Modesty Question

  • Thread starter Thread starter jeanne71350
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Yesterday I had a rather surreal experience. There’s a Shrine dedicated to Our Lady of Charity in my area, built by the Cuban-American community. The church, or Shrine, is open all day long, and the Fathers at the Shrine hear confessions for several hours every day. There’s a convenient Mass late in the evening (in Spanish but that doesn’t bother me - I kind of understand already the prayers in Spanish), and although the Shrine is close to downtown, parking is easy and free. So, it’s almost the ideal place to visit… But you have to keep your eyes closed not to see some of the visitors, or else… :o

So, I went to confession, and was told to pray the Rosary, Glorious Mysteries as my penance. As I sat down, and prayed, there were many visitors coming and going… and out of every 10 ladies, 8 or 9 were so outrageously dressed, it was surreal… There was this girl, maybe 10 years old, and you could see deep down the crack of her butt. One could ask, wasn’t there an adult person to tell her, not to wear those low-riding jeans? Well, she was with an older lady (probably grandma), maybe 60 years old, who wore an extra-low cut spaghetti strap tank top… :o So, I guess, that’s how ladies dress in that family, regardless of age. Then, there was this other lady, also in the 55-60 y.o. age range, who walked in and looked really nice from behind, until she turned around! :eek: Because her blouse was this deep V-cut, down to her belly button (or almost :D), so that she looked exactly as if she was going to audition for the next after-midnight TV commercial for male enhancement tablets! :bigyikes:

By the time I finished praying the Rosary, I was almost ready to go back into the confessional, and confess my new sins committed since my last confession, less than an hour ago. :o I usually utter a curse reflexively, when I see something scandalous, and by the time it registers in my mind, it’s too late… the uncharitable words have been uttered already.

And there was nowhere to run, nowhere to hide. The church has an unusual round shape, with 5 or 6 entrances evenly distributed around the perimeter of the circle. If you sit in the pews, there will be people coming in, facing you directly, with these V-cut dresses cut to the level of the bottom of their breasts… in earlier times, these were a matter for X-rated movies… you can see these in the TV ads for male enhancement tablets, but even there, only after midnight. And that’s what’s going on in a Catholic church, in a Catholic Shrine dedicated to Our Lady, in broad daylight. 😦

It was horrible. There was hardly a female visitor, appropriately dressed during the afternoon. But it got better right before Mass. Several female visitors walked in right before Mass, dressed very nicely in modest clothes that didn’t let all hang out and everything on display. Then, during Mass it became apparent that many immodestly dressed people were visitors. The priest specifically instructed us at length and explained it before Holy Communion, that only Catholics who complied with the requirements for sacramental confession and are in the state of grace, can partake in Holy Communion. Only about 25% of those present took Communion, so I guess we had a lot of visitors. My conclusion is this: we are the salt of the Earth, and we should set an example by the way we dress. Maybe a lot of those visitors really don’t know any better, that’s why they dress immodestly. 😦 But we know better, we MUST dress modestly, and show a positive example to others. Some of these other ladies who came before Mass started, were really so nice-looking in their modest outfits. They looked classy, they totally stood out from the crowd.
 
Yesterday I had a rather surreal experience. There’s a Shrine dedicated to Our Lady of Charity in my area, built by the Cuban-American community. The church, or Shrine, is open all day long, and the Fathers at the Shrine hear confessions for several hours every day. There’s a convenient Mass late in the evening (in Spanish but that doesn’t bother me - I kind of understand already the prayers in Spanish), and although the Shrine is close to downtown, parking is easy and free. So, it’s almost the ideal place to visit… But you have to keep your eyes closed not to see some of the visitors, or else… :o

So, I went to confession, and was told to pray the Rosary, Glorious Mysteries as my penance. As I sat down, and prayed, there were many visitors coming and going… and out of every 10 ladies, 8 or 9 were so outrageously dressed, it was surreal… There was this girl, maybe 10 years old, and you could see deep down the crack of her butt. One could ask, wasn’t there an adult person to tell her, not to wear those low-riding jeans? Well, she was with an older lady (probably grandma), maybe 60 years old, who wore an extra-low cut spaghetti strap tank top… :o So, I guess, that’s how ladies dress in that family, regardless of age. Then, there was this other lady, also in the 55-60 y.o. age range, who walked in and looked really nice from behind, until she turned around! :eek: Because her blouse was this deep V-cut, down to her belly button (or almost :D), so that she looked exactly as if she was going to audition for the next after-midnight TV commercial for male enhancement tablets! :bigyikes:

By the time I finished praying the Rosary, I was almost ready to go back into the confessional, and confess my new sins committed since my last confession, less than an hour ago. :o I usually utter a curse reflexively, when I see something scandalous, and by the time it registers in my mind, it’s too late… the uncharitable words have been uttered already.

And there was nowhere to run, nowhere to hide. The church has an unusual round shape, with 5 or 6 entrances evenly distributed around the perimeter of the circle. If you sit in the pews, there will be people coming in, facing you directly, with these V-cut dresses cut to the level of the bottom of their breasts… in earlier times, these were a matter for X-rated movies… you can see these in the TV ads for male enhancement tablets, but even there, only after midnight. And that’s what’s going on in a Catholic church, in a Catholic Shrine dedicated to Our Lady, in broad daylight. 😦

It was horrible. There was hardly a female visitor, appropriately dressed during the afternoon. But it got better right before Mass. Several female visitors walked in right before Mass, dressed very nicely in modest clothes that didn’t let all hang out and everything on display. Then, during Mass it became apparent that many immodestly dressed people were visitors. The priest specifically instructed us at length and explained it before Holy Communion, that only Catholics who complied with the requirements for sacramental confession and are in the state of grace, can partake in Holy Communion. Only about 25% of those present took Communion, so I guess we had a lot of visitors. My conclusion is this: we are the salt of the Earth, and we should set an example by the way we dress. Maybe a lot of those visitors really don’t know any better, that’s why they dress immodestly. 😦 But we know better, we MUST dress modestly, and show a positive example to others. Some of these other ladies who came before Mass started, were really so nice-looking in their modest outfits. They looked classy, they totally stood out from the crowd.
I’m surprised at this post. Guests in a church. Curses said under the breath of someone who was just showered undeservedly with the healing forgiving grace of Christ…? Where does this come from?

I remember a few years back I was in Medjugorje,… a town in Europe full of all kinds of pilgrims and many just embarking on a Christian path… and yet the place is not scarce of American conservative Catholics who function as self-proclaimed ‘moral police’, pointing out half centimeters of skin seen at a backside, or a pair of shoulders uncovered etc. All puzzling if you think about how Christ Himself went about things.

I remember being there at that holy place one evening for mass, and there were two women, probably in their forties, who were standing in front of me in very short shorts and black tank tops. But they were there, see… it was clear that they were “new”, and that the Holy Spirit had just recently begun to call them into greater intimacy with Himself.
I was very pleased to see these women present. I thought… these are who we need… I remembered how they were like me a few years before… standing there oblivious to the fact that not everyone’s eyes are as innocent as the eyes of a 20 year old girl.
I remembered also that the men who, back then, tried to point out to me that I was somehow impure, pointing at my attire, I thought of them as impure and hypocrites.
It was the Holy Spirit who was my internal educator…

Only very, very few people have the call to speak to other people about their clothes (and even less have the call to be annoyed about “someone else’s servant”)… those are family members and priests or very good friends. Because these are the one’s that love, and are thus trustworthy in their motive, as was the Lord.
I also presume that the annoyed one is him who didn’t love the young lady with the “vertical smile” nor the “cleavage lady”. but was merely disturbed in his own little spiritual world, and it was an annoyance to him… .?
 
I’m surprised at this post. Guests in a church. Curses said under the breath of someone who was just showered undeservedly with the healing forgiving grace of Christ…? Where does this come from?
Only in very modern times has it become a liability to be shocked at flagrant immodesty in a church. To answer your question, it comes from a place deep in the soul that is outraged over the violation of human dignity, the sacrilege in God’s house, and the stumbling block that is placed before others. It has nothing to do with hostility toward the person, rather, toward the great moral evil that is so much of our culture’s “fashion.” We must separate the two, and we must realize that these people are under a great deception. Let us pray that in the confessional these women received good counsel and the knowledge and grace to amend their pattern of dress, for their own sakes.
I also presume that the annoyed one is him who didn’t love the young lady with the “vertical smile” nor the “cleavage lady”. but was merely disturbed in his own little spiritual world, and it was an annoyance to him… .?
Just as it is unkind to assume that these ladies dressed this way in order to show offense, it is equally unkind to assume that the person who is outraged is being uncharitable. Best not to make either judgment.
 
Earlier there were three young women in front of me during Mass.

One was wearing hotpants which looked like they were two sizes too small.
One was wearing a skirt so short it may aswell not have been there.
The third was pushing out so much cleavage there couldn’t have been anything left in her bra.

The third woman actually went around with the offeratory tray and as she lent over I thought they were going to fall out.

I don’t sit there in super tight cycling shorts, bulging out.

I remember when I was an altar boy we had to wear our school shoes but at Mass last week they were all in (dirty) trainers but one was wearing flip-flops.
 
I’m surprised at this post. Guests in a church. Curses said under the breath of someone who was just showered undeservedly with the healing forgiving grace of Christ…? Where does this come from?

I remember a few years back I was in Medjugorje,… a town in Europe full of all kinds of pilgrims and many just embarking on a Christian path… and yet the place is not scarce of American conservative Catholics who function as self-proclaimed ‘moral police’, pointing out half centimeters of skin seen at a backside, or a pair of shoulders uncovered etc. All puzzling if you think about how Christ Himself went about things.

I remember being there at that holy place one evening for mass, and there were two women, probably in their forties, who were standing in front of me in very short shorts and black tank tops. But they were there, see… it was clear that they were “new”, and that the Holy Spirit had just recently begun to call them into greater intimacy with Himself.
I was very pleased to see these women present. I thought… these are who we need… I remembered how they were like me a few years before… standing there oblivious to the fact that not everyone’s eyes are as innocent as the eyes of a 20 year old girl.
I remembered also that the men who, back then, tried to point out to me that I was somehow impure, pointing at my attire, I thought of them as impure and hypocrites.
It was the Holy Spirit who was my internal educator…

Only very, very few people have the call to speak to other people about their clothes
(bolded emphasis mine) Well, I see this differently. Church attire in certain places has become so scandalous, so lewd, that frankly I think all of us have to speak out against it when possible.
(and even less have the call to be annoyed about “someone else’s servant”)… those are family members and priests or very good friends. Because these are the one’s that love, and are thus trustworthy in their motive, as was the Lord.
I also presume that the annoyed one is him who didn’t love the young lady with the “vertical smile” nor the “cleavage lady”. but was merely disturbed in his own little spiritual world, and it was an annoyance to him… .?
(bolded emphasis mine) Oh c’mon Grace, give me a break! If a natural disaster (earthquake) or fire struck the church, and I got trapped inside the church with them, I would gladly give my life for both the coin slot girl and the cleavage lady, trying to rescue them. But that doesn’t mean that I am somehow obliged not to get outraged at their blatant disrespect for the holy place which is the church, the House of God.

We all need to lay aside this PC cr*p and put on more clothes, and we will be fine - that’s what we need to do.

These people present a public scandal and a danger not only to their own salvation but to the salvation of everyone else around them. Why, do you think there isn’t a correlation with so many of our Catholic priests getting entangled in affairs with women and leaving the priesthood, when we have a whole carnival of boobs and cleavages on display showing up in their church and walking up for Holy Communion at every single Mass? :mad: And you think I shouldn’t be outraged about that? 🤷
 
The third was pushing out so much cleavage there couldn’t have been anything left in her bra.

The third woman actually went around with the offeratory tray and as she lent over I thought they were going to fall out.
Maybe stick a pound or euro bill into her cleavage? 😃

Other than that, I think we should attend church with one of those fish landing nets, to help catching them if they fall out :cool:

http://ep.yimg.com/ca/I/tackle_2154_106319739
 
I don’t know about anybody else, but when I go to Mass, I either have my head down in prayer, or raised toward the altar and the priest; and either way have never been bothered by what anybody was wearing or not wearing.

When I used to go to Mass with family, I would be successively asked “Did you see X, Y, Z at Mass” to which I would say, “I really don’t go to church to look at people.”

While I respect the right of churches to limit what can and can’t be worn, I’d say that average persons might not be so bothered by others’ appearance if they devoted their minds fully to the worship that was going on.

After all, if we do not go to Purgatory for “immodesty”, we will almost certainly go there for something else.

Just MX$2 worth from an average sinner.

GOD bless and ICXC NIKA.
 
I don’t know about anybody else, but when I go to Mass, I either have my head down in prayer, or raised toward the altar and the priest; and either way have never been bothered by what anybody was wearing or not wearing.

When I used to go to Mass with family, I would be successively asked “Did you see X, Y, Z at Mass” to which I would say, “I really don’t go to church to look at people.”

While I respect the right of churches to limit what can and can’t be worn, I’d say that average persons might not be so bothered by others’ appearance if they devoted their minds fully to the worship that was going on.
Those of us with multiple small children in the pew must constantly be looking around to make sure the kids are behaving. Since I, a mother, have my attention frequently grabbed by immodesty in Mass, I feel very sorry for the fathers for whom this is a near occasion of sin. Also, many men are already battling impurity and perhaps have to struggle harder than you do not to look at the mini-skirt standing right in front of them for over an hour. My heart goes out to these good men who are trying their best to remain pure and faithful to God and their wives in their thoughts.
After all, if we do not go to Purgatory for “immodesty”, we will almost certainly go there for something else.
Just MX$2 worth from an average sinner.
GOD bless and ICXC NIKA.
Yet every deliberate venial sin wounds the heart of our Father and separates us from Him. Let’s not shoot for Purgatory, lest we fail to make it there!
 
While I respect the right of churches to limit what can and can’t be worn, I’d say that average persons might not be so bothered by others’ appearance if they devoted their minds fully to the worship that was going on.
True, and this certainly bears consideration, but perhaps they aren’t devoting their minds because they are so distracted. For example, how often do you hear of people being distracted by well-behaved kids or the modest clothing nuns and sisters wear? Pretty seldom I bet
 
Also, many men are already battling impurity and perhaps have to struggle harder than you do not to look at the mini-skirt standing right in front of them for over an hour. My heart goes out to these good men who are trying their best to remain pure and faithful to God and their wives in their thoughts.
That’s not an excuse to tell people what to wear. I was bullied for many years because I looked like a nerd. Who is to blame? The bullies who have a chronic, brainless disorder that causes them to attack anybody carrying big books and wearing glasses, or me? Tragically, everyone in my life chose the latter (parents, siblings, relatives, even teachers).

A person’s appearances are always superficial compared to what’s inside. Proven fact. A book with a fancy cover yet with poor content will lose a reader’s interest whereas a good story will always keep him/her going, regardless of whether that cover is hardbound, paper back, or no cover at all.

Why do you people emphasize so much on physical appearances? Do you have any idea how many suffered (and continue to suffer) because of such excess emphasis?
True, and this certainly bears consideration, but perhaps they aren’t devoting their minds because they are so distracted. For example, how often do you hear of people being distracted by well-behaved kids or the modest clothing nuns and sisters wear? Pretty seldom I bet
As a child, I’ve been to Masses with nuns and sisters more than once.
Yes they are very distracting. The big railing that separated them from the rest of the crowd didn’t help either.
 
Why do you people emphasize so much on physical appearances? Do you have any idea how many suffered (and continue to suffer) because of such excess emphasis?
people consciously choose to wear these clothes that are immodest. They may not consciously choose them because they are immodest, though some might, but there is a difference between a physical appearance that someone can affect and one that they can’t.

Physical appearance at mass is out of respect for God and the surrounding community.
As a child, I’ve been to Masses with nuns and sisters more than once.
Yes they are very distracting. The big railing that separated them from the rest of the crowd didn’t help either.
I would be surprised if this were the experience of most, but I could be wrong
 
people consciously choose to wear these clothes that are immodest. They may not consciously choose them because they are immodest, though some might, but there is a difference between a physical appearance that someone can affect and one that they can’t.
This does not even address the superficiality of it all. It doesn’t matter if it’s skin color or clothes or what you perceive as modest or immodest. They all still base on the same shallow principle that aesthetic appearances carry some oh-so-holy moral value.

They do not. Putting on your clothes is no more a moral action than drinking a glass of water. It’s people, with their shallow tendencies to overvalue appearances, that are the problem, not clothing.
I would be surprised if this were the experience of most, but I could be wrong
A nun’s outfit stands out in the same manner a soldier’s uniform does. Such clothes are an official indicator of one’s vocation/profession/culture that identifies itself differently from the common, urban citizen.

The virtue of modesty is in complete opposition to the idea of standing out (look the word up on the dictionary).

I’m not saying that it’s bad for a nun to stand out but to say they cannot be distracting for people is a bit of a stretch.

They’re probably even more distracting in places outside the church. Take some of the arcades here for instance. I wouldn’t look twice at a girl in a mini-skirt or sleeveless, in the same manner that I wouldn’t stop and stare at the guy with pierced ears and the weird, spiky hairdo. If I saw nun walking through such a place however, I might just run the risk of botching up my game.
 
They’re probably even more distracting in places outside the church. Take some of the arcades here for instance. I wouldn’t look twice at a girl in a mini-skirt or sleeveless, in the same manner that I wouldn’t stop and stare at the guy with pierced ears and the weird, spiky hairdo. If I saw nun walking through such a place however, I might just run the risk of botching up my game.
A nun might ruin your game, but is a nun’s modest dress really going to distract you as frequently as immodest dress in church?

and if you deny that the way you present yourself in thought and action (appearance) before God matters, do you also deny that the way you dress (if immodest) can cause others to sin?
 
A nun might ruin your game, but is a nun’s modest dress really going to distract you as frequently as immodest dress in church?
Forms of modesty are relevant to culture. The CCC itself concedes to this. When you live in a place where everybody dresses in a certain manner, then it’s your responsibility to adapt to their culture. You do not make everyone adapt to you (like how the imperialistic colonists did when they destroyed my country’s pre-colonial heritage).

If people in Church started dressing in a manner that significantly makes them different from nuns, you have to face the inevitable: Nuns will stand out.
and if you deny that the way you present yourself in thought and action (appearance) before God matters, do you also deny that the way you dress (if immodest) can cause others to sin?
You are sorely mistaken to think thought and action are in the same boat as appearance. People sin because they can’t control their shallow tendencies. Judging a person as a sex object because of their looks is no different than judging them as an occasion of sin for that very same, confounded reason.

By your logic, do you actually agree that it was my fault for getting beat up because I dressed liked a nerd? Are you saying the bullies were right to blame me for their misconduct because I chose to wear glasses instead of contact lenses?
 
Forms of modesty are relevant to culture. The CCC itself concedes to this. When you live in a place where everybody dresses in a certain manner, then it’s your responsibility to adapt to their culture. You do not make everyone adapt to you (like how the imperialistic colonists did when they destroyed my country’s pre-colonial heritage).
I don’t see how this response addresses what you quoted, unfortunately. Could you restate this?
You are sorely mistaken to think thought and action are in the same boat as appearance. People sin because they can’t control their shallow tendencies. Judging a person as a sex object because of their looks is no different than judging them as an occasion of sin for that very same, confounded reason.
Do you think that certain modes of dress can lead others to sin?
By your logic, do you actually agree that it was my fault for getting beat up because I dressed liked a nerd? Are you saying the bullies were right to blame me for their misconduct because I chose to wear glasses instead of contact lenses?
I never said or analogized that the bullies who beat you up were right or justified. What I’m saying is that if sinful situations can be avoided, they should be. St. Paul mentions this several times in Corinthians, regarding not tempting those who are of weaker self-control
 
I don’t see how this response addresses what you quoted, unfortunately. Could you restate this?
I added a last-minute line about nuns standing out.
Do you think that certain modes of dress can lead others to sin?
Nope. That’s in fact justifying people’s pushy demands to change my “weird” sense of fashion.

If anything should change, it’s how people put excessive focus on physical appearances.
I never said or analogized that the bullies who beat you up were right or justified. What I’m saying is that if sinful situations can be avoided, they should be. St. Paul mentions this several times in Corinthians, regarding not tempting those who are of weaker self-control
In other words, if I dressed like a member of the A-crowd and pretended to someone I’m not, just to avoid a “sinful situation” (e.g. getting beat up) then I should.

Just because we shouldn’t tempt others does not mean we justify being labeled as occasions of sin. No good Christian would want to tempt those of weaker self-control. That’s still not an excuse to address the real problem: the weaker self-control.

Instead of focusing on people’s clothes like they somehow matter on the same level as their internal character, why can’t we simply man up and say, “Hey Shallow Hal! Get real!”
 
Think I’m going to disengage now, as we’ve strayed from the original post and I don’t particularly feel like getting into an exhausting argument against relativism today. Suffice it to say, I agree with all the Catechism says about the importance of modesty in dress and particularly with regards to how we ought to dress and conduct ourselves at Mass. The Church has it right. There is a standard, and it’s there for a very good reason.

Peace of Christ,

Mary
 
Think I’m going to disengage now, as we’ve strayed from the original post and I don’t particularly feel like getting into an exhausting argument against relativism today. Suffice it to say, I agree with all the Catechism says about the importance of modesty in dress and particularly with regards to how we ought to dress and conduct ourselves at Mass. The Church has it right. There is a standard, and it’s there for a very good reason.

Peace of Christ,

Mary
From the CCC
2524 The forms taken by modesty vary from one culture to another. Everywhere, however, modesty exists as an intuition of the spiritual dignity proper to man. It is born with the awakening consciousness of being a subject. Teaching modesty to children and adolescents means awakening in them respect for the human person.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top