Is catholicism biblical

  • Thread starter Thread starter noobio
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
*I received recently two book gifts from a dear friend:
  • Evangelical is not Enough by Thomas Howard who converted to Catholicism years ago.
  • Return to Rome (confessions of an Evangelical Catholic) by Francis J Beckwith
    Why the President of the Evangelical Theological Society left his Post and returned to the Catholic Church. - This is what it says on the back cover: “In 2007 Beckwith, an esteemed scholar on ethical and political issues at Baylor University, after announcing he had returned to the Catholic Church, resigned as president of the Evangical Theological Society. In this highly readable apologia pro vita sua, Frank reveals the reasons for his surprising spiritual odyssey.”
It takes courage to convert especially when one has invested so much in a ministry in a non-Catholic Church. One has to resign from a Ministry one loved, risk the criticism of family and friends. It can be a very trying time. But when you have to choose between the fullness of the truth and… There is a special ministry that caters for assisting ministers of religion who want to convert but who have a great deal of issues. Right now they have over 1 800 ministers on their books who they counsel and assist in many different ways.

We need to pray for the “Coming Home Network” (Marcus Grodi, director and a convert himself).

God bless all
Cinette:)
 
Cinette, I love to watch his show: “Coming Home Network” (Marcus Grodi, director and a convert himself). 👍
 
Lol. Protestant comes and challenges Catholics. Catholics pile him with answers. Protestant can’t bear how informed Catholics are on this forum. Protestant Retreats.
First of all I am not a protestant!!! I think I made that clear in some of my posts. I can answer, but I don’t think there will be an end to the discussion. I did not quit because I can not answer.
 
But obviously we can reach a conclusion about the points I raised yesterday in Post #48 (which you have not yet responded to).
And not only that, we can easily reach a conclusion.

For example, I asked whether or not you are an adherent to Sola Scriptura (“Scripture Alone”). Some of your posts suggest you are, and some don’t.
We can easily reach a conclusion to this question by you simply telling me “yes” or “no”.

Once that is established, then you can answer my follow-up inquiry (also from Post #48). I’ll present it again here:

If you are not an adherent of Sola Scriptura then why do you demand that Catholic teachings be expressly found in the Bible in order to be valid? Isn’t that a fair question?

If you are an adherent of Sola Scriptura then where does the Bible actually teach this? After all, if Sola Scriptura is a Christian teaching and it says to reject Christian teachings that aren’t in the Bible, then Sola Scriptura would itself have to be in the Bible, wouldn’t it? In other words, I’m asking if Sola Scriptura follows its own rule. I’m asking if it passes its own test.

This is another subject with which we can easily reach a conclusion. Namely, if Sola Scriptura is in the Bible, give me the book, chapter and verse. If you do that, and if the verse actually teaches* Sola Scriptura*, then we will have reached a conclusion demonstrating its validity.

But if neither you nor anyone else can provide a book, chapter and verse from the Bible which actually teaches Sola Scriptura then we will conclude that Sola Scriptura is an invalid teaching because it presents itself as a teaching which fails its own test for validity (meaning that it tells us to only accept Christian teachings which are expressly found in the Bible while itself not being expressly found in the Bible; something that presents this kind of paradox cannot possibly be a truthful teaching).

I’m guessing this was sarcasm. If not and you are serious then this, of course, brings up more questions…
I

I accpet Sola Scriptura because I believe that that the Bible alone should be authoritative over the Christian faith.

The bible supports this teaching.

1 Corinthians 4:6
6 Now, brothers and sisters, I have applied these things to myself and Apollos for your benefit, so that you may learn from us the meaning of the saying, “**Do not go beyond what is written.” **Then you will not be puffed up in being a follower of one of us over against the other.
 
First of all I am not a protestant!!! I think I made that clear in some of my posts. I can answer, but I don’t think there will be an end to the discussion. I did not quit because I can not answer.
You identify yourself as “Protestant” on your profile. You hold to Protestant theology and insist on the abridged Canon, so if not Protestant then what are you?
 
*Randy has given you proof that Purgatory is in the Bible! He has sited chapter and verse - what more do you want!.

I think that you do not read his posts in which case I ask you why did you begin this thread?

Cinette*
I think I refuted this doctrine on post 16.
 
Cinette, I love to watch his show: “Coming Home Network” (Marcus Grodi, director and a convert himself). 👍
*The show is called “Journey Home” and his ministry is Coming Home Network. If you Google you will be led to it.

He has just written a book about his Ministry.

God bless
Cinette:)*
 
You identify yourself as “Protestant” on your profile. You hold to Protestant theology and insist on the abridged Canon, so if not Protestant then what are you?
I don’t know what I am but I know that I accept what the Bible says only.
 
I

I accpet Sola Scriptura because I believe that that the Bible alone should be authoritative over the Christian faith.

The bible supports this teaching.

1 Corinthians 4:6
6 Now, brothers and sisters, I have applied these things to myself and Apollos for your benefit, so that you may learn from us the meaning of the saying, “**Do not go beyond what is written.” **Then you will not be puffed up in being a follower of one of us over against the other.
In context this passage is a condemnation of division (one of the hallmarks of Protestantism). Furthermore, the Bible does not condemn Tradition:
I commend you because you remember me in everything and maintain the traditions even as I have delivered them to you.
1 Cor. 11:2
So then, brethren, stand firm and hold to the traditions which you were taught by us, either by word of mouth or by letter.
2 Thess. 2:15

Sorry, but Sola Scriptura is not in the Scriptures. It is an assumption that Protestants make that has no Scriptural support.
 
I

I accpet Sola Scriptura because I believe that that the Bible alone should be authoritative over the Christian faith.

The bible supports this teaching.

1 Corinthians 4:6
6 Now, brothers and sisters, I have applied these things to myself and Apollos for your benefit, so that you may learn from us the meaning of the saying, “**Do not go beyond what is written.” **Then you will not be puffed up in being a follower of one of us over against the other.
*Noobio - You must learn to think. Pray for an infilling of the Holy Spirit so that you may be guided. You display such confusion. Ask the Holy Spirit for the gift of discernment and Faith.

God bless you
Cinette:)

P.S. 2 Peter 3:16 “For there are many things in scripture that are hard to understand which ignorant and unstable people distort as they do the other scriptures to their destruction.” *
 
Cinette, that is a great question which was the same question I asked myself as a former non–Catholic, only I substituted my name for the murderer:

If I, Joe, who is repentant, died on the same day as say, Mother Teresa, would I go straight to heaven with M. Teresa? No way! Would there be no need for me to atone for my sin, mortal or otherwise? No way! Would my repentance be enough? Now way! Would I need some sort of purification before I could behold the ineffable beatific vision? Yes way!

That day which will bring our works to light, clearly applies to the after life, as opposed to this life.

Our works will be tested by the Divine fire of God.

Heaven.

Upon our demise, if our works are burned up, the builder (the Christian) - will suffer loss **but will still be saved, as one escaping through the Divine purifying flames of our Savior. **If this is not what the CC labeled - Purgatory, then I don’t know what else it could be?
I believe 1 Cornithians 3 is talking about judgement day. I t makes sense because the passage talks about God judging us.

Purgatory is the purging of sins and includes bieng burned by fire.

newadvent.org/cathen/12575a.htm

The passage you talk about does not say anything about bieng purified by fire. but talks about “escaping fire” You do not burn, but your works do. Your works bieng burned up is not the same as purgatory.

Why woudn’t you go to heaven? If you accept Christ he will cleans ALL YOUR SINS.
 
I believe 1 Cornithians 3 is talking about judgement day. I t makes sense because the passage talks about God judging us.

Purgatory is the purging of sins and includes bieng burned by fire.

newadvent.org/cathen/12575a.htm

The passage you talk about does not say anything about bieng purified by fire. but talks about “escaping fire” You do not burn, but your works do. Your works bieng burned up is not the same as purgatory.

Why woudn’t you go to heaven? If you accept Christ he will cleans ALL YOUR SINS.
*Study Matthew 25 - pray and read s l o w l y.

God bless
Cinette:)*
 
Noobio English does not seem to be your first language. The word Purgatory is not mentioned in the Bible neither is Incarnation and Trinity and others but the Church, through prayer, study and discernment arrived at that conclusion. The same with Purgatory. From the way you spell Baptism I suspect that you might be Arabic. I worked with an Egyptian who always pronounced p as b for instance.

If I am right then you must think carefully and go back to the NT and Randy’s explanation - you should pray about it.

God bless you
Cinette
I know the word trinity and incarnation are not in the Bible. But, the principles are in the Bible. Purgatory is not in the Bible at all. 1 Cornthians 3:11-15 is talking about something else.
 
I believe 1 Cornithians 3 is talking about judgement day. I t makes sense because the passage talks about God judging us.

Purgatory is the purging of sins and includes bieng burned by fire.

newadvent.org/cathen/12575a.htm

The passage you talk about does not say anything about bieng purified by fire. but talks about “escaping fire” You do not burn, but your works do. Your works bieng burned up is not the same as purgatory.

Why woudn’t you go to heaven? If you accept Christ he will cleans ALL YOUR SINS.
Jesus said “It is not those who call me Lord, Lord…”

:whistle:“Spirit of the Living God fall afresh on Noobio…”

God bless you
*
 
I am know the word trinity and incarnation are not in the Bible. But, the principles are in the Bible. Purgatory is not in the Bible at all. 1 Cornthians 3:11-15 is talking about something else.
Actually, Biblical interpretation must be done in light of the Magisterium, and the Church has always taught that this is a reference to Purgatory. Although you believe it does not refer to Purgatory, it is intellectually dishonest to say that it absolutely cannot be interpreted that way.
 
I believe 1 Cornithians 3 is talking about judgement day. I t makes sense because the passage talks about God judging us.

Purgatory is the purging of sins and includes bieng burned by fire.

newadvent.org/cathen/12575a.htm

The passage you talk about does not say anything about bieng purified by fire. but talks about “escaping fire” You do not burn, but your works do. Your works bieng burned up is not the same as purgatory.

Why woudn’t you go to heaven? If you accept Christ he will cleans ALL YOUR SINS.
Sin has two aspects: eternal and temporal. Christ does remove the guilt, but not the damage done to your soul. It would be like borrowing a friends shirt and getting it stained. You apologize and show sorrow for ruining the shirt (repentance and contrition), and your friend forgives you, but at the end of the day, you still need to take the shirt to the cleaners!
 
Actually, Biblical interpretation must be done in light of the Magisterium, and the Church has always taught that this is a reference to Purgatory. Although you believe it does not refer to Purgatory, it is intellectually dishonest to say that it absolutely cannot be interpreted that way.
Is the Magisterium inspired by God? I am pretty sure the Bible is clear and you can interpret it without any tradition or Magisterium.
 
Sin has two aspects: eternal and temporal. Christ does remove the guilt, but not the damage done to your soul. It would be like borrowing a friends shirt and getting it stained. You apologize and show sorrow for ruining the shirt (repentance and contrition), and your friend forgives you, but at the end of the day, you still need to take the shirt to the cleaners!
But where is it in the Bible. If you properly interpret 1 Cornithians 3:11-15 you notice its talking about burning works and “escaping fire” which doesn’t seem to really talk about removing any damage.Don’t you think the death of Christ completly recover every damage?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top