J
Jennifer_J
Guest
No, NFP can NEVER be as immoral as contraception, it could, possibly, be used seflishly or for a wrong reason (making it a sin of selfishness, NOT contraception), but by it’s VERY DESIGN (abstinence) it cannot be immoral to simply use it. When you ‘use’ NFP you are simply gathering data and then deciding to have sex or not. How can that be immoral?That should be “it’s not immoral to use NFP to space pregnancies…if you are using NFP correctly and for the right reasons”
NFP can be just as immoral as contraception, if it is misused. That’s the whole point of discussion in this thread I believe.
I’d argue that in most cases, NFP is used immorally, as every NFP class I’ve been to spends 90%+ of the time talking about how to do it, and not why or why not to do it. My personal opinion is that most practioners view it as “Catholic contraception”, and I fail to see the reason for instructing every soon-to-be married Catholic couple in the method before they are even married. If they later encounter serious reasons not to desire children, they can abstain, seek guidance, and then be instructed in NFP if it is appropriate.
The message put out by the pre-Cana NFP classes is that Catholics have two choices:
Contraception (forbidden)
NFP (what you should do- according to the classes)
That’s a false choice. It leaves off:
-Abstaining from relations entirely if you have serious reasons to avoid pregnancy.
-Simply living your life, having relations, and trusting to the divine providence of God.
Both of those are entirely valid Catholic views. Both are dismissed by the “Catholic Contraception NFP crowd”.
Pax and God bless.