Modesty Question

  • Thread starter Thread starter jeanne71350
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
With the traditionalist circles within the Roman Catholic Church, I would try to concentrate on what those Bishops and Priests tell us who are in full communion and good standing with Rome. But I just don’t know enough about who prescribes what, who is in a good standing with Rome and who’s not.
It was just a simple FYI. Women in pants are fairly a modern novelty and I highly doubt it would have been acceptable in ages past. I once even saw a notice board saying that women in long skirts were more pleasing to the Virgin Mary whilst it was the opposite for pants.

That tells me a lot about how change in the forms of modesty is inevitable.

I must also note that the dress code you are prescribing on the basis of sacred places seem more to do with formality than modesty.
 
It was just a simple FYI. Women in pants are fairly a modern novelty and I highly doubt it would have been acceptable in ages past. I once even saw a notice board saying that women in long skirts were more pleasing to the Virgin Mary whilst it was the opposite for pants.

That tells me a lot about how change in the forms of modesty is inevitable.

I must also note that the dress code you are prescribing on the basis of sacred places seem more to do with formality than modesty.
Well, when the Pope and the Cardinals and Bishops of the Vatican Curia will decide that it’s OK to visit the Vatican, and the churches of Rome, in miniskirts, shorts, and with exposed shoulders, then maybe we should all adapt to “change”. 😃 But thankfully this is not the case and I sincerely hope it will never be. In my interpretation, the dress code is still about what to cover - a modesty issue. It’s not about wearing business suits and formal wear, but rather about what to cover: Cover the shoulders, cover the back, don’t expose cleavage, don’t expose midriffs, don’t expose the knees and the thighs.
 
A CAF member just posted a great video, a sermon entitled Purity, Modesty, and How We Dress (especially at Mass), by a Catholic priest named Fr. Dominic Mary at a Mass broadcast by EWTN. See video:

youtube.com/watch?v=PZHECJJbzPM

It is well worth watching. Partly, he explains what do we mean by the virtues of purity and modesty, and partly, he gives specific instructions about how to dress when visiting a Catholic church.

Also, here’s a thread this CAF member started at another subforum:

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=563667
 
Hm… I am thinking this way, but it is only my opinion…

When not thin, young, great looking for woman is best not to reveal not-so-flattering parts of her body, it is just not nice.

But, if young, good looking woman is showing her parts, she is like stepping out - look, this on me is great, this is nice, this is beautiful. Not like those, covered ones.

Once, she will also be older, pregnant, nursing, have maybe few kilos more or less and in terms of femininity and beauty she will be “second league”.

So, I think that modesty has to do with respecting woman’s dignity. That no matter how thin or fat, no matter are we cellulite free or not, young or old, we should not expose each other to eye of critics for our bodies.

I am sad because so many of us today suffers from feeling of not being thin, beautiful, young… whatever .- because all we have is revealed and showed and on display.
Like something is wrong if we don’t wear revealing clothes.

So, if what I wear is not something appropriate for any woman, I will not wear.
 
Hm… I am thinking this way, but it is only my opinion…

When not thin, young, great looking for woman is best not to reveal not-so-flattering parts of her body, it is just not nice.

But, if young, good looking woman is showing her parts, she is like stepping out - look, this on me is great, this is nice, this is beautiful. Not like those, covered ones.

Once, she will also be older, pregnant, nursing, have maybe few kilos more or less and in terms of femininity and beauty she will be “second league”.

So, I think that modesty has to do with respecting woman’s dignity. That no matter how thin or fat, no matter are we cellulite free or not, young or old, we should not expose each other to eye of critics for our bodies.

I am sad because so many of us today suffers from feeling of not being thin, beautiful, young… whatever .- because all we have is revealed and showed and on display.
Like something is wrong if we don’t wear revealing clothes.

So, if what I wear is not something appropriate for any woman, I will not wear.
Zenzena, I see those women showing as much of their breasts as they can, in church, and I think, this has nothing to do with the weather anymore. Yes, they want to show it, it’s as plain and simple as that. In the youtube video above, the priest Fr. Dominic Mary suggests that fashion has come to be about “how much more can I show”?

This year, the overwhelming trend I see is tops that try to have the deepest possible V-cut exposing as much as possible of the inner portion of breasts, between the nipples. Of course, we are way past of the horizontal necklines plunging to a point that’s just above the nipples. That’s so yesteryear. Now, it’s not enough to have tops with a horizontal cut that shows everything above the nipples, women in my area have moved to tops that show everything above the nipples, plus this deep V-cut that shows as much as possible of the breasts between the nipples. It’s really exactly as Fr. Dominic Mary says in his EWTN Mass sermon available on youtube - How much more can I show?

Showing the nipples is still a social taboo - thus they will show as much as possible above the nipples, and between the nipples. This is 2011’s fashion in Miami, and this is what I see day in and day out inside the Catholic church buildings.

2010’s fashion was this: let me show not just my shoulders, but also my whole upper back. Lots of women were wearing these tops to Holy Mass that looked like the typical sports bras in the back. They didn’t simply show the shoulders, they rather had that sportsbra-cut with only a narrow vertical strap covering the middle of the back (covering the backbone area), and exposing everything else in the back. And that’s how lots of women attended Holy Mass last year, and they still do this year.

I really think Fr. Dominick Mary got it exactly right in his sermon. This has nothing to do with dressing for the weather, and everything to do with “How much more can I show”, “How else can I tempt you and awaken unhealthy curiosity towards my hot body”, and “How can I wield power on you, and enjoy seeing that I awakened your curiosity towards my body”?

As Fr. Dominick Mary says in his sermon, this has nothing to do with LOVE towards my brother/sister, and everything to do with wielding POWER over him or her.
 
Zenzena, I see those women showing as much of their breasts as they can, in church, and I think, this has nothing to do with the weather anymore. Yes, they want to show it, it’s as plain and simple as that. In the youtube video above, the priest Fr. Dominic Mary suggests that fashion has come to be about “how much more can I show”?

This year, the overwhelming trend I see is tops that try to have the deepest possible V-cut exposing as much as possible of the inner portion of breasts, between the nipples. Of course, we are way past of the horizontal necklines plunging to a point that’s just above the nipples. That’s so yesteryear. Now, it’s not enough to have tops with a horizontal cut that shows everything above the nipples, women in my area have moved to tops that show everything above the nipples, plus this deep V-cut that shows as much as possible of the breasts between the nipples. It’s really exactly as Fr. Dominic Mary says in his EWTN Mass sermon available on youtube - How much more can I show?

Showing the nipples is still a social taboo - thus they will show as much as possible above the nipples, and between the nipples. This is 2011’s fashion in Miami, and this is what I see day in and day out inside the Catholic church buildings.

2010’s fashion was this: let me show not just my shoulders, but also my whole upper back. Lots of women were wearing these tops to Holy Mass that looked like the typical sports bras in the back. They didn’t simply show the shoulders, they rather had that sportsbra-cut with only a narrow vertical strap covering the middle of the back (covering the backbone area), and exposing everything else in the back. And that’s how lots of women attended Holy Mass last year, and they still do this year.
I find the styles way too low cut on most tops. I just learned to layer. I have all kinds of color tops that I can wear underneath the low cut tops. I am lucky that my daughter will wear boy shorts before she would even consider wearing short shorts. And she hates anything see through or low cut.

Our church bulletin had a small sections on how to dress appropriately now that warm weather has arrived. No short shorts, low cut tops and cover shoulders (no tank tops or spaghetti straps). No underwear, like boxers showing.
 
Hi everyone,

First of, I’m not trying to start an argument about what’s appropriate and what’s not. I listen to what the Church says, but I’m asking this question mainly for my own knowledge. Now, I understand why women must cover the chest area, lower back area, and keep skirts and dresses around knee-length, but why is it considered immodest for a women to have bare shoulders?

Any answer is appreciated!

Thanks, God bless, and Happy Easter!

-Jeanne
I have never heard that bare shoulders were immodest (but just because I have not heard it really doesn’t mean much). It may be personal opinion. And of course parish priests will have differing opinions. My opinion is if everything else that needs to be covered are properly covered, shoulders should not matter. Again, that is my opinion.
 
It was just a simple FYI. Women in pants are fairly a modern novelty and I highly doubt it would have been acceptable in ages past. I once even saw a notice board saying that women in long skirts were more pleasing to the Virgin Mary whilst it was the opposite for pants.

That tells me a lot about how change in the forms of modesty is inevitable.

I must also note that the dress code you are prescribing on the basis of sacred places seem more to do with formality than modesty.
Actually, it’s the “concern” over women in pants that is a fairly modern novelty** 😉 In Eastern lands and cultures (or Native American, for that matter), both women and men have been wearing trousers since the time of the OT folks wearing robes and tunics. A Franciscan Friar here on CAF had this to say about the Blessed Mother and apparel: (#2 of his post…but the rest is good reading, too)

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?p=7861846&highlight=miriam+of+nazareth#post7861846
 
I have never heard that bare shoulders were immodest (but just because I have not heard it really doesn’t mean much). It may be personal opinion. And of course parish priests will have differing opinions. My opinion is if everything else that needs to be covered are properly covered, shoulders should not matter. Again, that is my opinion.
Bare shoulders are clearly forbidden throughout the Vatican, when visiting Catholic churches in Rome, in Italy, Catholic pilgrimage sites such as the sites of Marian apparitions in Europe, and so on. American priests may not always speak out, but for example Father Dominick Mary goes into great detail in the video below, a video recorded during a televised Mass on EWTN, and he clearly says that bare shoulders are forbidden, see between 4:20-5:45 in the video below, especially at 5 min 28 sec:

youtube.com/watch?v=PZHECJJbzPM

People are quite simply not allowed to enter Catholic churches in Italy, with bare shoulders. They will be asked to leave and cover up. Many churches have sweaters, scarves, or similar things that tourists can borrow and cover their shoulders while visiting the churches.

I have seen this also in the USA, for example at the Shrine of the Blessed Sacrament in Hanceville, Alabama - this is a beautiful Catholic church associated to the Poor Clares convent of Mother Angelica’s nuns. The Shrine has sweaters, and the Receptionist lady will provide those sweaters to any tourists who arrive with their shoulders uncovered. People are NOT allowed inside the Shrine of the Blessed Sacrament in Hanceville, Ala, with bare shoulders. This rule is nothing extraordinary, nothing special, it’s simply a rule that mimics the same rules that the Holy Father and the Vatican enforce throughout the Vatican City, and throughout the churches of Rome and the whole Italy.

In my opinion, enforcing the rule for covering one’s shoulders makes a lot of sense. People do not stop at exposing their shoulders, they now go to church wearing stuff that exposes their shoulders and a lot more, as in the two pictures below. It’s similar to the case with skirts and shorts above the knees. Once people start wearing that stuff, they soon show up in mini skirts and daisy dukes. Also, with exposed shoulders, they expose not only their shoulders, but their backs as well. That’s why knees and shoulders are a cutoff point. Btw, yesterday I had one more of those hellish experiences at church. A lady came wearing something like attachment 1 I posted below, and sat in front of me. I don’t feel comfortable, having to sit behind someone with half of her back exposed. And as the priest walked in, I really felt sorry for poor Father, as he passed by this woman with half of her back naked. And there were all sorts of visitors with tank tops and miniskirts around, at least half of all women below the age of 60 were dressed in a way that they would surely not be allowed into the Vatican, or into any of the churches in Rome. I tried to tune out, I was watching the ceiling or stayed with my eyes closed most of the whole Mass. Then, after Holy Communion, I opened my eyes for a second, and there was a little girl, 7 or 8 years old, filing through the Communion line, and she wore some top that had a strap tied behind her neck, and the top actually had no coverage at all in the back. That little girl had her whole back exposed, down to her waist. She looked like some sort of an X-rated actress, in a steamy movie or at a Hollywood reception. It’s really depressing. Especially when I see little girls dressed like this.
 
Bare shoulders are clearly forbidden throughout the Vatican, when visiting Catholic churches in Rome, in Italy, Catholic pilgrimage sites such as the sites of Marian apparitions in Europe, and so on. American priests may not always speak out, but for example Father Dominick Mary goes into great detail in the video below, a video recorded during a televised Mass on EWTN, and he clearly says that bare shoulders are forbidden, see between 4:20-5:45 in the video below, especially at 5 min 28 sec:

youtube.com/watch?v=PZHECJJbzPM

People are quite simply not allowed to enter Catholic churches in Italy, with bare shoulders. They will be asked to leave and cover up. Many churches have sweaters, scarves, or similar things that tourists can borrow and cover their shoulders while visiting the churches.
I knew that about the Vatican and pilgrimage sites, but have never heard it addressed in the USA. That is why in my post I qualified my statement with “just because I have not heard it really doesn’t mean much”. Because I can only speak for what I have personally seen and heard.

Thank you for the link to the video I will be sure and watch it.

When I spoke of bare shoulders I was not meaning spaghetti straps or open back, I was thinking more of something more like this:

http://www.styleceo.com/images/stores/44/j/jessica-howard-sleeveless-dress-11413067
 
I knew that about the Vatican and pilgrimage sites, but have never heard it addressed in the USA. That is why in my post I qualified my statement with “just because I have not heard it really doesn’t mean much”. Because I can only speak for what I have personally seen and heard.

Thank you for the link to the video I will be sure and watch it.

When I spoke of bare shoulders I was not meaning spaghetti straps or open back, I was thinking more of something more like this:

http://www.styleceo.com/images/stores/44/j/jessica-howard-sleeveless-dress-11413067
Yes, it’s true that many churches in the USA fail to enforce the rules for modest dressing including the requirement that one’s shoulders and knees must be covered, and we don’t hear these things often from the pulpit. I guess it’s similar to many other things that we seldom hear addressed by our clergy, such as the Catholic teachings that masturbation, watching pornography, or the use of artificial contraception (birth control pill, condoms, surgical sterilization) are sinful. Many Catholics grow up not having a clue that we are not supposed to wear to church shorts and other clothing that expose our knees and shoulders (as well as backs, midriffs, bellies), thinking that masturbation is not a sin at all, and believing that birth control pills are no big deal and not a serious offense against God’s moral law, not because they don’t care about the teachings of our Church, but rather because they never had the occasion to hear those teachings.
 
Yes, it’s true that many churches in the USA fail to enforce the rules for modest dressing including the requirement that one’s shoulders and knees must be covered, and we don’t hear these things often from the pulpit. I guess it’s similar to many other things that we seldom hear addressed by our clergy, such as the Catholic teachings that masturbation, watching pornography, or the use of artificial contraception (birth control pill, condoms, surgical sterilization) are sinful. Many Catholics grow up not having a clue that we are not supposed to wear to church shorts and other clothing that expose our knees and shoulders (as well as backs, midriffs, bellies), thinking that masturbation is not a sin at all, and believing that birth control pills are no big deal and not a serious offense against God’s moral law, not because they don’t care about the teachings of our Church, but rather because they never had the occasion to hear those teachings.
Very true. Faith formation was really in a sad state in the 70’s in a lot of places. And a lot of parents did not want to impose their beliefs and wanted their children to “make their own choices”. And it causes a chain reaction of you can not teach what you did not learn. Even some of the seminaries had some liberal teachers so some priests did not learn everything they should have. That has thankfully been changing over the last few years.
 
Considering we are all born with bare shoulders:🙂 I can’t imagine such fashions being so hideously sinful.

ICXC NIKA
Considering we are all born nude, so nudism is also not sin right? Well I also do not thing that it( even nudism) is sinful,because of the point of view of an atheist. But personally I believe that nudity or revealing culture is not right idea and modesty is the best way.because immodesty only brings attention, but modesty brings respect always and win our heart.

PS.Do not get me wrong because I am not talking about Islamic covering system, because this is not modesty but this is oppression.
 
I read a story about a woman who spent many years in purgatory for having bare shoulders. In the story the woman was seen (by a Saint…I forget which one), in purgatory, with snakes crawling all over her. Its immodest. Just thought I’d share.
o.0 Well that’s morbid…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top