O’Donnell Clarifies First Amendment Remarks

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I guess they will take their chances.
Right. It's amazing that the public has been so ill-informed and brainwashed that they are willing to try, yet again, a system that has lead to nothing but misery, poverty and human slaughter. Rob
 
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

No where does the phrase “separation of church and state” appear in the text of the Constitution and the plain text of the First Amendment doesn’t infer it. The first time the phrase “separation of church and state” came into constitutional jurisprudence was in the 1947 case *Everson v. Board of Education *, some 156 years after the First Amendment was adopted. It was in the opinion of justice Hugo Black who quoted a letter from Thomas Jefferson to the Danbury Baptist.

There are lots of things liberal, revisionist justices have read into the text of the Constitution over the years in an attempt to make it a “living document.” Among these are things such as a “right” to an abortion, the boundless scope of the Commerce Clause and yes, the supposed “separation” of church and state.

I don’t know what’s more terrifying about this situation; that so many Americans are completely ignorant of the fact that separation of church and state is found nowhere in the text of the Constitution and was nowhere in Establishment Clause jurisprudence until about 60 years ago, or that a group of law school students (future lawyers and judges) actually laughed at the notion.

In Christ
Joe
Joe, you are correct.

Chris Coons demonstrated his lack of knowledge about the Constitution and the Bill of Rights. Separation of church and state nowhere appears in that document. Neither does the “concept”.

Apparently Mr. Coons has also demonstrated his lack of appreciation of the tax payers resentment over the tax increases he imposed in his day job of County Executive. [He inherited a $200 million budget surplus and in no time at all, converted it into the brink of bankruptcy.]

Mr. Coons’ memory also seems have a lack of retention: he said his family company (his step-father’s company) would not benefit from government stimulus money, which turned out to be somewhat … not in compliance with the truth.
 
Joe, you are correct.

Chris Coons demonstrated his lack of knowledge about the Constitution and the Bill of Rights. Separation of church and state nowhere appears in that document. Neither does the “concept”.

Apparently Mr. Coons has also demonstrated his lack of appreciation of the tax payers resentment over the tax increases he imposed in his day job of County Executive. [He inherited a $200 million budget surplus and in no time at all, converted it into the brink of bankruptcy.]

Mr. Coons’ memory also seems have a lack of retention: he said his family company (his step-father’s company) would not benefit from government stimulus money, which turned out to be somewhat … not in compliance with the truth.
This constant referring of the separation of church and state seems to come mostly from those who are either anti-religious or extremely religious and do not wish to be constrained in thought or deed in any way. The fact that the early fathers of this country came from Europe and many of those countries had a state religion should tell one something.
 
You sound pretty ignorant b/c u are misunderstanding the whole point of the establishment clause: it is to prevent the US govt from establishing a state religion ala the Church of England, much different from keeping religion w/in the government.
It is pretty clear that a government institution (i.e. the public school system) teaching religious doctrine as though it were on par with scientific evidence would be government sponsorship of a religion. However, it is technically correct that the 1st amendment only prohibits the federal government from establishment, state governments could declare a “state religion” for their state if they so chose. I think most people would agree that such an action would be ill advised.
 
In an exclusive interview with Battle ’10, Republican senate candidate Christine O’Donnell talked about her remarks made earlier this morning that the words “separation of church and state” are not present in the Constitution.

“It seems the AP and others are twisting it out of context,” O’Donnell said. “What I was trying to prove is that my opponent does not know the First Amendment.”
“What our constitution prevents is … government establishing a religion, but it also says that it won’t prohibit free exercise thereof,” argued O’Donnell.

O’Donnell’s original comment was made to address a question asked in a debate this morning about whether local public schools could teach creationism. Talking to Battle ‘10, O’Donnell said that if the local school board approves, there was nothing unconstitutional about a public school teaching the intelligent design theory.

“He’s [Coons] saying the school board has no right do that, that the First Amendment prevents that,” she said. “My position was that’s not true. It gives them the freedom to teach that if that’s what local schools want.”

nationalreview.com/battle10/250293/exclusive-o-donnell-clarifies-first-amendment-remarks-katrina-trinko
I will make an educacted guess and say Coons is making the Assumption that ID is basically Religion, not Science.

Not true.

So O’Donnell is indeed right. 👍
 
If you actually watch the debate, it’s very obvious that she doesn’t recognize the establishment clause as part of the First Amendment

tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo.com/2010/10/christine-odonnell-where-in-the-constitution-is-the-separation-of-church-and-state.php?ref=fpb

It’s not about separation of church and state. She’s obviously ignorant of the Constitution.
I wouldn’t quite say “ignorant” OVERALL, but on that important point, she appears indeed to be so.

Even I will admit that is a pretty bad gaffe. And given that the leftist-leaning media is looking or ANY information available to totally discredit her, this just gives them some pretty good ammunition.

Oh, well. 😊
 
However, it is technically correct that the 1st amendment only prohibits the federal government from establishment, state governments could declare a “state religion” for their state if they so chose.
Not since judicial review was thrust upon the states. If a state attempted such a thing, even through a state constitutional amendment, I’d bet $1M that the ACLU would be all over it in federal court.
 
I wouldn’t quite say “ignorant” OVERALL, but on that important point, she appears indeed to be so.

Even I will admit that is a pretty bad gaffe. And given that the leftist-leaning media is looking or ANY information available to totally discredit her, this just gives them some pretty good ammunition.

Oh, well. 😊
Please don't be fooled by the MSM, Melkite! Coons did not answer her query, so after his boilerplate spiel, she reiterated it, bypassing his dullard prior comments. Personally, I wouldn't care if Coons' opponent was a Martian. Anyone who doesn't vote against this raging Communist does not deserve the blessings of freedom. :o Rob
 
Just ran across this from Volokh Conspiracy legal blog:
On this, I reprint part of an old post from 2005:
6. The phrase “Separation of Church and State,” as Philip Hamburger establishes in his classic book on the subject, is not in the language of the first amendment, was not favored by any influential framer at the time of the first amendment, and was not its purpose.
  1. The first mainstream figures to favor separation after the first amendment was adopted were Jefferson supporters in the 1800 election, who were trying to silence Northern clergy critical of the immoral Jeffersonian slaveholders in the South.
  1. After the Civil War, liberal Republicans proposed a constitutional amendment to add separation of church and state to the US Constitution by amendment, since it was not already there. After that effort failed, influential people began arguing that it was (magically) in the first amendment.
  1. In the last part of the 19th century and the first half of the 20th century, nativists (including the KKK) popularized separation as an American constitutional principle, eventually leading to a near consensus supporting some form of separation.
  1. Separation was a crucial part of the KKK’s jurisprudential agenda. It was included in the Klansman’s Creed (or was it the Klansman’s Kreed?). Before he joined the Court, Justice Black was head of new members for the largest Klan cell in the South. New members of the KKK had to pledge their allegiance to the “eternal separation of Church and State.” In 1947, Black was the author of Everson, the first Supreme Court case to hold that the first amendment’s establishment clause requires separation of church & state. The suit in Everson was brought by an organization that at various times had ties to the KKK.
  1. Until this term, the justices were moving away from the separation metaphor, often failing to mention it except in the titles of cited law review articles, but in the last term of the Court they fell back to using it again.
  1. As Judge Roberts pithily pointed out in the hearings, only one justice (Breyer) thought that both of the leading establishment clause cases delivered this last term were correctly decided.
 
Again, separation of church and state is not the point here.

O’Donnell failed to recognize the establishment clause when it was quoted to her.
 
Again, separation of church and state is not the point here.

O’Donnell failed to recognize the establishment clause when it was quoted to her.
Why are you not disturbed about the Communist citing "church and state" separation as a Constitutional principle? Some Christians are trying every which way to justify a vote for this man with a failed un-American philosophy, but it doesn't wash logically. Rob
 
Why are you not disturbed about the Communist citing “church and state” separation as a Constitutional principle? Some Christians are trying every which way to justify a vote for this man with a failed un-American philosophy, but it doesn’t wash logically. Rob
True indeed, RACJ.🙂
 
Why are you not disturbed about the Communist citing “church and state” separation as a Constitutional principle? Some Christians are trying every which way to justify a vote for this man with a failed un-American philosophy, but it doesn’t wash logically. Rob
What Communist?
 
Not since judicial review was thrust upon the states. If a state attempted such a thing, even through a state constitutional amendment, I’d bet $1M that the ACLU would be all over it in federal court.
Judicial review was “thrust” upon the states by the 14th Amendment, and the 1st Amendment, incorporated to the states by the 14th, would certainly bar a state from establishing a state religion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top