chance, and I hope it is true. I personally have had a problem with that teaching though because I could not find anything in the Bible to support it. Can you help me out? I really would like it to have some kind of Biblical foundation.
40.png
Nate13:
What do you think “full of grace” means 😉
I certainly don’t think it means she was sinless. I can understand Catholics holding Mary as special because she was the Mother of Jesus (as was stated earlier in the thread), but to call her sinless puts her on par with Christ. I can’t say I would go so far with it.
 
I’ve been lurking on these forums for a few months now, and this thread has been by far the most helpful to me.

I am a Missionary Baptist and hold most of the same beliefs that baptistguy does. My girlfriend of almost two years is Catholic, although I still am unsure of the difference between a devout and lukewarm Catholic. She was raised in Catholic school, K-12, and attends mass every Sunday.
I am a devout protestant, and we are starting to realize that we don’t fully understand each other’s faith.

Between reading a lot on here, and attending mass with her several times, I can say that the Catholic Church is much better and much worse than what I expected to find.

My dissention, and baptistguy, I think you will likely have similar issues… comes from several different places. I think a few knowledgeable folks have already listed the most common ones.
  1. The Eucharist- While I still don’t fully understand the extent that this is revered, I do know that communion is taken with fellow Christians as Christ commanded “in rememberance of me”. Catholics believe that the bread and juice you are eating and drinking is the actual flesh and blood of Christ. I still have no idea why, and do not understand why the representation of it amongst your brothers and sisters is wrong.
  2. Mary- Catholics believe that Mary was sinless. From what I gather, being “full of grace” means that she was perfect. Equal to Jesus but you cannot obtain salvation through her. That is why she is so revered in the CC.
  3. The Bible- In talking with my girlfriend about these things, the Bible is not always her first source of information to answer spiritual questions. Catholics have several other writings they hold dear as well. I’m not certain if any is more important that the other though. I believe that the writings of the Bible were divinely inspired and that is all we need to live our life for Christ.
  4. Structure- the CC is VERY structured and there is a clear hierarchy. The popes and bishops are always correct in their interpretation and have the final say, regardless of what you read and how you interpret the Bible. You MUST believe this to become a true member of the Catholic church. There are a lot of rules that extend beyond sin/not a sin.
  5. Traditions- There are too many traditions in the CC for me to count. As someone who is not familiar, it is very overwhelming, especially the specific language and terminology. There are prayers, hymns, readings, ceremonies, etc. that have root in the Bible.
When we first started talking about the possibility of marriage, I told her than I would never convert and that our children would be raised baptist. She agreed. But she still wants a traditional Catholic wedding.
After reading some of the discussions on this site, I am tending to think she is a little confused.

My biggest problem (I think) is the evangelical part. She feels no conviction to bring others to the Lord. And from what I can tell, most Catholics are the same way. I think this stems from the interpretation of Matthew 28:19.
Jesus spoke only to the apostles so I think that Catholics believe that it is the repsonsibility of the heirarchy to do that.

I apologize for the long rant, but I am in a similar situation and want to get to the bottom of this.
I have an aunt (catholic) and uncle (baptist) who married and couldn’t agree on how to raise their children, so the entire family of five had no Christian influence whatsoever. It’s heartbreaking to see and I intend to avoid that situation at all costs.

Also, thank all of you for being so hospitable.
Catholics are very rare in the south so there are plenty of misconceptions. I am sure that most Catholics believe all our sermons are fire and brimstone speeches from old men at the pulpit. 😉
 
Joe, welcome “officially” to CAF 🙂 - although I understand you have been lurking for quite a while. 😃 I’m glad you found this thread informative.

Regarding Catholic layfolks’ failure to evangelize, I would say we Catholics need to move our butts and take a lesson from you Baptists and Evangelicals. I have made a number of non-Catholic friends in my life, and I’m eternally indebted to them for bringing me back to the Church after I have fallen away during college years. One of my best friends is a Lutheran who attends a Baptist Church, and he was and continues to be a great positive influence in my life.

Yeah, you can’t allow your children to grow up without God, and without religious education. Your future wife will have to promise to the Catholic Church to give a Catholic upbringing to your future children, if she chooses to stay Catholic. Without that promise, the Catholic Church will not grant her permission (“dispensation”) to marry you. Even if there will be a certain disagreement among you and your wife on faith issues, it’s a lot better to educate the children in both faiths than not to give them faith formation at all.

I will continue to comment on various Catholic issues - the Eucharist, Mary, etc. Now I would only like to make this point: all the Catholic issues should be looked at also from the standpoint of Church history, and from the writings of the Early Church Fathers. Thus, we have writers such as St. Ignatius of Antioch in the early 2nd century, and others, saying that Christians regard the bread and the wine as truly the flesh and blood of Christ. That’s one of the great strengths of Catholic teachings, in my opinion. First, you can show Jesus’ own words that “my flesh is truly food, and my blood is truly drink”, then you can show that Christians in the first 3-4 centuries after Christ regarded the Eucharist as truly his flesh and blood, and finally show that the Catholic Church believes today what the Early Christians, and the Early Church Fathers believed. There’s a continuity of teaching encompassing 2000 years, and not only with the Eucharist, but with all issues - including such topics we already discussed here, like the role of Papacy, Mary, contraception, abortion, and so on.

With the Eucharist and Mary, I would absolutely like to mention two of my favorite topics - Eucharistic miracles, and Marian apparitions… miraculous, supernatural events, such as the apparition of this famous image on the Aztec Indian Juan Diego’s tilma (tilma = cloak woven of coarse cactus fibers) in 1531, the image of Our Lady of Guadalupe - it’s a miraculous image, not painted by human hands:



For a good description of the story of Our Lady of Guadalupe, see this website:

sancta.org/nican.html
 
I certainly don’t think it means she was sinless. I can understand Catholics holding Mary as special because she was the Mother of Jesus (as was stated earlier in the thread), but to call her sinless puts her on par with Christ. I can’t say I would go so far with it.
No, it doesn’t put her on par with Christ. Christ is God. Mary is a creature. That fact alone means she is not “on par” with Christ. It is only through Christ, the power of God, that Mary is who she is. Her role is given to her by God. Saying she is sinless is honoring God, not lowering Him
 
Every Christian was told by Christ how to evangelize.

That by our WORKS all men will know we are His disciples.

That they will see our good works and glorify our Father in heaven.

That we are to love one another.

So, to the second Baptist poster, your girlfriend does not love people and does not live life of service and love to others? Heck, why would you want to marry someone who is selfish and hateful?
 
Regarding indulgences, here’s a description of the famous Portiuncula Indulgence, which St. Francis of Assisi obtained through a direct supernatural (mystical) encounter with the Lord Jesus Christ and Our Lady, in 1217. St. Francis asked that anyone visiting the Portiuncula church with a contrite heart, and fulfilling certain conditions (confession, Eucharist, prayers - see quote below) would receive a PLENARY INDULGENCE.

This was almost unheard of at that time, to gain a plenary indulgence so easily, yet Christ granted St. Francis his request on account of St. Francis’ great merits. That’s an important principle - when we gain indulgences, either for ourselves, or for the departed (so that their souls may be released from Purgatory), we gain them not on account of our own merits, but on the account of the infinite merits of Christ, and the great (finite) merits of the Saints.

There’s yet another important principle illustrated in the story: Christ grants the request to St. Francis, but sends him off to his Vicar, Pope Honorius III, because nothing happens without the approval of the Pope, who is the head of Christ’s Church on the Earth, and Christ’s Vicar until Christ’s second coming when he will head that authority back to Christ.

The Portiuncula Indulgence was originally approved for people who would visit the Portiuncula church in Italy, 5 km from Assisi, between sundown on Aug 1 and Aug 2. Later on the Portiuncula Indulgence was extended to people visiting any Franciscan church anywhere in the world, on the mentioned date, and complying with the conditions necessary for the indulgence.

continued…
 
@JoeFL
I think you have similar views to baptistguy except with respect to the Eucharist. He seemed to understand the idea of transubstantiation. Read John 6:22-71. God promised the Israelite’s a sign so that they would believe in him and he gave them Manna. The Jews ask Jesus for a sign and he promises them the bread of life which is his body and blood. This is not an abstract statement. Whenever Jesus repeats anything 3 times you know its important and he is not fooling around. Jesus tells Peter he is going to deny him three times. There was nothing abstract about that prediction.

I would say you appear to have a better understanding of how Catholics view Mary though. From your comments on the hierarchy of the Church though I believe there are a few misunderstandings. You don’t have to believe everything your bishop says just because your bishop says it. You believe it because he is teaching in congruence with the Magisterium, the bishops as a whole throughout the world, and the Pope. If your bishop or a priest tells you one thing and the Pope is saying another there is a problem. For example if your bishop or priest tells you contraception is fine, that should set off some warning lights considering that teaching is not in line with the Magesterium let alone what all of Christendom has held up until the 1930’s. A bishop or priest is a purveyor of the Truth that has already been established by Christ, not an inventor of new truths.
 
Here’s a quote from franciscanfriarstor.com/archive/stfrancis/stf_portuncula_indulgence.htm regarding the story of the **Portiuncula Indulgence **- please go to the website for more on the story.

Quote:

HOW ST. FRANCIS ASKED AND
OBTAINED THE INDULGENCE OF FORGIVENESS

He awoke one night in 1216 at the Porziuncola and an inspiration stronger than usual prompted him to arise and go into the little chapel. He knelt in prayer and, as he prayed, our Lord, accompanied by His Mother, appeared to him and bade him ask for that which he desired most. “O God,” he said, “although I m a great sinner, I beseech You to grant a full pardon of all sins to all who, having repented and confessed their sins, shall visit this church.” And Jesus said to him: “Francis, you ask much, but you are worthy of greater things, and greater things you shall have.”

Our Lord then granted Francis’ request and told him to go to His Vicar for ratification of the indulgence. Honorius III, who was just beginning his Pontificate, was holding court at Perugia, and it was to him that Francis presented his petition.

Honorius wanted to give Francis the document of the indulgence, but Francis saw no need for it. “What have you to show that this indulgence has been granted you?” the Pope asked in amazement as Francis prepared to depart for Assisi without any written confirmation of the great permission. “Holy Father,” he replied, “Your word is enough for me. If this is the work of God, it is for Him to make His work manifest. I desire no other document. The Blessed Virgin Mary shall be the charter, Christ the notary, and the angels the witnesses.” Some days later, before the Bishops of Umbria, Francis said: “Brethren, I want to send you all to Heaven!”

I also heartily recommend anyone to read The Biography of St. Francis of Assisi, written by Omer Englebert, to learn more about the life story of this extraordinary and beloved saint, including the Portiuncula Indulgence, how he received the stigmata, his mystical encounters with Christ, the many miracles he performed, including the taming of the man-eating wolf of Gubio, his sermon to the birds, and so on. The book transports the reader into 13th century Italy, and it’s a very enjoyable read.

And here are some teachings on the indulgences and the specifics of the Portiuncula Indulgence, from the Adult Catechism of the Italian Bishops’ Conference, quoted again from the franciscanfriarstor.com/archive/stfrancis/stf_portuncula_indulgence.htm website:

CONDITIONS TO OBTAIN
THE PLENARY INDULGENCE
OF THE FORGIVENESS OF ASSISI
(for oneself or for a departed soul)

Sacramental Confession to be in God’s grace
(during the eight days before or after);

Participation in the Holy Mass and Eucharist.

Visit to a Catholic Church, followed by PROFESSION OF FAITH, in order to reaffirm one’s own Christian identity;

Say the OUR FATHER, in order to reaffirm the dignity as child of God that one received in Baptism;

A prayer for the Pope’s intention, in order to reaffirm one’s membership in the Church, of which the Roman Pontiff is the foundation and sign of visible unity.

THE INDULGENCE
Italian Bishops’ Conference, Adult Catechism, n. 710

Sin not only destroys communion with God, but also compromises the interior state of persons and their relationship with other creatures. For a total repentance, it is not enough to be sorry and to receive the remission of faults. It is also necessary that reparation be made for the disorder provoked by sin, a disorder that usually continues after the sin. In this process of purification the penitent is not alone. The penitent participates in a mystery of solidarity, for which Christ and the Saints rejoice with one. God communicates to one the grace merited by others with the immense value of their existence, in order to effect one’s reparation rapidly and effectively.

The Church has always exhorted the faithful to offer prayers, good works and sufferings for the conversion of sinners and for the repose of the faithful departed. During the first centuries, bishops reduced the duration and the severeness of public punishment, through the intercession of the witnesses of faith who survived tortures.

Progressively the consciousness grew that the power to bind and unbind, received from the Lord, included the faculty to free penitents from the residue left by already forgiven sins, by applying to them the merits of Christ and the Saints, in order to obtain the grace of a fervent charity. Priests grant this privilege to those who have the right interior disposition and have adhered to the prescribed norms. Participation in this penitential rite is a prerequisite to the concession of an indulgence.
 
I’ve been lurking on these forums for a few months now, and this thread has been by far the most helpful to me.

I am a Missionary Baptist and hold most of the same beliefs that baptistguy does. My girlfriend of almost two years is Catholic, although I still am unsure of the difference between a devout and lukewarm Catholic. She was raised in Catholic school, K-12, and attends mass every Sunday.
I am a devout protestant, and we are starting to realize that we don’t fully understand each other’s faith.

Between reading a lot on here, and attending mass with her several times, I can say that the Catholic Church is much better and much worse than what I expected to find.

My dissention, and baptistguy, I think you will likely have similar issues… comes from several different places. I think a few knowledgeable folks have already listed the most common ones.
  1. The Eucharist- While I still don’t fully understand the extent that this is revered, I do know that communion is taken with fellow Christians as Christ commanded “in rememberance of me”. Catholics believe that the bread and juice you are eating and drinking is the actual flesh and blood of Christ. I still have no idea why, and do not understand why the representation of it amongst your brothers and sisters is wrong.
  2. Mary- Catholics believe that Mary was sinless. From what I gather, being “full of grace” means that she was perfect. Equal to Jesus but you cannot obtain salvation through her. That is why she is so revered in the CC.
Mary gave her Yes to God and so Jesus was conceived in her womb. Don’t you think that God would choose a pure and sinless human being too be the holy vessel for Jesus? She was not perfect like God but she was sinless, obedient to His will and the mother of our Savior. We don’t worship her we honor her.
  1. The Bible- In talking with my girlfriend about these things, the Bible is not always her first source of information to answer spiritual questions. Catholics have several other writings they hold dear as well. I’m not certain if any is more important that the other though. I believe that the writings of the Bible were divinely inspired and that is all we need to live our life for Christ.
Yes, the Bible is divinely inspired. Jesus was talking to the 12 apostles when he said this to them, John 16: 12 “I still have many things to say to you but they would be too much for you now. But when the Spirit of Truth comes he will lead you to the complete truth.”

And He said this to them, John 16: 12" When the Spirit of Truth comes, he will guide you into all the truth; for he will not speak on his own authority, but whatever he hears he will speak, and he will declare to you the things that are to come. He will glorify me, for he will take what is mine and declare it to you. All that the Father has is mine; therefore I said that he will take what is mine and declare it to you."

And He said this to them too, John 14:25 “These things I have spoken to you, while I am still with you. But the Counselor, the Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in my name, he will teach you all things, and bring you to your remembrance all that I have said to you.”
  1. Structure- the CC is VERY structured and there is a clear hierarchy. The popes and bishops are always correct in their interpretation and have the final say, regardless of what you read and how you interpret the Bible. You MUST believe this to become a true member of the Catholic church. There are a lot of rules that extend beyond sin/not a sin.
What happens if there is no authority? Matt 16. Peter was given the authority by Jesus. He was the first pope.
2 Peter 1:20-21 “First of all you must understand this, that no prophecy ever came by the impulse of man, but men moved by the Holy Spirit spoke from God.”

The teachings of the Church are not rules made up by men but are divinely guided by the Holy Spirit.
  1. Traditions- There are too many traditions in the CC for me to count. As someone who is not familiar, it is very overwhelming, especially the specific language and terminology. There are prayers, hymns, readings, ceremonies, etc. that have root in the Bible.
Traditions are also in the divinely inspired in the Bible. John 21:25 But there are many other things which Jesus did; were every one of them to be written, I suppose that the world itself could not contain the books that would be written.

When we first started talking about the possibility of marriage, I told her than I would never convert and that our children would be raised baptist. She agreed. But she still wants a traditional Catholic wedding.
After reading some of the discussions on this site, I am tending to think she is a little confused.

My biggest problem (I think) is the evangelical part. She feels no conviction to bring others to the Lord. And from what I can tell, most Catholics are the same way. I think this stems from the interpretation of Matthew 28:19.
Jesus spoke only to the apostles so I think that Catholics believe that it is the repsonsibility of the heirarchy to do that.

I think that a good way to evangelize is with humility and love to all people.

I apologize for the long rant, but I am in a similar situation and want to get to the bottom of this.
I have an aunt (catholic) and uncle (baptist) who married and couldn’t agree on how to raise their children, so the entire family of five had no Christian influence whatsoever. It’s heartbreaking to see and I intend to avoid that situation at all costs.

Also, thank all of you for being so hospitable.
Catholics are very rare in the south so there are plenty of misconceptions. I am sure that most Catholics believe all our sermons are fire and brimstone speeches from old men at the pulpit. 😉
 
Cast, I have heard it said before that those who never heard of Christ would be given a chance, and I hope it is true. I personally have had a problem with that teaching though because I could not find anything in the Bible to support it. Can you help me out? I really would like it to have some kind of Biblical foundation.

I certainly don’t think it means she was sinless. I can understand Catholics holding Mary as special because she was the Mother of Jesus (as was stated earlier in the thread), but to call her sinless puts her on par with Christ. I can’t say I would go so far with it.
haha well Christ was God and no one makes that claim about Mary. Saying Mary was sinless puts her on par with Adam and Eve who were also born without original sin. I don’t see any problems with saying she is sinless and there is substantial proof to back this claim in the Bible as well as in Tradition that has been passed down from the Apostles. Its worth looking into the phrase “full of grace” and how it was used in the Bible in other places and who it was referring to. It is also beneficial to look at the original Hebrew text, as the English translation is not capable of fully doing it justice.
 
More on indulgences - if you go to the Catholic Answers homepage (catholic.com), you will find a link to “Tracts”. These tracts are essentially brochures explaining various aspects of the Catholic faith.

The founder of this website, Karl Keating, is an attorney from California. One day, as he returned to his car in the parking lot of a Catholic church after Sunday Mass, he found some brochure left on the windshield of his car, a brochure composed by some anti-Catholic Christian ministry trying to convert people away from Catholicism. The brochure was full of errors. This event motivated Karl Keating to compose “counter-brochures” or “tracts”, succint printed material explaining the Catholic faith and disspelling errors and misinformation about the Catholic Church, misinformation that’s widely circulated in circles hostile to Catholicism.

So, here’s the link to a tract, or brochure, about indulgences:

catholic.com/tracts/myths-about-indulgences

Here’s a quote - please go to the link provided for the very informative, short article:

Myths about Indulgences

Indulgences. The very word stirs up more misconceptions than perhaps any other teaching in Catholic theology. Those who attack the Church for its use of indulgences rely upon—and take advantage of—the ignorance of both Catholics and non-Catholics.

What is an indulgence? The Church explains, “An indulgence is a remission before God of the temporal punishment due to sins whose guilt has already been forgiven, which the faithful Christian who is duly disposed gains under certain defined conditions through the Church’s help when, as a minister of redemption, she dispenses and applies with authority the treasury of the satisfactions won by Christ and the saints” (Indulgentarium Doctrina 1). To see the biblical foundations for indulgences, see the Catholic Answers tract A Primer on Indulgences.
Step number one in explaining indulgences is to know what they are. Step number two is to clarify what they are not. Here are the seven most common myths about indulgences:

Myth 1: A person can buy his way out of hell with indulgences.

This charge is without foundation. Since indulgences remit only temporal penalties, they cannot remit the eternal penalty of hell. Once a person is in hell, no amount of indulgences will ever change that fact. The only way to avoid hell is by appealing to God’s eternal mercy while still alive. After death, one’s eternal fate is set (Heb. 9:27).

Myth 2: A person can buy indulgences for sins not yet committed.

The Church has always taught that indulgences do not apply to sins not yet committed. The Catholic Encyclopedia notes, “[An indulgence] is not a permission to commit sin, nor a pardon of future sin; neither could be granted by any power.”

Myth 3: A person can “buy forgiveness” with indulgences.

Folks, click the link provided above, to read the rest of the article. 🙂
 
How about a statement from the SBC?
Mark, I clicked your signature line out of curiosity, since I have no clue who Willibald Pirkheimer was, or whether your signature line is a quote from Willibald Pirkheimer… :o

However, the article you are “hiding” 😛 under that signature line, is a most amazing one! I knew of this article, I’ve read it before, and now I’m so grateful I’m going to re-post the link:

touchstonemag.com/archives/article.php?id=20-04-020-f

CHILDREN OF THE REFORMATION
A Short & Surprising History of Protestantism & Contraception

by
Allan Carlson

Read more: touchstonemag.com/archives/article.php?id=20-04-020-f#ixzz1aQMBg8qn

The article is written by an Evangelical Lutheran, who is - according to the article:

Allan Carlson is President of The Howard Center for Family, Religion & Society in Rockford, Illinois (www.profam.org). His books include Conjugal America: On The Public Purposes of Marriage and The Natural Family: Bulwark of Liberty. He is married and has four children and is a member of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. He is a senior editor for Touchstone.

Here’s a short introductory quote:

It is a reckless analyst who risks reopening sixteenth-century disputes between Roman Catholics and the Protestant Reformers. I do so in the interest of a greater good, but my purpose is not to say who was right or who was wrong. I would simply like to explore why the Protestant churches maintained unity with the Catholic Church on the contraception question for four centuries, only to abandon this unity during the first half of the twentieth century.

I write as a historian, not an advocate. (I am a “cradle Lutheran,” but one who believes Martin Luther was wrong about what he called the impossibility of lifelong celibacy; I have come to know too many faithful Catholic priests to accept that.)

And here’s another quote from the end of the article:

A Major Rethinking

“ It is clear that there is a major rethinking going on among Evangelicals on this issue, especially among young people,” R. Albert Mohler, Jr., president of the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary, recently told the Chicago Tribune. “There is a real push back against the contraceptive culture now.”

In his last years, Francis Schaeffer seemed to be moving toward the historic Christian view of contraception. Since 1980, several resolutions adopted by the Southern Baptists at their annual meeting have criticized contraception. By the close of the twentieth century, the Family Research Council featured special reports on “The Empty Promise of Contraception” and “The Bipartisan Blunder of Title X,” the latter referring to the domestic contraception program in the United States.

Conservative Calvinist publishers are producing books not only against contraception but promoting Natural Family Planning. A movement of Missouri Synod Lutherans is working to overturn their church’s current teaching and return it to Luther’s, and observers report a new interest in the traditional teaching among conservative movements in the mainline churches.

There have been other signs of Protestant rethinking on this question, including individual pastors and their wives who have opened their lives to bringing a full quiver of children into the world. For example, Pastor Matt Trewhella of Mercy Seat Christian Church in Milwaukee concluded that “we have no God-given right to manipulate God’s design for marriage by using birth control.” He had his vasectomy reversed, and he and his wife Clara have had seven more children.

While surely in the minority, the Trewhellas are not alone. In so acting, they are rediscovering their distinctive theology and their heritage, and they are accepting their special responsibility as a pastor’s family to serve as witnesses to the original Protestant understanding of the divine intent for marriage. Importantly, they are also rebuilding a common Christian front on the issue of contraception, one lost in the dark days of the first half of the twentieth century.

(Large, bold emphasis above mine)

Folks, read the article. It’s an amazing, amazing article, and it gives much hope to us Catholics who believe that acceptance and mainstreaming of the intrinsic evil named “contraception” by all non-Catholic (Protestant, even conservative Eastern Orthodox) Christian denominations during the 20th century has been one of the most destructive, tragic mistakes - one that opened the door to many more intrinsic evils, including fornication, masturbation, adultery, disrespect for women, disrespect for wives, gay marriage, and abortion.
 
Will? So, the position of the CC is that no matter what, you eventually get salvation?
No. I was just about to correct him. No one is guaranteed salvation. And being outside the Church reduces the chances (due to lack of access to the Sacraments); it does not increase them. However, a baptized Protestant who never sins is, in fact, saved - if such a person exists. 🙂
 
This stood out for me. Mary was not sinless, or did I miss the passages in the Bible that acknowledged she was perfect, just like Jesus?
Must have. “Hail, full of grace.” Somewhere in Luke 2. (Often mistranslated as “Hail, highly favoured one,” even in Catholic Bibles, so probably not your fault.) 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top