Jesus Christ is our only 'mediator' as stated by St. Paul

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bill_Pick
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
shw:Most of your recent post was very tedious, and irrelevant! Jesus’s disciples partook of communion, by each taking of the bread, and drinking from the cup! As believers, we are also disciples(Matthew 28:20), and therefore should partake of communion in the same manner(each taking of the bread, and drinking from the cup! Other than interpretation, and oral tradition, there doesn’t seem to be a precedent for the priest to be the sole drinker! And I don’t believe that anyone is the vicar of Christ, or the visible representative of Jesus on this earth(sorry, pope!)👍
 
prmerger: There is some disrespect going on in this forum; on both sides! Good thing Jesus has taught us to “turn the other cheek”! And I am not so much upset by the priest being the only one drinking from the cup, as I am disturbed bt your belief, that all Christians should partake of communion this way, when our Saviour, and His disciples did not! the three times that I have been to catholic churches(3 weddings and a funeral), the priest drank from the cup, and placed wafers on the tongues of parishioners! Even in prison, the catholic inmates partake of communion, with the priest or his representative performing the ritual, again being the ony one drinking from the cup!
 
prmerger: There is some disrespect going on in this forum; on both sides!
One person, (was it you, 1beleevr??), called elvisman"anal" on this thread. I dunno, but that seemed quite disrespectful to me. 🤷 Was that treating elvisman as you would Christ?
Good thing Jesus has taught us to “turn the other cheek”!
Yes, and elvisman, by God’s grace, was most gracious about the disrespect hurled at him. I know I would not be so gracious.
And I am not so much upset by the priest being the only one drinking from the cup, as I am disturbed bt your belief, that all Christians should partake of communion this way, when our Saviour, and His disciples did not! the three times that I have been to catholic churches(3 weddings and a funeral), the priest drank from the cup, and placed wafers on the tongues of parishioners! Even in prison, the catholic inmates partake of communion, with the priest or his representative performing the ritual, again being the ony one drinking from the cup!
You are quite mistaken again about Catholic practice, 1beleevr. We receive under both species at Mass. Both priests, deacons and the laity.
 
prmerger: God bless you for supporting your fellow catholics:thumbsup: Being anal, is not so much a sign of disrespect, as it is pointing out that someone is stubborn, as some have said about me! I also remember being called ignorant, and blind! But knowing that I am accepted by God, allows me to be rejected by man. I believe we also, at least give the impression, that we challenge others faith! this could stem from our devotion to our own faith, and passion to defend it:thumbsup: I don’t believe that I knowingly criticize or “bash” the catholic religion, but it may be taken as such! Like the 3 catholic churches I have been in(for weddings and funerals of friends), communion has been done as I described, with the priest being the only one drinking from the cup! All that I have read about communion, the Lord’s Supper, the Last Supper, etc., portrays Christ passing the cup around to His disciples, and them all taking their own piece of unleavened bread! A catholic friend of mine, a co-worker, and I were having a discussion about communion; and he asked me how our church did it> I told him, just like Jesus and His disciples did it. He said, “That’s why youcouldn’t partake of communion at a catholic church, because you are not a catholic! I said, :But I am a Christian!” I said something else, and he said, “are you bashing catholics?” No, I replied. just asking a question!:confused:One last thing about treating others like we would Christ. If I wanted to be a jerk, I could have called elvisman or any other peson on this forum, something a lot worse! But I do believe that we all are obsessive about something, and anal retentive, is a term used to describe someone who can’t or won’t see the other person’s point of view, because it conflicts with theirs; what they have been taught! I think we need to look at each person as if they were Christ, in blue jeans or a dress, and treat them with love, respect and tolerance, probably the hardest to do! Let me apologize to elvisman, and any other catholics, whom I may have offended in the last 5 months! You know, as far as the communion, it may just be how these catholic churches do it(including my friend’s church:D
 
prmerger: God bless you for supporting your fellow catholics:thumbsup: Being anal, is not so much a sign of disrespect,
Ok, 1beleevr. 🤷 I just wouldn’t call that treating someone as you would Christ. But, whatever…
 
prmerger: This issue seems to be getting a bit out of hand:cool Someone said that yelling at your children, when you were upset, was a sin. You said that it was a sin of not treating them like Christ would treat them, or how Christ would treat them. And then I was comparing how some in this forum treat each other, even if it is by the written word! If I treated everyone I met, like Christ, I would be able to walk on water! Oh wait, by my faith in Him, I could walk on water, if that were His will. Do people frustrate me, sure they do; I work in prison, and beinf a hotbed of negativity, conditions are ripe for disrespect, name calling and just overall chaos! Thanks to the peace of Christ, I have been able to survive 20 years, “behind bars”. He is still working on me, shaping, refining, and building me into the man He wants me to be! But, I can tell you, I am better than I was:thumbsup:(Phil 1:6)
 
He is still working on me, shaping, refining, and building me into the man He wants me to be!
It seems, 1beleevr, that we are all in need of some cleansing, yes? Some purgation, maybe? If you died today, perhaps purgatory would be the place for that final cleansing. 👍
 
prmerger: We, even as Christians, need daily cleansing:D Anyone who tells you they don’t, is not being honest with youor themselves! hank God for the cleansing power of Jesus’s blood, and forgiveness:thumbsup: As for purgatory, who knows what waits on the other side, besides God I mean?:cool:
 
prmerger: We, even as Christians, need daily cleansing:D Anyone who tells you they don’t, is not being honest with youor themselves! hank God for the cleansing power of Jesus’s blood, and forgiveness:thumbsup: As for purgatory, who knows what waits on the other side, besides God I mean?:cool:
That’s the thing, 1beleevr. Some things we can know by *reason–*such as God’s existence, and some things we can know only by God’s *revelation–*such as the dogma of the Trinity. (Our reason could never come up with the concept of the Trinity–One God with 3 persons consubstantial with one another).

And, we *can indeed know *what waits on the other side because God has revealed it to us! :dancing:
 
shw:Most of your recent post was very tedious, and irrelevant! Jesus’s disciples partook of communion, by each taking of the bread, and drinking from the cup! As believers, we are also disciples(Matthew 28:20), and therefore should partake of communion in the same manner(each taking of the bread, and drinking from the cup! Other than interpretation, and oral tradition, there doesn’t seem to be a precedent for the priest to be the sole drinker! And I don’t believe that anyone is the vicar of Christ, or the visible representative of Jesus on this earth(sorry, pope!)👍
My “post was very tedious and irrelevant” to you and perhaps to some others also, but I did not write it just for you non-Catholics alone. Catholics are on Catholic Answers Forum to learn about their faith. 😃

Catholics are allowed at the present time to take the Precious Body of Christ in the hand and also to drink His Precious Blood from the cup if they desire to.

It really, truly, does not matter one whit whether you believe that the pope is the vicar (representative) of Christ on earth. Truth is truth whether anyone believes it or not. What does matter is that truth should be searched out and then believed in after it is found, regardless of the personal cost. (Matthew 10:37-38)

The popes, beginning with Peter, are the only persons in Christ’s Church who are given the “keys of the kingdom of heaven” which is the chief stewardship office/position which began in the Davidic kingdom (key of the house of David–Isaiah 22:19-23). He is the chief steward/representative of Christ on earth in Jesus’ Church. (Matthew 16:18-19) This is an office (chief stewardship position) as explained in Isaiah 22 and only one person can hold this office at a time. When he can no longer serve, another chief steward is chosen to carry on the duties of this office. It cannot be left vacant.

Only the chief steward has the keys to the storehouse/treasury in the kingdom. He ranks above all other stewards. (1 Corinthians 4:1, 1 Corinthians 9:17, Colossians 1:25) The New Covenant is the fulfillment of the Old Covenant and some of the things from the OC are carried over into the NC, but they are without fault in the NC because Jesus is the author and mediator of the NC. (Hebrews 8:6-7, Hebrews 8:13)

Even though persons such as yourself do not believe it, it is fact that the pope is Christ’s chief representative on earth, and this fact will not ever change no matter how many people such as yourself dislike the idea or refuse to acknowledge him as Christ’s chief representative (vicar) on earth.

Jesus structured His Church as a hierarchy and this hierarchy rules over the members of Christ’s Church. We cannot change this structure. It is mandated by God. We are required to accept it or else we become like Satan who was the first to say, “I will not serve.” We all know what happened to Satan. :eek:

Hebrews 13:7
Remember those who rule over you, who have spoken the word of God to you, whose faith follow, considering the outcome of their conduct.

Hebrews 13:17
Obey those who rule over you, and be submissive, for they watch out for your souls, as those who must give account. Let them do so with joy and not with grief, for that would be unprofitable for you.

Paul tells the new bishop Titus to “Speak these things, exhort, and rebuke with all authority. Let no one despise you.” Titus 2:15

Moses seat/chair (office of authority) in the OC (Matthew 23:2) is changed to Peter’s chair (office of authority) in the NC and this is recorded in the early church writings. staycatholic.com/ecf_primacy_of_rome.htm

The Church is hierarchical in nature according to Christ’s mandate and this cannot ever be changed by men who decide to reform Jesus’ Church. People who try to change Christ’s Church’s dogmas and Its structure into their own individual churches based on their own private interpretation of Scripture are called heretics. (2 Peter 2:1-3)

Maintaining the Oral traditions and safeguarding the correct interpretations of the Written Scriptures (Bible) traditions are responsibilities of the Catholic Church’s hierarchy. (2 Thessalonians 2:15)
 
shw: Thank you for acknowledging that I am not the only one who doesn’t recognize the pope(any pope past or present) as “our” spititual leader:thumbsup: As Christians, we are the visible hands and feet of the invisible Christ! He, of course, is the head! We are charged with taking His Word to the masses, who are unsaved(Matthew 28:20) While we as the body, require leadership, those who are anointed to fill those positions, have been chosen by God and not man! But, because we don’t believe that the pope speaks for us, does not mean that we don’t respect him(speaking for myself here). If by chance, I were to meet pope Benedict, I would surely shake his hand, and say,“God, bless you, my brother in Christ!” But to look upon his face, and imagine him as Christ on earth; no:D
 
I were to meet pope Benedict, I would surely shake his hand, and say,“God, bless you, my brother in Christ!” But to look upon his face, and imagine him as Christ on earth; no:D
That is not what is meant … the pope is not Christ on earth but carries Christ’s authority on earth … binding and loosing. We are all called to be Christ’s on earth … but I nor you have the binding and loosing authority.
 
shw: Thank you for acknowledging that I am not the only one who doesn’t recognize the pope(any pope past or present) as “our” spititual leader:thumbsup: As Christians, we are the visible hands and feet of the invisible Christ! He, of course, is the head! We are charged with taking His Word to the masses, who are unsaved(Matthew 28:20) While we as the body, require leadership, those who are anointed to fill those positions, have been chosen by God and not man! But, because we don’t believe that the pope speaks for us, does not mean that we don’t respect him(speaking for myself here). If by chance, I were to meet pope Benedict, I would surely shake his hand, and say,“God, bless you, my brother in Christ!” But to look upon his face, and imagine him as Christ on earth; no:D
It is good that you respect the pope (2 Peter 2:10, Jude 1:8) because Jesus does recognize the pope (Peter’s successor) as His representative on earth. **The Church hierarchy is appointed by Him. **(1 Corinthians 12:28, 1 Timothy 2:7, Philippians 1:17, John 6:70) Jesus even personally chose Judas, but he betrayed Him.

He did not tell people to pick up a bible, read it, and then they (themselves) decide that they are the anointed of God. No, the apostles taught the elder/priest candidates firsthand by oral tradition and then laid their hands on them (Sacrament of Holy Orders) in order to ordain them. (1 Timothy 4:14, 2 Timothy 1:6, 1 Timothy 5:22, 2 Timothy 2:2)

Contrary to popular Protestant belief, Christianity is not a do-it-yourself religion meaning that a person only needs to claim that Jesus’ Blood will save him/her and that this is all that is necessary for salvation or to claim that their personal Bible reading and their personal interpretation of the Scriptures qualifies them to become the anointed of God. (1 Corinthians 14:37, James 1:26-27) Catholic Christianity is the religion/gospel of Christ and this will never change. (John 16:13, Matthew 16:18-19, Matthew 28:18-20) Jesus promises to be with His one Church until He returns again at His Second Coming (the end of the age).

He built His Church upon Peter first who He claims is the new Rock, and then He also built His Church upon the apostles and the prophets. Jesus Himself changes from being the Rock to the Chief Cornerstone and this is why He has appointed “Peter” to be the new Rock (Chief steward of His Church on earth), and His Holy Spirit will continue to guide His Pope and His Church until He returns at His Second Coming, in order to prevent It from teaching error in faith and morals.
 
Did Jesus not “seek the dead” at the Transfiguration? Weren’t Elijah and Moses “dead”?

We also know from St. John’s Gospel that whoever believes in Him shall have eternal LIFE. That means when you die and go to heaven you are ALIVE. No one who is in heaven is “dead in Christ.”

And, you are under the mistaken impression that it must be written in the Bible for it to be part of God’s Divine Word. Remember, your own Bible does not make that claim.
Jesus had conversation with Moses and Elijah. Yet, he is their Lord. He died for them as well as you and I.

When the scriptures refer to the dead in Christ, it is telling us those who suffered physical death and were believers. It is their spirit/soul that is alive in Christ goes to be with Jesus in heaven. The body sleeps and awaits the day of resurrection when it will be changed from corruptible to incorruptible. It is then the soul/spirit is put into the eternal body.

You are right in saying no one in heaven is dead. For God is not the God of the dead, but the living and unless a man is born again in his spirit, unless a made is made alive again in his spirit though salvation, he cannot get into heaven.
 
Well for one St. Louis de Montfort writes in True Devotion to Mary

"It is more perfect, because it is more humble, not to approach God by ourselves, without taking a mediator…if we rely on our own works, skills and preparation to reach God and to please Him, it is certain that all of our rightous works will be sullied or of little weight before God, in urging Him to unite Himself to us and to hear us and answer us… we have need of a mediator before the mediator (Jesus) Himself, and that the divine Mary is the one who is the most capable of fulfilling this charitable office.-4th Truth in Chapter 3
 
guanophore: In one of your earlier posts, you bemoaned the fact that some have indicated that you shouldn’t pray through Mary or the saints; when in fact, it was a catholic who started the thread"Why won’t Protestants pray through Mary and the saints?" While I applaud anyone who is loyal to what they believe in, we must also remember that because of free will, we don’t always agree on things spiritual! To me the greatest gift, is still the gift of salvation, and Easter is still more important than Christmas! And I don’t believe that if you don’t confess to a priest, that you are bound for hell(unless, maybe you’re a catholic).
I don’t think it was I who “bemoaned” that some some people object to communion with the saints. I understand why people object to this Apostolic Doctrine. I think it is a loss, but communicating with one’s family members is always a loss.

The Catholic Church does not teach that, if you do not confess to a priest, you are hellbound, even for Catholics. However, this is the way He set things up, and we are most benefitted when we follow His direction. People who refuse this limit themselves access to the grace that flows through it. However, God’s grace is not bound by the sacrament, and He is able to forgive anyone He wants, however He wants!
 
Jesus had conversation with Moses and Elijah. Yet, he is their Lord. He died for them as well as you and I.

When the scriptures refer to the dead in Christ, it is telling us those who suffered physical death and were believers. It is their spirit/soul that is alive in Christ goes to be with Jesus in heaven. The body sleeps and awaits the day of resurrection when it will be changed from corruptible to incorruptible. It is then the soul/spirit is put into the eternal body.
You are not making any sense, heis. First to admit that Jesus talked with Moses and Elijah, then you say that they are “dead”. Was Jesus talking to “dead” people?

Do you think the rest of us cannot communicate with them because we are not God?
You are right in saying no one in heaven is dead. For God is not the God of the dead, but the living and unless a man is born again in his spirit, unless a made is made alive again in his spirit though salvation, he cannot get into heaven.
Well, many who have been made alive in spirit are in heaven. They know what is going on here on earth, and can communicate with us about it.
 
Well for one St. Louis de Montfort writes in True Devotion to Mary

"It is more perfect, because it is more humble, not to approach God by ourselves, without taking a mediator…if we rely on our own works, skills and preparation to reach God and to please Him, it is certain that all of our rightous works will be sullied or of little weight before God, in urging Him to unite Himself to us and to hear us and answer us… we have need of a mediator before the mediator (Jesus) Himself, and that the divine Mary is the one who is the most capable of fulfilling this charitable office.-4th Truth in Chapter 3
This is not an official Catholic Teaching, and this quote is likely to cause more problems than it solves with evangelicals. Most of them already think Catholics worship Mary and the saints, so when someone refers to “the divine Mary” they will all be sure to think we are blaspheming and committing idolatry!
 
Hi,

“I urge therefore, first of all, that SUPPLICATIONS, PRAYERS, INTERCESSIONS and THANKSGIVINGS be made for all men; for kings, and for all in high positions, that we may lead a quiet and peaceful life in all piety and worthy behavior. This is GOOD and AGREEABLE in the SIGHT OF OUR SAVIOR, who wishes all men to be saved and come to the knowledge of the truth. For there is one GOD and one mediator between GOD and men, himself man, Christ Jesus.” 1Timothy 2:1-5

Quote=onenow1, This seems pretty simple to me, if our seperated brethern are correct which they are not, they better stop praying to Jesus on someone elses behalf. 🤷

My Opinion :" We get so bogged down in exegesis, we lose sight of the lessons learned from the cross. LIKE: The Great Mediation Jesus’s request to the Father."End Quote. Forgive them for they know not what they do ! 🙂

Intersession, looks quite acceptable to our beloved St.Paul a family as one the prayer Jesus Prayed.🙂

Peace, onenow1 🍿
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top