O
OraLabora
Guest
You missed the point entirely. You’ll note that I was responding to a conversation where one person said basically that he had no sympathy for someone caught in a situation where sexual relations were no longer possible because he himself has not been able to have legitimate sex and didn’t masturbate and was doing just fine.And this is where you’re going wrong, this isn’t about judgments as has been stated many times. It’s about providing good, accurate information which is offered to help build the spirit of our fellow Christian’s.
The fact of the matter is, there is never any situation under which masturbation would not be considered sinful. If there is some reason why the (married) individual can’t have sex with their spouse, then a more positive approch is to maybe help figure out if there is anything that can be done about that situation. If there is nothing to be done, then more positive than “lock the door, do what you want, God won’t smite you” is to offer spiritual support for their situation, and help them to maintain their trust in God and his (and the Church’s) precept.
This isn’t a judgment, it’s promoting the truth of what God wants from us with regard to our sexuality. Promoting sin (which is what the example statement I used does) is never the right path.
In short he was saying “since I can do it you can do it too”, which in essence is passing judgement on the person’s moral fortitude, and he was unwilling to consider the pressures the sinner’s situation had on his degree of culpability.
It is this legalism without mercy that drives me nuts and makes us appear as a bunch of Pharisees.