Is this a good or bad idea?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Nitro-Zeus1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Would you like to give you a Salaf forum where you can discuss this matter? I’m a member if that forum. I’ll be glad if we could gather and have a discussion together about this topic.
 
That talks about after life. It has nothing to do with this life. And those who are (name removed by moderator)ure and those who have heard correctly and perfectly the message of God Almighty and yet still they reject it.
 
Nitro-Zeus1 said:
Would you like to give you a Salaf forum where you can discuss this matter? I’m a member if that forum. I’ll be glad if we could gather and have a discussion together about this topic.
Click to expand...
I have no interest in discussing a false and violent religion.

This is the so-called peaceful Islam: “Although we are asked to be compassionate amongst each other, we have to be “harsh with unbelievers”, our Christian, Jewish and Atheist neighbours and colleagues (48:29).”
 
That was revealed at the time of Battle of Trench where three Arab Jewish tribes were oppressing Muslims back then and the objective of this is to stop oppression. But now, harsh can be in many ways and not necessarly as what you’re thinking. For example, if you’re being oppressed by another person, what would you do to put stop to oppression if being kind and nice won’t help?

Seems like you do not know our own history for you to talk about this
 
Last edited:
Nitro-Zeus1 said:
The point is to prove that there are Good and Kind Muslims.
Click to expand...
By talking about Christianity ? 🤔

We have a quote about preaching the Gospel, often attributed to St. Francis of Assisi : "Preach the Gospel at all times. If necessary, use words.”

I’d try the same way if I was wanting to prove that there are good and kind Muslims (which I do not doubt): focusing on showing God’s unconditional love through my daily actions.
Nitro-Zeus1 said:
I still believe that there is a enormous wisdom behind the capital punishments which God Almighty have prescribed
Click to expand...
If you’ll forgive me for saying so, I think such statements are not helping your cause, particularly on a Catholic forum where most people believe in God’s gift of free will to man and the sanctity of human life.
 
Montrose said:
Who wants to know Islam. The thrust of Islam is to convert everyone by conversion or coercion if necessary. It is a religion of violence.
Click to expand...
Nitro-Zeus1 said:
No no, not true. This has happened thousands of years ago. I can prove you wrong. For starters, please subscribe to my own website discoverthetruefaceofislam.wordpress.com where I will make a succesful debunk the myth that Islam is violent.
Click to expand...
I don’t know. On the one hand you ask us to subscribe to your website where you will “make a succesful debunk the myth that Islam is violent.” And yet you agree with the practice of honor killing. Where coercion is completely at play and where violence is not only acceptable, but is the rule. You either stay Muslim or you’re dead! Simple as that.

I can’t help but think that those of us who are trying to follow your argument that the Muslim faith is peaceful, are left scratching our heads and seeing the huge contradiction and disconnect here, by simply reading your posts!
 
Last edited:
I’m a tually trying to help you understand the “honor” of killing. Also, I’m gonna explain in what context the capital punishments are revealed by God Almighty so you can understand them. Actually, I’m gonna make a history about this. And I’m gonna prove that there is no violence in Islam, and that’s because I strongly do not believe in violence.

What would you think of Islam, if all Muslim countries practices fully the capital punishments. Like for example, if the Muslim police officers caught a Muslim civilian murdering a non-Muslim, then he is to be arrested and jailed but he is jailed until it is found strong and authentic proof that he committed murder intentionally, if it is found this, then he is to be executed but if it is found that he did unintentionally, then the family of the deceased will be called to Islamic Court in front of the Muslim Judge where they will be asked if they can forgive his mistake or no, but if the family of that non-Muslim does not forgive him, then he shall be executed as Retribution. How would you view Islam, then? If
 
Last edited:
Is this a good or bad idea?
Click to expand...
Sorry. I think it’s a bad idea.

An edit-able wiki for random internet users to contribute their thoughts about generic ‘Christianity’ (you know how much disagreement exists between groups that self-identify as ‘Christians’, right?) and you want it to be hosted by someone who intends to “delete” any content considered, from a Muslim perspective, to be “critical”, “negative”, or otherwise not “respecting all religions and faiths”?

Sorry, no. I do not think that’s a good idea. I wouldn’t even think that’s a good idea if the Catholic Church decided to host an editable wiki like that… I certainly don’t think it’s a good idea for such a wiki to be hosted by someone who intends to editorialize and delete the content posted by arguing Christians, on subjective criteria decided upon from a non-Christian perspective in the first place.
 
Last edited:
No no, not murder but executing. There’s a difference between murder and execution. The execution is done by Muslim authorities like police officers, soldiers etc… but murder is done by a civilian which murder is also punishable by death. I mean if a Muslim civilian murders a Christian civilian intentionally, then that Muslim civilian is subject to death penalty, because he disrespected the life.
 
No no, not from Muslim perspective butfrom Christian perspective. However, I’ll not inferer in your projects, you do whatever you want. Because, this is wiki is created for you
 
Last edited:
Nitro-Zeus1 said:
No no, not from Muslim perspective butfrom Christian perspective.
Click to expand...
But in your OP you expressed that you, a Sunni Muslim, would consider yourself qualified to subjectively decide what counts as “negative” or not “respecting all religions and faiths” from the content Christians discuss, and you would feel free to delete what the Christians wrote that you don’t want written.

No thanks. Christians don’t need to opt-in to have Muslims host and censor a forum for teaching the world about Christianity.
 
Well, the reason for this is because I believe that if people are not intrested to know about what Islam says, then we must prove them wrong by actions
 
Yes. What I mean by this is that if I see something insultive about Bible like saying that Noah is drunker it shall be edited, corrected or deleted. Because, in Islam, we respect every Prophet and Messenger of God and we do nit differentiate nor critique them because critiqing them is a big thing to us. I don’t mean to say that this wiki does not teach about Christianity. The objective of this wiki is actually for readers to see and learn about Christianity by using this wiki and informations about Chritianity is found in this wiki more than in wikipedia.org
 
Last edited:
Nitro-Zeus1 said:
Yes. What I mean by this is that if I see something insultive about Bible like saying that Noah is drunker it shall be edited, corrected or deleted. Because, in Islam, we respect every Prophet and Messenger of God and we do nit differentiate nor critique them because critiqing them is a big thing to us.
Click to expand...
Exactly.

What you have said here is exactly why no Christian should ever submit themselves to the censorship of Muslims when it comes to teaching the world what Christianity teaches.

Muslims have one way of looking at the prophets.

Christians have a different way of looking at the prophets.

If you let a Muslim “edit, correct or delete” what a Christian says about a prophet, your forum no longer represents Christian views. It represents Muslim views.
 
Nitro-Zeus1 said:
if I see something insultive about Bible like saying that Noah is drunker it shall be edited, corrected or deleted.
Click to expand...
But the Bible does tell that Noah got drunk on at least one occasion.
20Noah, a tiller of the soil, was the first to plant the vine. 21He drank some of the wine, and while he was drunk, he lay uncovered in his tent. 22Ham, father of Canaan, saw his father naked and told his two brothers outside. 23Shem and Japheth took a cloak and they both put it over their shoulders, and walking backwards, covered their father’s nakedness; they kept their faces turned away, and they did not look at their father naked. 24When Noah awoke from his stupor he learned what his youngest son had done to him, 25and said: Accursed be Canaan, he shall be his brothers’ meanest slave. 26He added: Blessed be Yahweh, God of Shem, let Canaan be his slave! 27May God make space for Japheth, may he live in the tents of Shem, and let Canaan be his slave! 28After the flood Noah lived three hundred and fifty years. 29In all, Noah’s life lasted nine hundred and fifty years; then he died.
Click to expand...
(Genesis 9:20-29)

So what would you do ? Would you censor the Bible ? How would that be good or kind to people who see the Bible as their Holy Scripture ?
 
Nitro-Zeus1 said:
No no, not murder but executing. There’s a difference between murder and execution. The execution is done by Muslim authorities like police officers, soldiers etc… but murder is done by a civilian which murder is also punishable by death.
Click to expand...
If a father kills his daughter, as in the linked story,
Gail Gattrell, the sisters’ great-aunt, described the deaths as an “honor killing” — which are often carried about by a relative who believes a woman went against conservative Islamic values on love or marriage
Click to expand...
Is this execution or murder?
 
Last edited:
Oh my, honor killing is false attribution to Islam. Because, a civilian whether he is Muslim or not, haveno right to do this but only Muslim authorities and Muslim court have the right to do this. This is a great corruption indeed and that’s all because of terrorists. There is absolutey no such thing as honor killing in Islam. Honor killing have no place in Islam. And what the Islamic Court does, is not honor killing, it is punishment.
 
Last edited:
Aaa, ok. Seems like I got wrong message. My apologise. Anyways, you have convinced me. That wiki will be totally yours and you do whatever you want with it. I’ll just be the monitor, but I’ll have to ask a Christian organization who can take the ownership of this wiki.
 
Ok, then I’ll let you write whatever you want. I’ll just not interfere with your projects and I just mind my own bussiness.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top