O’Donnell Clarifies First Amendment Remarks

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Puhleassse. Brush up on the constitution. The framers were wild eyed liberals or we would still be an English colony.
The framers were?

pro abortion?
pro homosexual act?
pro euthanasia?
pro-death in general?

Anti - 10 Commandments?
 
I don’t care how you interpret the Establishment Clause but someone running for high federal office should know that it is in the constitution, which I am not sure Ms. O’Donnell did.

Or is that requirement elitist?
 
Poor Christine. Being right in front of the uneducated (wasn’t this at a law school) is never a win.
 
You would think that someonew who is running on the “don’t tread on me” constitutional rights could at least have a basic knowledge of the constitution. The audience actually LOL’d her.
She did. You don’t…go read it.
 
Poor Christine needs to brush up on the Constitution, yet, given the history of bogus interpretation of the Establishment Clause by liberals, her gaffe is relatively minor. Her mistake can easily be corrected. Theirs, not so easily because it requires repentance.
 
Are you saying that the framers did not want freedom of religion?
 
In an exclusive interview with Battle ’10, Republican senate candidate Christine O’Donnell talked about her remarks made earlier this morning that the words “separation of church and state” are not present in the Constitution.

“It seems the AP and others are twisting it out of context,” O’Donnell said. “What I was trying to prove is that my opponent does not know the First Amendment.”
“What our constitution prevents is … government establishing a religion, but it also says that it won’t prohibit free exercise thereof,” argued O’Donnell.

O’Donnell’s original comment was made to address a question asked in a debate this morning about whether local public schools could teach creationism. Talking to Battle ‘10, O’Donnell said that if the local school board approves, there was nothing unconstitutional about a public school teaching the intelligent design theory.

“He’s [Coons] saying the school board has no right do that, that the First Amendment prevents that,” she said. “My position was that’s not true. It gives them the freedom to teach that if that’s what local schools want.”

nationalreview.com/battle10/250293/exclusive-o-donnell-clarifies-first-amendment-remarks-katrina-trinko
Christine had nothing to "clarify". The phony, distorted AP "report" needs clarification. It is the Marxist Coons who has not read the Constitution, though I'm sure that he is up to speed on Das Kaspital. It does seem that Delaware is about to send their posterity into financial ruin by sending Coons to the Senate. At least they have been given a chance to protect future generations by eschewing Obamanomics. They'll have no one to blame but themselves. :shrug: Rob
 
Poor Christine needs to brush up on the Constitution, yet, given the history of bogus interpretation of the Establishment Clause by liberals, her gaffe is relatively minor. Her mistake can easily be corrected. Theirs, not so easily because it requires repentance.
No "poor Christine". It's *poor America*! Coons had referred to "separation of church and state", and it is this phrase about which Christine demurred. :rolleyes: Rob
 
Christine had nothing to “clarify”. The phony, distorted AP “report” needs clarification. It is the Marxist Coons who has not read the Constitution, though I’m sure that he is up to speed on Das Kaspital. It does seem that Delaware is about to send their posterity into financial ruin by sending Coons to the Senate. At least they have been given a chance to protect future generations by eschewing Obamanomics. They’ll have no one to blame but themselves. 🤷 Rob
I guess they will take their chances.
 
They absolutely did; but they didn’t believe in freedom from religion, which is what a lot of ppl take that to mean
Yup - government does not force a state religion, but religion should influence government.
 
I salute Buffalo for his spirited and reasoned explanation of this pivotal issue. The reason O’Donnell is so vilified is that she wades/stumbles into the issues that serve as flashpoints in this country’s cultural shift. The separation of church and state argument, and everything taught about it in school and accepted as common knowledge, is one of those issues that have come to define the progressive vs traditionalist battle. As usual, the media calls her an idiot because she takes the opposite side on these views just as Palin did the same on evolution.
 
If you actually watch the debate, it’s very obvious that she doesn’t recognize the establishment clause as part of the First Amendment

tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo.com/2010/10/christine-odonnell-where-in-the-constitution-is-the-separation-of-church-and-state.php?ref=fpb

It’s not about separation of church and state. She’s obviously ignorant of the Constitution.
You sound pretty ignorant b/c u are misunderstanding the whole point of the establishment clause: it is to prevent the US govt from establishing a state religion ala the Church of England, much different from keeping religion w/in the government.
 
If you actually look at my post, I don’t comment on the First Amendment at all, except to state that if you watch the video, it’s very obvious that O’Donnell does not recognize the establishment cause when it is quoted to her.

I in no way interpreted it in my last post, so I have no idea what you’re talking about.
 
Liberal politicians believe government has unlimited authority, that the constitution does not matter when it comes to creating laws to somehow make life fair. What does it matter if she knows much about the constitution if liberal politicians could care less that it even exists.
 
If you actually watch the debate, it’s very obvious that she doesn’t recognize the establishment clause as part of the First Amendment

tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo.com/2010/10/christine-odonnell-where-in-the-constitution-is-the-separation-of-church-and-state.php?ref=fpb

It’s not about separation of church and state. She’s obviously ignorant of the Constitution.
Correct. I didn’t watch the debate but saw a replay of that part of the debate. It was very obvious to me as well. She did say she didn’t have a copy of the Constitution with her. So she asked what the 14th and 16th Amendments were as well. The mod told her he would think she should know what the 16th is since it’s about income tax.

firstread.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2010/10/19/5316312-odonnells-first-amendment-confusion-
 
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

No where does the phrase “separation of church and state” appear in the text of the Constitution and the plain text of the First Amendment doesn’t infer it. The first time the phrase “separation of church and state” came into constitutional jurisprudence was in the 1947 case *Everson v. Board of Education *, some 156 years after the First Amendment was adopted. It was in the opinion of justice Hugo Black who quoted a letter from Thomas Jefferson to the Danbury Baptist.

There are lots of things liberal, revisionist justices have read into the text of the Constitution over the years in an attempt to make it a “living document.” Among these are things such as a “right” to an abortion, the boundless scope of the Commerce Clause and yes, the supposed “separation” of church and state.

I don’t know what’s more terrifying about this situation; that so many Americans are completely ignorant of the fact that separation of church and state is found nowhere in the text of the Constitution and was nowhere in Establishment Clause jurisprudence until about 60 years ago, or that a group of law school students (future lawyers and judges) actually laughed at the notion.

In Christ
Joe
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top