O’Donnell Clarifies First Amendment Remarks

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Why are you not disturbed about the Communist citing “church and state” separation as a Constitutional principle? Some Christians are trying every which way to justify a vote for this man with a failed un-American philosophy, but it doesn’t wash logically. Rob
How do you know I’m not?

If I’m not mistaken, this thread is about O’Donnell’s response to questions about the First Amendment in the debate.

I am merely staying on topic.

Attacking me just because I make a point is hardly useful.

As Catholics, nothing should scare us more than a politician who appears to neither know nor understand the establishment clause.

I don’t care if she is Catholic. Nothing should be more important to us than politicians’ understanding and knowledge of the establishment clause.
 
Judicial review was “thrust” upon the states by the 14th Amendment, and the 1st Amendment, incorporated to the states by the 14th, would certainly bar a state from establishing a state religion.
Ummmm, Marbury was well before the 14th.

As for the 1st and 14th, they would only apply if judicial review were used, which was the point of my post. It was judicial review that empowered the USSC to review state laws.
 
Again, separation of church and state is not the point here.

O’Donnell failed to recognize the establishment clause when it was quoted to her.
She was expressing incredulity at Coon’s failure to realize that “separation of church and state” does not actually appear in the Constitution.
 
She was expressing incredulity at Coon’s failure to realize that “separation of church and state” does not actually appear in the Constitution.
If you actually watch the clips, that is not what you should take away. Again, it’s not about separation of church and state.

She quite clearly doesn’t recognize the establishment clause that Coons quotes to her.

I recommend watching the entire exchange.

tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo.com/2010/10/christine-odonnell-where-in-the-constitution-is-the-separation-of-church-and-state.php?ref=fpb
 
How do you know I’m not?

If I’m not mistaken, this thread is about O’Donnell’s response to questions about the First Amendment in the debate.

I am merely staying on topic.

Attacking me just because I make a point is hardly useful.

As Catholics, nothing should scare us more than a politician who appears to neither know nor understand the establishment clause.

I don’t care if she is Catholic. Nothing should be more important to us than politicians’ understanding and knowledge of the establishment clause.
In a debate today she could not name one democratic senator. That’s pretty funny, too.

thinkprogress.org/2010/10/20/o%e2%80%99donnell-dem-senator/
 
It is pretty clear that a government institution (i.e. the public school system) teaching religious doctrine as though it were on par with scientific evidence would be government sponsorship of a religion.
No, it is government recognizing that there are opposing viewpoints. teaching creationism instead of evolution would be government sponsorship of reilgion.
 
I just watched the entire exchange, several times. I’ve got no dog in this fight (if I lived in DE, I wouldn’t vote for either one of them).

It’s clear to me that she misspoke badly. That said, she’s not ignorant of the words in the First Amendment. She thinks she’s got him in a “gotcha” on the phrase “separation of church and state” not appearing in the text of the First Amendment. There are four distinct times when she asks some variant of “That phrase is in the First Amendment?” The problem (for her), is that she stopped saying “the phrase” after her initial usage of it. So by the end, when he reads the text straight and she says “That’s in the First Amendment?”, she’s not replying directly to his reading, but still trying to “gotcha” him on the phrase. When you read the debate transcript, it looks horrible, like she’s questioning what’s actually in there. But when you watch the video, note the giant “Reeeeally?” smirk on her face every time she asks a variant of “That’s in there?” She thinks she’s caught him, hence the smirks (ending in a huge smile). She doesn’t look confused - which she would if she was really asking for clarification on the text for her own edification. She looks smirky-then-happy because she thinks she caught him regarding the phrase.

If she’s going to play this game, she has to be very careful, lest she get burned. She needs to say “the phrase” every single time she asks her pointed question. She didn’t, and now she looks ignorant. And of course, her partisan opponents (including on this board) will ride this mistake all the way to the bank.

This is basically the John Kerry “You get sent to Iraq” gaffe, with the parties reversed (in both cases, partisan supporters see the innocous explanation; partisan opponents see only the least charitable interpretation).
 
I just watched the entire exchange, several times. I’ve got no dog in this fight (if I lived in DE, I wouldn’t vote for either one of them).

It’s clear to me that she misspoke badly. That said, she’s not ignorant of the words in the First Amendment. She thinks she’s got him in a “gotcha” on the phrase “separation of church and state” not appearing in the text of the First Amendment. There are four distinct times when she asks some variant of “That phrase is in the First Amendment?” The problem (for her), is that she stopped saying “the phrase” after her initial usage of it. So by the end, when he reads the text straight and she says “That’s in the First Amendment?”, she’s not replying directly to his reading, but still trying to “gotcha” him on the phrase. When you read the debate transcript, it looks horrible, like she’s questioning what’s actually in there. But when you watch the video, note the giant “Reeeeally?” smirk on her face every time she asks a variant of “That’s in there?” She thinks she’s caught him, hence the smirks (ending in a huge smile). She doesn’t look confused - which she would if she was really asking for clarification on the text for her own edification. She looks smirky-then-happy because she thinks she caught him regarding the phrase.

If she’s going to play this game, she has to be very careful, lest she get burned. She needs to say “the phrase” every single time she asks her pointed question. She didn’t, and now she looks ignorant. And of course, her partisan opponents (including on this board) will ride this mistake all the way to the bank.

This is basically the John Kerry “You get sent to Iraq” gaffe, with the parties reversed (in both cases, partisan supporters see the innocous explanation; partisan opponents see only the least charitable interpretation).
Quite honestly, her response was one who cannot connect the dots. She is a literal reader. We don’t need someone who cannot understand nuace in the senate. Do we?
 
Quite honestly, her response was one who cannot connect the dots. She is a literal reader. We don’t need someone who cannot understand nuace in the senate. Do we?
No, she is someone who does get it and believes in the Constitution and what the framer’s intended, not what a bunch of judges decided they would do on their own accord 60 yrs ago.
 
No, she is someone who does get it and believes in the Constitution and what the framer’s intended, not what a bunch of judges decided they would do on their own accord 60 yrs ago.
Right… That was clear from the debate.
 
Right… That was clear from the debate.
it was if you knew anything about the what the Constitution really says and what the framers really thought about it. If you don’t understand that, then it does look like she is ignorant.
 
it was if you knew anything about the what the Constitution really says and what the framers really thought about it. If you don’t understand that, then it does look like she is ignorant.
For a minute there, I forgot she was an expert in constitutional law as she proclaims. The fact that the law school was laughing out loud should be a clue that she might have not had quite the grasp of the law she says she has. IMHO
 
For a minute there, I forgot she was an expert in constitutional law as she proclaims. The fact that the law school was laughing out loud should be a clue that she might have not had quite the grasp of the law she says she has. IMHO
Don’t have to be a Constitutional lawyer to understand the Constitution; it was written for anybody who knew how to read to understand it. Sit down with a Constitutional law professor some time, makes for interesting conversation. Its funny to watch the blank look on their face when you ask them what the framers thought about what they wrote. Considering those factors, it really doesn’t matter if the law school was laughing or not. Fools typically laugh at things they really have no clue about.
 
Its funny to watch the blank look on their face when you ask them what the framers thought about what they wrote.
Who cares what they thought? They wrote that well over 200 years ago, and our country has changed a millenium’s worth since then.

What slaveowning aristocrats thought back then has little, if any, relevance to our 21st century as far as I’m concerned.

We can not be directed by the dead hands of skeletons reaching up from their graves. Our nation has changed - profoundly so, and we ought to look at the Constitution that way as well.
 
For a minute there, I forgot she was an expert in constitutional law as she proclaims. The fact that the law school was laughing out loud should be a clue that she might have not had quite the grasp of the law she says she has. IMHO
Code:
  The fact that the law school lemmings chortled only goes to show that the U.S Constitution is NOT taught there. Case law is. This has been a century-old ploy by progressives meant to separate Americans from their love of our Constitution.
  I have a question for those still supporting Obama here: Don't you realize that our republic is crumbling, and that the Democrat's punishing spending bills are KILLING our hopes for our children's future? We have one chance, on Nov.2 to defeat everyone who has played a role in bankrupting us, and in turning law and order on its head. Shame on America if they are too lazy or intransigent to consider the fact that the left despises all that is good in our country! :mad: Rob
 
The fact that the law school lemmings chortled only goes to show that the U.S Constitution is NOT taught there. Case law is. This has been a century-old ploy by progressives meant to separate Americans from their love of our Constitution.
I have a question for those still supporting Obama here: Don’t you realize that our republic is crumbling, and that the Democrat’s punishing spending bills are KILLING our hopes for our children’s future? We have one chance, on Nov.2 to defeat everyone who has played a role in bankrupting us, and in turning law and order on its head. Shame on America if they are too lazy or intransigent to consider the fact that the left despises all that is good in our country! :mad: Rob
They are complacent with it. It couldn’t happen fast enough, the quicker we become the best version of a European country they can re-create from the pieces of what is left of this Republic the happier they will be. You and I are too stupid to understand it.
 
Who cares what they thought? They wrote that well over 200 years ago, and our country has changed a millenium’s worth since then.

What slaveowning aristocrats thought back then has little, if any, relevance to our 21st century as far as I’m concerned.

We can not be directed by the dead hands of skeletons reaching up from their graves. Our nation has changed - profoundly so, and we ought to look at the Constitution that way as well.
Rich, I'm shocked that you seem to loathe our Founding Fathers. I suggest that you watch Glenn Beck for a few weeks. I don't think that you are a bad man, but rather a terribly misguided one. If Democrats win, the Cap and Trade law alone would cause energy prices to "skyrocket", as Obama said. That's only ONE issue among many which will serve to eviscerate our freedoms. Do you REALLY wish for a future in which your children have NO discretionary income, if indeed they even have a job? :shrug: Rob
 
They are complacent with it. It couldn’t happen fast enough, the quicker we become the best version of a European country they can re-create from the pieces of what is left of this Republic the happier they will be. You and I are too stupid to understand it.
Yes, you have just described Hell on earth, but in the secular muddled brains, humans are capable of creating Utopia if only we would free ourselves from the shackles of organized religions. Well, we have already caught glimpses of Paradise in Russia, China, Cuba and Nazi Germany, where man has decided to play God! Best, Rob
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top