NFP abused is sinful

  • Thread starter Thread starter tundra1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I could say the same thing about the self-appointed “NFP Police”…
This is by and far the most crazy forum I have ever encountered. Those who stand by Church teaching are mocked. Perhaps this is not an authentic or moderated Catholic forum?
 
Correct. St. Thomas Aquinas, according to Costello, was teaching heretical views because he did not believe that Mary was conceived without original sin. Yet the church leaders at the time never condemned his views or his writings as heretical.

The reason is quite simple. The Church at the time had simply not determined whether or not Mary had been spared from original sin at the moment of her conception. They believed that she never sinned, but they hadn’t yet determined if she had been spared from original sin from the very first moment of her conception. So St. Thomas Aquinas was not bound to believe in the Immaculate Conception as defined by Pope Pius IX.
Please, start a thread in the appropriate area for this kind of question. I am pretty sure that the forum rules would be better served if you take this over to a Catholicism or apologetics room.
 
This is by and far the most crazy forum I have ever encountered. Those who stand by Church teaching are mocked. Perhaps this is not an authentic or moderated Catholic forum?
But the Church has not provided a concrete list of what constitutes “gravis” reasons (there is even debate on how to translate “gravis”!) other than general terms such as “medical” reasons. If the Church doesn’t, then we laypeople shouldn’t be laying guilt trips on people who use NFP. It can lead to people being scrupulous and even neurotc (to use one poster’s words) if the wife is not pregnant 24/7 from her wedding night until menopause.

The bottom line is: it is none of our business; married couples should deal with it in pre-cana and confession.
 
Sure I read what the Catechism says. But I never bothered to read what Catholics and saints said about marriage and sex before the year 1900. I assumed that the Church’s teachings hadn’t changed, the saints and Catholics must have believed what the Catechism teaches. They did not. That was what was so scandalous to me.

And I do think there is still some baggage from those early ideas that the saints and other Catholic writers had.
By all means, then – please quote Church teaching that was binding on the faithful - i.e., not the private opinion of an individual theologian, but a papal encyclical or similar - from before the year 1900 that describes sex as a “necessary evil.”
 
Correct. St. Thomas Aquinas, according to Costello, was teaching heretical views because he did not believe that Mary was conceived without original sin. Yet the church leaders at the time never condemned his views or his writings as heretical.
That’s because Aquinas confirmed that Mary was born without sin, and the logic he used to define this belief was essentially the same logic for the dogma of the Immaculate Conception.

Jimmy Akin has a good explanation here. An excerpt (pay especial attention to #1, below):
Evangelicals often use the fact that Aquinas (unlike others of his age) did not believe that Mary was entirely sanctified from the moment of her conception to imply that she committed actual, personal sin–as Protestants assert. However, nothing could be further from the truth. Even though Aquinas did not claim that Mary was sanctified from the moment of her conception, he did claim that she was sanctified before her birth, and so never committed personal sin (for unborn children commit no personal sin; cf. Rom. 9:11).
For a Protestant to knowingly push this claim is deceptive on three fronts:
  1. It suggests that Aquinas’s views ought to be held to (on those rare occasions) when he disagrees with what the Church has since established as true, but the views of no one theologian, even an Aquinas, may be held in preference to what the Church later establishes. Aquinas’s views–as he himself would insist–simply cease to count as evidence concerning what a Catholic should believe once the Church has infallibly determined otherwise.
  1. The fact is that Aquinas did hold to Mary’s entire personal sinlessness, which is what Protestants really object to. They are not concerned about what Aquinas was looking at–whether she was free from each and every stain of original sin during a window of time prior to her birth. That is a trivial matter to them compared to the question of whether Mary committed actual, personal sin during her life. That is what they are obsessed about and which will get them hopping up and down issuing charges of heresy, claiming that a sinless life makes Mary out to be God (as if it would make us God when we have been entirely sactified and are leading totally sinless lives). When Protestants say that Aquinas didn’t believe in the Immaculate Conception but fail to say that he believed in her sinless life, they are picking at something that is from their position a nit and omitting the fact that Aquinas is not on their in the thing which really concerns them.
  1. Since Protestants have identified the doctrine of the Immaculate Conception with the doctrine of Mary’s personal sinlessness, it is deceptive of them to say that Aquinas did not believe in the Immaculate Conception because this will imply to their audience–and to anyone else who doesn’t have a good grasp on the doctrine–that he believed Mary sinned, which is simply not true. They will thus mislead their audience into thinking Aquinas said something he didn’t, and to do that knowingly is deception, plain and simple.
 
By all means, then – please quote Church teaching that was binding on the faithful - i.e., not the private opinion of an individual theologian, but a papal encyclical or similar - from before the year 1900 that describes sex as a “necessary evil.”
Please go back and reread what I posted.
 
But the Church has not provided a concrete list of what constitutes “gravis” reasons (there is even debate on how to translate “gravis”!) other than general terms such as “medical” reasons. If the Church doesn’t, then we laypeople shouldn’t be laying guilt trips on people who use NFP. It can lead to people being scrupulous and even neurotc (to use one poster’s words) if the wife is not pregnant 24/7 from her wedding night until menopause.

The bottom line is: it is none of our business; married couples should deal with it in pre-cana and confession.
Very true.

It’s interesting in a way that we assume that the couple with a large family is the virtuous family. The Early Church Fathers held that the desire for a large family was a sign of spiritual immaturity. It’s possible that a couple has a large family because they are being open to life. However, they may also choose to have a large family because they do not believe in the resurrection of the dead and the next world.
 
Please, start a thread in the appropriate area for this kind of question. I am pretty sure that the forum rules would be better served if you take this over to a Catholicism or apologetics room.
I have no problem wtith the Immaculate Conception. I believe in the Immaculate Conception. But I guess you disagree with Bl. John Henry Newman on the development of Christian doctrine. He felt that Christian doctrine developed over time, and I guess you do not.
 
Please go back and reread what I posted.
My point was that there is a complete disconnect between what the Church teaches about marriage and sex and what the saints and other Catholic writers throughout the centuries believed and wrote about sex and marriage. It was very difficult for me to understand why none of the saints or Catholics throughout the centuries believed what the Church teaches. It took me a lot of time to accept that.

The Church encourages people to read the writings of the saints, and yet in this case all the saints had views that were somewhat heretical. It was difficult to understand.
 
My point was that there is a complete disconnect between what the Church teaches about marriage and sex and what the saints and other Catholic writers throughout the centuries believed and wrote about sex and marriage. It was very difficult for me to understand why none of the saints or Catholics throughout the centuries believed what the Church teaches. It took me a lot of time to accept that.

The Church encourages people to read the writings of the saints, and yet in this case all the saints had views that were somewhat heretical. It was difficult to understand.
If every single saint and theologian prior to 1900 held the view that sex was a “necessary evil,” that it makes no sense that the Church’s teachings have never taught such. What do you think Church teaching is based on?

Again, please quote Church teaching that sex prior to 1900 was “a necessary evil.”
 
If every single saint and theologian prior to 1900 held the view that sex was a “necessary evil,” that it makes no sense that the Church’s teachings have never taught such. What do you think Church teaching is based on?

Again, please quote Church teaching that sex prior to 1900 was “a necessary evil.”
Please go back and reread what I posted. You missed what I was trying to say.
 
I understood what you said. It just makes no logical sense.
What is illogical about it? The saints and theologians throughout church history believed that sex was a necessary evil; the Church did not.
 
What is illogical about it? The saints and theologians throughout church history believed that sex was a necessary evil; the Church did not.
I am not so sure that that is even true. It is true that asceticism was more popular and widely practiced, but I can’t really think of any saints that thought sex was a necessary evil within marriage. With the usual suspects like St Gregory the Great, St Augustine, St Jerome it seems we are reading their works from a 21st century POV and missing what they are really attempting to say. Many saints were less pollyannaish and emphasized human weakness more but the idea they had an entirely negative view of marriage seems an exaggeration.
 
Jennifer, I converted to the Catholic Church 5 and a half years ago. I didn’t really bother to study what the Church had taught about marriage and sex before I converted. Then I started reading what the saints had written about marriage and sex throughout history. I was devastated. I felt deceived. It took me over a year to decide whether or not I wanted to stay in the Church.

I finally decided to stay, because I realized that whatever the Church used to teach, it’s teachings about marriage and sex are now more in line with what I learned as a Protestant. In other words, what the Church teaches now is true. I didn’t want to leave the Church because of what Catholics and saints used to teach. However, if the Church ever starts to teach what the saints have said throughout history, I will leave. I will run for the door and not look back.

That being said, I went to a meeting of the woman’s group at my parish. They were reading The Life and Thought of Edith Stein. One of the chapters was about her writings about marriage, sex, and women. The leader of the discussion asked “Could she have written like this if she had been raised Catholic?” The unanimous consensus was “No.” The women then went on to talk about how Jews have such a healthy and positive view of sexuality, and how they all envied that.
Yet Edith Stein and Pope John Paul were practically contemporary, Pope John Paul was raised Catholic and compiled the Theology of the Body.

Edith Stein and Dietrich Von Hildebrand were born 3 years apart. Von Hildebrand was a convert to the Church. He was raised in a secular home. His writings predate Theology of the Body by about 50 years.
 
Yet Edith Stein and Pope John Paul were practically contemporary, Pope John Paul was raised Catholic and compiled the Theology of the Body.

Edith Stein and Dietrich Von Hildebrand were born 3 years apart. Von Hildebrand was a convert to the Church. He was raised in a secular home. His writings predate Theology of the Body by about 50 years.
So, both Edith Stein and Dietrich Von HIldebrand were raised non-Catholic. Coincidence? I think not. 😉 😛
 
I am not so sure that that is even true. It is true that asceticism was more popular and widely practiced, but I can’t really think of any saints that thought sex was a necessary evil within marriage. With the usual suspects like St Gregory the Great, St Augustine, St Jerome it seems we are reading their works from a 21st century POV and missing what they are really attempting to say. Many saints were less pollyannaish and emphasized human weakness more but the idea they had an entirely negative view of marriage seems an exaggeration.
They may not have had an entirely negative view, but they had a very different sense of sexual ethics than modern day Catholics.

For example, imagine a man and woman celebrating their 10th wedding anniversary. The husband asks his wife if they can celebrate their wedding anniversary by having sex, and she agrees. They aren’t trying to conceive, but they don’t do anything to contracept. The Church would say that the husband has not committed any sin, but saints and throughout church history would say that the man commited a venial sin, by having sex with his wife for a reason other than attempting to impregnate her.

Even the OP represents this modern view. The OP believes that if a couple has no reason to postpone pregnancy, but no desire to have a child, they should have sex whenever they want and joyfully accept whatever children God sends them. Catholics in centuries past would argue that that would be venially sinful, and it would be better to simply abstain from sex until they wanted to have a child. They also felt that the desire for a large family was a sign of spiritual immaturity.
 
What is illogical about it? The saints and theologians throughout church history believed that sex was a necessary evil; the Church did not.
Read your second sentence again. It’s inherently illogical.

With what other teaching has every single saint and theologian in the Church believed something, and then all of a sudden the Church turned around and taught something completely different?

Don’t you think there would be some historical record of an outcry when the Church taught for a thousand years that sex was a “necessary evil,” and then all of a sudden started teaching the opposite? How could this even be taught if everyone from the Pope down believed otherwise?

I’m guessing one of your biggest issues is St. Augustine. Nowhere in this specific document “The Good of Marriage” does he say that the marital act in and of itself is an evil. He says that having sex within marriage with the intent to close the marital act to procreation is sinful. That is EXACTLY what the Church has always taught, and what the Church teaches today.

Think of this - if sex was considered a “necessary evil” then this teaching would contradict Scripture. Jesus spoke of two becoming one flesh as a *good *thing. So if we go with the logic that sex is a “necessary evil,” then Jesus told us to do evil! Yet in Romans 3:8, St. Paul condemns the philosophy, “Let us do evil so that good may come of it.”

Like I said, it’s illogical.
 
For example, imagine a man and woman celebrating their 10th wedding anniversary. The husband asks his wife if they can celebrate their wedding anniversary by having sex, and she agrees. They aren’t trying to conceive, but they don’t do anything to contracept. The Church would say that the husband has not committed any sin, but saints and throughout church history would say that the man commited a venial sin, by having sex with his wife for a reason other than attempting to impregnate her.
This is 100% false. Read “The Good of Marriage” by St. Augustine posted above - he does not say that a married couple having sex in this instance would be sinful. What would be sinful is if they attempted to impede procreation (by using “potions of sterility” or herbs to induce miscarriage).

The first time the Vatican spoke on the use of the rhythm method was 1853 (47 years before your date of 1900 when Church teaching apparently radically changed):
The first time Rome spoke on the matter was as long ago as 1853, when the Sacred Penitentiary answered a dubium (a formal request for an official clarification) submitted by the Bishop of Amiens, France. He asked, “Should those spouses be reprehended who make use of marriage only on those days when (in the opinion of some doctors) conception is impossible?” The Vatican reply was, "After mature examination, we have decided that such spouses should not be disturbed [or disquieted], provided they do nothing that impedes generation"6 By the expression “impedes generation”, it is obvious the Vatican meant the use of onanism7 (or coitus interruptus, now popularly called ‘withdrawal’), condoms, etc. For otherwise the reply would be self-contradictory and make no sense.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top