Kim-Trump Summit

  • Thread starter Thread starter CradleRC58
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
We got nothing on the human rights abuses, like the return of the crew and seven remaining passengers of Korean Airlines YS-11 that was hijacked to NK in 1969.
Denuclearization was on the table, changing North Korea’s internal political situation wasn’t.
[/quote]
That’s sad.
[/quote]

It took a while for human rights to come up in the Reagan / Gorbachev summits, too.
 
40.png
LeafByNiggle:
I’m going to express some skepticism here. There is no way an O-5 is going to publically undercut the Commander in Chief. I suspect there’s some context Reuters is leaving out.
It is well-known that South Korean military was quite surprised by the statement to stop joint exercises. This directly contradicts the statement that
…both US and ROK militaries were involved in the months of negotiations leading up to this meeting and bought off on it.
There may have been months of negotiations, but this issue was apparently not discussed. It totally blindsided SK.
Not true at all. It gives Kim great recognition back home, and is a serious blow to the NK resistance movement against this dictator, allowing him to tighten his grip on the NK people. Thanks, Trump!
You were thinking regime change was going to come out of this meeting? Really?
No, but the possibility of regime change has now been dealt a severe blow. The opposition inside NK surely feel betrayed by Trump.
We also got a promise from Iran, which Trump called the “worst deal in history” and pulled out of it. Apparently some promises from dictators are worth more than promises from other dictators.
In Iran, we got promises, Iran’s leader got cold hard cash. Call me when a C-130 lands in Pyongyang with a couple pallets of cash and then you can compare the two.
The money you speak of was not ours to hold. It belonged to Iran anyway.
 
What opposition are you referring to?

The people are best served following the Chinese model, with increased economics and standard of living but not full western freedoms
 
Updates today. Stephanopoulos, Hannity interview post-Summit Trump


Trump acknowledged to Stephanopoulos that the path ahead remained foggy.

“”Maybe in a year you’ll be interviewing and I’ll say I made a mistake. It’s possible. We’re dealing at a high level, a lot of things can change a lot of things are possible,” Trump told him.

The interview aired Tuesday morning on ABC. But the President said he expected immediate action as a result of the talks.

"It’s going to start very quickly. I think he’s going to start now. They’ll be announcing things over the next few days talking about other missile sites because they were, as you know, they were sending out a lot of missiles. It was a period of time where I was saying, what are they doing?” he said.

“Every week it seems another missile going up. I mean, they’re going to be getting rid of sites.”
 
Last edited:
Generals have to function within the limit set by their Presidents whose responsibility is in the bigger picture, not the other way round.
 
40.png
JonNC:
It took a while for human rights to come up in the Reagan / Gorbachev summits, too.
Yes, any process will take a while, so there is no reason to get excited or disappointed at this point. Trump got nothing meaningful yet, but at least the conversation has started. I just don’t understand why Trump gave up military exercises since that would be a good bargaining chip later when to get something useful in return.
I think military exercises are a small olive branch, as they can be reinstituted in a matter of moments. At this point, if no more rockets fly toward or over Japan, that is something useful in return. If no more nuclear tests occur, that is something useful in return.

But over all, you are right, this is something started.
 
40.png
niceatheist:
I must have missed something. Is there a peace treaty on the table?
First: Does anyone remember how many times Reagan met with Gorbachev before the INF was signed? Does anyone recall how often presidents prior to Reagan met with Soviet leaders?
This is THE FIRST TIME an American president had met with an NK leader.

Second: He is meeting with a socialist leader. Things will have to be verified.

This will take time.
If this will take time and we need to hold off of pronouncements of failure, we should also hold off of pronouncements of wonderful accomplishments. But Trump wants it both ways. He wants to benefit politically at home by telling his supporters how wonderful this summit was, but he wants critics to wait and see. Well, I am willing to wait and see if he is. But as long as he continues to make political hay from this summit, critics should be free to point out what was not yet accomplished.
 
The money you speak of was not ours to hold. It belonged to Iran anyway.
If you owe a guy $500 that he tells you he plans to buy a gun to shoot you with, are you going to pay him back? That’s about how stupid claims that it was “Iran’s money” sound to people with a lick of common sense.
 
That was particularly terrible.

No, he doesn’t love his people.

He’s a monster when it comes to human rights.
 
40.png
LeafByNiggle:
The money you speak of was not ours to hold. It belonged to Iran anyway.
If you owe a guy $500 that he tells you he plans to buy a gun to shoot you with, are you going to pay him back? That’s about how stupid claims that it was “Iran’s money” sound to people with a lick of common sense.
A crazy analogy of personal interactions that has no relevance to international affairs.
 
The meeting between the two leaders is an achievement in itself which was never been contemplated before. Somewhere along the line, a President of the US will come to this. This time it happens to Trump. We can argue on all the timing we want but someone has to do it. Whatever is one’s political preference, this is at least something positive.
 
The meeting between the two leaders is an achievement in itself which was never been contemplated before. Somewhere along the line, a President of the US will come to this. This time it happens to Trump. We can argue on all the timing we want but someone has to do it. Whatever is one’s political preference, this is at least something positive.
Yes, it is extremely positive for dictator Kim and his stranglehold on power.
 
40.png
Reuben_J:
The meeting between the two leaders is an achievement in itself which was never been contemplated before. Somewhere along the line, a President of the US will come to this. This time it happens to Trump. We can argue on all the timing we want but someone has to do it. Whatever is one’s political preference, this is at least something positive.
Yes, it is extremely positive for dictator Kim and his stranglehold on power.
Diplomacy can never be one sided. Nobody would meet with you if he has nothing from it. A great leader would weigh on a possible outcome of a win situation. Sometimes that has to be a win-win situation, for who would start if one is in a lose-win situation? Or lose-lose situation?
 
Last edited:
Yes he is, but can’t we pray that someday we can say yes he WAS ?

Who knows what Kim’s mindset is ? Perhaps China told him to cool it and appease Trump in some way. I would not doubt that China told Kim that they had his back if he was ever attacked by the US.

Only time will tell.

At any rate surely any educated person should feel that the world is a little bit safer without Trump and Kim hurling insults and threats of nuking each other.
 
Last edited:
At any rate surely any educated person should feel that the world is a little bit safer without Trump and Kim hurling insults and threats of nuking each other.
Or uneducated one. As long as they are in a right frame of mind.

Seriously, the goal of denuclearization is worth every penny in this diplomacy.

It is hard to argue against one less nuclear risk falling in our cities from an unstable despot. Being unstable, making it more likely to happen and thus the need to nip it somewhere and anywhere possible.
 
Kim is likely the most murderous thug despot in the world. He imprisons and kills at will, including his half-brother and uncle, often in gruesome, public spectacle. His people are starving while he lives in opulence. Kim raises evil to mind-boggling levels. To see N. Korea’s flag displayed next to ours and to hear an American president saying how honored he is to meet this monster, and how Kim “loves his people”, is thoroughly disgusting.

While we should all hope and pray that something good comes out of it, we must remember that N. Korea has made promises to denuclearize multiple times before. We gave up a lot (military exercises, our dignity) in exchange for little.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top