Oklahoma Execution Botched

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sooner87
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you go back to the first post, size was the issue, not movement or shape, though similar arguments could be made for each of those issues as well. (quadriplegics are less human? Disable and injured that look less human lose humanity based on looks?)

I do think it is very simple and logic cannot favor pro-abortion arguments, unless we want to open up really scary stuff.
Ok, maybe mentioning movement and breathing was a digression; although both are inseparable from the visible human body – that was my point, my oops.

DP defendants are visibly human. That is the issue, not size. If embryos could be seen, and recognized as human, they would be sympathized with more than they are; just as we sympathize with babies and children although they are small – they can be seen to be human.

Embryos have no existence apart from the maternal body, which makes them hard to sympathize with.

And no, I am not defending abortion. I believe it to be wrong, although I am not emotionally bound to the issue.

ICXC NIKA.
 
Didn’t this convicted murderer give a death sentence to the 19 year old girl he murdered. Was he concerned about her suffering when he shot her twice or when she was buried alive?
 
Didn’t this convicted murderer give a death sentence to the 19 year old girl he murdered. Was he concerned about her suffering when he shot her twice or when she was buried alive?
Death Penalty is usually for the most heinous acts, multiple murders, etc.

I empathize with what you say but I also recognize that feeling this way seems a bit like wanting revenge. An eye for an eye. Maybe, I’m undecided about that.
 
Death Penalty is usually for the most heinous acts, multiple murders, etc.

I empathize with what you say but I also recognize that feeling this way seems a bit like wanting revenge. An eye for an eye. Maybe, I’m undecided about that.
For this 19 year old girl who had graduated from high school only a month before she was murdered in such a brutal way this was a heinous act and I am sure her family agrees.
I am sorry this was not a “clean” execution, but otherwise it is hard to find sympathy.
 
In fact, almost proof that the government has been faulty in defending law and order in Mexico has led to the “Auto-Defensas”, “Self-Defense”, so the people took the law into their own hands, some call it Vigilantism though it seems being a Vigilante is something related to the Auto-Defensas and not exactly Vigilanitism.
The “Autodefensas” of Michoacan, Mexico became an instant hit a few months ago when they started taking control of local communities in an area known as “Tierra Caliente”, then under control of the Knights Templar drug cartel.
voxxi.com/2014/03/21/mexico-vigilante-infighting-violence/

So, yes, Mexico has totally lacked a semblance of law and order in parts of it, it has been virtually a failed state in a number of towns. Just this show of law has drastically helped the common people even if it in exchange is fraught with problems itself.

Again, if you have a real functioning court system in Mexico, a strong police force, a decline is inevitable and has happened in Juarez and Tijuana to the point the latter has made somewhat of a comeback in the tourist industry.
 
For this 19 year old girl who had graduated from high school only a month before she was murdered in such a brutal way this was a heinous act and I am sure her family agrees.
I am sorry this was not a “clean” execution, but otherwise it is hard to find sympathy.
So are you saying the Death Penalty serves to exact revenge? I’m divided on the issue because of horrible crimes like this. Some people are against the death penalty and I admire that. They are not looking for revenge in this matter.
 
No I am not talking revenge. I am saying “don’t forget the victim”.
He was not concerned for her right to life or her suffering.
 
The only time an execution is “botched” is when the crook suffers less than the victim.

That is all.
 
I live within sight of Mexico.

They have not had a death penalty in more than two generations, yet the current violent conditions there date back less than a decade.

So it would not seem that the lack of executions foments violent crime.

ICXC NIKA.
Yeah, I’m sure the fact most of the violence in Mexico is linked to the US drug trade has nothing to do with it. Nope, it’s because they don’t have the death penalty. I’m also sure that European states that don’t have the death penalty are much more violent than the US. Yep, places that use the death penalty have the lowest violent crime rate.:rolleyes:
 
**Time to get real and wake up on this situation…
  • The inmate shot a 19 year old girl twice with a shotgun. The shotgun malfunctioned and she was wounded terribly, so he ended up burying her alive.
  • The second inmate who was scheduled to die, was convicted of murdering an 11 month old baby after he had raped it multiple times.
  • For people crying foul on him suffering during the execution, get over it. It is an honor to suffer like Christ did on the cross.
  • There are quicker and arguably more humane ways to execute someone, yet people see a hanging or bullet to the head as inhumane…?
  • The CC says that the death penalty should be utilized only as a last resort. If you let all the men out of life sentences and death row today, you will have more murders tomorrow. People need to realize that some souls are determined to be lost.
  • Thomas Aquinas was well in favor of the death penalty.**
No souls are determined to be lost, I can’t believe that for a second. Be careful about being eager to see others suffer like Christ. We are to accept suffering when it comes but we should not purposfully make others suffer. Christ expects us to meet prisoners where they are to ease their suffering (it is an act of mercy). To follow your statement to it’s logical conclusion, it was a good thing for the 19 year old to suffer. That was even difficult to type, there is no way I can accept that reasoning. I will not get over it.

I always felt that Aquinas’ philosophy (what I could understand) was above reproach but when he moved from the abstract to the particular, his statements were a product of his time. We no longer belive that a woman should only dress for her husband or to attract a husband, we no longer believe that masturbation is worse than rape, and hopefully someday we will realize that the death penalty is not needed in todays society. He is an authority on many things related to our faith but he can’t be an authority with regards to the particulars of living our faith in modern society because things are very different now. Christianity is a living faith.
 
No I am not talking revenge. I am saying “don’t forget the victim”.
He was not concerned for her right to life or her suffering.
Hence his punishment (death). My understanding in regards to punishment is that the Church holds there is just suffering and unjust suffering. What this man went through would be unjust (unintentional, which is much different than intentional) suffering.
 
I’m saying Christ taught us that suffering is a good thing. Christ was guilty of nothing.
So the victim that was shot and was buried alive was a good thing? The criminal did the victim a favor by making her suffer more?
 
The only time an execution is “botched” is when the crook suffers less than the victim.

That is all.
Physically, the criminal should suffer less, because ending human life is so easy when a whole state is doing it!

Mentally, he will suffer far more, because he will have a long time to think about it.

Possibly the worst part of the whole psychopathic ceremony occurs when one looks upon the hordes of witnesses, knowing that in an hour, everybody will be alive except oneself. No wonder some culprits have asked to be blindfolded.

ICXC NIKA
 
I’m just stating facts.

In times past, a vicious murderer like this would’ve simply been shot on the spot. Nowadays, we spend a fortune (hundreds of thousands to millions) trying a case like this and housing such people until their execution (if ever). Then we argue about how long his execution took. Or we can argue about sticking him in a small cell for the rest of his life void of any pleasures (i.e., mental torture).

I assume you support the latter?
And in the times past you are citing it is just as likely that someone with nothing to do with the crime but happened to be in the area would be strung up on the nearest tree with no due process whatsoever. So yes, I do think we are better off with our current system.
 
In a nutshell, the violence in Mexico largely became inflamed cerca 2005 when one cartel, Sinaloa decided to take over the land route for transporting drugs near El Paso Texas/Juarez Mexico. That land is called the Juarez Plaza. The Sinaloa Cartel in other words, did not want to pay fees, a toll, to use that land but decided to take it over. And from there, it spread, Juarez was the so-called “murder capital of the world” for a few years but that has declined to an extent.

From there is has spread through the country, not all of it but major portions.

So, I do think it’s a little more complex than just saying Americans use drugs, that fuels the violence when previously, this kind of violence was NOT going on. No, a gang war is the reason for it, that and greed and power. But when Police Departments favor certain criminal organizations or are even cowed from dealing with the Cartels, as said, there is/was a lack of law and order and that as well is part of the problem.

Remember, it’s hard to totally pin it on American drug use when great violence happens well into the interior of Mexico in say Veracruz. I think the situation is a bit more complex.

They called out the Mexican Military but that has had limited success. Sometimes good but can not be counted on to always be “the good guys” to put a simplistic interpretation on it.

Mexico has long had a little bit of this always but it spiraled out of control. It’s probably a little better now than it has been 3 years ago, drug kingpins arrested and the auto-defensas springing up.

Though I’m not sure about being for legalization of pot as in Colorado, in ways, making it an official business does seem to take a lot, maybe most of the black market and therefore organized crime out of the situation.

Either that or really seal up the border but it doesn’t seem like that challenge is not seriously addressed. And indeed, if you want to fight the crime, make penalties harsh for those who may inadvertently help organized crime.

There is a news website that is called borderlandbeat. It is graphic in its descriptions at times so that should have a bit of a disclaimer on it.

Sometimes, their news is not even straight the newspapers because many journalists have been killed by the cartels to thwart mainstream news coverage. The nightmare stories there can be unbelievable but I do think massacres and the like are on the decline.
 
So the victim that was shot and was buried alive was a good thing? The criminal did the victim a favor by making her suffer more?
I don’t think you are intentionally trying to twist someone’s words but Luke 9:22-26 clearly shows what the poster is talking about.
** 22] And he said, “The Son of Man must suffer many things and be rejected by the elders, chief priests and teachers of the law, and he must be killed and on the third day be raised to life.”
[23] Then he said to them all: "If anyone would come after me, he must deny himself and take up his cross daily and follow me. [24] For whoever wants to save his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life for me will save it.**
This is very basic Catholic teaching. One could postulate your question as to whether Jesus was telling us to do this which would be nonsense.
 
So the victim that was shot and was buried alive was a good thing? The criminal did the victim a favor by making her suffer more?
I think we all know what Punisherthunder was saying. He meant that since suffering can be a gift, depending on how it is received, that the criminal could have submitted to it as a fair punishment for his actions. He could have died as a consequence of his own sins yet offered this suffering to Christ crucified for his own salvation.

(Like St Dismas who was crucified beside Our Lord. He was absolved on the cross and the same day he was Jesus in Paradise. The suffering of the punishment paid for the time he would have spent in purgatory.)

It doesn’t mean that the execution in Oklahoma was justified because of it or if it ever should have happened in the first place, just that he might actually have gotten a fair punishment even if it was unintentional. (See my last post if this doesn’t seem to make sense.)
 
In a nutshell, the violence in Mexico largely became inflamed cerca 2005 when one cartel, Sinaloa decided to take over the land route for transporting drugs near El Paso Texas/Juarez Mexico. That land is called the Juarez Plaza. The Sinaloa Cartel in other words, did not want to pay fees, a toll, to use that land but decided to take it over. And from there, it spread, Juarez was the so-called “murder capital of the world” for a few years but that has declined to an extent.

From there is has spread through the country, not all of it but major portions.

So, I do think it’s a little more complex than just saying Americans use drugs, that fuels the violence when previously, this kind of violence was NOT going on. No, a gang war is the reason for it, that and greed and power. But when Police Departments favor certain criminal organizations or are even cowed from dealing with the Cartels, as said, there is/was a lack of law and order and that as well is part of the problem.

Remember, it’s hard to totally pin it on American drug use when great violence happens well into the interior of Mexico in say Veracruz. I think the situation is a bit more complex.

They called out the Mexican Military but that has had limited success. Sometimes good but can not be counted on to always be “the good guys” to put a simplistic interpretation on it.

Mexico has long had a little bit of this always but it spiraled out of control. It’s probably a little better now than it has been 3 years ago, drug kingpins arrested and the auto-defensas springing up.

Though I’m not sure about being for legalization of pot as in Colorado, in ways, making it an official business does seem to take a lot, maybe most of the black market and therefore organized crime out of the situation.

Either that or really seal up the border but it doesn’t seem like that challenge is not seriously addressed. And indeed, if you want to fight the crime, make penalties harsh for those who may inadvertently help organized crime.

There is a news website that is called borderlandbeat. It is graphic in its descriptions at times so that should have a bit of a disclaimer on it.

Sometimes, their news is not even straight the newspapers because many journalists have been killed by the cartels to thwart mainstream news coverage. The nightmare stories there can be unbelievable but I do think massacres and the like are on the decline.
Thank you. I intentionally used an oversimplification in my post in order to get such a response (US drug use is a major factor in the violence in Mexico, but as you correctly pointed out it’s more complex than just that). Claiming that the lack of the death penalty is the reason for so much violence in Mexico is as much as an oversimplification of the issue as blaming it on US drug use.
 
I think we all know what Punisherthunder was saying. He meant that since suffering can be a gift, depending on how it is received, that the criminal could have submitted to it as a fair punishment for his actions. He could have died as a consequence of his own sins yet offered this suffering to Christ crucified for his own salvation.

(Like St Dismas who was crucified beside Our Lord. He was absolved on the cross and the same day he was Jesus in Paradise. The suffering of the punishment paid for the time he would have spent in purgatory.)

It doesn’t mean that the execution in Oklahoma was justified because of it or if it ever should have happened in the first place, just that he might actually have gotten a fair punishment even if it was unintentional. (See my last post if this doesn’t seem to make sense.)
I don’t see how you got that from his comment- “For people crying foul on him suffering during the execution, get over it. It is an honor to suffer like Christ did on the cross.” This quote plus the manner in which he crafted his comment, plus the listings of what these two criminals did indicate to me he was arguing against those who object to this man’s suffering due to a botched execution. His follow up comment about suffering being good and that Christ was guilty of nothing also indicates to me that he understands there is just and unjust suffering. Given that the suffering the executed criminal went through due to his botched execution was unintentional, it would have to be classified as unjust suffering. I don’t remember Christ or the Church teaching us to just “get over” unjust suffering.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top