Is it ok to listen to Dr Taylor Marshall?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Moniabay
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Aquinas11 said:
40.png
gracepoole:
If that’s not sowing division I don’t know what is.
Click to expand...
Note that this is not what the Church teaches
Click to expand...
Your statement doesn’t seem to mean anything. Can you explain?
 
Aquinas11 said:
40.png
gracepoole:
What a telling choice of words.
Click to expand...
Well it means “accept as true and valid”

Unless one chooses a more “telling” choice of definition
Click to expand...
First definition that pops up for concedes: “admit that something is true or valid after first denying or resisting it.”
 
Aquinas11 said:
40.png
gracepoole:
Note that this is not what the Church teaches
Click to expand...
Now this doesn’t mean anything, can you explain?
Click to expand...
It means, per the comment below to which I was originally responding, that the Church does not consider the Novus Ordo a “liturgical failure.” It does not teach that the Church is bifurcating into two religions and it does not teach that we ought to make a choice of the “original and traditional Catholicism.”
On Taylor Marshall’s FB April 27. He said:
“the Novus Ordo has been a liturgical failure. Catholicism seems to be bifurcating into two religions. Choose the original and traditional Catholicism.”
Click to expand...
 
Aquinas11 said:
40.png
gracepoole:
Hardly.
Click to expand...
then by all means link us the source where Dr Marshall denied or resisted that NO is valid.
Click to expand...
You keep reverting back to this red herring. As far as I know, no one has said that Marshall claims the OF is invalid. His personal preference, however, definitely has morphed into something of a moral imperative of late.
Aquinas11 said:
40.png
gracepoole:
It does not teach that the Church is bifurcating into two religions
Click to expand...
nor does it teach that commenting on liturgical preference constitutes “sowing division”
Click to expand...
And again, Marshall isn’t just “commenting on liturgical preference” when he claims the OF is a “liturgical failure.”

I’m not really sure why you’re so insistent on defending Marshall at every turn. I like him enough that I’ve seen most of his videos and read his most recent book. But I recognize that he’s a layman and therefore his personal preferences can become obsessions. Respectfully, you seem rabidly in his corner – and I don’t think that’s a good place to be with any non-religious commentator.
 
gracepoole said:
no one has said that Marshall claims the OF is invalid.
Click to expand...
so that definition choice was “telling”
gracepoole said:
And again, Marshall isn’t just “commenting on liturgical preference” when he claims the OF is a “liturgical failure.”
Click to expand...
Sure he is. You disagree, but its not more than opinion.
gracepoole said:
why you’re so insistent on defending Marshall at every turn…can become obsessions
Click to expand...
Your post zeroed in on one word in a long post about him. Then another post asking forum about his mental state. Then starting a thread regarding his social media account status. Its clear where the obsession with him lies.
 
Last edited:
No because if that were true, she would have cleared it up and said he 's never said that which she concedes he hasn’t. Instead it was just “he concedes? what a telling choice of words” Thus, all that did was further add to any confusion you’re discussing.
 
Last edited:
He also has a very good podcast page. I think it’s called Stay Salty. I really enjoyed and learned alot about the book of Apocalypse. Lots of good lessons.
 
Last edited:
In the past sure. Nowadays unfortunately a lot of conspiracy theories and I-know-better-than-the-Pope videos.
 
Yes. I think that the good found in anything Marshall says can be found elsewhere without all the bravado.

IMO, he is too Protestant in his approach. That may just be me.

As far as the Church being in crisis, she has been since the time of the Apostles - yet she is still here.

Does pouring gasoline on a fire help put the fire out, or does it make the fire worse? It seems to me that Marshall and Coffin, et al are better at pouring gasoline on fires than in helping to put them out.

Others are free to disagree. Just my opinion - and Marshall’s opinions are just his, nothing more.

#PrayTheRosary
 
What do you suggest? Ignoring the truth and bury the head under the sand?
For what i gathered the guy just put the light on very real issues of the church
 
His goal is to red pill 1 million Catholics about Pope Francis.

Seriously?

Peace.
#PrayTheRosary
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top