C
carn
Guest
The point is, when the president is allowed from the constitution to spend the tax payers money on bringing people to the moon, but is in doubt whether all that NASA math and science does add up to bringing people to the moon, it is at worst a small mistake if he just says “They are the experts, i trust them.” and spends the money.Imagine it this way: you have a room full of economics experts at a meeting at the white house who are debating solutions to economics problems. Next door is a NASA meeting discussing the return to the moon. A few of the aeronautics scientists grow bored and wander into the economics meeting. What do they say that is of use to the meeting? “We can get to the moon but you can’t figure out how to reduce unemployment?”
If he doesn’t think the economics make much sense, it would be possibly a huge mistake if he just says “They are experts, i trust them.” and spends the money.
Because tax payers can expect that their money is spend wise and if there is doubt whether the money spend will have the intended effect, it should be at least carefully thought about, whether sucess is likely enough to try. With blindly trusting the NASA experts the president although having personally doubt does not fail there (except maybe for the size of the final sum, they know space travel but not efficient funding). With blindly trusting the economic experts although he has also personally doubt the president fails.
Therefore when listening to the experts of a field and basing our decisions on their advice, one should keep in mind that the reliability of experts differs. You shouldn’t just agree with the expert opinion if it is in a field, where even the experts have little reliable knowledge.
And you should not assume that the expert opinion in a unreliable field is close to objective truth. While doing the latter in some fields regarding their subject is acceptable (e.g. we can safely assume that for the current definitions of “sun”, “earth”, “center of mass”, “km” that it is close to objective truth that the earth is 150 million km away from the sun. But it would be stupid to safely assume that it is close to objective truth that x billion dollars of stimulus spending will end the recesssion - although there are experts claiming this, at best this is an educated guess.)