Irish abuse report is 'shocking'

  • Thread starter Thread starter Daz
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
“Sometimes, I cannot find You, God. And the reason I cannot find You is simple: it is with that in me that eclipses You that I seek You”. John Moriarty, Dreamtime. (Yellow Belle’s signature quote)

I don’t know if anyone else reads the signatures attached to these posts. For my part, I find them instructive and revelatory of an aspect of the poster’s state of awareness. In the case of Yellow Belle, I found a real gem, and I feel that it is applicable to the resolution of the scandal we are addressing here, that scandal being, I sense, a simple symptom of a greater problem that only appears to include the Catholic Church and the Irish government as a momentary focus. Certainly, as Catholics, it is right and appropriate to address the issue as having been a manifestation within the Church. However, it may be more ultimately useful to look at this occurrence as a phenomenon capable of analysis at a deeper level. Some may say that there is no deeper level than addressing it in terms of the faith, but in fact, many of the terms and sanctions that might be used as treatment in that way would not wash on a global scale, which is the actual arena of this misfortune. I am implying very directly that this problem is not, and cannot be, separate from the human condition in general.

But back to YB’s signature. I am someone who believes that the Federal Aviation Administration ought to have a far larger part in our American government than it does, in terms of results stemming from analysis. You see, it is the job of the FAA to minutely dissect, reconstruct, and analyze the remains of a catastrophe with a view to implementing regulations, practices, and designs that will materially increase the safety of passengers. Though it is a far, far, simpler matter to get folks safely from A to B than it is to be a formative influence on the lives of our children, there is a proceedural attitude present in FAA methods that might serve us well in preventing the reprise of any such thing as happened in the situations that are the subject of the reported abuse.

Now I am someone who does believe that whatever it is that constitutes prayer, contemplation and meditation have an effect at least on “other” minds and may to some degree be noticed in whatever “spiritual” hierarchy there certainly must be. This is despite my sense that the Catholic description of all that, IMHO, is sadly lacking and tragically unfortunate. But so are those of other systems, both religious and secular. And that, together with their contradictions and momentums, is what needs to be gotten past. And whatever your opinion of my particular take on this, one thing does need to be accounted for: There *are *great differences in what different belief based groups, including governments, secularists, and scientists might bring to bear as their understanding of the roots of our current misfortune.

This is where YB’s signature and the FAA come together. If we are going to pray for the victims and perpetrators of these events, what is the point of our doing so, and what does the result look like? My concern is that if it is, as it seems to be, the unfortunate and prevalant state among religionists that “it is with that in me that eclipses You that I seek You” is operative, as we might well conclude from the state of the world and its beliefs, what universal points of agreement might we use to parse or tease out the entirety of our drama?

I humbly submit that my experience, and that of many I know both directly and indirectly, lead me to conclude that a strictly Catholic analysis of this tragedy is not the sole/soul avenue of approach. This is applicable both to the private mode of prayer and the assumptions behind it, and the public mode of prescribing faith formulas that are not universal in nature, save in the minds of believers. I firmly and completely believe by dint of my own decades long work on myself and the witnessing of the transformations of others, that the way to a resolution is in the honest, sincere, and scrupulous examination of what we use to find God. My conviction about this is so strong I feel that I can guarantee that anyone who delves into the origins and assumptions of their faith, be it political, religious, economic, or whatever, will come up with gems of self understanding undreamed of in the course of their “normal” lives.

I am further convinced that neither God nor Truth is harmed, bent, distorted, or abused by assuming and pursuing the idea that one’s personal understanding is fundamentally off. In fact, this attitude assuming ignorance is what might break the bounds of our necessarily parochial thinking into a greater acceptance of the world as it is, not as we think and believe it to be. As One man said “Admit that you do not know what you do not know. That is knowledge.” Such a statement has extraordinarily far reaching consequences that few have experienced, it seems, or there would be far greater agreement in matters of Spirit throughout the world. This inaccuracy in Spirit allows not only the kinds of things we now face on many fronts, but leaves us as well with not much other choice than to look to secular solutions in practical matters. Religious solutions seem, historically, to only cause, in great part, strife and enhance separation. Seemingly pertinent Biblical statements notwithstanding, this is not the purpose of religion. The results of such activity reveal the inefficiency of the premises adhered to, as is clearly evident. Some other course, founded on the supremacy of Deity, yet exclusive of religion, must be plotted and followed. That which we use to seek God which eclipses God, that must first be dissolved, then may our vision be clearer at least. Have you or I the courage to make such a Quest? Is not that Quest, though, the original reason for our beliefs in any case?
 
i would agree that there definitely should be some kind of analysis regarding the abuses commited by those associated with the Catholic church like the FAA investigations, but there won’t be anything as in depth i feel. the FAA does an excellent job after an air disaster of investigating what happened to further protect passengers in the future. i like your analogy. i think Rome moves very slow and we should be thankful that in the 21st century, they are finally acknowledging these abuses -
although it is sometimes 50 years or more after the fact. more than likely similar abuses occurred earlier, but we are dealing with these cases in our lifetime.

i believe the Church has made some changes since all of these lawsuits have been filed and so many of these cases have been brought to our attention in the newspaper headlines and extreme amounts of money has been paid out, but only time will tell whether the Church has done enough.

regarding another post and the State in Ireland having to pay the damages, this is sad for the taxpayer’s, but the State should have been paying attention to the conditions where they were placing these young people so i would say the State bears some culpability.

where i live, we have had children die in the foster care system, killed or neglected by the people the were placed with. the agency is called child protective services. although the agency is put in place to protect children, it is a flawed system.

you would think that institutions run by the Church or any church would be safe, but they are all run by human beings who are also flawed.
 
7,

It is exactly the source of the flaw in the system that I am attempting to address. Without impugning the sincerity of people’s faith, nor the humanitarian efforts of the Church, what does it say about Rome, the alleged keeper and example of faith and morals, that a) these things happened within its flock, and b) that Cathholicism is seen, evidently, by the world public as mostly reacting to breaches, not carrying a torch, in matters of the betterment of Mankind? It has, as far as I can tell, no better success than other institutions at this task.

How well would any other commercial institution fare if it was appologizing for transgressions against its stockholders not only of a decade ago, but fifty, five hundred, and even seventeen hundred years ago? Is the future arrival of Jesus really an adequate bail out for this institution and our responsibility as men and women capable of using conscience? Do not the (in)actons of the Church as an institiution evidence a self serving interest superceeding the welfare and promotion of a rightful charge? And again, this is couched in terms relative to the Church because we are dealing here with our own house. It does not deny the horrors of other sytems and institiutions, but it does require us, claiming to be the one, holy, and apostolic faithful, to look at our own doorstep and what we have allowed across the threshold in ignorance and complicity and why we could do that. The same hold for us and everyone in all our roles and hats.

So what is it specifically in the system of Catholic promulgation and propagation that fails to convey the doing of good, in these cases, according to the Golden Rule, that most simple and far reaching of standards? Intellections and faith seem to fall short, and are not measurably better in our system than others allegedly designed to do good or save souls. Is the claiming by faith that the stated goals of the institutional Church are ultimately “good” an adequate answer to the actual, practical, and moral functioning of the institution, its leaders, and its constituency?
 
i just know that i get tired of people making excuses that these type of things happen in other churches and other institutions. does that make it okay that it happens in the Catholic Church? if we are trying to be the beacon of light for people to follow to Christ,
in my eyes, it doesn’t make it okay. or someone might say, “yes, but that happened a long time ago”.

after awhile, you have to stop making excuses.
 
i just know that i get tired of people making excuses that these type of things happen in other churches and other institutions. does that make it okay that it happens in the Catholic Church? if we are trying to be the beacon of light for people to follow to Christ,
in my eyes, it doesn’t make it okay. or someone might say, “yes, but that happened a long time ago”.

after awhile, you have to stop making excuses.
Completely and utterly agree with you…! I have been talking about this on other forums and do not feel the need to take cheap shots at other faiths…I’ve experienced enough of these myself… However, I do think that being Irish and “knowing” and waiting for this “news” to go public AGAIN! That my own society, history and acceptance of “wrong doings” was allowed…It’s crazy! Even now in Ireland we are fighting over this as a “Roman Catholic” problem! No such thing…the pedophiles are as pervasive as they ever were… Our biggest crime was to " allow " it to happen! And every single Irish person owns that…indeed we even exported it…We’ve got to own that problem and not let evil hide or have shelter behind the cloth…Cover ups only take so much time to “uncover…”…honesty and truth is the real way of Jesus!

Our biggest sin is giving them “refuge” and “excuses”…In todays “enlightened society”…I say that tongue in cheek…!!!

Yeah right…

Not one of them consider history…

Eldest, or at least one child “pushed” into the cloth…because it was seen as being a “good” upstanding thing in society to have a family member as either a priest or a nun…
Don’t mention a “calling”…it was more like a “shoving”…

We have given our critics such food…Let’s not do it anymore…Please!

Prayer is all well and good, but God gave us free will for “action” too…every parishioner owns their parish…

We desperately need to show the world that we can be transparant and just! with the least of our children…otherwise what have we??? The cleansing is long overdue…

I love my faith, I want it to rise to this challenge!!! Desperately…
 
Completely and utterly agree with you…! I have been talking about this on other forums and do not feel the need to take cheap shots at other faiths…I’ve experienced enough of these myself… However, I do think that being Irish and “knowing” and waiting for this “news” to go public AGAIN! That my own society, history and acceptance of “wrong doings” was allowed…It’s crazy! Even now in Ireland we are fighting over this as a “Roman Catholic” problem! No such thing…the pedophiles are as pervasive as they ever were… Our biggest crime was to " allow " it to happen! And every single Irish person owns that…indeed we even exported it…We’ve got to own that problem and not let evil hide or have shelter behind the cloth…Cover ups only take so much time to “uncover…”…honesty and truth is the real way of Jesus!

Our biggest sin is giving them “refuge” and “excuses”…In todays “enlightened society”…I say that tongue in cheek…!!!

Yeah right…

Not one of them consider history…

Eldest, or at least one child “pushed” into the cloth…because it was seen as being a “good” upstanding thing in society to have a family member as either a priest or a nun…
Don’t mention a “calling”…it was more like a “shoving”…

We have given our critics such food…Let’s not do it anymore…Please!

Prayer is all well and good, but God gave us free will for “action” too…every parishioner owns their parish…

We desperately need to show the world that we can be transparant and just! with the least of our children…otherwise what have we??? The cleansing is long overdue…

I love my faith, I want it to rise to this challenge!!! Desperately…
Lettyd!

I feel your pain and determination. The Irish have a wonderful and herioc history and have contributed much to the world in terms of spreading the faith and the foundation of western civilization! Ireland’s role in laying the foundations of civilization in Europe and England insofar as spreading the faith, agriculture, building monasteries, education, law, health care - you name it - is enormous! Ireland shines! What about America? The Irish were everywhere. It sent missionaries into the whole world.

I love the Irish. Yes paedophilia is in every nook and crany of society. It is a curse and the side effects of abuse which grows like a cancer. This must be fought and the exposure will be painful but necessary.

As for the cover up. It was completely wrong but very human. Who want to expose such a terrible thing? The first reaction is the shame and the effects on the innocent, holy and self-giving clergy who are in the majority. But it was wrong. The facts must be made known and laid out in the open as painfull as it may be.

Towards the end of the last century there were conferences on the subject “Missionaries of the 21st century is the Laity” This is so true. Since Vatican II the role of the laity has increased 100 fold. It is terribly important - we are all priests - we all need to minister to one another - we must support the Church - we all have a role to play.

Here are the Works of Mercy:

The Spiritual Works of Mercy
  • to admonish the sinner
  • to instruct the ignorant
  • to counsel the doubtful
  • to comfort the sorrowful,
  • to bear wrongs patiently,
  • to forgive all injuries
  • to pray for the living and the dead
The Corporal Works of Mercy
  • to feed the hungry
  • to give drink to the thirsty
  • to clothe the naked
  • to ransom the captive
  • to harbour the harbourless
  • to visit the sick
  • to bury the dead
These are the duty of every Christian

So Lettyd, we feel your pain and we can analyse the situation and see exactly the situation. We will pray and ask for the protection and guidance of the Holy Spirit.

May God bless all on CAF and may God bless the Body of Christ which has been wounded.

Blessings
Cinette:):love::love::love:
 
I found this useful as well:

“Order never comes out of chaos. It is so wonderful to note that when chaos is present, you are perceiving it because Order is the Law of your Being.” ~~KG Mills
 
I came across this article when I spent Christmas 1999 in the UK and I have kept it and re-read it numerous times and passed it on. The emphasis is my own.

*CHASTITY’S CHALLENGE

By Fr Ronald Rolheiser

In her marvelous little book, Holy the firm, Annie Dillard describes how she once learned a fundamental lesson about life simply by watching a moth emerge from its cocoon. She had been fascinated watching the nearly imperceptible process of metamorphosis but, at a point, it became too slow for her. To speed up things a little, she applied a tiny bit of heat from a candle to the cocoon. It worked. The extra heat quickened the process and the moth emerged a bit sooner than it would have otherwise. However, because nature had not been able to take its full course, the moth was born damaged; its wings were not able to form fully.

What Dillard describes here is a violation of chastity. Properly understood, chastity is precisely a question of having the patience to bear the tension of the interminable slowness of things. To be chaste is not to prematurely force things, so that everybody and everything, each within its own unique rhythm, is properly respected.

That is normally not the way we think of chastity. Generally we relate chastity to sex, more particularly to the lack of it. For most of us, chastity means celibacy – and celibacy, in our culture, suggests an unenviable innocence, an ignorance really, a missing out on the most popular in our culture; partly because we conceive of it so badly. What is it?

Chastity is not first and foremost a sexual concept. It has to do with the way we relate to reality in general. In essence, chastity is proper reverence and respect. To be chaste is to stand before reality, everything and everybody, and fully respect the proper contours and rhythm of things.

To be chaste then means to let things unfold as they should. Thus it means, among many other things, not to open your gifts before Christmas, not to rush our own or our children’s growth, not to experience things for which we aren’t ready, not to lose patience in life or in sex because there is tension, not to violate someone else’s beauty and sexuality, not to apply a candle to a moth emerging from its cocoon because we are in a hurry and not to sleep with the bride before the wedding. To be chaste is to let gift be gift. Biblically, to be chaste is to have our shoes off before the burning bush.

Chastity is reverence and respect. All irreverence and disrespect is the antithesis of chastity. Chastity as a practical virtue is then predicated on two things; patience and the capacity to carry tension.

Patience is basically synonymous with chastity. To fully respect others and the proper order of things means to be patient. Something can be wrong for no other reason than that it is premature. To do anything too quickly, whether that be growing up or having sex, does what applying extra heat does to the process of metamorphosis. It leaves us with damaged wings.

Allan Bloom, the renowned philosopher of education, in describing lack of chastity in today’s youth, puts things this way: premature experience is bad precisely because it is premature. In youth, for example, yearning is meant precisely for sublimination, in the sense of making things sublime, of orientating what aches in us towards great love, great art and great achievement. Premature experience, like the false ecstasy of drugs, artificially induces the exaltation naturally attached to the completion of some great endeavour – victory in a just war, mature consummated love, great artistic creation, real religious devotion and the discovery of deep truth. Premature experience has precisely the effect of clipping our wings in that it drains us of great enthusiasm and great expectations. Great longing then becomes little more than being horny. Only sublimination, tension and waiting (the proper definition of patience) allow for the sublime.

The capacity to carry tension is also an integral part of chastity. To properly respect others, to have the patience to not act prematurely, requires that we be willing and able to carry tension and to carry it for a long time, perhaps even for a lifetime. To wait in tension, in incompleteness, in longing, in frustration, in consummation and in helplessness in the face of the interminable slowness of things, especially in the face of how slow love and justice seem to appear in our lives, is to practice chastity.

When Jesus sweated blood in the garden of Gethsemane he was practicing chastity; just as when Mary stood under the cross, unable to stop its senselessness and unable even to protest Jesus’ innocence, she too was practicing chastity. Unless we are willing to carry tension in the same way we will, precisely, never wait for the wedding night.

Chastity’s challenge reads this way: Never short-circuit the process of metamorphosis. Whether you are dealing with sex or with life in general, wait for the wedding night for the consummation.
*
 
OOps! I notice that my underlining and bold did not come out as I transferred from a Word document. It does not matter - you can insert your own !

For me this article is simply wonderful and I hope you will agree with me.

Blessings
Cinette:)
 
This is just the tip of the Iceberg. I am a Historian by vocation and so therefore I have a grasp of the sweep of History. The truth is there if you are willing to see it. The Roman Church has a consistent history as an abusive system.
Starting in 1200 until 1800 the Roman Church has abused, tortured, and killed thousands of people who disagreed with its teachings.
Since you claim to be a historian, you would also know that the Catholic Church goes way back to the year 33 AD when Christ founded it wouldn’t you?

And if you are any good as a historian, you would also know that while abuses did and does happen within the Church, you would know that there is a lot of good that happened **because **of the Cathoclic Church. Or is your study of history skewed in which case you are not worthy of the title historian:)
It has sanctioned slavery, mistreatment of indigenous peoples by Spain, Portugal, and other Catholic European powers. It has opposed Science by choking freedom of inquiry and has silenced those who challenged Rome in the field of the intellect.
Whoa, now I really know that you are NOT a reliable historian. All these myths have since been debunked. Now don’t get me wrong, I am not denying that there is some truth to what you say, but some truth is not all truth. Some truth actually comes out a lie. :tsktsk:
Starting in the 1800s it has opposed Democratic principles and social democratic principles which most of us take for granted today. The Roman Church has fought tooth and nail against freedom of Religion and freedom of conscience.
With every word you utter, you are only convincing me that you are not really the objective, erudite historian you claim to be. Hiding behind the title does not spare you the burden of proof.
I have been surfing the web and going to different Catholic forums and what I see there is what I see here, Catholics trying to make excuses for and downplay and cast doubt on the victims of this scandal Ireland. I find such behaviour sickening and morally repulsive.
Hey, there are scandals. It is tragic that it happens but it does not make the Church any less the Church that Christ founded on this earth. By virtue of that, she will always triumph inspite of the foibles of her member. Christ founded His Chruch so that her members may avail of the sacraments necessary for the advancement into holiness. And this is not downplaying, it will all happen in God’s time.
I left the Roman Church not long ago over Doctrinal issues.
Now we really see what you truly are.
If I hadn’t done it then this scandal certainly would have caused me to leave.
That is understandable. You are probably one of those who been so ill taught as to the truth of Christ’s Church. You are terribly ignorant of doctrines of the Catholic and this time around we will consider ignorance an excuse.😃
Because this is just yet another expose in what has become an endemic institutional behaviour, IE the Roman System with its combination of wrong Dogmas,
Which ones?
Clerical Celibacy, and Hierarchical Pope who has absolute authority to the point of allegedly being infallible
Which is how Christ willed it or don’t you read your Bible?
are the actual causes of this long train of abuses and institutional behaviour, from the 600 year reign of terror of the Inquisition,
You keep showing your lack of historical knowledge everytime you open your mouth. Have you read the latest on what the inquisition is truly about? I thought not, you prefer to wallow in the lies that the devil feeds you.
the enslaving of native peoples, opposition to Science, freedom of Religion, liberty of Conscience, Social Democratic principles,and the silencing of Scientific and academic inquiry.
Proof? For a “historian” you are full of hot air and not much else.🙂
This latest scandal is the last straw for me.
Hey, you’ve already said you’ve left the church long ago so how can this be the last straw. Inconsistencies my dear. They will be your undoing.
I really don’t care what Roman Catholic Apologists say now. As far as I am concerned, based on the behaviour of the Roman Church in this and other scandals and its barbarous callous behaviour, I know that these “Apologists” are distorters of truth and in some cases have been liars whose only interest is to justify Rome and “prove” the Roman Church right at the expense of facts and truth.
Hot air again. So much anger and not much sense in your post I dont’ even know why I am bothering to reply to this except it is quite fun.😃
When Lech Walesa in Poland started “Solidarity” and the Polish shipyard workers went on strike the Communist government sent negotiators to talk it out. Lech Walesa climbed up a scaffolding with a bullhorn and shouted

“We don’t believe your lies anymore”

to the government representatives.
I say now

to the Popes

to the Hierarchy and Magisterium of the Roman Church

to all the Roman Catholic Apologists and “Catholic Answers”

**I Don’t Believe Your Lies Anymore **
How dramatic:rolleyes:. ****You mean you prefer to believe your own lies? Hmmm, there is a mental disorder that fits that description.:rotfl::rotfl:
But seriously, which lies are you talking about?
 
There is no doubt that we have experienced abuse and corruption in the Catholic Church and as long as our members are human we will continue to experience these things. Our corrupt secular world finds a way to affect even some clergy - Sex is a commodity which is in our faces all the time - there are temptations at every turn, every moment.

However in our God-less world we see the divorce rate at its highest, the genocide of abortion, the huge number of single parents (some as a result of divorce but many choose this state) splintered and broken families, suffering children without direction - abandoned, abused and lost, human trafficking, slavery, huge numbers of refugees who leave their countries fleeing from wars and corrupt and cruel Dictators. The world has gone mad!

Let us look at the human suffering which surrounds us all the time.

We need to pray NOW!
 
I believe deep in my heart that we, the Catholics are living the greatest moments of all history, regardless of scandals, complaints, false accusations or sensationalism. WHAT A GREAT TIME TO BE CATHOLIC!!!!🙂
Why? Because we belong to the ONLY Church founded by Christ Himself and He as our Head is all holiness even though Her members are in struggle.
When a renegade Catholic, one day decided to protest the Church’s teachings and starts looking for a menu that pleases him/her, (a “church” with a better PREACHER, parking lot, music, etc, etc.) is based on wrong motives, only. I have the assurance that a true Catholic DOES NOT SWITCH CHURCHES just because doesn’t like something. Love for our Church is love for Her Founder and is not based on feelings of any kind that come and go. The Catholic Church is not based on a democratic ballot. With all respect, what other “church” can say the same?
Guided by the Holy Spirit, we bring a problem to the Pope, if necessary, discuss it but most importantly PRAY about it until we find relief. The Holy Spirit will never mislead any one because He is ALL TRUTH, can’t deceive nor can be deceived.🙂
I believe when a problem can’t be solved at a human level, I do not waste any more time, I pray and pray with other members, alone, it doesn’t matter, and after that, I still pray and you know what? He listens and answers. If He doesn’t provide me the answer I was looking for, He gives me the fortitude needed to keep carrying the cross to the end.
In great humility, I am praying for all those brothers and sisters who call themselves separated from the **ONLY CHURCH ** so that one day Jesus leads them to the right track, to their HOME, where the FULLNESS OF ALL BIBLICAL AND HISTORICAL FACTS RESIDE.
2,000 YEARS OF JOY AND PAIN
but faithful to the teachings of Jesus Christ because He is and will be with us until the end of time.
WE ARE NOT A PERFECT MARRIAGE, BUT WHICH ONE ISN’T? I love my Catholic Church and very proud of Her beauty, many Heroes and Miracles, History, Love and Peace. WOW!!🙂

Love is a mutual self-giving that ends in self-recovery. You recover God, and He recovers you. Archbishop Fulton J. Sheen
 
The results of the dreadful recent report in Ireland is not as big a shock here in Ireland as around the world. How big and widespread it was however is. We have been expecting the report for some time and are appauled and ashamed by the eventual report. The abuse has been going on for perhaps over 60 years. A great effort is being put forward by both government and Clergy to try and rectify what they can, and try and put some plan of action into force for the victims and their families. Some of the abused are deceased, others in their 60s, and the hurt is beyond belief for them.
Thousands of ordinary Irish people have signed books of condolences
in unity with the victims.
We must pray for the victims, that justice will be done and be seen to be done, but also for the Brothers, and Priests, who have done no wrong,( and for those who have) and for the lay people that their faith
will hold strong, and support our Priests who must be feeling very betrayed and to give them courage to carry out their Priestly duties in the knowledge of the support of their congregation.
God Bless, protect ,and have Mercy on us all.
 
As a member of the Catholic Church, and a person who tries and struggles sometimes to seperate the faith from the misdeeds of some of it’s members.

I would like to unreservedly apologise to the victims. I feel shame…sorrow and disgust.

I love my faith, I can see the “good” too…although I understand that it would be in poor taste to talk of this at these times.

In all humility and I am broken hearted, and so very very sorry that any child suffered at the hands of members of my faith. I am so very sorry. I will speak and do my bit on your behalf from the “inside”. I promise.
 
BBC: Irish abuse report is “shocking”

An inquiry into abuse suffered by children in Catholic institutions in Ireland is “shocking reading” the country’s parliament has been told.

About 35,000 children were placed in a network of reformatories, industrial schools and workhouses up to the 1980s.

More than 2,000 told the Commission to Inquire Into Child Abuse they suffered physical and sexual abuse while there.

The leader of Ireland’s Labour Party said the report contains accounts of children being flogged.

Eamon Gilmore told the Irish Parliament that the report will shock many people when it is published.

The Irish Prime Minister Brian Cowen said: “We are all agreed that it is appalling the vista that will emerge in respect of a bygone day that is no longer with us, thankfully.”

The BBC’s Mark Simpson said the inquiry was expected to criticise the Church’s handling of sex abuse complaints.

The institutions housed abandoned or neglected children, but courts also sent those guilty of truancy and petty crime.

Unmarried mothers were also sent to institutions known as Magdalene Laundries, many by their own families.

Hundreds of the victims moved away from Ireland once they left the care homes and went to live in the UK.

Many of those who are alleged to have carried out the abuse are now dead

Apology

The commission was established in 2000 after the then Taoiseach Bertie Ahern issued an apology on behalf of the state to the victims of child abuse.

A government compensation scheme was also established. It has already paid out almost one billion euros in compensation and legal fees to 12,500 people.

Led by Mr Justice Sean Ryan, the commission’s report is believed to be five volumes and 2,500 pages long.

Thousands of abused men and women testified to the commission, which was set up after a television series revealed the scale of the abuse.

Journalist Mary Raftery, who was behind the series, said the extent and depravity of the abuse was “profoundly shocking”.

“It is off the scale in terms of anything we have any knowledge of or any ability to deal with, particularly, as it was perpetrated, in the main, by members of religious orders,” she said.

Ms Raftery said the children ended up in “houses of horror” and were essentially locked up until they were 16.

“They emerged deeply disturbed and damaged and so many of them immediately emigrated,” she said.

"They felt their country had abandoned them as well as everything else, as well as their religion, that just stripped them bare of any kind of support.

“It is an absolutely shameful episode in our history.”

The allegations include sexual abuse and repeated beating of boys and girls with a leather strap.

Some punishments were said to be handed out for talking at mealtimes or writing left handed.

More than 100 institutions run by religious orders have been examined and the inquiry is expected to produce specific findings against a number of facilities.

Another major report is due next month on abuse by Catholic priests working in parish churches around Dublin.

The Archbishop of Dublin, the Most Reverend Diarmuid Martin, warned last month that it would “shock us all.”
Sounds a lot like the boarding schools the American govt. set up across the country for NDN kids. The same sort of abuse was done, the same sort of attitudes emerged from the govt schools. They fostered drunkeness, and generations of abuse. Many of us have named it the boarding school attitude. My grand parents and parents were victims of the boarding schools, they were abused by the officials of the schools, and the abuse they learned was passed down thru the generations. They abuse the received was mostly at the hands of protestant teaches and govt employees. I feel sorry for those Irish kids, sounds like their country treated them like NDNs. I know how rough that was. Pray for them. Pax Christi
 
i just know that i get tired of people making excuses that these type of things happen in other churches and other institutions. does that make it okay that it happens in the Catholic Church?
No it does not make it okay. And what people are saying is not an excuse but just a statement of fact that we all belong to the sinfull human race. Yes we are called to live by higher standards but it is also a reality that we all fail (some more so than others).

Let those without sin cast the first stone.
if we are trying to be the beacon of light for people to follow to Christ,
in my eyes, it doesn’t make it okay. or someone might say, “yes, but that happened a long time ago”.
Yes and no. To say that happened a long time ago is to put things in perspective, to show that perhaps there has been a change, albeit small, towards the good.

Still we cannot brush off these incidents with such a statement. We are called to acknowledge our sins and repent. Sometime repentance takes time.
after awhile, you have to stop making excuses.
If they are not excuses then we must keep reiterating them.

Another important thing we must remember is that the Church is here to preach the Truth even if some of her members fail miserably.
 
I was abused by a priest and my mother forced me to go to confession. Guess who was the only priest in my parish I had to go to confession to ?
But I also have a comment : Sexual abuse is the only crime I know of who, when declared a crime, was also retro-active. I was quite shocked when I heard on TV a priest coming out of a court-room, saying to the crowd of parishioners who were applauding his conviction : I agree it was a sin, but it was not a crime. I am not in any way excusing him, but it got me to thinking :What if I am doing something now which will be declared a crime in ten years and be retro-active ? This could happen to all of us who comment on homosexuality if it comes under the list of hate-crimes law .
 
Yeah right. For every money hungry welfare bum trying to line his pockets, there are probably 10 “good Catholics” who concealed the matter “for the good of the church.”
Several problems here. first off, as far as the numbers they quote, youn need to remember this is over a 60 year period of time. That is a fact the media likes to ignore. Taken in that perspective, while it is still awfull and unacceptable, it is not as shocking as they would want you to belive.
Secound, what was the rate of abuse for the country as whole? The Church pulls her Priests, Brothers, and Nuns from that population, so if the rate for the Church is equal or less than the nnational level, that mean she needs to screen aplicants at the Seminary better.
Third over a sixty year period of time culture has changed, some of what we see as abusetoday, was “correction” then. I attended public school from 2nd Grade to High School graduation. I clearly remember being paddled in fourth grade by the teacher over an incident. I do not belive it was right, nor that it taught me anything other that to be afraid of being noticed. Was it abuse? In the midwest in the late 60’s it was not considered that. Today it is.
The bigest problem is there are many folks who were abused by a clergy member. To do this is to betray their vows, and to do the work of the devil. Because it makes it harder for the majority of clergy who are faithfull to do the work of Christ
😊
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top