Quran 5:116

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jay53
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
**JC, Thanks. More good news. I always respected Pilate who tried his best to save beloved Jesus. That was enough of him. He was pressurised by the enemies of Jesus to deliver Jesus into the hands of the devils. Such devils are called Kafir in the Quran.

Now I am wondering, if people in Africa could be honoring Pilate and his wife, how much more they may be doing for Mary, the mother of Jesus.

**
 
** swariffin, Cannonised by Planten at this moment. Thanks to J C.
I have broken the ice with this news**.
:rotfl: I think you are a serious kind of person, my dear friend. I just realize that you can be joking too.
 
I know that there is a gospel of Pilate, who tried its best to point out how innocense Pilate was. But historically speaking, Pilate was sent to Galia (not France) in year 38 AD, and committed suicide there. It was under emperor Caligula if I am not mistaken, but I can check later.
 
I thought this may be interesting for you all.

Very recently a priest explained the “Catholic” understanding of saints.

It is like a corporation and God is the head of it, with much to be done He delegates jobs and this is why people pray to saints.

As you know from my posts it is far from my belief.

It is not my understanding of Catholic teaching.

It is far from the sharing i have seen here.

He is a priest i guess he has a better understanding but tried to offer an understanding. People in that parish put absolute trust in priests and call them Father repeat their words and follow their way.

my point is how easy oral teachings can mess up the truth even when well intended.
 
Cannonized by whom and in what year? That is a good info.
SHe may not have ever been Cannonized. Many of the saints were made saints more by popular acclaim or just because they should be.

The vast majority of the saints in the Bible (Peter, The BVM, etc) were never cannonized. They are just Saints.

There are traditions that say that Pilot’s wife became a Christian and eventually left Pilot, living in Jerusalem, hidden until he left for Gaul.
 
Would that be revealed or inspired?
**Could not be any revelation to me. At the most it could be called inspired, or inner feeling because God informed (warned) the wife of Pilate of some thing. That was in the dream, most likely. She said that she suffered a lot due to the case of Jesus.

She called Jesus an innocent man (see bibleNT). She acted on the advice of God and informed her husband. She tried to do what she was told and tried to save Jesus.

I just had an idea about it. But long ago, I was told by some very learned person that wife of Pilate was a believer and follower of Jesus, we could say “She loved Jesus as a righteous person.” But I ignored all that information. I just used to feel well for her not knowing about her Cannonisation.

J C has done it all (gifted me) by giving more information that she was Cannonised and well respected in the eastern orthodox church in Africa. So I tried to take the blame of her Cannonisation. I hope not much of my fault. There is nothing adverse in the bible about that good lady. May Allah bless her with forgiveness and higher ranks in heavens.**
 
**Could not be any revelation to me. At the most it could be called inspired, or inner feeling because God informed (warned) the wife of Pilate of some thing. That was in the dream, most likely. She said that she suffered a lot due to the case of Jesus.

She called Jesus an innocent man (see bibleNT). She acted on the advice of God and informed her husband. She tried to do what she was told and tried to save Jesus.

I just had an idea about it. But long ago, I was told by some very learned person that wife of Pilate was a believer and follower of Jesus, we could say “She loved Jesus as a righteous person.” But I ignored all that information. I just used to feel well for her not knowing about her Cannonisation.

J C has done it all (gifted me) by giving more information that she was Cannonised and well respected in the eastern orthodox church in Africa. So I tried to take the blame of her Cannonisation. I hope not much of my fault. There is nothing adverse in the bible about that good lady. May Allah bless her with forgiveness and higher ranks in heavens.**
If in fact that the wife of Pilate was a Christian at that time, or at least during the time when the gospel were written, she would have caught the attention of the gospel writers. There would be more detail written about her. The early Christians were like to gather together discussing the teaching of Jesus and breaking bread (Act 2:42). No way that a Christian to live by his/her self without any contact with other Christians. Being the wife or ex-wife of Pilate during the early Christian time, should gain attention of many fellow Christians, and her life would have been discussed by many. It is also interesting that only Matthew wrote this, not with other gospel writers. The fact that Jesus was considered as a “great man” was well known already even to the non-believer. So, the fact that Pilate’s wife said that Jesus was a great man, could not be crucial. Saying that God or angel sent the message to Pilate’s wife is purely speculative.
 
To be fair many Catholics pray straight to God, others ask the saints for intercession.

You would have to explain why people who have prayed to the Saints for intercession recieved an answered prayer.
I’d wish to add that many of us pray to God AND to the saints.
And that those who pray to the saints often ask them to join them in their prayer to God…
 
Absolutely.

If Jesus didn’t teach you how to pray to saints, then who did? Or, not you, but those Catholics who ask saints for “intercession.” Why didn’t Jesus teach it? Rhetorical question.
Do you absolutely need words from Jesus?
Jesus’mother interceded to him on behalf of those in the wedding feast of Cana (John 2). It doesn’t say if she was asked by anyone to do so, of course, but intercession bore fruit!
Also, in the Old Testament, you must have seen the wonders that the prophet Elisha performed in little things. Like Naaman the Syrian who came to be purified of his leper. Elisha then asked of him to bathe 7 times in the Jordan river. Naaman at first was furious and refused, but then he changed his mind and did what Elisha told him. And Naaman was purified and cured.
And once, when Elisha was dead, somebody threw a companion’s dead body into Elisha’s tomb, just to escape bandits more easily. Why and how did the corpse, when come into contact with Elisha’s bones, come back to life, I don’t know. I only know that it is reported in the 2nd Book of Kings that it did!!!
 
Sister Amy, do you yourself take only what Jesus said as Jesus’ teachings, like it seems to be the case for a good number of Muslims, at least here on CAFs?
My understanding is that you came from a Protestant background. Well, to my knowledge they don’t take only Jesus’ words as His teachings. His works also are powerful works of God. Also, what the whole New Testament teaches authentically comes from Jesus through the Holy Spirit, not just the Gospels.
(Cradle Muslims disagree, but they were not raised in our faith, while you, unless I am mistaken, should be aware of this.)
 
Muslims believe that everyone is going to be held accountable.(QUOTE)

Christians and observant Jews believe this, too!

(QUOTE) About saints performing miracles (even so-called “saints” in Islam), I generally discount them totally. That’s my personal opinion, because I don’t have any verifiable proof. Nobody can really prove they happened (or, for that matter, can prove that they didn’t happen.) So I won’t argue it with you.
I’m sure you know my opinion about praying to saints (if not, my opinion is that it’s a big no-no) and my proof (namely, the Qur’an, which I believe to be the miraculously revealed word of God.)
(QUOTE)
Ah, yes! This also is what the Evangelical Protestants would teach, I don’t know how nor when they came to the conclusion that prayers to the saints are wrong. But that conclusion must have been made after certain particular cases of disorder in the area of prayer aroused, and might have thought that praying to the saints in all cases is disorder…

I generally try to avoid (I fail more often than I’d like unfortunately) arguing for or against something in Christianity based on Christian sources (i.e., the Bible), because I’m not an expert on those sources, nor are they (to me) sufficiently binding proof of anything whether they agree with me or not.

Sorry.

Maybe it does seem like I have a twisted way of arguing…
 
Muslims believe that everyone is going to be held accountable.

About saints performing miracles (even so-called “saints” in Islam), I generally discount them totally. That’s my personal opinion, because I don’t have any verifiable proof. Nobody can really prove they happened (or, for that matter, can prove that they didn’t happen.) So I won’t argue it with you.

I’m sure you know my opinion about praying to saints (if not, my opinion is that it’s a big no-no) and my proof (namely, the Qur’an, which I believe to be the miraculously revealed word of God.)

I generally try to avoid (I fail more often than I’d like unfortunately) arguing for or against something in Christianity based on Christian sources (i.e., the Bible), because I’m not an expert on those sources, nor are they (to me) sufficiently binding proof of anything whether they agree with me or not.

Sorry.

Maybe it does seem like I have a twisted way of arguing…
Oops! I did it again!!!
The preceding post of mine should read these words as all being Sister Amy’s, not mine. The rest are my words.
Moreover, I meant not to include the quote starting with “I generally try to avoid(…)” to the end of the quote. As they appeared, one could think the words are mine but they aren’t.

How do you separate the quotes from your words when they are many? Up to now I was unsuccessful in leaving my own words outside of the coloured rectangles between two quotes. How do you do that? Can someone explain it to me, please?
Thank you…
 
How do you separate the quotes from your words when they are many? Up to now I was unsuccessful in leaving my own words outside of the coloured rectangles between two quotes. How do you do that? Can someone explain it to me, please?
Thank you…
Type your statement…
You can type something like this and if you want to place it in a quote, highlight it as I will do now… the click on the little icon called (wrap quote tags around selected text).
It’s the **one to the left **of the pound/hash mark… #

All my best,
Pam
New York
 
**

So angels are useful and they are communicating, bringing messages and the will of God to people, specially to the prophets, in large quantity and high quality messages.

In Quran, it is written that God sent messages to :
  1. The mother of Moses a.s.
  2. The mother of Jesus a.s.
  3. The apostles of Jesus a.s.
    even though they were non prophets.
and of course to Moses a.s. and Jesus a.s. much more of those things was given, care of the angels.**The Qu’ran forgot to mention also Joseph, spouse of Mary, Jesus’ mother, who received one of Gabriel’s announciation according to the Gospel according to Matthew, chapter 1 or 2 (I don’t have the NT in front of me, but the passage about this is in one of those two chapters, I am sure of this!)
 
Type your statement…

It’s the **one to the left **of the pound/hash mark… #

All my best,
Pam
New York
Adding to the assistance of your inquiry. If you want to browse and copy/quote scroll down to the statment of the invidual user, highlight what you need to address, and then copy and paste.

Once copy/paste is done, highlight it and then click on the quote icon.

All my best again,
Pam
New York
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top