Preventive Double Mascectomies

  • Thread starter Thread starter SubjectVerb
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

SubjectVerb

Guest
Angelina Jolie announced that she had a preventative double mascectomy because of results from genetic testing that said she had a gene that increased her risk of breast cancer. Amputating your breasts because of a risk of breast cancer but no diagnosis doesn’t sit easy with me. It seems seems like harming the integrity of your body unnecessarily, and with today’s medicine, close monitoring of your breasts by doctors should help catch cancer early.

Does the Catholic Church have a direct teaching on removing body parts for preventive reasons? Jolie also said that she has an increased risk of ovarian cancer (her mother died of it). What if she had her ovaries removed for preventive reasons? Would the Church not allow this because of procreative reasons?

Here’s the link to her op ed: nytimes.com/2013/05/14/opinion/my-medical-choice.html?_r=0"

P.S. If this belongs in the “In the News” forum, I apologize. The story gave rise to my general moral questions.
 
Angelina Jolie announced that she had a preventative double mascectomy because of results from genetic testing that said she had a gene that increased her risk of breast cancer. Amputating your breasts because of a risk of breast cancer but no diagnosis doesn’t sit easy with me. It seems seems like harming the integrity of your body unnecessarily, and with today’s medicine, close monitoring of your breasts by doctors should help catch cancer early.

Does the Catholic Church have a direct teaching on removing body parts for preventive reasons? Jolie also said that she has an increased risk of ovarian cancer (her mother died of it). What if she had her ovaries removed for preventive reasons? Would the Church not allow this because of procreative reasons?

Here’s the link to her op ed: nytimes.com/2013/05/14/opinion/my-medical-choice.html?_r=0"

P.S. If this belongs in the “In the News” forum, I apologize. The story gave rise to my general moral questions.
I honestly do not know the official Church position on this, and I really don’t think that they have one.

However, I can tell you that there is a VERY strong link between the BRACA gene and the development of breast cancer. If you have the gene it is highly likely that you will develop breast cancer. I do not see any reason to not take preventative measures. You may be harming part of your body, but you are protecting the whole body and protecting your life, which is a foremost moral duty.
 
:hmmm: yes this piece of news disturbed me too 😦

I guess she has no plan to ever breastfeed her children a known factor that dimishes the risk of breast cancer and I would bet you a trillion $ to 1 she had reconstructive plastic surgery with silicone implants a well known Cancer trigger.

So only God knows wether all this manipulation of her body will result in a positive outcome for her health.
 
:hmmm: yes this piece of news disturbed me too 😦

I guess she has no plan to ever breastfeed her children a known factor that dimishes the risk of breast cancer and I would bet you a trillion $ to 1 she had reconstructive plastic surgery with silicone implants a well known Cancer trigger.

So only God knows wether all this manipulation of her body will result in a positive outcome for her health.
She is likely not to have any more children, and if she does they will likely be adopted, so the breast feeding issue is off the table.

Most breast implants today are saline and not silicone. Silicone is very rarely used.
 
The BRACA gene increases the odds of contracting breast cancer by 87% and ovarian cancer by 50%.

That is huge.

Not to mention…her mother died from breast cancer.

I don’t think we should judge her actions in this regard. She isn’t doing it for selfish reasons. Her mother fought the disease for a decade and passed away at the age of 56…she is reported to say she did it so she would be around for her children.

I have a problem with people nitpicking about her life. Pray for her and her children. Pray for her conversion as well.
 
:hmmm: yes this piece of news disturbed me too 😦

I guess she has no plan to ever breastfeed her children a known factor that dimishes the risk of breast cancer and I would bet you a trillion $ to 1 she had reconstructive plastic surgery with silicone implants a well known Cancer trigger.

So only God knows wether all this manipulation of her body will result in a positive outcome for her health.
I am sorry, but this has nothing to do with Hollywood, and attitudes like this are harmful to women. I work with many breast cancer patients, there most certainly is an increased familial risk, and a big one at that, in certain types of breast cancer, and these types can be very aggressive and spread rapidly. Also silicone implants are no longer done–saline implants are used, also there are other types of plastic surgeries using abdominal fat and the woman’s own tissue.

She may be a Hollywood star, but she is a human being, and deserves more respect than what you are giving her. The threat of cancer is very high and she, like anyone else has a difficult and potentially life preserving decision to make. She would benefit more from your prayers than your criticism.
 
The BRACA gene increases the odds of contracting breast cancer by 87% and ovarian cancer by 50%.

That is huge.

Not to mention…her mother died from breast cancer.

I don’t think we should judge her actions in this regard. She isn’t doing it for selfish reasons. Her mother fought the disease for a decade and passed away at the age of 56…she is reported to say she did it so she would be around for her children.

I have a problem with people nitpicking about her life. Pray for her and her children. Pray for her conversion as well.
👍👍👍
 
Angelina Jolie announced that she had a preventative double mascectomy because of results from genetic testing that said she had a gene that increased her risk of breast cancer. Amputating your breasts because of a risk of breast cancer but no diagnosis doesn’t sit easy with me. It seems seems like harming the integrity of your body unnecessarily, and with today’s medicine, close monitoring of your breasts by doctors should help catch cancer early.

Does the Catholic Church have a direct teaching on removing body parts for preventive reasons? Jolie also said that she has an increased risk of ovarian cancer (her mother died of it). What if she had her ovaries removed for preventive reasons? Would the Church not allow this because of procreative reasons?..
that’s a harsh judgment towards someone with a well founded fear of cancer. would you articulate some of your personal moral concerns, other than these?
 
I am sorry, but this has nothing to do with Hollywood, and attitudes like this are harmful to women. I work with many breast cancer patients, there most certainly is an increased familial risk, and a big one at that, in certain types of breast cancer, and these types can be very aggressive and spread rapidly. Also silicone implants are no longer done–saline implants are used, also there are other types of plastic surgeries using abdominal fat and the woman’s own tissue.

She may be a Hollywood star, but she is a human being, and deserves more respect than what you are giving her. The threat of cancer is very high and she, like anyone else has a difficult and potentially life preserving decision to make. She would benefit more from your prayers than your criticism.
:amen: :clapping:
 
I am sorry, but this has nothing to do with Hollywood, and attitudes like this are harmful to women. I work with many breast cancer patients, there most certainly is an increased familial risk, and a big one at that, in certain types of breast cancer, and these types can be very aggressive and spread rapidly. Also silicone implants are no longer done–saline implants are used, also there are other types of plastic surgeries using abdominal fat and the woman’s own tissue.

She may be a Hollywood star, but she is a human being, and deserves more respect than what you are giving her. The threat of cancer is very high and she, like anyone else has a difficult and potentially life preserving decision to make. She would benefit more from your prayers than your criticism.
Very well said.
 
I am a huge breastfeeding advocate.

With that said, I personally do not take any issue with her decision or with other women who have made the same decision. This gene has been proven to increase the risk of breast cancer by 87%. That is HUGE. If there were a history of this in the women of my family and I found myself to be positive with the gene, I would consider it also. I would personally want to do it as late as possible, if that were a possibility. Don’t the risks of breast cancer increase in the late 30’s/ early 40’s? I would aim for then if at all possible.

Ultimately, we aren’t talking about a celebrity or about Hollywood or anything like that. Many women are facing their own mortality because of this disease and heightened risks of it, and are taking preventative action. The breasts are not the same as our uterus. This is not a preventative hysterectomy or anything that closes our bodies to life.

I will always do what I can to sit in alignment with Church teaching. If I am wrong and if the Church has made a statement regarding this matter, then I will learn to side with Her wisdom. 🙂
 
I am sorry, but this has nothing to do with Hollywood, and attitudes like this are harmful to women. I work with many breast cancer patients, there most certainly is an increased familial risk, and a big one at that, in certain types of breast cancer, and these types can be very aggressive and spread rapidly. Also silicone implants are no longer done–saline implants are used, also there are other types of plastic surgeries using abdominal fat and the woman’s own tissue.

She may be a Hollywood star, but she is a human being, and deserves more respect than what you are giving her. The threat of cancer is very high and she, like anyone else has a difficult and potentially life preserving decision to make. She would benefit more from your prayers than your criticism.
👍 Very well said.
 
I am pretty sure that the position of the church on this is that it is mutilation of a healthy organ so I think it would be considered a sin. I know one of the reasons wihy Tubal litigation is sinful is because is considered mutilation of a healthy organ so I think the same applies to the preventive mastectomy. Now I totally understand her fears but there are no guarantees in life. The only person who I know that got this procedure done died exactly one year after of a heart attack. On the other my great grandfather was diagnosed with bone cancer and decided he didn’t want to get any treatment at all. He ended up dying at 95 years old after spending 25 years (and he did quite good during those years) with a cancer that was never treated. So only God knows.
 
I think it’s awesome. This woman, in a town and profession OBSESSED with appearances, threw pride completely out the window and decided to have a disfiguring surgery so that she will be around to raise her children. I can’t believe you people are condemning her for it.
 
And just for the record I don’t know if there are any exception to the mutilation of a healthy organ, that is why I say that I think. If anyone has more knowledge on this sin and its details it would be great for them to chime in.
 
I am pretty sure that the position of the church on this is that it is mutilation of a healthy organ so I think it would be considered a sin. I know one of the reasons wihy Tubal litigation is sinful is because is considered mutilation of a healthy organ so I think the same applies to the preventive mastectomy. Now I totally understand her fears but there are no guarantees in life. The only person who I know that got this procedure done died exactly one year after of a heart attack. On the other my great grandfather was diagnosed with bone cancer and decided he didn’t want to get any treatment at all. He ended up dying at 95 years old after spending 25 years (and he did quite good during those years) with a cancer that was never treated. So only God knows.
The Church doesn’t approve of tubal litigations because its a procedure on a healthy organ to prevent pregnancy. Its birth control. Having a mascectomy has nothing to do with birth control as far as I understand it.
 
I am pretty sure that the position of the church on this is that it is mutilation of a healthy organ so I think it would be considered a sin. I know one of the reasons wihy Tubal litigation is sinful is because is considered mutilation of a healthy organ so I think the same applies to the preventive mastectomy. Now I totally understand her fears but there are no guarantees in life. The only person who I know that got this procedure done died exactly one year after of a heart attack. On the other my great grandfather was diagnosed with bone cancer and decided he didn’t want to get any treatment at all. He ended up dying at 95 years old after spending 25 years (and he did quite good during those years) with a cancer that was never treated. So only God knows.
Nope, it is because it closes the body to life.

Of course there is no guarantee of life, there are no guarantees of anything, but that is like saying that there is no guarantee I won’t have a heart attack so I am not going to exercise or eat right.
 
The Church doesn’t approve of tubal litigations because its a procedure on a healthy organ to prevent pregnancy. Its birth control. Having a mascectomy has nothing to do with birth control as far as I understand it.
yes that is true, but the procedure also mutilated a healthy organ. Another example of mutilation of a healthy organ is sex reassignment surgery. Mastectomies made under sex reassignment fall into the sin of mutilation of a healthy organ. Another example is that guy I don’t.remember in which state who wanted to look like a snake and had surgery to split his tongue and turn it into a snake tongue. That is mutilation of a healthy organ. What I don’t know is in her case there would be an exception because she is doing it as preventive medicine not for reassignment or to look like something else.
 
As someone waiting test results, and wondering if I have breast cancer, I can’t begin to say what I might or might not do in her situation.

Just pray for her.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top