It’s hard to give advice because I don’t know if he’s a child or just an idiot. A different approach is needed for each of those. But if what you’ve been doing isn’t working then try something else.
You could sit him down and tell him that he’s dead weight, and you’re sick of carrying him. Or, the idea of hiring a helper is a good one. Tell your husband that you’ll have to hire a real man to get some stuff done around the house. Or marriage counseling is another option. Your husband sounds like the type that would dislike marriage counseling so much that he would do anything to avoid having to go back, including cleaning up after himself.
I think this is kind of harsh.
Everyone is a product of their upbringing. Everyone brings baggage from childhood to their adulthood.
Allegra has described her husband’s childhood, and it sounds to me like he was “trained” as a child and teenager to not work around the house. This means that even if he has a good heart, he probably simply does not see what needs to be done.
I know this is hard for the “doers” to understand, because we SEE everything–the dustball under the sofa, the stack of dirty dishes after evening family ice cream, the child whose sweater is on backwards, etc.
But people like Allegra’s husband have been trained NOT to see these things. And it’s possible that he has also been trained to consider them “not important,” so even if he is asked to take care of them, he asks, “Why?”
So it’s not a question of his considerateness vs. selfishness. Shaming someone who doesn’t realize that they are doing something “wrong” will only confuse and anger him.
I put “wrong” in quotes so that we realize that there is nothing morally “wrong” with dustballs, dirty dishes, and backwards clothing. It’s just that some of us have been trained to take care of these situations as soon as we become aware of them, while others have been trained to let them go.
It’s very common for couples who are opposite when it comes to “chores” end up getting married! The neatness and orderliness of the “clean” spouse is attracted to the free-spirit and laid-back attitude of the “messy” spouse, and vice-versa!
BTW, a lot of “clean” people truly feel that this is a moral issue–that “cleanliness is next to godliness” and that order is God’s intent for all situations. They feel justified in “correcting” others who aren’t like them.
I don’t think this is the case with the “messy” people, who are able to separate “cleanliness” from “godliness”, and don’t see cleanliness and order as “right” and “proper.” These"messies" often are the people who do well in adverse situations, because their “routine” is not turned upside-down (because it already IS upside down!), and often they can roll with the punches and keep their faith better than the
erson who MUST have order and neatness in order to function and have faith in God.
Of course these are generalizations.