T
TheMc
Guest
I wish we could trust the publishing houses, and actually follow their guides without distorting the liturgy.Also, if OCP says it’s okay, it must be okay, right?![]()
I wish we could trust the publishing houses, and actually follow their guides without distorting the liturgy.Also, if OCP says it’s okay, it must be okay, right?![]()
Cool!The Psalm will come from the Grail Psalter.
I’m wondering if we ever will be. When you have their liturgical planning magazine suggesting “Christ, Be Our Light” as the Easter Proclamation, (Exsultet), you know something’s up.I wish we could trust the publishing houses, and actually follow their guides without distorting the liturgy.
I actually would rather hear Alstott’s Psalm 23 from his book Respond and Acclaim than “On Eagle’s Wings.” I might have to make a point to have it sung on my funeral.Interesting…I’ve never heard of On Eagle’s Wings used as a psalm. Who in the world would use that?? I typically “Shepherd Me, O God” (Haugen), “Psalm of the Good Shepherd” (Landry), or “Shelter Me O God” (Hurd) at funerals.
On Eagle’s Wings is usually a communion hymn…
They have to push the music that their composers composed. Once they do that, what do they get? $$$$!OCP is…well…OCP. We will never understand why they make the suggestions that they do. I use NPM as a guide.
I’m aware of that, I’m talking mainly where they suggest the song to be used. Who in the world would use (for example) “Sing of the Lord’s Goodness” for the Preparation?They have to push the music that their composers composed. Once they do that, what do they get? $$$$!
Some of their suggestions (like you have stated above) are totally inappropriate for what is happening at that time during Mass. “Sing of the Lord’s Goodness” is more appropriate for the processional or recessional, NOT the preparation of the gifts!I’m aware of that, I’m talking mainly where they suggest the song to be used. Who in the world would use (for example) “Sing of the Lord’s Goodness” for the Preparation?
On another note, trying to decide what Mass Settings I want my congregation to use…so many choices!! Anyone decided what settings they will use?
I would actually learn the default ICEL settings that are imbedded within the Roman Missal. These are easy. The composers’ revised settings do sound different, even musically, because the music had to be adapted to fit the text.Some of their suggestions (like you have stated above) are totally inappropriate for what is happening at that time during Mass. “Sing of the Lord’s Goodness” is more appropriate for the processional or recessional, NOT the preparation of the gifts!
In regards to Mass settings, I think that it would be easier to start off with a revised Mass setting. Maybe use a revised setting from the First Sunday of Advent through the Baptism of Our Lord, and then teach a new setting when we go back into Ordinary Time?
This is a new one that I think is beautiful:
stmichaelhymnal.com/buythehymnal/NewEdition/MassofthePatriarchsRecordings.aspx
Beautiful! I love “Praise to the Lord.”Here’s what my choir did tonight:
Optional Memorial of St. Henry — Wednesday, July 13, 2011
Processional: Praise to the Lord LOBE DEN HERREN
Responsorial Psalm: The Lord is kind and merciful (improvised chant)
Gospel Acclamation: Solemn Alleluia (verse, improvised chant)
Offertory: On a Hill Far Away OLD RUGGED CROSS
Great Amen: simple chant
Agnus Dei: ICEL Latin chant