I agree with everything in this movie accept that it is an addition to say that Mary was without original sin. When the Angel greets Mary and says "Hail ye full of Grace (Gods grace) it is a bit of an overstatement to conclude that she was preserved from origninal sin. Grace = Gods undeserved love, not sinless.
It has been taught and believed from the beginning that Mary was saved from Original Sin at the moment of her conception.
So lets look at this another way, Do you believe it was impossible for God to save the Blessed Mother at the MOMENT of her conception from being tainted from any sin?
Now it is said she is indeed saved from all sin. Now God became Human through the Blessed Mother. So he indeed got his human nature through her.
Now if the Blessed Mother was indeed not preserved from Original Sin would she not have passed it down to Jesus in his human nature then?
She would have had to. Because all Original sin is inherited to us from our Parents. the first being Eve.
So she was either saved as the Apostles and Early Fathers have always taught and as the Angel stated. or she was not full of God’s grace as the angel stated and the scripture is not the true word of God.
You cannot have it both ways.
You cannot be FULL of Grace which means without ANY sin at all, and still have original sin in you.
Is not original sin indeed sin? Did Jesus have original sin? Of course not. The scripture tells us he was human in every way except in Sin.
So either the Blessed Mother was saved as the Church teaches at the moment of her conception and free from ALL sin and indeed FULL of Grace BEFORE Christ died on the cross and we all became free of Original sin.
Or you are correct and the scripture and Church are indeed both wrong and actually the whole gospel has to be wrong.
It is said she was saved for the merit of her son. Anotherwards She was saved before Christ died and because of the merit of his death. Which also lines up with the Teachings of Christ. He came here to die so we could live.
So you either have to believe she could indeed be saved by the death of Christ before it happened because God knows all that has happened, will happen because there is no time for God.
Or she could not be saved from original sin and had to have it, and if she did, she had to have passed it on to her Son.
Because there is nowhere in the Scripture that states the Father saved the Son from Original sin. It just states the Son was perfect without sin.
But it does state the Blessed Mother was indeed free from sin before the angel appeared to her. How do you feel this is possible? If not the way the Church teaches.
You say full of Grace is a stretch to believe means free from ALL sin. I believe its a stretch to believe we can have original sin and be free from all sin and full of Grace.
Another thought where is the scripture or teachings of the Fathers of the Church that teaches Jesus was cleansed from Human Sin, that he got from his Mother?
The Church teaches he never had it, because she was saved at the moment of her conception. SAVED! Many people miss the word saved.
Who saved her? Jesus the same person who saved us.
So now lets do it your way for one moment. Since we need scripture. Where is it said Jesus was saved from Original sin, and how then? Scripture only states he was Perfect, Human and Divine.
It also stated the Blessed Mother was full of Grace.
Now the early Fathers of the Church explain this, they explain how Christ was human in every way but sin, by his Mother being saved at the moment of her conception. GOd saved her by the merit of her son.
Now what is your proof? Where is your teaching?