No runaway trolley this time

  • Thread starter Thread starter Scowler
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I disagree with Scowler, but I’ll take a crack at a better dilemma for him:

You’re a city perimeter guard in a “WWZ” scenario. There are hordes of brain-eating zombies trying to get past the wall you’re guarding, which protects the city’s few million inhabitants. You’re armed with a scoped rifle. Unfortunately, you see a curious man trying at what for him is just a strange, obscure door, which you know to in fact be an unlocked, not-well-thought-through door directly to the outside. From your position in the tower you can see the mobs of ravenous zombies just on the other side, ready to infect the city. You shout as loud as you can, but you’re too far away and the man doesn’t hear. You shoulder your gun to fire a warning shot, but the man is already turning the handle. You know you’re not a good enough shot to reliably hit his hand at this distance. What do you do?

.

This is just for fun–Rau, I don’t think your answer to it would be any different than your answer to Scowler. This is only a specific a scenario “where “stopping” the threat posed by the carrier might involve his death.”
 
Not even a “single venial sin”? Whoa! What a vile and callous disregard for other people’s well-being! I never thought that the pedophile cases were indicative of the general lack of “morality” in the Catholic clergy, and likewise I refuse to believe that such a twisted and evil approach is a proper description of Catholic “morality”.
I would suggest you leave if you cannot abide by even the most basic rule of respecting the faith of others.
 
Because Scowler struggles to come up with “real good dilemmas”. 🤣
Thanks. When a person has to set impossible thought experiments, why give them any validity? An empty philosophy is making an impossible choice where we have no information. As St. Paul said:
My goal is that they may be encouraged in heart and united in love, so that they may have the full riches of complete understanding, in order that they may know the mystery of God, namely, Christ, in whom are hidden all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge. I tell you this so that no one may deceive you by fine-sounding arguments… See to it that no one takes you captive through hollow and deceptive philosophy, which depends on human tradition and the elemental spiritual forces of this world rather than on Christ.
Philosophy, as a love of wisdom, is rooted in the divine. As with all things created by God. the devil can pervert it into vanity, which is why we are warned repeatedly about the dangers of the wisdom of this world. Consequentialism makes a lot of sense, but only be discounting a whole heck of a lot, like morality, mortality, the resurrection, the value of suffering, etc.
 
Last edited:
40.png
Gorgias:
If there is no morally licit act, then one cannot simply choose one of the evil options.
So what do you choose then?
Yes. And we are called to avoid all of them, not just the “more naughty” ones.
Excellent. How do you choose among the options if all of them are “sinful”? And some of them are more “sinful” than others?
You choose not to sin.
The greater evil is not of your making.
And is that an excuse?
No, but the moral absolute still stands: do no evil.
I wonder… is Pontius Pilatus one of your saints? Let’s just wash our hands…
Ahh… but Pontius Pilate did commit an evil act – he put to death an innocent man! However, he simply tried to pass the blame off on the Jews! Essentially, he said, “I’m not the cause of me putting an innocent man to death; you’re the cause of me putting an innocent man to death!”

Subtle – but significant! – difference in the cases we’re discussing here! (If Pilate were an adherent of Catholic moral theology, his answer should have been, “I’m sorry, but I cannot put this innocent man to death.” Instead, his answer of “OK… I’ll cooperate in your moral evil” is the exact opposite of what Catholic moral theology teaches – and the exact analogue of what you want us to agree to do! So, in a rather ironic twist, it’s you, not us who are acting like Pontius Pilate! 🤔 )
 
Excellent. How do you choose among the options if all of them are “sinful”? And some of them are more “sinful” than others?
We Christians believe that Jesus Christ is no liar.

In 1st Corinthians chapter 10 we are promised that there will be no temptation where there is not a means of escaping that temptation without sin. Period.

That is the wall you are going to hit with Christians. We simply reject the premise that Scripture lied to us.
 
I would suggest you leave if you cannot abide by even the most basic rule of respecting the faith of others.
I respect Catholicism very much. That is why I spoke up against such a representation of the Catholicism. Cardinal Newman is not infallible and does not speak for the Church. His individual opinion cannot be construed as an infallible expression of the Church’s stance.
You choose not to sin.
No, but the moral absolute still stands: do no evil.
How can you avoid “sinning” and/or doing “evil” when all the choices are “evil”, some more, some less. Inaction can be just as evil as active choices.
Ahh… but Pontius Pilate did commit an evil act – he put to death an innocent man! However, he simply tried to pass the blame off on the Jews! Essentially, he said, “I’m not the cause of me putting an innocent man to death; you’re the cause of me putting an innocent man to death!”
Well, let’s see. He just stood aside and allowed the sentence brought by the Sanhedrin to be carried out. A typical instance of non-action.
 
How can you avoid “sinning” and/or doing “evil” when all the choices are “evil”, some more, some less. Inaction can be just as evil as active choices.
Do you believe one can have only sinful options to choose from? Can you give an example?
 
Do you believe one can have only sinful options to choose from?
Sometimes. And those are called “moral” dilemmas.
Can you give an example?
Several examples were given in this thread and others. All the moral dilemmas are built around scenarios, where one must choose between “lesser” and “greater” evils. If a dilemma contains at least one morally correct option, then it is not a “moral” dilemma. I will ask you back: “Do you believe that there are NO moral dilemmas?”
 
Sinful is likely an unhelpful word to use when debating non Catholics.
They mean any evil, we tend to mean only moral evil.

Clearly some scenarios only have outcomes with bad consequences any which way. But not all of them will involve immoral choices.

The two of you are arguing different things.
Scowler, as observed above, cannot distinguish an evil legal action from an evil human act.
 
Last edited:
But not all of them will involve immoral choices.
Indeed, not all of them. How about “some” of them? What do you do, if all possible actions cause harm?
Scowler, as observed above, cannot distinguish an evil legal action from an evil human act.
Sure I can. I was only talking about one concept: “murder” which is defined differently. It would be a very good thing if we could come to some agreement about basic concepts, and their proper usage. The word “evil” comes to mind as an example. My definition is simple: “an intentional act to cause direct or indirect harm to someone (or something) with a nervous system which has a pleasure / pain center and who does not approve of this harm - and which harm is not mitigated by some greater good”. Obviously the so-called “natural evil” is an oxymoron, is it just used as a euphemism.
 
Excuse us on a Catholic Forum for not being interested in using your definition.
If you do not wish to use, or do not understand, the Catholic one I cannot imagine why anybody here would want to run with yours.
If you disagree with the Catholic one start a new topic on that point and see if anyone has the spare time to engage you.
 
Several examples were given in this thread and others.
I don’t recall you saying it was sinful to take the action you proposed. I don’t recall any scenarios where a person would sin no matter what he did.
All the moral dilemmas are built around scenarios, where one must choose between “lesser” and “greater” evils.
I suspect you (in your ethical view of the world) fail to see a distinction between “committing” evil (by action or inaction) and an act (a choice) in which some evil is anticipated.
 
Sinful is likely an unhelpful word to use when debating non Catholics…The two of you are arguing different things.
I know that full well. But Scowler elected to use the word “sinning” in his post to which I responded. He likes to present himself as understanding catholic moral theology though he plainly does not.
 
Which was my point. Continuing to use words our protaginists use different from us is not always helpful.
 
Which was my point. Continuing to use words our protaginists use different from us is not always helpful.
Not always, but in this case it was to lead him to acknowledge that he assigns a different meaning - even when he thinks he uses the Catholic meaning.

I have less objection to Scowler adopting his own ethical frameworks and noting where it leads than I do to him claiming the Catholic system leads somewhere it does not.
 
Last edited:
I don’t recall you saying it was sinful to take the action you proposed. I don’t recall any scenarios where a person would sin no matter what he did.
“Sinful” is a religious term. I used the term: “moral dilemma, where one must choose between “lesser” and “greater” evils”.
It is never obligatory to sin.
That is not what I asked. Gorgias stipulated that one cannot make a decision based on the ground of “lesser” or “greater” evils. Both he and you used the word “sinful”. In a sense I am guilty, because I should have immediately refused to accept your wording of “sinful”. Mea culpa. 🙂
I suspect you (in your ethical view of the world) fail to see a distinction between “committing” evil (by action or inaction) and an act (a choice) in which some evil is anticipated.
Of course I see the difference. There are instances when an action has multiple results or outcomes; some good, some bad. In such cases one must perform a cost/benefit analysis, and find out if the “good” more than balances the “bad”. The word I prefer is: “does the positive outcome justify the bad side-effects”? Sometimes it does, other times it does not. And that is where the moral dilemmas play an important part. (I do not want to introduce another problem, so please read is as an illustration, not as something that should be resolved here: “you have a limited amount of medication, and you must choose to save one sumo wrestler or two midgets”. These kinds of moral dilemmas are dime a dozen, fortunately only as hypothetical scenarios.)
With a good motivation, you choose a good act anticipated to cause more good than harm.
Now that came as a huge, but very welcome surprise. Typical consequentialist argument! Maybe we can agree on something. If only you (and others) would agree that we need to examine ALL fonts of an action before we come to a conclusion about declaring the action as “moral” or not. Just looking at one font is insufficient. To clarify: the goodness of the act hinges on the fact that it causes more good, than harm - all other things being equal.
 
Last edited:
“Sinful” is a religious term. I used the term: “moral dilemma, where one must choose between “lesser” and “greater” evils”.
You took it upon yourself to use “sinning” in post #90. You may have meant something different.
There are instances when an action has multiple results or outcomes; some good, some bad. In such cases one must perform a cost/benefit analysis, and find out if the “good” more than balances the “bad”.
That may be sufficient under Scowler’s ethical system, but it is only 1/3 of the task in Catholic moral theology. You must also act from a good motivation, and the thing you do must not itself be morally evil (which is a concept having no place in the Scowler system). And then finally, the act you contemplate ought be anticipated to produce more good than harm. If all are true, then the act contemplated is moral - but not otherwise.
I used the term: “moral dilemma, where one must choose between “lesser” and “greater” evils”.
If the motivation for acting is good, and if the deed itself contemplated is good (again, not a concept that exists in the Scowler system), THEN one should choose to minimise the presence of harm in the consequences. There is no proposition in Catholic Moral Theology to suggest one may or should choose to commit any kind of evil - be it “lesser” or “greater”.
Now that came as a huge, but very welcome surprise. Typical consequentialist argument!
If you think that, then you plainly did not understand what was said to you.:roll_eyes:
If only you (and others) would agree that we need to examine ALL fonts of an action before we come to a conclusion about declaring the action as “moral” or not. Just looking at one font is insufficient. To clarify: the goodness of the act hinges on the fact that it causes more good, than harm - all other things being equal.
Catholic Moral Theology does require all 3 fonts to be examined and to be “good”. So, we’d have to agree the identity of the fonts and how they are to be evaluated - and from previous of your posts, we don’t. Second, we’d have to agree that all fonts need to be good for a moral act, which stands in contradiction to your claim that all hinges on the balance of good and harm in the consequences. This latter focus is the typical consequentialist’s approach.
 
Last edited:
Catholic Moral Theology does require all 3 fonts to be examined and to be “good”.
Not exactly. They need to be good or neutral. The consequentialist approach only focuses on the outcome. I keep on disagreeing with it. The end itself cannot justify the means. The problem with the Catholic approach is that it declares certain acts “evil” without examining the rest. It is my view that all 3 must evaluated together and none of them can be evaluated alone.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top