Y
YinYangMom
Guest
Oh, and if everybody’s dead, were they dead before the 8 got off the island?
What about Claire’s son who’s living with his grandmother? And Walt’s boy living with his?
We know John Locke definitely died. Killed OFF the island so he couldn’t have been dead the first time, though he DID get off the island via a time warp.
Don’t know how Esau took the form of John but it had to be after John’s body was returned to the island. John’s body is buried, but for a while there, Esau was walking around in John’s form while John’s body was still in the coffin.
We know Jacob was killed by Ben and supposedly there is a short window of time available for him to find a replacement body. However, that window is not so short because he’s still appearing to Hurley as himself, and perhaps as other people (Jack’s dad, Isabella).
Sayid definitely died in the temple. He came back to life, though. Maybe that’s proof he wasn’t the chosen one for Jacob. If Jacob has to abide by the same conditions as Esau’s, there has to be a dead body among the chosen. Perhaps the body has to be dead for a length of time and since Sayid did not remain dead for that entire time (the hourglass perhaps?) he just got a second chance at life…
Temple people are dead.
The other Island, however, has Charles Whitmore - is he alive or dead?
In Esau’s Camp:
Claire disappeared. Jin should have blown up on the freighter. Sayid died and came back to life. That we know of, Kate and Sawyer haven’t died.
**
In Jacob’s Camp**:
Jack, Sun, Lapidus, Miles, Ben, Hurley, and guards: Ilana and Richard…
They’re not dead enough for Jacob to take on their form…yet.
And what’s with the alternate reality off the island - Jack with a son, a lot of past characters from the different time periods alive and crossing paths with each other in a time period in which they all exist - including Ben’s daughter and father and Claire (still pregnant)??
What about Claire’s son who’s living with his grandmother? And Walt’s boy living with his?
We know John Locke definitely died. Killed OFF the island so he couldn’t have been dead the first time, though he DID get off the island via a time warp.
Don’t know how Esau took the form of John but it had to be after John’s body was returned to the island. John’s body is buried, but for a while there, Esau was walking around in John’s form while John’s body was still in the coffin.
We know Jacob was killed by Ben and supposedly there is a short window of time available for him to find a replacement body. However, that window is not so short because he’s still appearing to Hurley as himself, and perhaps as other people (Jack’s dad, Isabella).
Sayid definitely died in the temple. He came back to life, though. Maybe that’s proof he wasn’t the chosen one for Jacob. If Jacob has to abide by the same conditions as Esau’s, there has to be a dead body among the chosen. Perhaps the body has to be dead for a length of time and since Sayid did not remain dead for that entire time (the hourglass perhaps?) he just got a second chance at life…
Temple people are dead.
The other Island, however, has Charles Whitmore - is he alive or dead?
In Esau’s Camp:
Claire disappeared. Jin should have blown up on the freighter. Sayid died and came back to life. That we know of, Kate and Sawyer haven’t died.
**
In Jacob’s Camp**:
Jack, Sun, Lapidus, Miles, Ben, Hurley, and guards: Ilana and Richard…
They’re not dead enough for Jacob to take on their form…yet.
And what’s with the alternate reality off the island - Jack with a son, a lot of past characters from the different time periods alive and crossing paths with each other in a time period in which they all exist - including Ben’s daughter and father and Claire (still pregnant)??