Nathan Phillips rally attempted to disrupt Mass at DC’s National Shrine

  • Thread starter Thread starter Guinness
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This is a cheap shop at pro-lifers. You are absolutely and entirely WRONG about this.
He did say “some of which.” There are some that can do that to the point of being a single issue voter. I get those that strongly weigh abortion among all the issues the Church teaches as pro-life. It should be number one, head and shoulders. Yet I have seen all other pro-life issues dismissed by some in the name of abortion. There are people like this out there. That is why it has become a joke with me that every topic on CAF is eventually abortion (or Hitler).
 
I didn’t say it’s status as a “mortal evil” has changed, I said it has been de-emphasized.
I see. Well consider that morality is not zero sum. Teaching about other issues does not, in fact, de-emphasize previous teaching, any more that Christmas de-emphasizes Advent.
 
What is my opinion is that at some point opposition to abortion will be dropped in favor of combating climate change (which requires a reduction in the number of humans) or universal healthcare (which will include abortion as a right).
You come to this conclusion because Church leaders are now speaking about evils other than abortion while also speaking out against abortion?
 
Just because Trump is courting Catholics for Pro Life causes doesn’t make him a Pro Life nor proves his authentic cares for the unborn. All his life, he was busy womanizing, grabbing women’s private parts, neither reading the bible nor attending Church and just woke up one day and became a heroic leader advocate for the Pro Life movement? Hmmmm, Sounds very suspicious. I believe, all of the legislative decisions he has done were all about taking the funding and resources away beneficial to the Liberal left. That is, in a nutshell, what the fight behind the elections, is how the resources is used, to what causes, where it needs and to whom are we going to use the resources that we have. Of course, politically speaking, Trump will take away all of the resources going towards the Liberal left which might seems to appear to be Pro Life causes for the pro lifers. I cannot be fooled, will never be fooled by this con man.
 
Last edited:
You come to this conclusion because Church leaders are now speaking about evils other than abortion while also speaking out against abortion?
You think driving an SUV is morally equivalent to aborting a child? Thinking markets can do a better job delivering healthcare than government? Supporting restrictions on immigration?
 
He did say “some of which.” There are some that can do that to the point of being a single issue voter. I get those that strongly weigh abortion among all the issues the Church teaches as pro-life. It should be number one, head and shoulders. Yet I have seen all other pro-life issues dismissed by some in the name of abortion. There are people like this out there. That is why it has become a joke with me that every topic on CAF is eventually abortion (or Hitler).
Well it’s no joke that a lot of topics also devolve into people who don’t like big government entitlements hate the poor. There are a lot of SJW’s on these forums.
 
Last edited:
40.png
gracepoole:
You come to this conclusion because Church leaders are now speaking about evils other than abortion while also speaking out against abortion?
You think driving an SUV is morally equivalent to aborting a child? Thinking markets can do a better job delivering healthcare than government? Supporting restrictions on immigration?
I said “speaking about evils other than abortion while also speaking out against abortion.” How did we get from there to making a moral equivalency between all evils?
 
As to unemployment, it dropped about 5% (half) during the Obama administration. It has also declined under Trump, though not as much. There is wasn’t much room left for it to decline. So the 1% decline in two years is very significant.
 
I said “speaking about evils other than abortion while also speaking out against abortion.” How did we get from there to making a moral equivalency between all evils?
You think driving an SUV is evil? Supporting market based health insurance reforms? American immigration laws favoring American citizens over illegal immigrants?
 
Last edited:
All his life, he was busy womanizing,
If you are insinuating that Trump has had a mystical experience, I highly doubt that. It is reserved to religious and spiritual people, something lacking in Trump’s personification that is being displayed. Why do you deny or why is it hard for you to believe that Trump’s motive is pure political?
 
Wow! Comparing Trump to St. Augustine! That has to be the biggest stretch I have seen here. He is no more a saint that he is Hitler.
 
40.png
gracepoole:
I said “speaking about evils other than abortion while also speaking out against abortion.” How did we get from there to making a moral equivalency between all evils?
You think driving an SUV is evil? Supporting market based health insurance reforms? American immigration laws favoring American citizens over illegal immigrants?
We started with climate change (which creates environmental refugees), healthcare (not who is responsible for delivering it – access to it), and immigration (which results in deaths for many). Now we’re on to driving SUVs and illegal immigration. It’s kind of tough to have a discussion when the goal posts keep moving.
 
If you are insinuating that Trump has had a mystical experience, I highly doubt that. It is reserved to religious and spiritual people, something lacking in Trump’s personification that is being displayed. Why do you deny or why is it hard for you to believe that Trump’s motive is pure political?
Quite possibly she realizes it is not given to her to judge his soul.
 
As to unemployment, it dropped about 5% (half) during the Obama administration. It has also declined under Trump, though not as much. There is wasn’t much room left for it to decline. So the 1% decline in two years is very significant.
Interesting that the unemployment rate can go up or down having nothing to do with the percentage of the population that’s employed or the number of jobs. I see that in the last measurement, the unemployment rate went up slightly while jobs went up a lot more than expected. The unemployment rate went up (or so the experts say) is because more people are entering or re-entering the work force. The reverse can also be true. There have been times in the past when the unemployment rate went down because the number of people who gave up looking for a job went up.
 
And she realizes to judge someone to be a “saint” for pro life causes because of his political decisions?
Not that she said that, because she didn’t.

But if she ever does, we can consider its implications then.
 
Judging one’s soul and judging one’s character sound alike, but really aren’t. A person of low character may well have an invincible ignorance based on upbringing that would not condemn the soul to Hell. Likewise, we do not judge people as saints, as there may be flaws known to God alone. Church canonization is an exercise of the authority of the Church, meaning, it is only through divine guidance of some sort.

The one time we simply must consider prudence as well as charity is in voting. We have to consider who a person is beyond the speeches and spin. Such judgement does not judge the soul, but the suitability to the offices sought.
And she realizes to judge someone to be a “saint” for pro life causes because of his political decisions?
It was an analogy only. I almost spit out my drink on it, but it was just an analogy. The point is that a person can change by the grace of God. This is usually accompanied though by repentance and humility.
 
Last edited:
Especially words like “I wouldn’t want my daughter to be punished” by a pregnancy.
I’ll never get over this. His own grandchild. How could he think this? Why was not his first thought (as it would be, I think, with most) “I’ll raise the child myself if it comes to that.” How was killing his first thought, and a thought he felt okay about expressing to the world?
 
The one time we simply must consider prudence as well as charity is in voting. We have to consider who a person is beyond the speeches and spin
Primarily we must judge performance, not good intentions or platitudes one might carry in his heart but do nothing to carry out. From a prolife perspective, Trump’s performance has been better than most expected or thought he could accomplish. I don’t think you would deny that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top