Kim-Trump Summit

  • Thread starter Thread starter CradleRC58
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think you know as well as I do that the left will never give Trump credit for anything or fail to put everything he says or does in a negative light.

I think we all know that if NoKo really does de-nuke, the Dem response will be just like your post: “Oh, they could start it up again, so nothing accomplished.”
It seems the liberal-haters here are not content with saying what the liberals have done that is bad, but must go on and speculate about what the liberals will do even before they do it.
 
Last edited:
How hilarious, and how typical! Democrats criticize Trump for not accomplishing de-nuclearization of NoKo in less than 24 hours!
That would be OK if we had not granted the immediate cessation of joint US/SK military exercises that have kept relative peace on the peninsula for more than half a century. Kim got something he really wanted. Immediately. He also got status recognition on the world stage, which is something else he really wanted. He got that immediately too. All we got was a promise to start a process that should lead to de-nuclearization. We got nothing on the human rights abuses, like the return of the crew and seven remaining passengers of Korean Airlines YS-11 that was hijacked to NK in 1969. Their families in SK are still waiting, as are many other families of prisoners of this brutal dictator. But hey, as long as there the possibility of US businesses benefiting from trade with NK, including maybe a Trump hotel, we don’t need to concern ourselves with those unimportant people rotting away in NK jails. We got a 2-page memorandum! Whoopee!
 
Last edited:
It seems the liberal-haters here are not content with saying what the liberals have done that is bad, but must go on and speculate about what the liberals will do even before they do it.
As soon as you say something good about Trump, I’ll make note of it.
 
Maybe other countries can ask for their Gitmo prisoners back. Both the US and North Korea commit human rights abuses. Yes Kim is bad, but so is every other government.
 
That would be OK if we had not granted the immediate cessation of joint US/SK military exercises that have kept relative peace on the peninsula for more than half a century
We just finished them. What are you thinking? Do you think they are conducted every week? By the time they would be scheduled again, Trump is going to know how serious Kim is about other things.
 
That would be OK if we had not granted the immediate cessation of joint US/SK military exercises that have kept relative peace on the peninsula for more than half a century. Kim got something he really wanted.
I know you like to imagine that Trump just pulled this out of his hindquarters on the fly, but the reality is both US and ROK militaries were involved in the months of negotiations leading up to this meeting and bought off on it. Besides, military exercises occur every year or so and the US and ROK forces just finished theirs and could be easily restarted if needed. The US is still basing troops in South Korea and ROK and US commands are still working together.
Kim got something he really wanted. Immediately. He also got status recognition on the world stage, which is something else he really wanted. He got that immediately too.
That and $5 will get him a cup of coffee at the Seoul Starbucks.
All we got was a promise to start a process that should lead to de-nuclearization.
Which is what we wanted.
We got nothing on the human rights abuses, like the return of the crew and seven remaining passengers of Korean Airlines YS-11 that was hijacked to NK in 1969.
Denuclearization was on the table, changing North Korea’s internal political situation wasn’t.
 
I can’t believe people really thought the whole thing would be solved in one meeting. More TDS at work here. More negotiations are on tap with Pompeo taking the lead. Let’s be a little patient and see how things progress.
 
40.png
LeafByNiggle:
That would be OK if we had not granted the immediate cessation of joint US/SK military exercises that have kept relative peace on the peninsula for more than half a century. Kim got something he really wanted.
I know you like to imagine that Trump just pulled this out of his hindquarters on the fly, but the reality is both US and ROK militaries were involved in the months of negotiations leading up to this meeting and bought off on it.
Oh, really?
A spokeswoman for U.S. military forces in Korea, meanwhile, said it had not received any direction to cease joint military drills.

“USFK has received no updated guidance on execution or cessation of training exercises - to include this fall’s schedule Ulchi Freedom Guardian,” U.S. Forces in Korea spokeswoman Lieutenant Colonel Jennifer Lovett said in a statement. “In coordination with our (South Korean) partners, we will continue with our current military posture until we receive updated guidance from the Department of Defense (DoD) and/or Indo-Pacific Command (INDOPACOM).”

The Pentagon was not immediately able to flesh out Trump’s remarks about suspending drills, a move the U.S. military has long resisted.

Lieutenant Colonel Chris Logan, a spokesman, said: “The Department of Defense continues to work with the White House, the inter-agency, and our allies and partners on the way forward following the summit. We will provide additional information as it becomes available.”

One South Korean official said he initially thought Trump had mis-spoke.

“I was shocked when he called the exercises ‘provocative,’ a very unlikely word to be used by a U.S. president,” the official said, speaking on condition of anonymity because it was a politically sensitive issue.
Kim got something he really wanted. Immediately. He also got status recognition on the world stage, which is something else he really wanted. He got that immediately too.
That and $5 will get him a cup of coffee at the Seoul Starbucks.
Not true at all. It gives Kim great recognition back home, and is a serious blow to the NK resistance movement against this dictator, allowing him to tighten his grip on the NK people. Thanks, Trump!
All we got was a promise to start a process that should lead to de-nuclearization.
Which is what we wanted.
We also got a promise from Iran, which Trump called the “worst deal in history” and pulled out of it. Apparently some promises from dictators are worth more than promises from other dictators.
We got nothing on the human rights abuses, like the return of the crew and seven remaining passengers of Korean Airlines YS-11 that was hijacked to NK in 1969.
Denuclearization was on the table, changing North Korea’s internal political situation wasn’t.
That’s sad.
 
I’m going to express some skepticism here. There is no way an O-5 is going to publically undercut the Commander in Chief. I suspect there’s some context Reuters is leaving out.
Not true at all. It gives Kim great recognition back home, and is a serious blow to the NK resistance movement against this dictator, allowing him to tighten his grip on the NK people. Thanks, Trump!
You were thinking regime change was going to come out of this meeting? Really?
We also got a promise from Iran, which Trump called the “worst deal in history” and pulled out of it. Apparently some promises from dictators are worth more than promises from other dictators.
In Iran, we got promises, Iran’s leader got cold hard cash. Call me when a C-130 lands in Pyongyang with a couple pallets of cash and then you can compare the two.
That’s sad.
It was sad when Stalin kept most of Eastern Europe after WW2 too. Global politics is often sad.
 
The journalist invited destruction of the NK nuke facilities wasn’t all it seemed.

Stay tuned…
 
40.png
LeafByNiggle:
That would be OK if we had not granted the immediate cessation of joint US/SK military exercises that have kept relative peace on the peninsula for more than half a century
We just finished them. What are you thinking? Do you think they are conducted every week? By the time they would be scheduled again, Trump is going to know how serious Kim is about other things.
And I remember those exercises being criticized here by CAF liberals as having shut down the summit because they ticked off Kim. They were deemed provocative.
 
That would be OK if we had not granted the immediate cessation of joint US/SK military exercises that have kept relative peace on the peninsula for more than half a century.
The exercises themselves haven’t kept any peace, they are just a practice event, a parade so to speak.
The forces are still there and they will still conduct training.

A new exercise will be scheduled if NK detours from their march to peace. This olive branch can be quickly reinstated.
 
Last edited:
You were thinking regime change was going to come out of this meeting? Really?
Regime change is why North Korea wants nukes in the first place. Anyone paying attention knows what happens to countries the US wants to control that don’t have nukes. Who would want to be another Libya or Iraq?
 
Regime change is why North Korea wants nukes in the first place. Anyone paying attention knows what happens to countries the US wants to control that don’t have nukes. Who would want to be another Libya or Iraq?
And I can’t imagine any enticement great enough to persuade them to give them up, which is why I think the vicious tyrant Kim is playing us and not bargaining in good faith.
 
Last edited:
I am curious why Kim would agree. But Trump knows this too. What is so odd is Trump has surrounded himself with neocons who never met a war they didn’t like. They won’t concede anything. I’d love to know what is actually going on.
 
Military exercises may be side show in part, but they’re also about keeping a military in top form. And where two or more militaries are involved, it’s about practicing and perfecting coordination.

I have a feeling neither US nor South Korean generals are at all happy about this.
 
Kim agrees because it costs him little. Maybe he stops working on nukes, but he’s already developed them. It’s hardly the first time a US administration has made a deal with the Kims, and then went about their business when it suited them. I’m not specifically criticizing Trump, you take the opportunities as they come, but I think everyone should put a hold on any kind of victory lap.
 
It’s not like they were sent back home to work the farms,
they are still a fulltime military doing constant training.

The generals will be delighted if the move reduces tensions and the risk of war.

The joint large scale training is an annual event, it will happen next year unless real progress is made. It’s the stick for us to pull out.
 
Regime change is why North Korea wants nukes in the first place.
Which is why the US security guarantees were made. They don’t really cost the US or South Korean’s anything because we’re not going to invade North Korea, nukes or no, but they bring the US, South, and North closer, and create separation between Kim and China and betweeen Kim and Iran. It’s somewhat analogous to Nixon and China.
 
I must have missed something. Is there a peace treaty on the table?
First: Does anyone remember how many times Reagan met with Gorbachev before the INF was signed? Does anyone recall how often presidents prior to Reagan met with Soviet leaders?
This is THE FIRST TIME an American president had met with an NK leader.

Second: He is meeting with a socialist leader. Things will have to be verified.

This will take time.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top