Protestants listen up

  • Thread starter Thread starter rinnie
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If this wasnt so sad it would be hillarious. Read your own posts.
What I posted is true, because these are teachings of Christ preserved through the ages. Unfortunately, those so far away from the truth can no longer recognize it. Please come to the truth, and see. It’s wonderful. You deserve to be set free from the ignorance which currently has you in a fog.
 
If this is true, then why was this speech given only to his Apostles? Why did he not wait until there were others present, such as when he issued the Great Commission?
The good news or the gospel is that Jesus Christ came to redeem and to save us from our sins. This is the good news we are to bring to all non believers in doing so we are partaking in the ministry of reconcilliation. Reconcilling a sinner to God. In doing so we declare that God has forgiven them their sins when they confess Jesus as Lord and believe that God raised Him from the dead.
 
This is your private interpretation.
No, it’s the sad truth which accurately describes reality. The beautiful thing is that God built His one Church, which we have to teach truth. The man made churches have no real way of knowing what they’re teaching is truth or falsehood. The proof is that they will mix these up on a regular basis, as you have done.
 
Christianity is all those that follow Christ, some Catholics do some dont.
Please understand what was said, as it is very important. What was said is that Catholicism is the fullness of Christianity. The fullness of Christ’s Church subsists only in the Catholic Church. The man made churches have bits and pieces of the truth of Catholicism, but these “churches” also teach error and are deprived of five of Christ’s Sacraments. Notice that I said nothing about the adherents, as that’s a completely different discussion. It is the teachings and the Sacraments, the Magisterium, Godly Tradition, and Scriptures authored by the Catholic Church. You have to be Baptized to be a Christian, that is initiated into the Church.
 
Christ is the truth. He is not my truth He is the Truth.
Christ is the Truth. This is different that what you’ve posted, which is more often not the truth, that is not a description of the reality of Christ’s teachings nor of His Church.
 
Bible Christians attempt to live their lives based of the instructions presented in the bible----to order their steps in the word.
I know you dont know this but what is sad is that you dont care.
No, the self described “Bible Christians” live their lives based on someone’s interpretations of the Bible. I have never seen one that is accurate without error. What is sad, is that these people think they understand the word of God, when in reality it is a distortion of His word through their misguided interpretations.
 
Christ is the Truth. This is different that what you’ve posted, which is more often not the truth, that is not a description of the reality of Christ’s teachings nor of His Church.
I used to wear the same Fundamentalist blinders he wears. In actuality it was RCIA when the final pieces fell into place. Scripture started to make sense!
 
Did you read and comprehend what I said?
I did. I must ask if you understood what I said about sin. You have to put your thinking cap on, because this is a new understanding for you. I think you can understand, but from what you write, my post would be very foreign to you and very different from what you “know” about the Sacrament of Reconciliation in the Catholic Church, which is what Christ established with His instruction to the Apostles.
 
No, the self described “Bible Christians” live their lives based on someone’s interpretations of the Bible. I have never seen one that is accurate without error. What is sad, is that these people think they understand the word of God, when in reality it is a distortion of His word through their misguided interpretations.
This is so true. They don’t realize that they don’t adhere to Sola Scriptura, but rather Sola “what their Pastor says” (Sorry, don’t know thw latin for that last part!! :D)
 
Jesus gave his disciples the authority to forgive sin. If anyone is a disciple of Christ He has that authority.
No. Jesus gave His Apostles authority. These Apostles passed this down to the succeeding Bishops in the Church, who ordained Priests. These people have Apostolic Succession and can affect the Sacraments, with the authority to forgive sin. It is actually Christ, the High Priest who forgives sin.

You have no authority whatsoever to minister the Sacrament of Reconciliation. All you can do is forgive someone personally, which is not a Sacrament. You can’t just usurp this authority and claim it for yourself,when it was never intended for you. The Apostles knew better than you what Christ meant, and this was handed down through the laying on of hands of ordination.
 
So you claim that as a believer you do not have the ministry of reconciliation?
The “churches” which were born after the Reformation for instance definitely do not have ministry to perform reconciliation. The reason is that they are deprived of Apostolic Succession, which is how the authority was transferred from the Apostles to succeeding Bishops, and on down the line until today. The post Reformation “churches” for instance only have two valid Sacraments, that of Baptism and Marriage. These two Sacraments don’t require a ministerial priest. The remaining five other Sacraments are not valid in the post Reformation “churches” as these require ministerial priesthood, which requires that there be validly ordained Bishops.
 
I used to wear the same Fundamentalist blinders he wears. In actuality it was RCIA when the final pieces fell into place. Scripture started to make sense!
God bless you. I am so happy when the Holy Spirit leads God’s children to the Church. Those already formally in the Church also may need to have blinders removed as well, due to poor catechesis and outside influences which can cloud understandings. We know that the Church is not just for me and you, but for all of us. I believe you also want, as I do, for everyone to see the beauty of God’s Church, and have available all the tools of salvation, including the Most Blessed Sacrament. I want all to be able to have a closer walk with Christ, which can be done when the blinders come off and the revealed truth is seen more clearly.
 
The good news or the gospel is that Jesus Christ came to redeem and to save us from our sins. This is the good news we are to bring to all non believers in doing so we are partaking in the ministry of reconcilliation. Reconcilling a sinner to God. In doing so we declare that God has forgiven them their sins when they confess Jesus as Lord and believe that God raised Him from the dead.
No. That’s not how the Apostles taught. The washing away of original sin is done in Baptism by water and the Spirit. After that, remission of sin is through valid sacrament in God’s Catholic Church or by perfect contrition (which is by comparison, very difficult). However, you have no right to reject what Christ established.

It cheapens and waters down Christianity when someone says, all you need to do is confess Jesus is Lord, and all your sins are forgiven. This is simply a distortion of man, for convenience in not really believing as Jesus asked. This is not how God’s Church ever taught.
 
I celebrate Easter the same day you do and in conjunction with Passover. So many of my Christian family and friends clebrate it on Resurrection Sunday or Easter sunday I made a decision some years back not to draw a line in the sand on this. But at one time participating in a Messianic Jewish congregation I celebrate Christs passion on Passover and His resurection three days later.

You are correct on the meaning of the cups the 3rd cup the cup of redemption was offered at the last supper the fourth cup the cup of completion or the cup whereHe will take unto Himself a nation.

Do the third and fourth cups apply to the Jews?
There seems to be a double-standard in your accusation when you accuse the Catholic Church of using a pagan holiday to celebrate Easter, and you celebrate the same dates as Catholics do.

The 4 cups apply to all through the new and everlasting covenant. The Passover meal became the Lord’s Supper when Christ became the sacrificial Lamb.
 
Jesus gave his disciples the authority to forgive sin. If anyone is a disciple of Christ He has that authority.
Yes, you are correct. But that teaching must be passed on the same way that God passed it on. through someone with authority. That is why we have holy orders to do that. If not we would be just like you, and think we know more than the church.

The bible tell’s you Jesus said I have picked you, you have not picked me. You seem to think that your have been given authority that does not exist.

Jesus gave the disciples privileges. Read luke. Blessed are the eyes that see what I see. Many prophets and kings desired to see what you see, and do not see it, hear what you hear and do not hear it.

It is funny how yesterday was Pentecost Sunday. That is when from the sky the Holy Spirit came to the Apostles. They were all gathered in one place. I do not recall the bible saying that the HS come upon the whole earth. It did not say that did it. It says it filled the entire house in which they were. And it came to rest on each one of THEM. (were you there). They were with Jesus the whole time, and could not preach the word until that time. Read it in acts its there. They were filled with the Holy Spirit and began to SPEAK in different tongues, as the SPIRIT ENABLED them to PROCLAIM. It is that power that is HANDED down to our Bishops and Priests. IT can only come from a Bishop or Pope. Now tell me which Pope or Bishop gave you your Power?
 
Also hisalone if you read Ephesians 3:7 Paul talks of his UNIQUE Apostolic role. Paul has been given the task of explaining to all the divine plan. Through THE CHURCH Gods plan to save through Christ is is becoming mainifest to angelic beings in accord with Gods purpose.

Read on he shows how we are to become one religious community in one Body belonging to a single Lord. Now how is that possible if we do not agree with one teaching.

We a Catholics have been called many things. We are said we never change, we stick by the church, we are brainwashed, I have heard it all. Now lets see what the bible says:

But wicked people and charlatans will go from bad to worse, deceivers and deceived. But you, remain faithful to what you have learned from INFANCY you have know the SACRED SCRIPTURES which are capable of giving you wisdom fo Salvation through faith in Christ Jesus.

Yes hisalone, we have kept the teachings of our early Father’s and are very proud to have done that! Our Priests, Bishops, and Pope and all the religious order are called to Christ in this plan he has for them. To teach us the true light, of this world. TO keep us on the right road. We are warned that for the time will come when people will not tolerate sound doctine and be diverted to myths.
 
This is so true. They don’t realize that they don’t adhere to Sola Scriptura, but rather Sola “what their Pastor says” (Sorry, don’t know thw latin for that last part!! :D)
It is called

Sola Outto Pastura

.
 
Prodical lives on this forum and will attack but will file a formal complaint if you attack back, be carefull. 90% of his scripture citings are out of context. Yet he will claim his is basing on scripture, he will continue to ask you questions but never address any of yours.
One has to continue asking others questions, as some answer questions with questions. Others prefer personal attacks, for which I will report the offending post in violation of the forum rules. At this time, I’ll remind you we are to discuss topics and not individuals personally.

The interpretations I provide are Church interpretations, which I believe has the authority over private interpretations. If I am wrong, please provide scriptures stating that private interpretations are infallible. If you can’t do that, then please provide scriptures that give you the authority to say all other interpretations besides yours is wrong. It seems you think the Church has fallible interpretations and your interpretations are infallible.

I can only check in periodically while I’m on duty, but I’ll be able to catch up tomorrow and Wednesday. So please ask any questions you like. I try to answer all questions and points and expect the same courtesy in return.
 
Can you address my point?
Did Peter and Paul venerate Mary?

Heres another one, Did Peter consider himself an infallible pope?
I believe Peter and Paul honored Mary. Do you know of anything they wrote to indicate they did not?

Peter considered himself chosen and ordained, by Christ, to lead His Church, that Christ built and promised to be with until the consummation of the world… Peter believed in the infallibility of God, the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. Remember God communicated with Peter prior to His ascension and afterwards.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top