Masturbation a Sin ? :confused:

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ransri
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Why do you waste your time on talking to an “insane” person? After all you said that only and insane person would deny that our sexual organs are designed for procreation? And since I disagree, I must be “insane”.
Because I care about sanity. Sanity is healthy. You should be healthy.
Others should be healthy.

Part of good health is to be outwardly directed, toward the good of others, and by unity, toward the good of one’s self.

Masturbation is not ordered to that.
Chastity is the rightly integrated state of sexuality with the whole person, in the context of other persons.

We should be whole,not fragmented by misdirected passions.
We should be directed to good, not to mere self absorption and gratification.

Why would you want it any other way?
 
You misunderstand. I took exception to the expression of “design”. And I take exception to “man and woman were made for each other”. Any sex between consenting adults is fine. It is very good to have a loving mother and father for a child. But the emphasis is on loving, not the gender of the people involved. In the past there was a social stigma on “bastards”, there was a huge uproar against same-sex relationships.

But this is getting outdated. Every time I see a commercial with same-sex couples, I must grin ear-to-ear. The fact that businesses dare to use same sex couples in commercials aimed at the general public is wonderful. It shows that the prejudice is disappearing. In a few decades the concept of same sex couples will not even be “ho-hum”. No one will even see it… with a miniscule exception of some ultra-orthodox people.
This is where you have explicitly departed from the Church’s teaching and wandered off into your own speculations, to the point where I’m not even sure if you’re being serious or just trolling these forums.

We don’t cherry pick those aspects of God’s teaching which are more palatable to our modern fashions. Either we accept what He sought fit to teach us or we reject Him.
 
This is where you have explicitly departed from the Church’s teaching and wandered off into your own speculations, to the point where I’m not even sure if you’re being serious or just trolling these forums.
If you can give a rational reason why to follow those teachings, I will follow the lead.
We don’t cherry pick those aspects of God’s teaching which are more palatable to our modern fashions. Either we accept what He sought fit to teach us or we reject Him.
You have no direct access to God. What the church teaches may or may not be what God considers correct. And since God never shoes his face, you have no extra evidence that God agrees with you.
 
I took exception to the expression of “design”. And I take exception to “man and woman were made for each other”.
No need to take any exception. I don’t believe that language aims to argue that a god ‘designed’ what is before us. Rather - it is simply making an observation about what “is” - not how it came to be.
It is very good to have a loving mother and father for a child.
Yes, exactly.
But the emphasis is on loving, not the gender of the people involved.
Keep the focus on the child. In principle (by which I mean - other things being equal) the child is best placed when those loving parents are his actual parents. This necessitates the sex of the parents - one male, one female. It is the right of every child, though circumstances may fail to see it delivered. And then there are the pernicious case eg. surrogacy - where the rights of the “soon to be child” are deliberately set aside.
 
There’s much I admire about Catholic culture, but this part is pure insanity.

But hey, I’ll join in. Teaching people to go to war with their own bodies is a huge evil ruthlessly cruel sin punishable by 5,000 eternities in hellfire damnation etc etc.

This whole masterbation thing, nuts, completely nuts. Wacky cult nonsense. So much pointless suffering. Isn’t there enough real suffering in the world already?? Do you really have to invent some more, out of nothing? For crying out loud, show some mercy to the young folks who aren’t married yet. Give them a @#!#$ break. Such a cruel philosophy.
The Church has no authority to “give people a break” by purporting to change moral law. To give people anything less than the truth about moral law, including God’s plan for human sexuality, would be truly cruel.

If you’d like to understand why the Church understands masturbation to be a grave sin, plenty of great Catholic writers have covered the topic over the past 2,000 years.

Here are a couple of short explanations:

chastity.com/question/if-sex-is-good-for-us-why-is-the-church-so-hostile-to-it
vatican.va/archive/ccc_css/archive/catechism/p3s2c2a6.htm#2352
 
The Church has no authority to “give people a break” by purporting to change moral law. To give people anything less than the truth about moral law, including God’s plan for human sexuality, would be truly cruel.

If you’d like to understand why the Church understands masturbation to be a grave sin, plenty of great Catholic writers have covered the topic over the past 2,000 years.

Here are a couple of short explanations:

chastity.com/question/if-sex-is-good-for-us-why-is-the-church-so-hostile-to-it
vatican.va/archive/ccc_css/archive/catechism/p3s2c2a6.htm#2352
Here’s the “break:” God sent His only-,begotten Son to suffer and die in atonement for our sins. And we’re not expected to be perfect, but we’re expected to try, to learn from our mistakes and when we do stumble, to REPENT!
There’s a break!
 
What makes this case different is that there are no others involved.
Which is a common lie, as one does not exactly get off thinking about something like basketball or something like that, and then welcome to the pornography industry which harms and enslaves many. And for those who do not train themselves with self control in their aspiration for chastity, it will lead on to other things such as prostitution, promiscuity, and in some cases even rape, abuse and other sexual perversions.

“For the sake of His sorrowful passion have mercy on us and on the whole world.”

God Bless

Thank you for reading
Josh
 
And for those who do not train themselves with self control in their aspiration for chastity, it will lead on to other things such as prostitution, promiscuity, and in some cases even rape, abuse and other sexual perversions.
Not to argue, but I think the average person who wants to believe that masturbation is okay will read this argument and say, “But I’ve never hired a prostitute or raped anyone and neither have most people who masturbate.” Some even tell themselves that masturbation helps them avoid those behaviors by “relieving tension.” (As one who has both struggled with this sin and, at other times through God’s grace, avoided this sin for long periods of time, I have found that the perceived tension relief is not real. It is akin to the relief smokers feel when they have a cigarette, easing the tension that was caused by their nicotine addiction, which in turn was caused by smoking in the first place.)

But even if masturbation doesn’t lead to any worse behavior, the act itself is a problem. It treats one’s own sexual faculties as an object for personal pleasure rather than a sacred gift to be used to unite a husband and wife and and bring them into the procreation of human life. It is an act that says, “My sexuality is nothing special; I will do with it as a please, regardless of what God intended.” That’s a statement that, in and of itself, seriously damages our relationship with God and closes us off to His grace.
 
I have found that the perceived tension relief is not real.
Perhaps the tension relief is not real for you. If that’s so, you should contact a scientific journal to help record this rare biological event. The “tension”, if one wishes to use that word instead of “libido”, is a completely natural biological mechanism whose function is to encourage us to reproduce. Then tension relief is a signal that the body is ready to rest from reproductive functions.

Libido pre-dates Christianity by millions of years, so we aren’t going to wish it out of existence any time soon. And if you believe God to be the creator of all things, then libido too is part of God’s creation, and is thus worthy of respect from the theological point of view.

I’m sure we all agree that libido being created by God does not mean that anything we do with our libido is then acceptable. We agree that there are uses of our sex drive that clearly should be defined as sin, and that the threat of punishment is appropriate in such cases as a deterrent. The issue would seem to be, what sexual behaviors should be defined as immoral, as sin?
But even if masturbation doesn’t lead to any worse behavior, the act itself is a problem.
The act can be a problem, but not from a moral point of view, because there are no second party victims. If someone loses their job because they’re too busy entertaining themselves that is surely a problem, but it’s a practical problem, not a moral one. Thus the concept of sin does not apply.

If someone misses out on some spiritual development because they are distracted by this activity, that too could be reasonably defined as a problem, but again, it’s a spiritual obstacle, not a moral failing, not a sin, not a crime. As example, not going to Mass for some period of time might create a spiritual obstacle, but no one is considering labeling that a sin. A problem perhaps, but not a sin.
It treats one’s own sexual faculties as an object for personal pleasure rather than a sacred gift to be used to unite a husband and wife and and bring them into the procreation of human life.
The personal pleasure you refer to was designed by God. It is God that made this joy available to us. And God’s design of the human body surely doesn’t discourage it, because we don’t have to stand on our head or do a yoga contortion to get there. There are our hands, exactly where they are most convenient for such an activity. Not my opinion my friends, but God’s design of the human body which you can observe for yourself.

**There is absolutely nothing standing in the way of a person performing this activity as a form of worship for the God who created that activity, and so generously provided this form of joy, because every act a human being takes can be approached in this manner. Perhaps you should learn how to do this before proclaiming it not to be possible, eh? **

I remind my friends that there are many lonely people in the world, many lonely Catholics too, and their bodies still speak to them, even though they are not in a position to produce children. I suggest to you that it would be more Catholic to show mercy, kindness and grace to these entirely innocent folks rather than to feed your own need to play the role of morally superior judge, spiritual expert, knower of the mind of God.

Speaking only for myself, I know that many of you voted for Trump, a proudly bragging sexual predator, so in such individual cases where that is true (obviously not all Catholics) I simply refuse to accept anything you have to say on the subject of sexual morality. Your credibility with me, on the topic of sexual morality, is completely shot. Maybe when Trump leaves office we can revisit this conclusion.
It is an act that says, “My sexuality is nothing special; I will do with it as a please, regardless of what God intended.”
Perhaps this is what you say, I don’t know. If so, that does not make the statement in to a universal principle applying to all persons.
That’s a statement that, in and of itself, seriously damages our relationship with God and closes us off to His grace.
There is nothing that can damage our relationship with God, there is nothing that closes us off to His grace. Read that again perhaps.

Could the problem here perhaps be that you believe in small stingy God, and so bring this perspective to your relationship with a great many of your fellow Catholics?

If you wish to point the finger of blame and shame, it’s your voice, you have the right to use it as you feel best. But please know that the sword of judgment can cut in all directions, and can be used to systematically destroy your world view just as much as it can be used to promote it.

So if you wish to judge others over nothing, ok, your right, your call, but be prepared to have the favor returned. The point of this statement is educational. I’m asking you if you really want to live in a world where we judge each other over nothing. If we create that world, you will have to live there too, right?
 
Perhaps the tension relief is not real for you. If that’s so, you should contact a scientific journal to help record this rare biological event. The “tension”, if one wishes to use that word instead of “libido”, is a completely natural biological mechanism whose function is to encourage us to reproduce. Then tension relief is a signal that the body is ready to rest from reproductive functions.
Cause we know that tension is just unbearable, and our passions need to be followed, cause it’s, like, biological. And biology is the sum of all things.

The avoidance of hard things.
It’s such a small view of human potential and flourishing.
I really don’t know how anything exceptional can be done in the world with attitudes like this.
 
… The “tension”, if one wishes to use that word instead of “libido”, is a completely natural biological mechanism whose function is to encourage us to reproduce…I’m sure we all agree that libido being created by God does not mean that anything we do with our libido is then acceptable…
Right. I note that you are not making an argument in favour of masturbation at this point.
We agree that there are uses of our sex drive that clearly should be defined as sin, and that the threat of punishment is appropriate in such cases as a deterrent. The issue would seem to be, what sexual behaviors should be defined as immoral, as sin? The act [masturbation] can be a problem, but not from a moral point of view, because there are no second party victims.
I have come across this view of the nature of morality from atheists, but I note you appear to acknowledge God. So, can I ask whether this understanding of “morality” [wrong acts necessitate a 2nd party victim] is that held by a particular Church or is it a personal view?
The personal pleasure you refer to was designed by God. It is God that made this joy available to us. And God’s design of the human body surely doesn’t discourage it, because we don’t have to stand on our head or do a yoga contortion to get there. There is absolutely nothing standing in the way of a person performing this activity as a form of worship for the God who created that activity, and so generously provided this form of joy, because every act a human being takes can be approached in this manner.
This seems to be superfluous, as your argument really rests on the earlier statement that says immoral acts must involve a 2nd party victim. Thus every other act must be moral (and I note you identify all moral (by your definition) acts as worship of God.
There is nothing that can damage our relationship with God, there is nothing that closes us off to His grace.
God loves us always - Is that what you mean? That would be very Catholic. But are you suggesting something more?
So if you wish to judge others
To judge others is usually understood to make a call on a person’s ultimate fate (before God) of a person. To do this is wrong - we have no competence to do that. However, to judge an action as objectively right or wrong is certainly within our power. We do so by comparing it with our understanding of the “moral law”. You expressed your moral law above, and the Church expresses that of the Catholic faith.
 
The act can be a problem, but not from a moral point of view, because there are no second party victims.
I do not agree with your saying that a sin should involve a victim party.
A christian worshipping a pagan god is, in the eyes of God, a mortal sin leading to eternal damnation.
There is no secondary party victims in such act.

Sin is not just equal to crime.
 
Perhaps the tension relief is not real for you. If that’s so, you should contact a scientific journal to help record this rare biological event. The “tension”, if one wishes to use that word instead of “libido”, is a completely natural biological mechanism whose function is to encourage us to reproduce. Then tension relief is a signal that the body is ready to rest from reproductive functions.

Libido pre-dates Christianity by millions of years, so we aren’t going to wish it out of existence any time soon. And if you believe God to be the creator of all things, then libido too is part of God’s creation, and is thus worthy of respect from the theological point of view.

I’m sure we all agree that libido being created by God does not mean that anything we do with our libido is then acceptable. We agree that there are uses of our sex drive that clearly should be defined as sin, and that the threat of punishment is appropriate in such cases as a deterrent. The issue would seem to be, what sexual behaviors should be defined as immoral, as sin?

The act can be a problem, but not from a moral point of view, because there are no second party victims. If someone loses their job because they’re too busy entertaining themselves that is surely a problem, but it’s a practical problem, not a moral one. Thus the concept of sin does not apply.

If someone misses out on some spiritual development because they are distracted by this activity, that too could be reasonably defined as a problem, but again, it’s a spiritual obstacle, not a moral failing, not a sin, not a crime. As example, not going to Mass for some period of time might create a spiritual obstacle, but no one is considering labeling that a sin. A problem perhaps, but not a sin.

The personal pleasure you refer to was designed by God. It is God that made this joy available to us. And God’s design of the human body surely doesn’t discourage it, because we don’t have to stand on our head or do a yoga contortion to get there. There are our hands, exactly where they are most convenient for such an activity. Not my opinion my friends, but God’s design of the human body which you can observe for yourself.

**There is absolutely nothing standing in the way of a person performing this activity as a form of worship for the God who created that activity, and so generously provided this form of joy, because every act a human being takes can be approached in this manner. Perhaps you should learn how to do this before proclaiming it not to be possible, eh? **

I remind my friends that there are many lonely people in the world, many lonely Catholics too, and their bodies still speak to them, even though they are not in a position to produce children. I suggest to you that it would be more Catholic to show mercy, kindness and grace to these entirely innocent folks rather than to feed your own need to play the role of morally superior judge, spiritual expert, knower of the mind of God.

Speaking only for myself, I know that many of you voted for Trump, a proudly bragging sexual predator, so in such individual cases where that is true (obviously not all Catholics) I simply refuse to accept anything you have to say on the subject of sexual morality. Your credibility with me, on the topic of sexual morality, is completely shot. Maybe when Trump leaves office we can revisit this conclusion.

Perhaps this is what you say, I don’t know. If so, that does not make the statement in to a universal principle applying to all persons.

There is nothing that can damage our relationship with God, there is nothing that closes us off to His grace. Read that again perhaps.

Could the problem here perhaps be that you believe in small stingy God, and so bring this perspective to your relationship with a great many of your fellow Catholics?

If you wish to point the finger of blame and shame, it’s your voice, you have the right to use it as you feel best. But please know that the sword of judgment can cut in all directions, and can be used to systematically destroy your world view just as much as it can be used to promote it.

So if you wish to judge others over nothing, ok, your right, your call, but be prepared to have the favor returned. The point of this statement is educational. I’m asking you if you really want to live in a world where we judge each other over nothing. If we create that world, you will have to live there too, right?
The sex instinct, and the accompanying pleasure, are like many other goods in that they can be abused. We get pleasure from food, but gluttony is a sin which can also lead to poor health. Likewise alcohol in moderation is good, possibly even better than being teetotal, but excessive drinking is bad for the health and bad in combination with driving.

God is not “small and stingy” - if He were He would create no pleasures or goods for us to enjoy at all. But He does want us to be moderate, and learn the equal if not superior good that comes from not being slaves to our hormones.

As a family lawyer, I see all the time the harm that is done in family relationships when one partner puts their own libido above the needs of their partner, be it in cases of adultery, extreme porn use or - which you so rightly condemn - an unnatural (but nonetheless real) sexual attraction to children.

And I don’t think it is coincidence that the modern emphasis on masturbation being “healthy” is accompanied by a high rate of relationship breakdown. Working through the ups and downs of a relationship with another person surely seems all the less worthwhile when one sees nothing wrong with having a “relationship” with one’s own right hand.
 
Right. I note that you are not making an argument in favour of masturbation at this point.

I have come across this view of the nature of morality from atheists, but I note you appear to acknowledge God. So, can I ask whether this understanding of “morality” [wrong acts necessitate a 2nd party victim] is that held by a particular Church or is it a personal view?

This seems to be superfluous, as your argument really rests on the earlier statement that says immoral acts must involve a 2nd party victim. Thus every other act must be moral (and I note you identify all moral (by your definition) acts as worship of God.

God loves us always - Is that what you mean? That would be very Catholic. But are you suggesting something more?

To judge others is usually understood to make a call on a person’s ultimate fate (before God) of a person. To do this is wrong - we have no competence to do that. However, to judge an action as objectively right or wrong is certainly within our power. We do so by comparing it with our understanding of the “moral law”. You expressed your moral law above, and the Church expresses that of the Catholic faith.
Well, you’re very kind and generous here, Rau. 🤷
Masturbation as an act of worship…
In the “Church of Satan,” perhaps…
:signofcross::knight1:
 
Right. I note that you are not making an argument in favour of masturbation at this point.
Thank you for noting that. Correct, I’m not arguing for or against masturbation. I’m arguing for compassion.
I have come across this view of the nature of morality from atheists, but I note you appear to acknowledge God. So, can I ask whether this understanding of “morality” [wrong acts necessitate a 2nd party victim] is that held by a particular Church or is it a personal view?
I don’t belong to any church. I am influenced by centuries of Catholic DNA in my bloodstream, and am attempting to speak from there. As example, do you walk up to strangers on the street and tell them they’re sinners who may be going to hell even though you have no evidence that they are hurting anybody? I’m sure that you don’t, that wouldn’t very Catholic at all. I’m not selling you something foreign, I’m selling you Catholic values, as I understand them. Members are free to disagree of course, no complaint there.
This seems to be superfluous, as your argument really rests on the earlier statement that says immoral acts must involve a 2nd party victim. Thus every other act must be moral (and I note you identify all moral (by your definition) acts as worship of God.
My point above was only that if God was so very concerned about masturbation, it seems unlikely he would have designed the human body so as to make it so incredibly convenient.

Thank you for a very intelligent response, but you seem to have missed the part of my post I deliberately bolded, which was.

There is absolutely nothing standing in the way of a person performing this activity as a form of worship for the God who created that activity, and so generously provided this form of joy, because every act a human being takes can be approached in this manner.
You expressed your moral law above, and the Church expresses that of the Catholic faith.
From my perspective, the Catholic clergy, a small influential fraction of the Catholic community, expressed their perspective on the matter. And I’m guessing that some significant fraction of them don’t even hold the view that masturbation is sin, but are required to say so in order to honor the terms of their employment.

Thanks for engaging, looking forward to more of that.
 
God is not “small and stingy” .
Agreed. My point was only that we sometimes define him that way, which may say more about us than God. You know, looking for God in the mirror.
if He were He would create no pleasures or goods for us to enjoy at all. But He does want us to be moderate, and learn the equal if not superior good that comes from not being slaves to our hormones.
I agree with the being moderate part, that’s wise. I agree also with the not being a slave to anything, including an ideology.
As a family lawyer, I see all the time the harm that is done in family relationships when one partner puts their own libido above the needs of their partner, be it in cases of adultery, extreme porn use or - which you so rightly condemn - an unnatural (but nonetheless real) sexual attraction to children.
Agreed some more. For myself, I am certainly not arguing for an “anything goes” philosophy. This may be hard to see at the moment, but I am highly judgmental when there are real victims involved. Don’t get me started on that unless you enjoy the Old Testament. I quit my job and spent a year full time as a volunteer crime victim political activist for instance. Come to think of it, that may partly explain why I resent and resist real victims being compared with imaginary ones.
And I don’t think it is coincidence that the modern emphasis on masturbation being “healthy” is accompanied by a high rate of relationship breakdown. Working through the ups and downs of a relationship with another person surely seems all the less worthwhile when one sees nothing wrong with having a “relationship” with one’s own right hand.
Here I must disagree. You seem to be attempting to apply some global universal principle to millions of particular family situations you know nothing about. No offense, but that’s not the flavor of Catholicism which interests me.

Could what you speak to be a problem in some situations? Of course, agreed. That’s something entirely different than a global conclusion about everybody everywhere. You didn’t exactly say that, but some here are.

Just as some relationships might be damaged by the “right hand” as you put it, some relationships might be saved by it. I’m sure both happen all the time. And none of us are in the middle of all these millions of relationships.
 
…I don’t belong to any church. I am influenced by centuries of Catholic DNA in my bloodstream, and am attempting to speak from there.
The idea that immorality requires a 2nd party victim is not a product of that “Catholic DNA”. That appears to be a very personal view.
As example, do you walk up to strangers on the street and tell them they’re sinners who may be going to hell even though you have no evidence that they are hurting anybody?
No, I don’t do that in that circumstance or any other. But again, this seems to be a statement again that the only immoral acts are ones with a 2nd party victim.
I’m not selling you something foreign, I’m selling you Catholic values, as I understand them. Members are free to disagree of course, no complaint there.
You appear to be selling a shandy of Catholic values and personal values, some of which are not Catholic.
My point above was only that if God was so very concerned about masturbation, it seems unlikely he would have designed the human body so as to make it so incredibly convenient.
That seems a very strange statement. Is there some principle that says our body is or should be designed to discourage morally wrong acts?
Thank you for a very intelligent response, but you seem to have missed the part of my post I deliberately bolded
Not missed, just struck me as groundless, and suffering from a reliance on the premise that the act is good.
 
Not to argue, but I think the average person who wants to believe that masturbation is okay will read this argument and say, “But I’ve never hired a prostitute or raped anyone and neither have most people who masturbate.”
Sure, A better way of articulating what I was thinking, is that it never remains stagnant, I believe everyone is either working up the ladder toward chastity or falling down the ladder to becoming enslaved by their every desire, which in turn can easily lead to such things I believe.
Some even tell themselves that masturbation helps them avoid those behaviors by “relieving tension.” (As one who has both struggled with this sin and, at other times through God’s grace, avoided this sin for long periods of time, I have found that the perceived tension relief is not real. It is akin to the relief smokers feel when they have a cigarette, easing the tension that was caused by their nicotine addiction, which in turn was caused by smoking in the first place.)
I agree, and that’s a good analogy too I think.
But even if masturbation doesn’t lead to any worse behavior, the act itself is a problem. It treats one’s own sexual faculties as an object for personal pleasure rather than a sacred gift to be used to unite a husband and wife and and bring them into the procreation of human life. It is an act that says, “My sexuality is nothing special; I will do with it as a please, regardless of what God intended.” That’s a statement that, in and of itself, seriously damages our relationship with God and closes us off to His grace.
I agree,

Thank you Cimachol

God Bless You

Thank you for reading
Josh
 
You appear to be selling a shandy of Catholic values and personal values, some of which are not Catholic.
Well, that depends on who gets to define “Catholic”, a word that doesn’t appear in the Bible even once. I propose that, in the real world, “Catholic” refers to the actions of a billion different individual people, none of whom own exclusive rights to the label.

Jesus didn’t give Christianity to the Vatican, he gave it to humanity.

Those in the Vatican are of course included in humanity, and thus have as much right to express their interpretations as anybody else. Given the serious study those in the Vatican have typically applied to these questions, surely their views are worthy of consideration.

I believe I’ve made a reasonable case that compassion for the entirely innocent can quite reasonably be labeled an admirable Catholic value. Or we could call it an admirable human value if you prefer, I don’t really care what we call it, just as I don’t care whether I am labeled a Catholic or something else.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top