Protestants; why won't you be CATHOLIC!?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zundrah
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
They did alot of horrible things besides sexually abusing minor boys. Hard to imagine this being the one true Church established by Christ isn’t it? Think about it, do you really believe that Christ would condone this and all other horrible atrocities in his Church (I mean his REAL Church. The Church spoken of in Matthew).
The Church does not do such things, Sellers. Sinful men, claiming to be Catholic, committed gross atrocities against the innocent. They were wolves in sheeps clothing. You are correct that the Church does not condone or support such acts, which are considered mortal sins.

The Church is the pure bride of Christ, and because she is ensouled by the HS, cannot commit such sins. Only those who have fallen away from the indwelling HS can do such things.
 
Okay, I will take a stab at this. It isn’t that I won’t become catholic, its that I haven’t been invited to learn about your faith. Frankly I get asked by Baptist all the time. I even get the occasional Episcopalian who will talk about their faith. Never has a Catholic entered into a conversation with me about what they believe. I am NOT a bible thumping Christian type person if anything I am the exact opposite. I want to know WHY you believe what you believe. The FACTS just the FACTS. Then I will make up my mind with my heart. I am not protestant or Christian Catholic or any other denomination.
Welcome to CAF Thumper! I think you will find the answers you seek here. And consider yourself invited!
Code:
I was raised by a Baptist minister who took me in when my parents past away. To abandon those teachings will take more than a "you should be Catholic" discussion.
Yes, of course! Besides, there is much of the Apostolic Tradition that has been retained by Baptists, so does not merit abandonment.
Also the few Catholics I have stumbled into have answered faith questions in a " I am Catholic and this is what the CHURCH says I am to believe." type answers. SO I turn the question around to you and ask Why SHOULD I be CATHOLIC?
What if what Catholics believe is what the Apostles believed and taught?
Why can I not just love GOD love my earthly family and do whats right. WHY MUST I be Catholic to go to heaven. For that matter why must I chose a denomination at all. Why can I just not journey in life and learn to do whats right in the sight of man and God without having to subscribe to one denomination or the other. Its like asking me if I want to drive a ford Chevy or BMW. Wont they all get me closer to God than I am now?
All very good questions. 👍
In closing I will say this. I do like that Catholics believe its a journey to salvation. I truely can subscibe to that. However questions like “why won’t you be…” will never get me closer to the answers I am looking for. Like WHO is god. WHAT must I do/believe to get to HEAVEN. WHEN will I get to see Jesus. WHERE will I go when I leave this world? And now WHY must I be (insert denomination) to get to heaven. I am more confused today than I was when I started this journey.
The Catholic church is not a “denomination”. It is the church founded by Christ. Denominations are those ecclesial communities that have left the Apostolic Faith and distinguish themselves by how much of Catholic Teaching they reject.
 
Try to observe some decorum, Zundrah. If you cannot take Jesus at His word, then you are not ready to become Catholic.
There really is an tremendous irony (or should I say hypocrisy?) in the fact that, in another thread, this young lady excoriates someone for using the word cr*p in a private message to her, but now feels free to use the phrase WTF , and moreover, uses it in connection with a belief she knows is more precious than diamonds to most of those on this forum.

The immaturity evident in this poster’s messages, particularly when the messages are seen as a whole by using the Search button, is worrying.
 
There really is an tremendous irony (or should I say hypocrisy?) in the fact that, in another thread, this young lady excoriates someone for using the word cr*p in a private message to her, but now feels free to use the phrase WTF , and moreover, uses it in connection with a belief she knows is more precious than diamonds to most of those on this forum.

The immaturity evident in this poster’s messages, particularly when the messages are seen as a whole by using the Search button, is worrying.
She is a troll and is playing people on this forum. Just read the history of her posts, it’s very obvious.
 
She is a troll and is playing people on this forum. Just read the history of her posts, it’s very obvious.
I’m sadly coming round to this point of view. For a time I thought she was sincere, but then some of the untruths began to worry me. One minute she hated attending Mass, the next she’s recommending it, one minute she’s completed an RCIA course, the next she hasn’t, one minute she’s convinced that the Catholic church is ‘her’ church, the next she’s being insulting about the core doctrine of the Eucharist.

I think she lost my sympathy when she began to respond with such extraordinarily childish and intemperate language, and swinging from one ‘tone’ to another.

I couldn’t decide which of the 3 M’s explain it. Mischief, malice or medical (broadly defined, i.e. a condition, or the influence of drugs/alcohol). A feeling that it was the third held me back up until now, but I’m suspicious now.

I would say that in any event, she needs our prayers (if indeed ‘she’ is the 21 year old girl living alone with a dog and cat that she tells us she is).

It’s tempting to get in touch with the parish she says she’s ‘joined’ and fill them in. I won’t, of course, but I hope the priest has sussed her by now. That is, provided her contact with them isn’t an untruth as well. The parish itself does exist.
 

If it won’t admit the possibility that it is corrupt, that is proof of its corruption. A corrupt Church that won’t admit its corruption, cannot be reformed. And a Church that refuses to be reformed is heading for trouble. If its apologists defend the indefensible, & minimise its crimes, they thereby condemn it as no non-Catholic ever could. :mad:

History has proven the corruption and resistance to reform
 
i didn’t know there was no sin in your church! how are you a member of a sinless church? i thought jesus said there would be tares with the wheat, in his kingdom of God, until the end. I would be careful about joining a church with no sin.
Depends on the definition… The true church is not an organization, not a series of buildings, but the body of true believers. The true church consists of those who are regenerate; that is, it consists of those who are the true Christians.
 
The Catholic church is not a “denomination”. It is the church founded by Christ. Denominations are those ecclesial communities that have left the Apostolic Faith and distinguish themselves by how much of Catholic Teaching they reject.
The Catholic Church is most cetainly a denomination.
Which do you believe has higher authority the pope or scripture?
 
Hold up here, slow down. Christ becomes present in the host. You are not “consuming” Christ, meaning “eating him up”, you are partaking in Him at mass. As he directed. He said, “This is my body, this is my blood” and directed us to have communion with him by partaking in the feast. That’s a strange and hard doctrine that cost him a lot of followers, too. “Who has ears to hear this?” was the lament.

To take part of this sacrament is not in any way to demean Christ. Instead it a participation in the divine sacrifice He performed on the cross. Christ is humbling, giving us grace motivated by his love that we did nothing to deserve.

Yes, it is unseemly to be faced with profound gift of the Eucharist. It always seems out of balance, in that you really shouldn’t be there for it. It’s not a casual thing. God is really too holy to have been concerned with all this. But, He is concerned with this. He did die on that cross, and he does offer Himself up for us again, drawing us to communion with Him.
I am so sorry but you are wating your time on me, I have given up trying to follow catholic beliefs now. But I will never leave my catholic church though.
 
There really is an tremendous irony (or should I say hypocrisy?) in the fact that, in another thread, this young lady excoriates someone for using the word cr*p in a private message to her, but now feels free to use the phrase WTF , and moreover, uses it in connection with a belief she knows is more precious than diamonds to most of those on this forum.

The immaturity evident in this poster’s messages, particularly when the messages are seen as a whole by using the Search button, is worrying.
The catholicchruch is not corrupt; only people are corrupt. And if you don’t mind I think I have eyes to read what swear words some one sends me in a private message. She said the “f” word on many, many occasions.
 
I am so sorry but you are wating your time on me, I have given up trying to follow catholic beliefs now. But I will never leave my catholic church though.
The problem is, Jennifer, is that one sentence, ’ I have given up trying to follow Catholic beliefs now’ does not go with the other’ ’ But I will never leave my Catholic chirch though’.

In what sense is it ‘your’ catholic church if you don’t believe the central doctrine?
 
The problem is, Jennifer, is that one sentence, ’ I have given up trying to follow Catholic beliefs now’ does not go with the other’ ’ But I will never leave my Catholic chirch though’.

In what sense is it ‘your’ catholic church if you don’t believe the central doctrine?
So do you think that I should leave my church? It is my church because it is Christ’s church!
 
Protestants, what ever your denomination is, please tell me why you will not be Catholic!? 🤷

xxx jennifer xxx
Because I have not discerned the Holy Spirit calling me to be Catholic. And because there are way too many rules to know let alone understand. It is my understanding that when one consents to be Catholic they are saying they know and agree with all the Church teaches and will uphold it to the best of their ability. Since I can’t know them all and I don’t believe in blind faith I am not going to be Catholic. This is subject to change if the Holy Spirit so prompts, of course.
 
Because I have not discerned the Holy Spirit calling me to be Catholic. And because there are way too many rules to know let alone understand. It is my understanding that when one consents to be Catholic they are saying they know and agree with all the Church teaches and will uphold it to the best of their ability. Since I can’t know them all and I don’t believe in blind faith I am not going to be Catholic. This is subject to change if the Holy Spirit so prompts, of course.
This is a very clear way to look at it.

xxx zundrah xxx
 
For your convenience I even linked every single Bible reference to a quote online…
Because protestants believe in lies.
That is completely unfounded.
They don’t like infallibility of the pope - they prefer their own infallibility:D as a result there are thousands of protestant popes: 2 Tm 4, 3 they will collect themselves a whole series of teachers according to their own tastes; (dear separated brethren, please pray for a gift of humility for yourselves). Jesus said: this is my Body, this is my Blood, but protestant non-believers know better than Jesus - it’s just bread and wine.
We do believe that every human being is fallible and born sinful and that does not exclude the pope, the magisterium or even Mary.
I am not Protestant because Protestants don’t obey the vicar of Christ…
The pope is not the vicar of Christ. The Vicar of Christ is the Holy Spirit… We do obey the Vicar of Christ… we just don’t obey the pope.
John 14:16, John 14:26, John 16:13, 1 Corinthians 2:11-13
…have no Real Presence and no Eucharistic miracles…
We refuse to accept a wafer God that has to be eaten. Jesus Christ died on the Cross and said that it was finished. We celebrate our communion Sunday in remembrance of Him, not eating “Him” in the form of a wafer.
John 6:33-35, John 6:40, John 6:63
…no sacrament of reconcilliation…
There is no need for a sacrament of reconciliation: We confess our sins to God and we should do that daily… For the purpose of spiritual guidance we may talk to a pastor, but we don’t have to confess to a priest.
Psalm 32:5, 1 John 1:9
…no stigmata, no Lourdes, no Fatima, no Guadalupe, no apparitions of Jesus and messages for the world (Faustina)…
We don’t need questionable apparitions to guide us… we have God’s Word in the Bible.
Miraclesceptic.com, Devilsfinalbattle.com
…preach nonsenses…
That is purely your opinion… You might not like it, but there are quite a few biblically founded preachers out there whose listeners are not there to get their ears tickled.
…and have really bad ideas (David Koresh, Jim Jones)…
You don’t really consider these men Christians, do you? I mean you might as well call Sai Baba a Christian and it would not make much of a difference to me, because He isn’t. You might call Joel Osteen a good preacher too, but he is a mere motivational speaker and not preaching the Gospel.
…are illogical - not able to answer why their denomination is the right one - prefer being generally “Christian”…
My “denomination” is not the right one. I am sure that the true church is more than just one denomination or one organisation or even a couple of buildings. It is the body of Christ and as a such the true church consists of all true Christians may they be Baptist, Methodist or any other denomination… Quite a few Catholics might be among those too…
…money Gospel, too strict or too liberal - blessing gay couples etc., …
We all know what God tells us about this in the Bible and I disagree with organisations that bless such behavior and even ordain these people.
Concerning the “prosperity Gospel” you are right, but true Christians do not go for that anyways…
…irritating and annoying way of preaching, ridiculous names of their denominations…
Another one of those personal problems you have? If you want to talk seriously, refrain from insults that are unfounded… it does not reflect too positively upon yourself if you don’t.
 
I can’t become catholic because I can’t believe in the Eucharist. 😦 I will however never leave my catholic church! 😃
You are one confused cookie! you do not believe in the practices of the holy catholic church, but you will attend services. You also show that you are methodist and catholic? I come from a long line of methodist minister and went to siminary to becom one myself and they are nothing like each other and teach verry differently! It was only when I recieved a college education on christianity did I aknowledge and embrace the Catholic church! Since it is obviouse that you are verry confused, perhaps you should do the same for a house devided cannot stand and nor will your soul! Good luck!
 
For your convenience I even linked every single Bible reference to a quote online…

That is completely unfounded.

We do believe that every human being is fallible and born sinful and that does not exclude the pope, the magisterium or even Mary.

The pope is not the vicar of Christ. The Vicar of Christ is the Holy Spirit… We do obey the Vicar of Christ… we just don’t obey the pope.
John 14:16, John 14:26, John 16:13, 1 Corinthians 2:11-13

We refuse to accept a wafer God that has to be eaten. Jesus Christ died on the Cross and said that it was finished. We celebrate our communion Sunday in remembrance of Him, not eating “Him” in the form of a wafer.
John 6:33-35, John 6:40, John 6:63

There is no need for a sacrament of reconciliation: We confess our sins to God and we should do that daily… For the purpose of spiritual guidance we may talk to a pastor, but we don’t have to confess to a priest.
Psalm 32:5, 1 John 1:9

We don’t need questionable apparitions to guide us… we have God’s Word in the Bible.
Miraclesceptic.com, Devilsfinalbattle.com

That is purely your opinion… You might not like it, but there are quite a few biblically founded preachers out there whose listeners are not there to get their ears tickled.

You don’t really consider these men Christians, do you? I mean you might as well call Sai Baba a Christian and it would not make much of a difference to me, because He isn’t. You might call Joel Osteen a good preacher too, but he is a mere motivational speaker and not preaching the Gospel.

My “denomination” is not the right one. I am sure that the true church is more than just one denomination or one organisation or even a couple of buildings. It is the body of Christ and as a such the true church consists of all true Christians may they be Baptist, Methodist or any other denomination… Quite a few Catholics might be among those too…

We all know what God tells us about this in the Bible and I disagree with organisations that bless such behavior and even ordain these people.
Concerning the “prosperity Gospel” you are right, but true Christians do not go for that anyways…

Another one of those personal problems you have? If you want to talk seriously, refrain from insults that are unfounded… it does not reflect too positively upon yourself if you don’t.
I like how you speak of opinion! that is what your beliefs are based off of; opinions not truth. I was once protestant until I recieved a college education in siminary on chritianity. Let me let you in on somthing that Baptists and other protestant religions teach. They teach that Catholics are not save becasue they believe they are saved by works and not faith, but think about it! If you are really saved and filled with the holy spirit than you cannot help but do works and those works Christ liked to call fruits! at the same baptist say you must be baptized to be saved, but why would you not call that a work? It is true! you must be baptized and you are compeled to do such a “work” becasue of your faith and love for Christ! I am sad to see that you have left the holy church for a counterfeit. I will pray for you!
 
i didn’t know there was no sin in your church! how are you a member of a sinless church? i thought jesus said there would be tares with the wheat, in his kingdom of God, until the end. I would be careful about joining a church with no sin.
You certainly have no worries in that department.
 
Welcome to CAF Thumper! I think you will find the answers you seek here. And consider yourself invited!

Yes, of course! Besides, there is much of the Apostolic Tradition that has been retained by Baptists, so does not merit abandonment.

What if what Catholics believe is what the Apostles believed and taught?

All very good questions. 👍

The Catholic church is not a “denomination”. It is the church founded by Christ. Denominations are those ecclesial communities that have left the Apostolic Faith and distinguish themselves by how much of Catholic Teaching they reject.
The catholic Church is not a denomination but the Church Christ founded. The Catholic church IS a denomination and is an institution NOT founded by Christ.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top