Kim-Trump Summit

  • Thread starter Thread starter CradleRC58
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Fights with Canada,
Trudeau picked a fight with the US. Trudeau started the whole thing. He has tariffs of 270% on Canadian dairy and says he is protecting the Canadian farmer. If Trudeau can protect the Canadian farmer, it is only fair for Trump to protect the American steel worker.
 
We gave up a lot (military exercises, our dignity) in exchange for little.
Denuclearisation and peace on the Korean peninsula is a lot, not a little. If N. Korea does not abide by the agreements, military exercises can begin again. Human rights is important of course, but many governments trample on human rights. For example, in the USA, the American government allows one million unborn children to be murdered on the operating table per year. And no one is prosecuted for this. Every American who collaborates or colludes in these murders goes scot free. I believe that the Trump administration will make a serious effort to improve human rights in N.Korea. This may come slowly, but a little improvement is better than nothing at all.
 
Last edited:
I have read some commentators saying that NoKor has been saying for decades that they would denuke. They say, so what makes yesterday’s meeting any different? Can Kim be trusted?
 
The people who trade in black market goods, especially outside media smuggled in on thumb drives and circulated among those eager for freedom.
sounds more like small scale entrepreneurs, not political opposition.
 
Maybe other countries can ask for their Gitmo prisoners back. Both the US and North Korea commit human rights abuses. Yes Kim is bad, but so is every other government.
To invoke Godwin’s law, that’s like saying Nazi Germany’s Holocaust was bad, but the US detained Japanese cities so there just bad all around. It may be true that both are wrong, but they’re on much different levels. Gitmo is one place where people, often involved with terrorism, are held. The whole of North Korea is a human rights violation.
 
I don’t disagree that the US and North Korea are different in degree and not kind. But when you start criticizing other nations for things it would be much better if your nation didn’t do the same thing. It is difficult to make a principled argument for why someone should not do the same things you do.
 
You will never give Obama credit for anything. But in Trump’s case, he hasn’t done anything to deserve any credit yet. The country is still cruising on the economic policies set up by Obama and the Dems.
Obama’s not the president.

Trump has done a few things. Everybody knows about the bigger ones. Some of the smaller ones affected me favorably, like repeal of the WOTUS regulation that put the army in charge of every stream, farm pond, dry wash and puddle in the U.S.
 
If you owe a guy $500 that he tells you he plans to buy a gun to shoot you with, are you going to pay him back? That’s about how stupid claims that it was “Iran’s money” sound to people with a lick of common sense.
Courts had held that the Iran money was subject to the claims of people victimized by the Iranian regime, including the hostage crisis victims. The Obama administration put up taxpayer money to pay those claims instead, so it could give the money to Iran.

So it really wasn’t “Iran’s money”.
 
It might be a mistake to assume that half or more of the world’s rulers are any better.
 
Crazy how quickly peace loving liberals can turn into war mongering neocons. Who says Trump isn’t changing things?
 
Trudeau picked a fight with the US. Trudeau started the whole thing. He has tariffs of 270% on Canadian dairy and says he is protecting the Canadian farmer. If Trudeau can protect the Canadian farmer, it is only fair for Trump to protect the American steel worker.
Fight fight fight!!!
That’s great! I love it. The more trade wars the better.
 
I don’t disagree that the US and North Korea are different in degree and not kind. But when you start criticizing other nations for things it would be much better if your nation didn’t do the same thing.
If that were the case, no instances of human rights abuse would ever be called out.
 
Non government institutions could criticize. For instance the Church could. That is the way it should be. The idea that different nation states criticize each other for how they treat their citizens is kind of silly.
 
Fight fight fight!!!
That’s great! I love it. The more trade wars the better.
Trump is for free trade and eliminating all tariffs. Canada doesn’t want that but wants to fight the US with tariffs of 270% against American dairy products.
 
Non government institutions could criticize. For instance the Church could.
Not even the institutional Church is entirely free of abuse, as we have seen from some of the sex-abuse cases. Does this mean the Church should not speak out against sex trafficking? Of course not, because the degree to which the Church is guilty of abusing children is tiny compared to the commercial trade. Similarly, the human rights abuses at Gitmo are tiny compared to the hell hole that is North Korea. The US has every right and even a moral duty to speak out against it.
 
One needn’t be free from abuse to crticize. One only need to not institutionally sanction the abuse. The Church didn’t sanction the abuse, even if memebrs hid it. This is different from sanctioned abuse by the state.

The US’s first moral duty is to clean up its own house. Gitmo is still open. The CIA still has secret prisons. It’s like removing the log from your own eye.
 
Trudeau picked a fight with the US. Trudeau started the whole thing. He has tariffs of 270% on Canadian dairy and says he is protecting the Canadian farmer.
This is nothing new. Trudeau didn’t suddenly impose a tariff on dairy products, just like the US has had a tariff on tobacco products of over 300% to protect the American tobacco industry. However the 270% figure is misleading. It is an average based on import amounts. Up to a certain limit, dairy imports into Canada are free of tariffs entirely. The tariff rate is 0%. It is only because of the huge trade imbalance that tariffs kick in a a control measure to exercise a balance of trade.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top