I have never heard that bare shoulders were immodest (but just because I have not heard it really doesn’t mean much). It may be personal opinion. And of course parish priests will have differing opinions. My opinion is if everything else that needs to be covered are properly covered, shoulders should not matter. Again, that is my opinion.
Bare shoulders are clearly forbidden throughout the Vatican, when visiting Catholic churches in Rome, in Italy, Catholic pilgrimage sites such as the sites of Marian apparitions in Europe, and so on. American priests may not always speak out, but for example Father Dominick Mary goes into great detail in the video below, a video recorded during a televised Mass on EWTN, and he clearly says that bare shoulders are forbidden, see between 4:20-5:45 in the video below, especially at 5 min 28 sec:
youtube.com/watch?v=PZHECJJbzPM
People are quite simply not allowed to enter Catholic churches in Italy, with bare shoulders. They will be asked to leave and cover up. Many churches have sweaters, scarves, or similar things that tourists can borrow and cover their shoulders while visiting the churches.
I have seen this also in the USA, for example at the Shrine of the Blessed Sacrament in Hanceville, Alabama - this is a beautiful Catholic church associated to the Poor Clares convent of Mother Angelica’s nuns. The Shrine has sweaters, and the Receptionist lady will provide those sweaters to any tourists who arrive with their shoulders uncovered. People are NOT allowed inside the Shrine of the Blessed Sacrament in Hanceville, Ala, with bare shoulders. This rule is nothing extraordinary, nothing special, it’s simply a rule that mimics the same rules that the Holy Father and the Vatican enforce throughout the Vatican City, and throughout the churches of Rome and the whole Italy.
In my opinion, enforcing the rule for covering one’s shoulders makes a lot of sense. People do not stop at exposing their shoulders, they now go to church wearing stuff that exposes their shoulders and a lot more, as in the two pictures below. It’s similar to the case with skirts and shorts above the knees. Once people start wearing that stuff, they soon show up in mini skirts and daisy dukes. Also, with exposed shoulders, they expose not only their shoulders, but their backs as well. That’s why knees and shoulders are a cutoff point. Btw, yesterday I had one more of those hellish experiences at church. A lady came wearing something like attachment 1 I posted below, and sat in front of me. I don’t feel comfortable, having to sit behind someone with half of her back exposed. And as the priest walked in, I really felt sorry for poor Father, as he passed by this woman with half of her back naked. And there were all sorts of visitors with tank tops and miniskirts around, at least half of all women below the age of 60 were dressed in a way that they would surely not be allowed into the Vatican, or into any of the churches in Rome. I tried to tune out, I was watching the ceiling or stayed with my eyes closed most of the whole Mass. Then, after Holy Communion, I opened my eyes for a second, and there was a little girl, 7 or 8 years old, filing through the Communion line, and she wore some top that had a strap tied behind her neck, and the top actually had no coverage at all in the back. That little girl had her whole back exposed, down to her waist. She looked like some sort of an X-rated actress, in a steamy movie or at a Hollywood reception. It’s really depressing. Especially when I see little girls dressed like this.