NFP abused is sinful

  • Thread starter Thread starter tundra1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
That should be “it’s not immoral to use NFP to space pregnancies…if you are using NFP correctly and for the right reasons”

NFP can be just as immoral as contraception, if it is misused. That’s the whole point of discussion in this thread I believe.

I’d argue that in most cases, NFP is used immorally, as every NFP class I’ve been to spends 90%+ of the time talking about how to do it, and not why or why not to do it. My personal opinion is that most practioners view it as “Catholic contraception”, and I fail to see the reason for instructing every soon-to-be married Catholic couple in the method before they are even married. If they later encounter serious reasons not to desire children, they can abstain, seek guidance, and then be instructed in NFP if it is appropriate.

The message put out by the pre-Cana NFP classes is that Catholics have two choices:

Contraception (forbidden)
NFP (what you should do- according to the classes)

That’s a false choice. It leaves off:
-Abstaining from relations entirely if you have serious reasons to avoid pregnancy.
-Simply living your life, having relations, and trusting to the divine providence of God.

Both of those are entirely valid Catholic views. Both are dismissed by the “Catholic Contraception NFP crowd”.

Pax and God bless.
No, NFP can NEVER be as immoral as contraception, it could, possibly, be used seflishly or for a wrong reason (making it a sin of selfishness, NOT contraception), but by it’s VERY DESIGN (abstinence) it cannot be immoral to simply use it. When you ‘use’ NFP you are simply gathering data and then deciding to have sex or not. How can that be immoral?
 
So impotent couples can validly have a Josephite marriage? :confused:
No. If one party has impotency that will last until they die, they are unable to enter a valid marriage.

Just like if someone is going to be 4 feet tall until they die, they cannot be an NBA player.
 
No, NFP can NEVER be as immoral as contraception, it could, possibly, be used seflishly or for a wrong reason (making it a sin of selfishness, NOT contraception), but by it’s VERY DESIGN (abstinence) it cannot be immoral to simply use it. When you ‘use’ NFP you are simply gathering data and then deciding to have sex or not. How can that be immoral?
Using NFP to attempt avoiding children, without serious reason, is an abuse of the sacrament of marriage and a sin of contraception in the heart and mind.

The Church tells us that one needs serious reasons to use NFP in order to attempt the spacing of children. Are you arguing that the Church doesn’t really mean what it says? Or that it means it, but Catholics are not bound by it?

Pax
 
I apologize, I misread your post a bit.

As I said, I was referring to using NFP to attempt avoiding children. I now see you are talking about simply charting.

Charting could still be sinful, if it is done with the intent of using that data to attempt avoiding children and there is not a valid reason for the couple to do so. So it depends on the intent of gathering data.

Actually attempting to avoid children without serious reason, would be mortally sinful, just like contraception.

Pax
 
I apologize, I misread your post a bit.

As I said, I was referring to using NFP to attempt avoiding children. I now see you are talking about simply charting.

Charting could still be sinful, if it is done with the intent of using that data to attempt avoiding children and there is not a valid reason for the couple to do so. So it depends on the intent of gathering data.

Actually attempting to avoid children without serious reason, would be mortally sinful, just like contraception.

Pax
Most of us agree that there needs to be grave/just/serious reasons to use NFP to avoid, but it is NEVER sinful like contraception. It can’t be. Abstaining is not sinful if both members of the couple agree to the abstaining (ie, not withholding the act, but abstaining). Contraception, used for contraception, is ALWAYS morally wrong.
 
I apologize, I misread your post a bit.

As I said, I was referring to using NFP to attempt avoiding children. I now see you are talking about simply charting.

Charting could still be sinful, if it is done with the intent of using that data to attempt avoiding children and there is not a valid reason for the couple to do so. So it depends on the intent of gathering data.

Actually attempting to avoid children without serious reason, would be mortally sinful, just like contraception.

Pax
But you see, it is not the charting it is the intent that is sinful, those are two different things, Charting is morally neutral. You could be charting to give your doctor information to help him treat you, or you could be charting to increase your chances of getting pregnant, or to avoid pregnancy, or just to know where you are in your cycle.

Think of it this way, I might have a good intent to avoid conception at this time (pick any reason you think is a good reason), then I can either use a morally acceptable way to do this (abstinence) or a sinful way to do it (contraception).

Or conversely I might not have a serious reason to avoid. That is intention can be sinful. But contraception on top of that bad intention is another sin, (a bad ends accomplished by a bad means). But if the couple used abstinence, they would be using a morally neutral means to accomplish a bad end, which btw is still sinful.
 
Dan Daly, you really need to read this post: NFP: Licit or Illicit?

It explains (using quotes from the Catechism and various papal encyclicals) why it is NOT sinful or illicit to use NFP for the purpose of spacing pregnancies.

This is a good one as well: Is NFP a Heresy? by Fr. Brian Harrison
 
Dan Daly, you really need to read this post: NFP: Licit or Illicit?

It explains (using quotes from the Catechism and various papal encyclicals) why it is NOT sinful or illicit to use NFP for the purpose of spacing pregnancies.

This is a good one as well: Is NFP a Heresy? by Fr. Brian Harrison
The post you linked to has the same problem some other posters here have- trying to have it both ways.

On one hand it says NFP is NEVER sinful.

On the other hand it says NFP is only allowed to be used in an attempt to avoid children if there are serious reasons.

So what happens if a couple uses NFP in an attempt to avoid children and there are NOT serious reasons?

??

As procreation is the primary end of marriage, there is an obvious answer. It’s a perversion of the sacrament. It would be like a priest celebrating Mass, and deciding he’s going to skip the Liturgy of the Eucharist simply because he feels like it. Now if the roof starts to cave in and people have to evacuate, there would be serious reason for not celebrating the sacrament in its fullness.

The CCC is quite confusing on the matter:
When it is a question of harmonizing married love with the responsible transmission of life, the morality of the behavior does not depend on sincere intention and evaluation of motives alone; but it must be determined by objective criteria, criteria drawn from the nature of the person and his acts, criteria that respect the total meaning of mutual self-giving and human procreation in the context of true love; this is possible only if the virtue of married chastity is practiced with sincerity of heart.
So we are told a couple must have OBJECTIVE reasons in order to attempt avoiding children, and that sincere intention is not an objective reason. But the objective reasons are not stated, and we are pointed back to sincerity of heart…which we were just told is not a good reason in and of itself.

I have never said NFP is bad in and of itself. What I have said, is that NFP is grossly misused by a great many people and seen as some sort of theological loophole that allows for “Catholic contraception”.

Pax and God Bless.
 
For the most part I agree with what you’re trying to say, Dan… but this confuses me…
What I have said, is that NFP is grossly misused by a great many people and seen as some sort of theological loophole that allows for “Catholic contraception”.
How do you KNOW it’s “grossly misused”?
Do you have data/statistics to show this?

Yes, it CAN be misused - we agree on that… but “grossly”?? Eh, I have a few doubts… mostly because so few people actually turn to church teachings in the first place (I don’t know the stats - but it’s like less than 5% of Catholics who are trying to avoid conception for any reason actually use it)… so most who would be of the “contraceptive mindset” in the first place would probably resort to *actual *contraception.

Possible?.. yes.
Grossly?.. Eh…:o
 
The post you linked to has the same problem some other posters here have- trying to have it both ways.

On one hand it says NFP is NEVER sinful.

On the other hand it says NFP is only allowed to be used in an attempt to avoid children if there are serious reasons.

So what happens if a couple uses NFP in an attempt to avoid children and there are NOT serious reasons?

??

As procreation is the primary end of marriage, there is an obvious answer. It’s a perversion of the sacrament. It would be like a priest celebrating Mass, and deciding he’s going to skip the Liturgy of the Eucharist simply because he feels like it. Now if the roof starts to cave in and people have to evacuate, there would be serious reason for not celebrating the sacrament in its fullness.

The CCC is quite confusing on the matter:

So we are told a couple must have OBJECTIVE reasons in order to attempt avoiding children, and that sincere intention is not an objective reason. But the objective reasons are not stated, and we are pointed back to sincerity of heart…which we were just told is not a good reason in and of itself.

I have never said NFP is bad in and of itself. What I have said, is that NFP is grossly misused by a great many people and seen as some sort of theological loophole that allows for “Catholic contraception”.

Pax and God Bless.
Dan, here’s the distinction you don’t seem to get:

NFP is morally neutral in all cases. It provides the couple with information, nothing more. I have used to achieve pregnancy as well as to avoid pregnancy. T

What the couple chooses to do with that information is where possible culpability comes into play. If a couple chooses to attempt to achieve pregnancy - permissible. If a couple chooses to attempt to avoid pregnancy for serious reasons - permissible. If a couple chooses to avoid pregnancy for frivolous reasons - possibly sinful, but nearly impossible for outsiders to judge given we probably don’t have all the facts of every given situation, nor can we read hearts and minds.

HOWEVER, the use of NFP even for “frivolous” reasons does not have the same gravity as using contraception for the same end. The end is not moral, but at least NFP is a morally neutral means to that end as opposed to an intrinsically evil means to that end. If a couple is using NFP to avoid, they are at least trying to follow Church teaching, even if they are doing so imperfectly.

We ALL follow Church teaching imperfectly; otherwise there’d be no need for Confession!

I don’t see what’s difficult to understand. I think this article was linked before, Dan, but it’s worth your time to read if you haven’t done so:

Why Doesn’t the Church Just Make a List? by Simcha Fischer

Given that only an estimated 3-4% of Catholics use NFP in lieu of contraception to avoid pregnancy, I would love to see proof for your claim that it is most often used for the wrong reasons. It seems to me that most people who are using NFP instead of contraception are at least attempting to follow the Church’s teachings instead of just yielding to the sinful temptation of using contraception.
 
For the most part I agree with what you’re trying to say, Dan… but this confuses me…

How do you KNOW it’s “grossly misused”?
Do you have data/statistics to show this?

Yes, it CAN be misused - we agree on that… but “grossly”?? Eh, I have a few doubts… mostly because so few people actually turn to church teachings in the first place (I don’t know the stats - but it’s like less than 5% of Catholics who are trying to avoid conception for any reason actually use it)… so most who would be of the “contraceptive mindset” in the first place would probably resort to *actual *contraception.

Possible?.. yes.
Grossly?.. Eh…:o
Dad believes that anyone that hasn’t consulted with a priest is using NFP sinfully.

In fact, he doesn’t believe that maternal health is a just reason for NFP. 🤷

So it doesn’t surprise me that he thinks that NFP is grossly misused.
 
Dan, here’s the distinction you don’t seem to get:

NFP is morally neutral in all cases. It provides the couple with information, nothing more. I have used to achieve pregnancy as well as to avoid pregnancy. T

What the couple chooses to do with that information is where possible culpability comes into play. If a couple chooses to attempt to achieve pregnancy - permissible. If a couple chooses to attempt to avoid pregnancy for serious reasons - permissible. If a couple chooses to avoid pregnancy for frivolous reasons - possibly sinful, but nearly impossible for outsiders to judge given we probably don’t have all the facts of every given situation, nor can we read hearts and minds.

HOWEVER, the use of NFP even for “frivolous” reasons does not have the same gravity as using contraception for the same end. The end is not moral, but at least NFP is a morally neutral means to that end as opposed to an intrinsically evil means to that end. If a couple is using NFP to avoid, they are at least trying to follow Church teaching, even if they are doing so imperfectly.

We ALL follow Church teaching imperfectly; otherwise there’d be no need for Confession!

I don’t see what’s difficult to understand. I think this article was linked before, Dan, but it’s worth your time to read if you haven’t done so:

Why Doesn’t the Church Just Make a List? by Simcha Fischer

Given that only an estimated 3-4% of Catholics use NFP in lieu of contraception to avoid pregnancy, I would love to see proof for your claim that it is most often used for the wrong reasons. It seems to me that most people who are using NFP instead of contraception are at least attempting to follow the Church’s teachings instead of just yielding to the sinful temptation of using contraception.
:clapping::clapping::clapping:
 
Just to clarify, are you trying to say that it can’t be both at the same time? Because the church teaches that you need both, marital relations are both unitive and ordered towards procreation. They are inseparable and we are not to separate them.
Trying to remember, this was part of another post. Think I was trying to get the point across that based on what the church teaches, sex is for having kids. If not, it wouldn’t declare sex has to be procreative and forbid other things. Someone disagreed sex was for having kids, but it has to be - it can’t just be unitive because the church forbids that and it is required to be procreative.
 
Yes, it is different. If the Church taught that sex was for having kids, then Her teaching would be, “Each and every sex act MUST be with the sole intent of conceiving a child.” If the Church actually taught what you thought it did, then it would be immoral to have sex during a woman’s infertile period.

Even post-menopausal couples? Wow! What about a woman who had to have a hysterectomy for medical reasons? Are you telling me that following Church teaching will magically make her able to conceive?

Are you serious? In the context of what we are discussing, you really want to go to the silly side of things? Get real, stay focused.

Exactly, and that’s why it’s not immoral to use NFP to space pregnancies. But using contraception violates this “order” toward procreation.
 
Sadly that is not always the case. As evidence you can look at the many married couples, who have sex, and want children, but for reasons known only to God have not been blessed with any.

Following the laws of the Church does not automatically create children.

Pax and God Bless.
Well, that at least makes sense!
 
Are you serious? In the context of what we are discussing, you really want to go to the silly side of things? Get real, stay focused.
That is the logical conclusion of your beliefs, searching04. If it’s “silly,” then it says something about your initial premises.

I repeat, once again:

If the Church taught that sex was only for having kids, then Her teaching would be, “Each and every sex act MUST be with the sole intent of conceiving a child.” If the Church actually taught what you thought it did, then it would be immoral to have sex during a woman’s infertile period.

Furthermore, if sex is “only for having kids,” then what of this quote from Gaudiem et Spes?
**Marriage to be sure is not instituted solely for procreation; **rather, its very nature as an unbreakable compact between persons, and the welfare of the children, both demand that the mutual love of the spouses be embodied in a rightly ordered manner, that it grow and ripen. Therefore, marriage persists as a whole manner and communion of life, and maintains its value and indissolubility, even when despite the often intense desire of the couple, offspring are lacking.
Do you see that? This is a papal encyclical promulgated by Pope Paul VI. It is authoritative teaching from the Church that marriage (and, following, the marital act) is not instituted SOLELY for procreation.

I don’t see how you can read the above and still believe that the Church teaches that sex is ONLY for having kids.
 
Using NFP to attempt avoiding children, without serious reason, is an abuse of the sacrament of marriage and a sin of contraception in the heart and mind.

Well, then, most Catholic couples are sinning, I bet. It is used more often than not to “space” children - yes, to avoid pregnancy to the degree possible.

The Church tells us that one needs serious reasons to use NFP in order to attempt the spacing of children. Are you arguing that the Church doesn’t really mean what it says? Or that it means it, but Catholics are not bound by it?

Church also says it is apparently up to the couple to decide what is serious, reading thru the threads…

Pax
 
But you see, it is not the charting it is the intent that is sinful, those are two different things, Charting is morally neutral. You could be charting to give your doctor information to help him treat you, or you could be charting to increase your chances of getting pregnant, or to avoid pregnancy, or just to know where you are in your cycle.

Think of it this way, I might have a good intent to avoid conception at this time (pick any reason you think is a good reason), then I can either use a morally acceptable way to do this (abstinence) or a sinful way to do it (contraception).

Or conversely I might not have a serious reason to avoid. That is intention can be sinful. But contraception on top of that bad intention is another sin, (a bad ends accomplished by a bad means). But if the couple used abstinence, they would be using a morally neutral means to accomplish a bad end, which btw is still sinful.
And people wonder why Catholics are neurotic and paranoid about sex!
 
The post you linked to has the same problem some other posters here have- trying to have it both ways.

On one hand it says NFP is NEVER sinful.

On the other hand it says NFP is only allowed to be used in an attempt to avoid children if there are serious reasons.

So what happens if a couple uses NFP in an attempt to avoid children and there are NOT serious reasons?

??

As procreation is the primary end of marriage, there is an obvious answer. It’s a perversion of the sacrament. It would be like a priest celebrating Mass, and deciding he’s going to skip the Liturgy of the Eucharist simply because he feels like it. Now if the roof starts to cave in and people have to evacuate, there would be serious reason for not celebrating the sacrament in its fullness.

The CCC is quite confusing on the matter:

So we are told a couple must have OBJECTIVE reasons in order to attempt avoiding children, and that sincere intention is not an objective reason. But the objective reasons are not stated, and we are pointed back to sincerity of heart…which we were just told is not a good reason in and of itself.

I have never said NFP is bad in and of itself. What I have said, is that NFP is grossly misused by a great many people and seen as some sort of theological loophole that allows for “Catholic contraception”.

Pax and God Bless.
You married, have kids? Living this?
 
And people wonder why Catholics are neurotic and paranoid about sex!
She wouldn’t have to be if people didn’t so often abuse and misuse sex.

You know what’s interesting? My husband and I were born and raised Lutheran. We were married in the Lutheran Church. We contracepted the first two years of our marriage, until our conversion to Catholicism, and than we began using NFP only and following the Church’s teachings regarding sex.

It has drastically changed our marriage for the better, and we would NEVER go back to contraception. There are similar testimonies all over the place by other Catholic converts or reverts who have lived on both sides of the fence, so to speak.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top