MARY is She necessary or optional?

  • Thread starter Thread starter De_Montfort
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I am very confused by this. Catholic Doctrine states that we will be judged according to our works, as does the Bible and the Church Fathers. Of course, the good works that are demanded of us are able to be done only through the grace of the Holy Spirit (grace which Christ merited for us by his passion and resurrection). How does consecration to Mary change all this, if not simply that you can receive even more graces through an additional devotion to Mary? Certainly it cannot change the fact that we are judged according to works!?!

No private revelations, however saintly the person may be, can contradict the public revelation of the deposit of faith.

Explanation would be greatly appreciated.
Go and read the book. I don’t have the book with me, I gave it to one of my friends.

Go and buy “33 days to Morning Glory” and read the chapter dedicated on why Total Consecration to Jesus through Mary means giving up your works. If you don’t give up the value of your works, then you cannot be totally consecrated to Jesus through Mary.

You are attacking a devotion you don’t know anything about. Therefore, I cannot characterize your attack as anything less than founded in ignorance. I would hope Catholics don’t just go about attacking portions of their own faith just because they are ignorant of them.

Total Consecration is part of the Catholic faith. If you don’t know anything about it, then go learn about it and get back with me. You shouldn’t attack things you don’t know anything about.

Pope Leo XIII granted indulgences to those who totally consecrate themselves to Mary. He encouraged EVERYONE to make total consecrations to Mary.
Pope St. Pius X wrote about St. Louis de Montfort’s total consecration in his encyclical: Ad Deum Illum. Pope St. Pius X granted an indulgence in perpetuity to all those who have recited St. Louis de Montfort’s formula of consecration to Mary.
Blessed Pope John Paul the Great consecrated the Catholic Church in the new millennium to Mary on October 8, 2000.
Pope Benedict XVI consecrated every single priest to the Immaculate Heart of Mary on May 12, 2010.

I mean, you can’t be Catholic without Mary and Marian consecration. The Catholic Church is consecrated to Mary, and every priest in it is consecrated to Mary. It would be impossible to find a Catholic priest that is not consecrated to Mary… Pope Benedict XVI consecrated all priests.

The practice of consecration to Mary began in the 11th century. You are arguing against Popes, Saints, Encyclicals, and Indulgences. You are arguing against the Tradition and Magisterium of the Church which goes back almost 1,000 years. Most importantly, you are arguing against Mary the Mother of God, and her son Jesus Christ. It is the will of Jesus Christ that Marian consecration happen. It is the will of Mary, the Queen of Heaven and all the Saints.

I would rather die than remain silent against an enemy of Jesus and Mary. If the devotion of total consecration is attacked, I would rather stay awake and yell myself blue in the face until I died of exhaustion, then remain silent.

For your information, I have been awake for 29 going on 30 hours. The above statement is no hyperbole.
Fullness Found:
No private revelations, however saintly the person may be, can contradict the public revelation of the deposit of faith.
  1. The saintliness of the person in question is: Mary, the Holy Mother of God. “Of all God’s creatures, Mary is the most conformed to Jesus” - St. Louis de Montfort
  2. Prove how Marian consecration violates Catholic doctrine. Not a single Pope since St. Louis de Montfort introduced his formula for total consecration has ever condemned it or even criticized it. But, unlike the Popes you *have * found reason to criticize total consecration to Mary. So, please, using the Tradition, Magisterium, and Scripture of our faith… prove how Marian consecration violates Catholic doctrine.
By what authority are you right, and around 25 Popes wrong? What have they gotten wrong about Marian consecration, please tell us.
 
A. I am still very confused by the statement: ‘When you consecrate yourself to Mary, you are no longer judged according to your works, but hers.’ I would appreciate some info about this if anyone can explain it to me, since it seems to contradict lots of Catholic doctrine.

B. Also, in DeMontfort’s writings about Mary, he says that he will share a ‘secret’ that he learned from the holy Spirit, and not from books. That seems to put his work in the category of private revelation. I am confused because I thought that private revelation functions to help us live out the deposit of faith handed to the apostles. How can it reveal new ‘secrets’ about what we have to do to be saved? (since that is certainly what many are implying).

P.S.- I am not trying to knock devotion to Mary (I pray to her daily). I am just really confused by some of these posts!
The Consecration of St. Louis de Montfort is a consecration to Jesus THROUGH Mary. It is not a cosecration to Mary alone. The Goal is Jesus Christ our final end.

If we live in Mary we will avoid sin, She will inspire us to follow the commandments of Her Son Jesus Christ, and She will enflame us will love for the Sacred Heart of Jesus.

Mary is our WAY to Christ, Christ is our goal.

St. Louis de Montforts term of “secret” is because not all our given the grace to know it. Only the Holy Spirit can give it. Because the Holy Spirit has put His seal on Mary, she is an enclosed garden of paradise for God,

This devotion should be spread because it is a sure means a direct way to Christ.
 
To Semper Zelare:

Attack? I can tell you have been awake 29 hours. I get the same way when I work extra night shifts. I call it trying to learn more, not ‘attacking.’ The notion of Mary’s works counting as mine is something that I never learned in RCIA or in reading multiple Catechisms. In fact, it sounds a little bit like the protestant notion of ‘imputed righteousness.’ Forgive me for wanting to know more about this VITAL teaching that I have not heard in Mass, RCIA, or the Catechism, but I apparently can’t be Catholic without!!! (and I thought the gnostics were good secret keepers)… Attacking Jesus and Mary? God forbid it! You are calling someone who prays daily rosaries, morning/evening liturgy of the hours, and attends daily masses an enemy of Jesus and Mary? I am far from perfect, but I love them both and their Church and I want to learn more. I will go read the book myself, and I hope that I will find more charitable clarification if I have questions when reading it. I forgive you for the accusations. May God forgive me for my trespasses as well.

-May the peace of Christ be with you.
 
To Semper Valare:

lol… Attack? I can tell you have been awake 29 hours. I get that cranky too when I work extra night shifts. I call it trying to learn more, not ‘attacking.’ The notion of Mary’s works counting as mine is something that I never learned in RCIA or in reading the entire Catechism. In fact, it sounds a little bit like the protestant notion of ‘imputed righteousness.’ Forgive me for wanting to know more about this teaching that I have not heard in Mass, RCIA, or the Catechism, but I apparently can’t be Catholic without!!! Attacking Jesus and Mary? God forbid it! You are calling someone who prays daily rosaries, morning/evening liturgy of the hours, and attends daily masses an enemy of Jesus and Mary?.. I forgive you for the accusation. May God forgive me for my trespasses as well.

-May the peace of Christ be with you.
  1. My username is Semper Zelare. Always Zealous. As in Galations 4:18 “It is fine to be zealous, provided the purpose is good, and to be so always and not just when I am with you.”
  2. It is an attack. You just attacked it again. I’ve bolded the portions of your post. You attacked it as Protestant. Well, again, if Marian Consecration was Protestant than the Pope’s wouldn’t have granted dozens of indulgences for it? Now would they have?
  3. I asked you by what authority you are choosing to disagree with almost 1,000 years of tradition, and the magisterium (vis a vis the leaders of that magisterium: IE: The Popes having never said anything bad about Marian consecration). You have named no authority from Scripture, Magisterium, or Tradition. And, I’ll wait until you do, or until you recant your attack.
 
The Consecration of St. Louis de Montfort is a consecration to Jesus THROUGH Mary. It is not a cosecration to Mary alone. The Goal is Jesus Christ our final end.

If we live in Mary we will avoid sin, She will inspire us to follow the commandments of Her Son Jesus Christ, and She will enflame us will love for the Sacred Heart of Jesus.

Mary is our WAY to Christ, Christ is our goal.

St. Louis de Montforts term of “secret” is because not all our given the grace to know it. Only the Holy Spirit can give it. Because the Holy Spirit has put His seal on Mary, she is an enclosed garden of paradise for God,

This devotion should be spread because it is a sure means a direct way to Christ.
Nicely put…but with all due respect, may I suggest that a better way to phrase the third paragraph would be “(Consecration to) Mary is a way to Christ…” - for the reasons you had already stated. This would be more clear.

I say this because it would seem fair to say that the Apostles did not “come to Christ through Mary”…Nor did Paul…Nor did any number of early Church converts come to Christ through any special “consecration” to Our Lady. Certainly the path of salvation has not changed since that time…

Peace
James
 
Nicely put…but with all due respect, may I suggest that a better way to phrase the third paragraph would be “(Consecration to) Mary is a way to Christ…” - for the reasons you had already stated. This would be more clear.

I say this because it would seem fair to say that the Apostles did not “come to Christ through Mary”…Nor did Paul…Nor did any number of early Church converts come to Christ through any special “consecration” to Our Lady. Certainly the path of salvation has not changed since that time…

Peace
James
Understood. Mary is A way to Christ. There are other ways even St. Louis de Montfort admits this, but they are harder, the way of Mary is easier, smooth, immaculate way to Christ.

And as far as Paul I can assure you He knew about Mary and was taught about Her the gospels are silent about somethings. Mary only wants Her Son to be glorified She kept Her self hidden at the begininng. She was known only to God.

But in these times She needs to be known so Christ maybe known loved and served through Her.
 
Thanks for this wonderful answer…
Question - slightly related…We had a brief conversation on another thread recently and I thought it would be worth copying here - but I can’t seem to find it…
you had mentioned about coming into church, genuflecting to the tabernacle and then going to Mary’s alter (or statue) and praying…I liked that imagery and responded to it…
Do you recall where that was?
Understood. Mary is A way to Christ. There are other ways even St. Louis de Montfort admits this, but they are harder, the way of Mary is easier, smooth, immaculate way to Christ.
This is really all the reassurance that any of us wish for in these discussions. That there ARE other ways to Christ…and while I’m sure you find De Monfort’s way to be the easiest…that may not be the case for others…Especially those new to the faith or to the investigation of the faith.
And as far as Paul I can assure you He knew about Mary and was taught about Her the gospels are silent about somethings.
I certainly agree with this…but if Mary were “necessary” (to get to Christ) Paul would certainly had said so…so in this case, the silence of Scripture speaks volumes.
Mary only wants Her Son to be glorified She kept Her self hidden at the beginning. She was known only to God.
Amen - Amen
But in these times She needs to be known so Christ maybe known loved and served through Her.
I fully agree that this is true. For Mary can offer, as you say above, a smooth path for those who are able to travel it.

Peace
James
 
I am very confused by this. Catholic Doctrine states that we will be judged according to our works, as does the Bible and the Church Fathers. Of course, the good works that are demanded of us are able to be done only through the grace of the Holy Spirit (grace which Christ merited for us by his passion and resurrection). How does consecration to Mary change all this, if not simply that you can receive even more graces through an additional devotion to Mary? Certainly it cannot change the fact that we are judged according to works!?!

No private revelations, however saintly the person may be, can contradict the public revelation of the deposit of faith.

Explanation would be greatly appreciated.
About works, De Monfort is saying that when a person consecrates themselves to Mary, then that means that they give away all the merits of their works to her and that she can dispose or distribute the good from them in any way she pleases. And the person gives up all rights to those merits from those works. That the person relies solely on Mary for any personal needs but does not ask for anything in return.

In this way prayer life and life itself becomes simple, totally given to Mary.

There is further explaination of this in De Monfort’s book. But that is basically it.

Just a thought.
 
  1. My username is Semper Zelare. Always Zealous. As in Galations 4:18 “It is fine to be zealous, provided the purpose is good, and to be so always and not just when I am with you.”
  2. It is an attack. You just attacked it again. I’ve bolded the portions of your post. You attacked it as Protestant. Well, again, if Marian Consecration was Protestant than the Pope’s wouldn’t have granted dozens of indulgences for it? Now would they have?
  3. I asked you by what authority you are choosing to disagree with almost 1,000 years of tradition, and the magisterium (vis a vis the leaders of that magisterium: IE: The Popes having never said anything bad about Marian consecration). You have named no authority from Scripture, Magisterium, or Tradition. And, I’ll wait until you do, or until you recant your attack.
Pardon me for mistyping your name. I will not forget again, as you have more than proven your zelousness by now…

Now, please stop putting words in my mouth, as if I have completely rejected all notions of consecration to the Blessed Mother. I will not give you sources to back up rejecting consecration to Mary, because I HAVE NOT REJECTED IT.

I did ask a few questions and I made few observations about what seemed to be a very new and strange teaching: ‘that Mary’s works will count as our works.’ I have not yet said anything bad about the idea of Marian consecration in general. I have asked questions regarding unclear statements that appeared to me to contradict the apostolic deposit of faith regarding such basic topics as judgement according to one’s works (I will give you sources for this if you want them). I do not believe that it is an attack on the faith to try to discuss and clarify how various Catholic teachings harmonize with one another. I was hoping that we could do just that in a respectful manner as mature and reasonable adults.

In my last post, I noted a parallel between what you described and the protestant idea of ‘imputed righteousness.’ I did not equate the two. I noted a similarity. It appeared to me that you described it as though her works would count as mine, which seemed strange, because even Jesus’ works don’t count as though they are mine (but I sure do benefit from the grace that he merited through his works!) I did not say that consecration to Mary was protestant! And since when is noting a similarity between something that is Catholic and something that is protestant an attack? According to our catechism, we still have much in common despite their various errors.

I am not an enemy of Mary, or Jesus, or the Church, or you. So please, stop and get some sleep. I pray that when you wake up, your responses will be more gentle, charitable, and humble (more Marian).

Fred Conty, thanks for clarifying this issue with a helpful and constructive response.
 
Thanks for this wonderful answer…
Question - slightly related…We had a brief conversation on another thread recently and I thought it would be worth copying here - but I can’t seem to find it…
you had mentioned about coming into church, genuflecting to the tabernacle and then going to Mary’s alter (or statue) and praying…I liked that imagery and responded to it…
Do you recall where that was?
Hi James! I greet you in Christ. Yes I remember saying that but I have forgotten which thread it was in.

I said I greet Christ in the tabernacle, kneel, make the sign of the Cross, then go back to an altar dedicated to Our Lady and pray.

May I ask you a question since I think this is were we may differ in opinion, do you believe everything given to Mary is given to Jesus? That any love given to Her is immediately given to Her Son?
This is really all the reassurance that any of us wish for in these discussions. That there ARE other ways to Christ…and while I’m sure you find De Monfort’s way to be the easiest…that may not be the case for others…Especially those new to the faith or to the investigation of the faith.
My goal is only to make Mary understood and how important She really is. I pray for those who don’t understand to come to understand Her important role in our salvation.
I certainly agree with this…but if Mary were “necessary” (to get to Christ) Paul would certainly had said so…so in this case, the silence of Scripture speaks volumes.
Paul did not teach on the Immaculate Conception, or the Assumption of our Lady either, those are necessary to believe for salvation right?! Why was he silent about things like that? Mary far surpassed even Paul in Her transformation into Christ. Not that I don’t look up to Paul he was a great man.
I fully agree that this is true. For Mary can offer, as you say above, a smooth path for those who are able to travel it.
I wish to leave you with a quote of St. Pope Pius X on why I wish to promote devotion to Mary.
  1. And that through the Virgin, and through her more than through any other means, we have offered us a way of reaching the knowledge of Jesus Christ, cannot be doubted when it is remembered that with her alone of all others Jesus was for thirty years united, as a son is usually united with a mother, in the closest ties of intimacy and domestic life. Who could better than His Mother have an open knowledge of the admirable mysteries of the birth and childhood of Christ, and above all of the mystery of the Incarnation, which is the beginning and the foundation of faith? Mary not only preserved and meditated on the events of Bethlehem and the facts which took place in Jerusalem in the Temple of the Lord, but sharing as she did the thoughts and the secret wishes of Christ she may be said to have lived the very life of her Son. **Hence nobody ever knew Christ so profoundly as she did, and nobody can ever be more competent as a guide and teacher of the knowledge of Christ. **
  2. Hence it follows, as We have already pointed out, that the Virgin is more powerful than all others as a means for uniting mankind with Christ
vatican.va/holy_father/pius_x/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-x_enc_02021904_ad-diem-illum-laetissimum_en.html

God Bless you!

Peace
James
 
I would like to say one additional thing about the total consecration for anyone who is curious.

Usually it is recommended that a person spend some time in retreat to make it.
But sometimes, many times, a person just dosen’t have the time.
So they may make up their own total consecration in their own words as long as it covers what the total consecration is. De Monfort’s way is on line below.

DeMonfort - marian devotion
ewtn.com/library/montfort/truedevo.htm
 
If God Himself chose Mary as Mother of Jesus,and Jesus HImself left His Mother as our Mother at the foot of the Cross (John 19:26-27) ,She is then not an option,but necessary in the plan of Salvation.
In other words,the Catholic Church does not go anywhere without Her.

God bless you all
 
Hi James! I greet you in Christ. Yes I remember saying that but I have forgotten which thread it was in.
Me too - I went back through my postings for at least a week and could not find it…Oh well…Maybe it was on a thread that got deleted for some reason…🤷
I said I greet Christ in the tabernacle, kneel, make the sign of the Cross, then go back to an altar dedicated to Our Lady and pray.
Yes - and I believe you were indicating that there was nothing wrong with that - to which I agreed. I then took that beautifully simple image and placed two different scenarios…We’ll call your Scenario above #1
2) You go in, Greet Christ in the Tabernacle, kneel, make the sign of the cross and pray there without going to the Marion altar at all…
3) You go in, ignore the tabernacle completely and just go to the Marion Altar and pray to Mary.
In Scenario’s 1 and 2, all is well for God is placed first and this is pleasing to Mary and to all concerned.
In scenario 3 however…Where Jesus is ignored in favor of Mary…Our Lady would be less than pleased since…as has often been expressed, her goal is to lead us to her Son.

Of course the usual caveats apply here…It’s a simple image to convey a simple idea about properly ordered devotion…
May I ask you a question since I think this is were we may differ in opinion, do you believe everything given to Mary is given to Jesus? That any love given to Her is immediately given to Her Son?
Of course I do…And I think that, in so far as there can be “greater or lesser” within the perfection of the heavenly realm, Mary’s intercession is the greatest and of course she is the model of perfect discipleship as well.
That said…it should be pointed out that everything given to ANY Saint is immediately given to Jesus. Any Love given to any saint is immediately given to Jesus.
Likewise, Any Love given directly to Jesus is immediately shared with Mary and the other Saints.
I don’t say this to denigrate Our Lady in any way. Rather to illustrate that, in a family as full of Love and united in the Will of God as the Heavenly family, that Love is all shared equally…
My goal is only to make Mary understood and how important She really is. I pray for those who don’t understand to come to understand Her important role in our salvation.
I appreciate that - and applaud it. My only goal is to suggest that, in your zeal, you recognize that not everyone is where you are. The Spiritual path that others are on may not perfectly parallel yours. That those investigating the faith - or new to the faith, can be deeply troubled by some of the language used and ideas presented.
Form all of this - I hope to suggest to you that you consider how Our Blessed Mother would feel and wish us to act toward these children of hers. Certainly devotion to her is a good thing…But only in so far as devotion to her furthers devotion to her Son.

So - what I am trying to say is that - in expressing the idea of this devotion…it is necessary to be sensitive to the one we are speaking to lest zealousness spill over into pride and cause strife instead of unity.
I wish to leave you with a quote of St. Pope Pius X on why I wish to promote devotion to Mary.
Thanks

Peace
James
 
Pardon me for mistyping your name. I will not forget again, as you have more than proven your zelousness by now…

Now, please stop putting words in my mouth, as if I have completely rejected all notions of consecration to the Blessed Mother. I will not give you sources to back up rejecting consecration to Mary, because I HAVE NOT REJECTED IT.

I did ask a few questions and I made few observations about what seemed to be a very new and strange teaching: ‘that Mary’s works will count as our works.’ I have not yet said anything bad about the idea of Marian consecration in general. I have asked questions regarding unclear statements that appeared to me to contradict the apostolic deposit of faith regarding such basic topics as judgement according to one’s works (I will give you sources for this if you want them). I do not believe that it is an attack on the faith to try to discuss and clarify how various Catholic teachings harmonize with one another. I was hoping that we could do just that in a respectful manner as mature and reasonable adults.

In my last post, I noted a parallel between what you described and the protestant idea of ‘imputed righteousness.’ I did not equate the two. I noted a similarity. It appeared to me that you described it as though her works would count as mine, which seemed strange, because even Jesus’ works don’t count as though they are mine (but I sure do benefit from the grace that he merited through his works!) I did not say that consecration to Mary was protestant! And since when is noting a similarity between something that is Catholic and something that is protestant an attack? According to our catechism, we still have much in common despite their various errors.

I am not an enemy of Mary, or Jesus, or the Church, or you. So please, stop and get some sleep. I pray that when you wake up, your responses will be more gentle, charitable, and humble (more Marian).
You have chosen to recant, and I’m glad that you did.

You may have never said Marian consecration violated Catholic doctrine… but you implied that you could find doctrine that it did violate. So, my mission was to destroy that notion that you held. The notion that somewhere in the universe of Catholic doctrine, a doctrine existed which contradicted Marian consecration. And I have destroyed it. The seeds of heresy have been defeated before they could even sprout.

In my view, as a soldier in Our Lady’s army, the Militia Immaculata, on the Feast day of the Immaculate Conception, I shouldn’t be apologizing, you should be thanking me.

Obviously if my statements were unclear, then by now they have been clarified. My statements were rooted in doctrine and dogma. They were rooted in Catholic theology that went all the way to the top… to the Papacy.

As for being reasonable… I have the spiritual gift of preaching. And, I can find plenty of examples of people who were unreasonable in Church history. St. Francis is a good place to start. St. Francis was a fiery preacher, and its amazing that he’s not remembered as such. If the popular culture actually read about him they’d probably brand him as a fire and brimstone preacher who was bigoted against Moslems and homosexuals.

My point is, people with all personalities can be Catholic. And unreasonable, zealous radicals are welcome too. I mean, just look at the Inquisitors. If modernism is the synthesis of all heresies, as Pope St. Piux X tells us, then we need more people following in the footsteps of the Inquisitors than ever before. There is more heresy in the world today than ever before!
Fullness Found:
And since when is noting a similarity between something that is Catholic and something that is protestant an attack?
We have many similarities in our faiths. But, Marian consecration is not one of them. It would be like calling something in the Protestant church that is about as far away from Catholicism as you can get, ‘Catholic’. Marian consecration is about as far away from Protestantism as you can get. The starting point of Marian consecration is Mary… who most Protestants believe a) had the stain of original sin or b) had other children after Jesus (like his ‘brother’ James).

And, I’m only glad that I get to denounce both notions today. Today is the Feast of the Immaculate Conception, and I just listened to a homily by a Bishop who said, “What Jesus did on the cross already happened to Mary, at her conception” and, “Mary didn’t need to be baptized, she was not stained by original sin”.

Lastly, I was motivated by love. And “where there is no zeal there is no love” -Fr. Bill Casey (who has been EWTN a number of times). The Biblical view of love can’t possibly mean a love which doesn’t make enemies. Biblical love is tough love, you might rub people the wrong way if you preach the truth, but if you love them you’ll give them the whole truth. You won’t water down the truth to be a people-pleaser, if you love them.

25 Popes, 1,000 years of tradition. I know what the truth is about Marian consecration, and I won’t water it down. You’re welcome.

Pax Vobiscum. Dominus Vobiscum.
 
One last comment that I forgot to include in my earlier post.

As a result of some of the interactions I have seen on this and on similar threads, I am less inclined to investigate the “consecration to Mary” or other special devotions to her.

I don’t like to feel pushed…and that is what it feels like…pushing…and pushing hard…This is not charity and I can’t think Our Lady would approve of some of it.

I know that is not the intent…but there it is…and if I feel that way, my guess is that others feel that way too.

So - I post this in order that those who read it might consider that their approach might not be attaining the desired outcome and as such - they might want to reconsider their approach.

Peace
James
 
One last comment that I forgot to include in my earlier post.

As a result of some of the interactions I have seen on this and on similar threads, I am less inclined to investigate the “consecration to Mary” or other special devotions to her.

I don’t like to feel pushed…and that is what it feels like…pushing…and pushing hard…This is not charity and I can’t think Our Lady would approve of some of it.

I know that is not the intent…but there it is…and if I feel that way, my guess is that others feel that way too.

So - I post this in order that those who read it might consider that their approach might not be attaining the desired outcome and as such - they might want to reconsider their approach.

Peace
James
Dear James I started this thread in order to show Mary’s importance in salvation.

So people who live the consecration are supposed to cower in a corner and not speak or promote its teaching in fear of “pushing” someone.

There are threads on this website that wish to take Mary completely out of the picture that are 20 pages long, but somehow a thread like this may “offened” someone.

I DO NOT understand this logic AT ALL! I am doing nothing wrong in giving Mary honor and showing Her purpose in our salvation
 
Semper Zelare,
It is clear that you feel that you feel you have accomplished a lot. You seem to have honorable intentions in your “defenses.” However, I must be honest and say that I feel that anything that I have learned from all of this has been from the constructive and beneficial posts of others, not from you. In fact, you have taught me how ‘not to go about Marian Consecration’ though your words and attitudes.

I will end my part of this public exchange by stating that I still believe (as I did at the beginning) that Marian consecration is a good thing (as I said in my first post, “I am not trying to knock devotion to Mary”). I also still believe that both you and I will be judged according to works that we have done (or not done) in faith (I did offer to give you biblical, patristic, and catechetical support for this position if you would have requested it). I do not believe that the good deeds that the Blessed Virgin did during her earthly life will count to you as if you personally were the one who did them (During the Reformation, the Church was clear that God doesn’t impute righteousness in this way). I do believe that through the communion of saints, you will benefit from the grace that she merited through her own good deeds (especially if you have a special devotion to her).

My other initial point has already been acknowledged by the original poster: Although St. Louis De Montfort himself said Total Consecration to Mary was the best way to Christ/salvation, he also said that it is not the only way. Enough said.

This ends my public part of this exchange. If I am wrong in any of these beliefs, I pray that God will correct and instruct me. If you feel that God is calling you to be the one to do that, please private message me so we can continue this conversation without you publicly twisting my questions and observations so that you can go on a self-righteous crusade against an enemy that never existed in the first place. In your last post, you stated, “we need more people following in the footsteps of the Inquisitors than ever before.” Well, you are surely doing just that. I guess you don’t care that Pope JPII publicly apologized for the inquisition on behalf of the Church…

I look forward to discussing all of this more through private messages if you so choose (I hope I am permitted to receive them even though I still have trial membership).

-May the peace of Christ be with you.
 
Dear James I started this thread in order to show Mary’s importance in salvation.
Fair enough.
So people who live the consecration are supposed to cower in a corner and not speak or promote its teaching in fear of “pushing” someone.
There are threads on this website that wish to take Mary completely out of the picture that are 20 pages long, but somehow a thread like this may “offend” someone.
I DO NOT understand this logic AT ALL! I am doing nothing wrong in giving Mary honor and showing Her purpose in our salvation
Perhaps the difficulty you have in understanding why I might feel pushed has to do with how you choose terms to use…
For example…Nothing in my post implied that you should “cower in a corner” or “not speak or promote”…it is you who have chosen to express yourself by using such extreme terms. I simply stated the effect that the approaches used have on me - and perhaps on others.
In your mind are the ONLY choices, in terms of style, approach, terms, etc. to either come out all guns blazing or "cower in the corner’? I’m sure this isn’t the case and that you are smart enough to know that there is always room for improvement in evangelizing - and part of that is getting to know your audience and catering your approach to that audience…not changing the message…but adjusting the approach.

St Paul speaks of being all things to all people…certainly this does not mean altering the truth…rather it means adjusting the approach, choice of terms…feeding milk when they are not ready for meat and so forth…

Of course if you prefer the “All or nothing” approach and that is the only way you can work and if you think that this is what Our Lady wants you to do…Well then all I can do is wish you the best of luck…But I won’t be joining you on that pathway…

As for threads that, “wish to take Mary completely out of the picture”, let me know the next time one gets started and I’ll be right there supporting Our Mother.

Peace
James
 
I also still believe that both you and I will be judged according to works that we have done (or not done) in faith (I did offer to give you biblical, patristic, and catechetical support for this position if you would have requested it). I do not believe that the good deeds that the Blessed Virgin did during her earthly life will count to you as if you personally were the one who did them (During the Reformation, the Church was clear that God doesn’t impute righteousness in this way). I do believe that through the communion of saints, you will benefit from the grace that she merited through her own good deeds (especially if you have a special devotion to her).
That part of your post is not personal, and still pertains to the topic of the thread. I’ll address all the personal attacks on my person in PM.
  1. You are the only one who is talking about the works of Mary during her lifetime. Mary’s works don’t become mine, my works become Mary’s. I will have no works when I get to Heaven. Possession is the key. I will have done works throughout my life, but I can no longer point to those works to reflect on me. I forfeited the merits of those works.
I thought I already addressed this in my last post… I don’t want you to point to Church doctrine which condemns unclear statements of mine. Don’t you get it? The error is yours in failing to understand the statements. The statements themselves are not in error.

If you brought out doctrine which says Mary’s works don’t become someones, then who is in error? Me? No, because I never claimed that. You did. So, your failed interpretation of my statements is the root of the error. And THAT is the reason why your offered doctrine is unnecessary.
  1. Everything I just said falls under the quote in my signature. Only 7% of what I’m communicating goes through text alone. And this is perhaps one of the most glaring examples of that. Your inability to understand my posts isn’t your fault. It’s scientifically proven that only 7% of my meaning can get through to you. So, therein lies the miscommunication.
The solution, is obviously for everyone to stop communicating through text alone. Which, is why I’m leaving Catholic Answers very very soon. Any forum with such a huge possibility for miscommunication shouldn’t be used for evangelism. It really shouldn’t be used for anything. You have a 93% chance of failing to communicate.

Therefore, the rise of the internet is clearly responsible for a decline in communication.
  1. We’re not judged by works done in faith. We are judged by faith and works.
  2. Everyone benefits from the grace which flows through Mary. Mary is the channel through which the most grace flows from the Holy Spirit to the world. At the day of judgement I will not have works to point to, instead I will have Mary to vouch for me. There’s a whole covenant of duties that I have to Mary, and extraordinary graces which she gives me in return.
Mary can deploy millions of angels and saints, MILLIONS to defend even one soldier in her Militia Immaculata from the forces of evil. And that’s not even part of the covenant. That’s just the caliber of how intensely awesome the consecration covenant with Mary is.
Fullness Found:
My other initial point has already been acknowledged by the original poster: Although St. Louis De Montfort himself said Total Consecration to Mary was the best way to Christ/salvation, he also said that it is not the only way. Enough said.
I mean, you could say enough said and forget about it. But, there’s no better way to know Chris than through Mary. It is the best way. Better than every other way.

Quite frankly, I would be astounded if someone knew Marian consecration was the BEST way to know Jesus and be saved, and then not be consecrated. So, I know you’ll get around to it. But, if you didn’t, I would be astounded.

Now that you know Marian consecration is, “The quickest, easiest, surest, and most efficacious way to know Jesus is through Mary”- St. Louis de Montfort. Now that you know it is the best way, how can you not be consecrated to Mary? …You’ll be consecrated.
 
For example…Nothing in my post implied that you should “cower in a corner” or “not speak or promote”…it is you who have chosen to express yourself by using such extreme terms. I simply stated the effect that the approaches used have on me - and perhaps on others.
In your mind are the ONLY choices, in terms of style, approach, terms, etc. to either come out all guns blazing or "cower in the corner’? I’m sure this isn’t the case and that you are smart enough to know that there is always room for improvement in evangelizing - and part of that is getting to know your audience and catering your approach to that audience…not changing the message…but adjusting the approach.

St Paul speaks of being all things to all people…certainly this does not mean altering the truth…rather it means adjusting the approach, choice of terms…feeding milk when they are not ready for meat and so forth…

Of course if you prefer the “All or nothing” approach and that is the only way you can work and if you think that this is what Our Lady wants you to do…Well then all I can do is wish you the best of luck…But I won’t be joining you on that pathway…

As for threads that, “wish to take Mary completely out of the picture”, let me know the next time one gets started and I’ll be right there supporting Our Mother.

Peace
James
The only thing that has happened in this thread (besides some minor frustration between users) is facts on Popes who have promoted True devotion and Church history showing promotion and indulgences for doing the Consecration.

No one has been pushed. Just truth about the Consecration has been given. I will not be made to feel guilty because my approach was foward or I propose the way of St. Louis de Montfort and St. Maximilian Kolbe who are SAINTS and their lives are to be imitated.

I think we differ because you consider devotion to Mary as an option, and I don’t. I know I am not wrong in thinking this, Church teaching and Popes have shown the importance of Marian devotion.

In fact all that Christ has obtained be it merits or grace come to us through the hands of Mary. St. Pope Pius X is clear on this in his teaching!
"13. It cannot, of course, be denied that the dispensation of these treasures is the particular and peculiar right of Jesus Christ, for they are the exclusive fruit of His Death, who by His nature is the mediator between God and man. Nevertheless, by this companionship in sorrow and suffering already mentioned between the Mother and the Son, **it has been allowed to the august Virgin to be the most powerful mediatrix and advocate of the whole world with her Divine Son **(Pius IX. Ineffabilis).
And from this community of will and suffering between Christ and Mary she merited to become most worthily the Reparatrix of the lost world (Eadmeri Mon. De Excellentia Virg. Mariae, c. 9) and Dispensatrix of all the gifts that Our Savior purchased for us by His Death and by His Blood.
and again
But Mary, as St. Bernard justly remarks, is the channel (Serm. de temp on the Nativ. B. V. De Aquaeductu n. 4); or, if you will, the connecting portion the function of which is to join the body to the head and to transmit to the body the influences and volitions of the head - We mean the neck. Yes, says St. Bernardine of Sienna, “she is the neck of Our Head, by which He communicates to His mystical body all spiritual gifts”
So we see that all things given to men pass through Our Holy Mother Mary’s hands.
I feel as though the post you have given are in some way **trying to make me feel guilty **for even talking about my devotion and trying to lead others to it. These efforts will go nowhere with me. I have used charity in my posts they may be to the point. You seem to not agree with St. Louis de Montfort way of True Devotion and I do. I am not wrong just because you don’t see eye to eye with me. I have a right to spread devotion to Mary since the history of the Church shows the acceptance of True devotion to Mary.

Devotion to Mary is only to make our devotion to Christ more perfect.

“Why do we love Mary Immaculate and consecrate ourselves to her unreservedly? Not because of what she is in herself, but because she is wholly God’s… We love her because we love God.” (St. Maximilian Kolbe)

What really gets me is on this website teachings of the Saints are looked down on as if they go against the Catholic Church, when in fact Pope John Paul II was the most to promote True devotion to Mary and St. Maximilian Kolbe. Like I said before I take my advise from the Vicar of Christ. He put it in his teachings!

So even though we differ in opinion I hope we can still be friends In Mary and Christ!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top