My husband won’t go to our sons wedding. I think this is the last straw for me

  • Thread starter Thread starter eliana
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
And what i hear in this post is, you’re ok with sacrificing that marriage to support your son’s disordered lifestyle.
This is a point which needs to be considered seriously. If there is a choice which has to be made, which is more important:
Your love and relationship with your adult child or
your love and your relationship with your spouse.
Wouldn’t it be preferred to support the husband - wife relationship? After all, you have taken solemn marital vows and the adult child is an adult going off on his own?
 
On your wedding day, did you promise to God that you would be faithful to your husband in good times and bad, and to love him all the days of your life?
If so, then recognize this is a bad time that you should resolve to figure out how to love him through. Please do not allow divorce or giving up on your husband to be an option for you. Also keep in mind that, as hard as it is, it is good to let go of our children. To let them take their inheritance, do with it as they will, hopefully good, but even if it is bad, our loving homes always have arms wide open for our prodigal children.
 
In the case of my son, had he ever uttered the words, “Dad I think, or I am, gay,” he’d have went to the hospital and I to jail for breaking his jaw. Me and my side of the family don’t put up with such. Wife can be as nice and polite as she wants, that’s her call. I state facts to my kids, not avoid issues.
Other posters have addressed this already, but I strongly suggest you rethink some things. This type of violence is not helpful. And may be sinful.
 
Last edited:
Some famous scientists, e.g. Isaac Newton, Henry Cavendish and Albert Einstein, have been said to have had aspergers, but in the end they did just fine.
 
It’s a sad world we live in where I’m pretty sure this is a troll post but could very easily not be.

What does that say about the state of the Church?
 
I don’t think that’s a charitable thing to say.
How, I didn’t attack anyone? I’m just talking about compatibility, so I would expect a fellow Catholic to understand.
 
Last edited:
You said her “temperament wouldn’t respond well”. You don’t know how someone could respond. She might be open to truth.
Edit: Her temperament isn’t her. We have predispositions but temperament isn’t character
 
Last edited:
You said her “temperament wouldn’t respond well”. You don’t know how someone could respond. She might be open to truth. Her temperament isn’t her.
But I saw her react negatively to a similar line of thought. By temperament I meant the views and personality she expresses, it was a mistake on my part, but I’m not sure what word would work better.
 
Last edited:
Yeah but talking about someone in the third person when they are present is a bit rude. Is dismissive. Just how I read it anyway, could have read it wrong.
 
Last edited:
This is a tough situation, but there are many Catholic priests, including the former chaplain of Catholic Answers who will say that Catholics (even parents) should not attend the wedding of any Baptized Catholic who is getting “married” without Church recognition.

Whether it’s
  • a same sex marriage
  • a divorce and remarriage without annulment
  • a Catholic getting “married” by a justice of the peace
  • or a baptized or Confirmed Catholic getting married outside the Catholic Church without dispensation from the Bishop.
… these priest say we Catholics should avoid attending any of those “weddings.” Even the parents of the bride or groom, these priest say don’t go because it is celebrating sexual sin.

You know your husband better than I, but don’t assume it’s simply homophobia.

If your husband is devout, he is surely concerned about your son’s soul. The Church teaches that homosexual acts are grave sins. After all, what good is it to be happy if that happiness potentially leads to Hell.

I know it’s hard to accept, but for some people, celebrating a same sex “marriage” is like celebrating a divorce or celebrating adultery.

I will pray for you and I suggest that you two see a priest and a good Catholic marriage counselor. Check out Catholictherapists.com

BTW - regardless of what is happening between you and your husband, your mother-in-law is way over the line. Her meddling is sinful on her part.

God Bless
 
Last edited:
Some things seem too good to be true.

This litany of problems seems almost the reverse.

Have to think on this a while. Meantime though, the issue by issue list of things the reluctant husband and father here may be dealing with per his decision – did remind me of this old story.
Mr. H and the Steward.

Mr. H.
Ha! Steward, how are you, my old boy? How do things go on at home?
Steward. Bad enough, your honor; the magpie’s dead.
H. Poor Mag! So he’s gone. How came he to die?
S. Overeat himself, sir.
H. Did he? A greedy dog; why, what did he get he liked so well?
S. Horseflesh, sir; he died of eating horseflesh.
H. How came he to get so much horseflesh?
S. All your father’s horses, sir.
H. What! Are they dead, too?
S. Ay, sir; they died of overwork.
H. And why were they overworked, pray?
S. To carry water, sir.
H. To carry water! And what were they carrying water for?
S. Sure, sir, to put out the fire.
H. Fire! What fire?
S. O, sir, your father’s house is burned to the ground.
H. My father’s house burned down! And how came it set on fire?
S. I think, sir, it must have been the torches.
H. Torches! What torches?
S. At your mother’s funeral.
H. My mother dead!
S. Ah, poor lady! She never looked up, after it.
H. After what?
S. The loss of your father.
H. My father gone, too?
S. Yes, poor gentleman! He took to his bed as soon as he heard of it.
H. Heard of what?
S. The bad news, sir, and please your honor.
H. What! More miseries! More bad news!
S. Yes, sir; your bank has failed, and your credit is lost, and you are not worth a shilling in the world. I made bold, sir, to wait on you about it, for I thought you would like to hear the news.

-McGuffey’s Fifth Eclectic Reader
 
The priest who said there was no problem . . . was wrong.

You’ve gotten a lot of good advice. I hope you take it; I.e;

-Don’t try to pressure your husband or indeed anyone into violating their conscience. At that point you’re asking them to love you more than they love God. No one has a right to make such demands. Not even a spouse or a parent or a child.

-Don’t ruin your marriage because your husband is firmer on this than you. I have attended house parties hosted by gay friends and been introduced to their partners but I would also not attend an explicit celebration/affirmation of such a union. And I’m sort of a lapsed/struggling Catholic in the current pontificate but I still retain the basic morality of the church. You sound like you’re distanced from the church, too, since you’re willing to put the morality aside. I’ll pray for you as I pray for myself.

-Love your son the way St. Monica loved St. Augustine. A mother’s prayer availeth much. You don’t even have to get preachy with him. But every night before you sleep and every morning when you wake up, pray to God for your son’s (and his partner’s) and their adopted children’s (if they get them) salvation.

All the best.
 
But is it Church teaching that a same-sex couple may not adopt children? Ever?
The Church preference is that a married couple (husband and wife) adopts a child. Single parents adopting isn’t ideal unless the adopting person is a relative or close family friend (like a single aunt, uncle, or Godparent).

The issue with same sex couples adopting is two part:
  1. the Church believes that children should be given the CHANCE of having a mother & father (role models from both sexes). This is why single people (even straight ones) are discouraged.
  2. most (not all) same sex couples disagree with a lot of Church teaching. Catholic orphanages like to grant children to couples who are going to raise kids to be 100% Catholic and agree with all Church teaching. The same sex couple (like the co-habiting couple or divorced & remarried without annulment couple) already publicly disagree with Church dogma regarding the one of the Seven Sacarments and the Church’s dogmatic teachings regarding sexuality.
 
Last edited:
This is where the problem lies: we got a wedding invitation in the mail last week. It was perfect because I’ve always wanted grandkids and to have my son be happy even if that means he follows a homosexual lifestyle.
So you’d rather your son was “happy in this life” than to actually go to heaven? Seems a bit odd for a Catholic.
My husband refuses to go.
He is correct. You cannot celebrate a gay “marriage” or relationship as a catholic. You are essentially saying that you approve of their sin and wish them to continue sinning.
My mother-in-law messaged me on Facebook to tell me I should only support my son from afar and not attend his wedding, and if I do then I’m not the woman my husband deserves. We never had a good relationship but I thought that‘s normal for mother-in-laws.
Not exactly her place but she is also right. I wouldn’t cut off contact from your son altogether but I would make it clear that you cannot attend their celebration and explain why. Maybe in a few months you could start inviting them around again but you shouldn’t do anything to approve of their relationship.
My husband has begun sleeping on the couch. I miss him, but he’s not the man I knew.
He probably thinks the same thing about you. You have to understand that he has obviously formed his conscience in the faith and is following that.
I’m coming here because I need advice from like-minded people.
Why do you think you’ll find approval for gay marriage on a catholic website?
 
The priest told us there is nothing wrong with my son
It’s priests who affirm sin that are destroying people’s lives. Homosexual tendencies are a disorder. I know that’s not a popular thing to say but for years this was recognised to be the case. That doesn’t mean that gay people should be abused or mistreated, but recognising that it is not a good thing is important. Just like straight men in their 40’s who exclusively/obsessively try to get with very young women (17+) could be said to be suffering from a disordered mentality.

Recognising that sin is not going to make your son happy is an important step in realising that you can’t support his choices in this area.
 
Last edited:
-Love your son the way St. Monica loved St. Augustine. A mother’s prayer availeth much. You don’t even have to get preachy with him. But every night before you sleep and every morning when you wake up, pray to God for your son’s (and his partner’s) and their adopted children’s (if they get them) salvation.
St. Monica‘’s devotion to God and her love for her unbelieving, sinful son—St. Augustine—are quite appropriate and helpful to bring to light here. The eventual conversion of her son to the Catholic faith was an answer to her relentless prayers to God and her commitment to her son. Her son later became a great saint and a Doctor of the Church.
 
Last edited:
One post, joined one hour ago…

(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
Yup, I get troll vibes too. The responses are just too on the nose. They’re like perfectly calibrated to rile people up. Calling shenanigans on this one.
 
The OP also hasn’t responded to this thread in 14 hours. Posted, answered a couple of responses right away and hasn’t been back.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top