Those who are obese, through choice and lifestyle, disrespect the very gift of their life and ordinary health. They also impose a burden of anxiety upon relatives and friends which in turn can generate some very legitimate and negative emotions, and yes, sometimes judgments. Eventually–the burden can become tangible in the form of decreased mobility, compromised health, limited lifespan.
To me, obesity raises a moral issue if an individual, through neglect or weakness of will, places him/herself–and necessarily those who care about them–in a vulnerable, even dangerous, position. Would you suggest that those who are diligent about their health and fitness, and yet have this concern and burden inflicted upon them by family members, should remain silent about it?
First: Obesity is very often, perhaps most often, about a great deal more than “choice and lifestyle.” It can be a symptom of something that is everything other than a quest to stuff oneself for the mere pleasure of it.
Moreover, of all the sins that we commit, gluttony of excess, the gluttony that shows its effects in obesity, is currently being given a heavy judgement. Gluttony of delicacy, OTOH, that gluttony that insists on having the best portion or to only be content with the highest quality ingredients for oneself or that is put out when the preparation is not of the best, is the current vogue. Getting one’s nose bent out of shape because the menu is geared toward the health and sensitivity towards loved ones instead of the particular holiday goodies that we personally had hoped to indulge ourselves in is gluttony, too. I’m not saying you do this. I am saying that not all glutton is currently under equal judgement.
Do you think the obese don’t care if they are fat? Do you think they forget that they can’t sit on every chair, that they can’t keep up with others, that they aren’t afraid of premature death? Yet you sound a bit as if this is all about their responsibility to keep you from worrying about them. If they turned around and told you that turning your concern into anxiety was
your choice, would that help you? How you handle your emotions, after all, is your responsibility, not theirs, right? So you see where that kind of thinking can go. Everyone gets blamed and no one gets helped.
It is important to learn to speak when it is helpful and to be silent when that is helpful…so yes, sometimes the most moral and loving choice for relatives of the obese is to be silent. It is not just obese people who will tell you that harping on someone’s weight and singling them out for correction is unhelpful and even counterproductive. It is doctors and nutritionists, too, the people whose job it is to help the obese keep to a healthy diet and lifestyle. Do not be too proud to take the advice of the people who professionally study how these problems are best managed. Believe them.
You love your relatives, that much is clear. Your concern is a beatiful thing. It would be the easiest thing in the world to just say, “Their health is their problem, their soul is their problem, not my worry”. You are right: that would be wrong. Just try to make what you choose to do as helpful as you can, and sprinkle the patience for the sins of all as liberally as possible.
People make the assumption that fat people are lazy which is so untrue. I work very hard in the Department I work in I am the one who is always on the run doing this and doing that. I am dependable, reliable, honest and truthful. And I do not care what people say about me.
I’m happy you’ve freed yourself of the need to worry about your weight and beat yourself up for reasons of vanity and self-esteem. That was very wise.
Nevertheless, keep yourself under examination, regardless of your weight, about whether you are doing your best with your body, the Temple of the Holy Spirit. I do not mean to beat yourself up about it. I mean do not become lax in that part of your life. If you work too hard at everything else to take care of your own body, maybe the focus needs to shift a little.
If you are doing your best and your weight doesn’t budge, so be it. But even if our clothes fit like a million bucks, we all have to guard the gift of life and health. As you say, only God can judge. We ought to invite that. The perfection God wills for us, after all, is where our greatest happiness is to be found, in this life and in the next.