Is it ok to listen to Dr Taylor Marshall?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Moniabay
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Michael Matt has been championing Church teaching and the TLM from the very beginning. I think you’re right that many wrote him off earlier – but it’s hard to do that now given the state of affairs…
The Matt family has been crying Wolf continuously for about 55 years, so yeah, they will be right sometimes. This is less helpful than Fr Mitch Pacwa, who cries cry Wolf rarely, but also communicates other things as needed.

A fire alarm that goes off all the time, for any and all reason, gets ignored.
 
Last edited:
Not protestant perspectives but rather a fresh enthusiasm that is often seen tainted or dulled in cradle Catholics. Their late arrival to work in the field can produce as much if not more than someone who has labored all day.
That is a good point. I have heard others say that also, converts and reverts can be your strongest Catholics. Many of the apologists on EWTN are reverts and converts.
 
Michael Matt had an awesome interview with Bishop Athanasius Schneider last week.
That interview was actually the first time I heard/viewed Bishop Athanasius Schneider at length.
For some reason I felt for him while he spoke. He sounds like a man of Truth. Plus I think he might have been coming down with a cold virus…I felt sad about that given his age and possible difficulty he might have felt extending himself for the hour interview.
 
Last edited:
That is a good point. I have heard others say that also, converts and reverts can be your strongest Catholics. Many of the apologists on EWTN are reverts and converts.
Yes, EWTN would be nothing without zealous converts. Zeal is awesome. When it slides into “celebrating Halloween is celebrating Satan,” something has really gone off the rails. That’s puritanism, not Catholicism.
40.png
gracepoole:
but it’s hard to do that now given the state of affairs…
Michael Matt had an awesome interview with Bishop Athanasius Schneider last week.
Yes, he did!
 
When it slides into “celebrating Halloween is celebrating Satan,” something has really gone off the rails
I think I missed the Halloween part somewhere. I know many traditional Catholics that celebrate Halloween and I know some non Traditional Catholics that don’t celebrate Halloween. I know protestants that celebrate Halloween and some that don’t.

This book written by a Jesuit Catholic priest advises Catholics to avoid Halloween.
https://www.amazon.com/Religious-Customs-Family-Radiation-Catholic/dp/0895556138

My point being celebrating or not celebrating Halloween does not dictate one’s level of zeal. I think Halloween is a controversial subject among all Christians.
 
That interview was actually the first time I heard/viewed Bishop Athanasius Schneider at length.
For some reason I felt for him while he spoke
I have just started reading his book Christus Vincit and am on his biography. That is awesome too. He knows the names and stories of all of his family and the struggles they went through during the Russian revolution and how they would secretly celebrate Mass, hide priests, celebrate the sacraments in their home and just pass the faith on in tumultuous times.
 
It’s just an example, but yes, many converts and those instructing converts tell fellow Catholics to avoid Halloween. And that’s illegitimate. Halloween is a Catholic holiday. Telling fellow Catholics that while, begrudgingly, we have to accept the OF as valid but we should do everything in our power to avoid it is also problematic – it’s an attitude full of zeal but it is not aligned with Church teaching.

Frankly, it’s a bit worrisome that those who are the “most Catholic” in Catholic media have been Catholic for only a fraction of their lives. But I know that’s a really unpopular opinion.
 
many converts and those instructing converts tell fellow Catholics to avoid Halloween. And that’s illegitimate. Halloween is a Catholic holiday.
True, could maybe be because secularism has taken over another holy day and Halloween is rarely seen as All Hallows Eve anymore but just a day to celebrate scarey things.
Frankly, it’s a bit worrisome that those who are the “most Catholic” in Catholic media have been Catholic for only a fraction of their lives. But I know that’s a really unpopular opinion.
I understand what you are saying. Perhaps their new found faith does cause them to have more zeal and gives them that desire to study and learn the faith more than someone who has been in the Church their whole life and has come to take it for granted.(not that all do). Perhaps it is like the parable of the woman and the lost coin, who wants everyone to rejoice with her when she finds it.
I think you will find those who grew up in the faith can be on fire or luke warm and just the same for converts. They can either be on fire or luke warm also. Probably just depends on one’s seriousness and desire to learn.
 
If so, parents need divine authority when they tell maturing kids truth about Santa Claus.

But to blue pill you do need to offer a non-truth (Marshall has offered himself as divine authority) and if anyone takes that blue pill they can take a permanent nap from Marshall in fantasy land based on the non truth (he’s nuts! he holds himself as divine authority!)
  1. Parents do have divine authority (i.e. it is given to them by God) over their children. To be quite frank, I wish I’d known that growing up. It might have saved me a lot of arguments with my parents.
  2. When did Dr. Marshall say that and in what context? I watched part of his interview with Michael Matt (still have to finish it) and think that’s his best one yet.
 
When it slides into “celebrating Halloween is celebrating Satan,” something has really gone off the rails. That’s puritanism, not Catholicism.
Imo, one should celebrate All Saints Day instead of Halloween. That’s why it’s All Hallow’s Eve, i.e. it’s the Vigil of All Saints Day.

Now on the Byzantine calendar we celebrate All Saints on the First Sunday after Pentecost (=Trinity Sunday on the Latin calendar). One year we had all the kids dress up as their favorite/patron saint even though we don’t observe All Saints Day as the West does.
 
  1. Great point thanks
  2. No sorry I didn’t mean to suggest he said that, but meant to suggest that’s what someone would need to show he did say to show he is “blue pilling” (deceiving). Thanks I’ll check out Matt show
 
Last edited:
40.png
commenter:
And Mother Angelica?
Imo, Mother Angelica would have publicly pilloried the idolatry and sacrilege that occurred in the Vatican Gardens. She was one tough nun.

Boy, do I miss her.
I miss her too. She walked that narrow path, being in unity with the teaching authority of the Church, in obedience to Church officials, but not putting up with nonsense either.

Her ministries were always with the (sometimes grudging) approval of appropriate Church officials. It is likely there were some things she would have liked to do, some dioceses she would have wanted to hold a conference in, some proposed articles she cancelled, because she valued that unity. She knew she wasn’t in the hierarchy.

In the world of 2019, she would be totally rejected by the liberals, and somewhat rejected by the Trads. Both of those groups have as much in common with each other as with her.
 
Last edited:
What is Nouvelle théologie?
Listening to this episode now wondering how many Catholic books on my shelf are junk. :crying_cat_face:Double sad because I recall seeing Trojan horse City of God Catholic Crisis Explained on my parents book shelves. Why didn’t I save every one of their books? 😿

Really, how do I begin to sort through my many books. One at a time, I suppose.
 
Last edited:
I know I have a few tan classics. Not too long ago I tossed a title by a certain Cardinal. There is no sense in donating unworthy books to unsuspecting souls. Garbage can 🛢️
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top