Jennifer, I converted to the Catholic Church 5 and a half years ago. I didn’t really bother to study what the Church had taught about marriage and sex before I converted. Then I started reading what the saints had written about marriage and sex throughout history. I was devastated. I felt deceived. It took me over a year to decide whether or not I wanted to stay in the Church.
I finally decided to stay, because I realized that whatever the Church used to teach, it’s teachings about marriage and sex are now more in line with what I learned as a Protestant. In other words, what the Church teaches now is true. I didn’t want to leave the Church because of what Catholics and saints used to teach. However, if the Church ever starts to teach what the saints have said throughout history, I will leave. I will run for the door and not look back.
That being said, I went to a meeting of the woman’s group at my parish. They were reading The Life and Thought of Edith Stein. One of the chapters was about her writings about marriage, sex, and women. The leader of the discussion asked “Could she have written like this if she had been raised Catholic?” The unanimous consensus was “No.” The women then went on to talk about how Jews have such a healthy and positive view of sexuality, and how they all envied that.