JPII now baptised by proxy by LDS

  • Thread starter Thread starter flameburns623
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
got it;)

***MEGATRON IS A CATHOLIC:thumbsup: ***
Cute! Actually, I was a cradle Catholic who joined the LDS church in his early 20s, was an active, temple-worthy Mormon for 5 years and came to the realization that I was duped and deceived shortly thereafter.

I’m once again a happy Catholic!
 
**Sexual **attraction to the dead?

Okay. I can’t take anymore. Because I am sorry I know we are supposed to be polite and everything about other religions but…
that’s too much for me.
Gotta go with you on this one tequilamac…that is just way over the top and too much for me also.
 
do you really mean that “those mormons” do sexual things with dead bodies?
No. Not at all. Sorry for even more confusion! :confused:

Although I think Mormonism is jacked up, it’s not that nuts!
 
Cute! Actually, I was a cradle Catholic who joined the LDS church in his early 20s, was an active, temple-worthy Mormon for 5 years and came to the realization that I was duped and deceived shortly thereafter.

I’m once again a happy Catholic!
wasnt trying to be cute:mad: …well ok just a bit:D …wanted to let you know that I am sorry for confusing you for one of them when you really where one of us:thumbsup:
 
Again, I glanced over the definition and should have read it a little more carefully.

Mormons do not seek any sexual from their ordinances involving the deceased.

Sorry again for any confusion.

God bless
 
No. Not at all. Sorry for even more confusion! :confused:

Although I think Mormonism is jacked up, it’s not that nuts!
Oh thank God. you had me really really scared there. so it would be safe to say though that there is a simple obsession with the dead.
 
wasnt trying to be cute:mad: …well ok just a bit:D …wanted to let you know that I am sorry for confusing you for one of them when you really where one of us:thumbsup:
Seriously, it’s all good. As for my “Mormon past”, I’ve been around the block in the LDS church and am more than willing to expose and discuss elements of their theology. I’m sure that there are also quite talented and intelligent ex-Mos in here that are also quite handy, but I just wanted to “join the team” so to say.
 
Your not joking are you?
So whom have you (mormons) married our beloved Pope John Paul off too?
they would not. They believe that only those who were married on earth can be sealed by proxy and then only to their earthly spouse. Now here is where it gets tricky… those who qualify for celestial kingdom but aren’t “sealed” become servants (ministering angels) there. Men can be sealed to an unlimited number of women and Mormon doctrine teaches that worthy women will be sealed to exalted men. So only men will be “ministering angels”. Of course what happens to those men who died before they were of age or didn’t have worthy wives to be sealed to? (it doesn’t matter if wife became unworthy later, they still had the sealing ordinance and believe the lord will provide wives in the afterlife but if they mere married outside the temple they have no promise) you see where this is going? some LDS believe that this all gets sorted out in the millennium. in any case the doctrine is clear that in the next life only polygamists are going to be Gods. If they didn’t practice polygamy on earth because the “prophet” said not to then they will be given wives in the next life.

This is what finally got my wife to leave the Mormon church. She finally had to accept that Joseph Smith was a polygamist and that his teachings on this created doctrine of celestial polygamy. My Temple worker Mom tried real hard to make her think this was okay because we would only practice this in heaven where there was no jealousy.

The next trip to the temple my wife looked at the absence of any visible role of heavenly mother(s) and the plight of eve and decided to go to RCIA. we are now happy Catholics.

Thanks be to God.🙂
 
Oh thank God. you had me really really scared there. so it would be safe to say though that there is a simple obsession with the dead.
Well, I don’t kow about an “obsession” but one of the supposed three primary tenets of the Mormon gospel is “salvation of the dead”.
 
Seriously, it’s all good. As for my “Mormon past”, I’ve been around the block in the LDS church and am more than willing to expose and discuss elements of their theology. I’m sure that there are also quite talented and intelligent ex-Mos in here that are also quite handy, but I just wanted to “join the team” so to say.
Okay but that earlier was a serious boo boo that could be quite offensive to Mormons and others. Maybe we should ask the moderators to edit it out.
 
they would not. They believe that only those who were married on earth can be sealed by proxy and then only to their earthly spouse. Now here is where it gets tricky… those who qualify for celestial kingdom but aren’t “sealed” become servants (ministering angels) there. Men can be sealed to an unlimited number of women and Mormon doctrine teaches that worthy women will be sealed to exalted men. So only men will be “ministering angels”. Of course what happens to those men who died before they were of age or didn’t have worthy wives to be sealed to? (it doesn’t matter if wife became unworthy later, they still had the sealing ordinance and believe the lord will provide wives in the afterlife but if they mere married outside the temple they have no promise) you see where this is going? some LDS believe that this all gets sorted out in the millennium. in any case the doctrine is clear that in the next life only polygamists are going to be Gods. If they didn’t practice polygamy on earth because the “prophet” said not to then they will be given wives in the next life.

This is what finally got my wife to leave the Mormon church. She finally had to accept that Joseph Smith was a polygamist and that his teachings on this created doctrine of celestial polygamy. My Temple worker Mom tried real hard to make her think this was okay because we would only practice this in heaven where there was no jealousy.

The next trip to the temple my wife looked at the absence of any visible role of heavenly mother(s) and the plight of eve and decided to go to RCIA. we are now happy Catholics.

Thanks be to God.🙂
This helped bring my wife out of the Mormon cult, too!
 
Okay but that earlier was a serious boo boo that could be quite offensive to Mormons and others. Maybe we should ask the moderators to edit it out.
I’m more than cool with having the moderators erase and remove those errant comments.
 
the stated mission of the LDS church is to preach the gospel, perfect the saints and redeem the dead.
 
Someone who qualifies for baptism of desire IS baptized from a sacramental point of view. It is NOT the human pouring the water and praying that infuses one with grace. It is GOD.

God bestows grace on earth and in heaven. When we die there is no need for human devices such as missionaries. Jesus preaches and in a perfect manner. God makes himself known in the afterlife. No one can fail to understand the gospel at the at point. “EVERY knee shall bow and EVERY tongue confess…”
I think I mentioned the “every knee shall bow” scripture before, in a previous post. That scripture doesn’t mean they’ll all accept the gospel/God’s Law. After all, James 2:19 Thou believest that there is one God; thou doest well: the devils also believe, and tremble.
Purgatory is removal of the stain of sin from the penitent. Hell is knowing the truth and knowing you didn’t accept it when given the chance and/or that you didn’t act on it. Heaven is the presence of God.
Okay but I don’t really feel like I can comment on this because I haven’t studied up on my purgatory. I know it doesn’t appear in the Bible so I guess I would need to study the library at www.catholic.com.
It is a very “sci-fi” human concept that we will have apartments in “spiritville” where missionaries will be lining us up for classes and trying to convince of the truth. that is what THIS life is for. God chooses where and when to place us on this earth. He knows who belongs where and his will be done.
But it’s a much more compassionate concept than tossing out all the souls who were never baptised through no fault of their own. I understand that is not the Catholic teaching. My purpose isn’t to refute that teaching, only to explain why this scripture should be removed from the Mormon Stumpers list.
Baptizing the dead implies that God needs us to do his work when in actuality we need to do his work for our own sake…here and now. After death it’s too late.
Baptising the dead is doing work for both God and ourselves as is most church work.

Things look bad for changing the ***Mormon Stumpers ***list doesn’t it? I’ll bet if we were to take a vote…

I’d also like a promotion from the Non-Christian Religions List to the Christian Religions List but since I don’t seem to be getting anywhere on this one!
 
I think I mentioned the “every knee shall bow” scripture before, in a previous post. That scripture doesn’t mean they’ll all accept the gospel/God’s Law. After all, James 2:19 Thou believest that there is one God; thou doest well: the devils also believe, and tremble.
the cognitive dissonance required to say this amazes me. you made my point for me. Everyone will know. no one will need to be “taught”. Those who qualify for baptism of desire obviously would accept.
Okay but I don’t really feel like I can comment on this because I haven’t studied up on my purgatory. I know it doesn’t appear in the Bible so I guess I would need to study the library at www.catholic.com.
fair enough
But it’s a much more compassionate concept than tossing out all the souls who were never baptised through no fault of their own. I understand that is not the Catholic teaching. My purpose isn’t to refute that teaching, only to explain why this scripture should be removed from the Mormon Stumpers list.
that isn’t true. the only ones who are “tossed out” ARE in that state THROUGH their own fault. They rejected God. baptism of desire IS baptism. It IS a sacrament.
Baptising the dead is doing work for both God and ourselves as is most church work.
not what I meant. God doesn’t NEED us to do the work. so when folks are dead and we can’t interact with them there is no benefit to us or them. In fact there is the detriment that the time, talent and treasure expended on “redeeming the dead” leaves the living in need. God has already taken care of the dead. they go where they are supposed to according to his will.
Things look bad for changing the ***Mormon Stumpers ***list doesn’t it? I’ll bet if we were to take a vote…

I’d also like a promotion from the Non-Christian Religions List to the Christian Religions List but since I don’t seem to be getting anywhere on this one!
are you serious? baptism for the dead isn’t supported in scripture even in the LDS church. The BoM teaches against it in principle and never mentions it explicitly. it is merely “tacked on” late in the D&C.

The definition of God is dealbreaker for Mormons as Christians but semantically the fact that Mormons don’t worship Jesus is the biggest problem. Mormons don’t pray to Jesus so they don’t worship him as God. Thus, they can’t by definition be Christians. Many religions acknowledge Jesus and some even revere him but only Christians worship him and pray to him.
 
You are always starting from the Catholic POV. I don’t feel that I need to because I am only trying to establish that this is not a stumper. But since you accept the Protestant POV (at least you haven’t excommunicated them from all of Christendom), I am arguing more from that POV.
the cognitive dissonance required to say this amazes me. you made my point for me. Everyone will know. no one will need to be “taught”. Those who qualify for baptism of desire obviously would accept.
When you say anyone who qualifies as a Baptism of desire would obviously accept, I can’t really refute that anymore than you can prove it. Do Protestants accepted the Baptism by Desire concept? At least the ones on the A List?
The BoM teaches against it in principle and never mentions it explicitly.
This I believe is a mis-interpretation.
The definition of God is dealbreaker for Mormons as Christians but semantically the fact that Mormons don’t worship Jesus is the biggest problem. Mormons don’t pray to Jesus so they don’t worship him as God. Thus, they can’t by definition be Christians. Many religions acknowledge Jesus and some even revere him but only Christians worship him and pray to him.
So true. We pray to the Father in Jesus’ name. But it’s not like we’re praying to Vishnu or Allah.
 
So true. We pray to the Father in Jesus’ name. But it’s not like we’re praying to Vishnu or Allah.
isn’t it though? You pray to Elohim. Who/what is Elohim according to LDS doctirne? he is an exalted man from an eternal progression of exalted men. That isn’t Allah but it is alot closer to vishnu than Christianity.
 
We could start another thread on that but frankly I’m not that interested. Maybe if you promise to invite us into the Christian fellowship…

Look, in this entire discussion we have to make a lot of assumptions about what happens in the afterlife. Some of it is based on our church teachings and is therefore a matter of faith.

I am saying that the scripture in Alma about there being no repentance in the afterlife does not contradict the requirement of baptism. Is the gospel only for the living? Who knows? But even if you understand the gospel, you still need to make a decision to accept it.
 
And of course, anyone who is saved under any of those categories is saved only through- and because of- the perfect once-for-all sacrifice of Jesus on the cross.
God bless,
Paul
:amen: :blessyou:
This makes no sense to me. The scriptures are clear. The catechism is clear.

Someone who qualifies for baptism of desire IS baptized from a sacramental point of view. It is NOT the human pouring the water and praying that infuses one with grace. It is GOD.

God bestows grace on earth and in heaven. When we die there is no need for human devices such as missionaries. Jesus preaches and in a perfect manner. God makes himself known in the afterlife. No one can fail to understand the gospel at the at point. “EVERY knee shall bow and EVERY tongue confess…” Purgatory is removal of the stain of sin from the penitent. Hell is knowing the truth and knowing you didn’t accept it when given the chance and/or that you didn’t act on it. Heaven is the presence of God.

It is a very “sci-fi” human concept that we will have apartments in “spiritville” where missionaries will be lining us up for classes and trying to convince of the truth. that is what THIS life is for. God chooses where and when to place us on this earth. He knows who belongs where and his will be done.

baptizing the dead implies that God needs us to do his work when in actuality we need to do his work for our own sake…here and now. After death it’s too late.
👍 👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top