Senate Scuttles Gun Limits

  • Thread starter Thread starter MattinTex
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
According to this logic, should we also refrain from enacting laws that limit alcohol consumption while driving since such laws infringe upon the legal rights of responsible, law-abiding citizens to drink? Perhaps we should target only those people whose medical records indicate they are alcoholics and leave the rest of the population alone to drink as much alcohol as they desire? After all, how do we know they might injure or kill others or themselves while driving under the influence? These are law-abiding, non-alcoholic drivers who should have a legal right to consume alcohol whenever they wish provided they are old enough to do so. Should we leave it entirely up to them to decide how much alcohol they wish to drink before driving?
meltzerboy I was looking forward to your response but this isn’t worthy of your usual level of argument. There is no correlation between number of bullets or number of guns owned and number of drinks consumed before one is impaired. Conceivably one could own thousands of guns and tens of thousands of bullets and be no threat to anyone. However beyond a certain limit ALL drivers are impaired.

You can do better and while you’re at it, respond to the many questions and facts posed here. I would really like to know if there is a reasonable argument for additional gun control and clip limits.

Lisa
 
It would be better if Democratic politicians were more open about their motives for gun control. The Democratic Party has presided over the murder of over 55 million children in this country. They fight for it, they preside over it and they glory in it. They are the worst mass murderers of children that history have ever known.

So when the Democrats say that they want to take away guns to protect children, this is like the Nazis saying that they want to take away guns to protect Jews. I cannot fathom why anyone would possibly be fooled by such rhetoric.

If only they would be honest, the discussion would be easier.
 
According to this logic, should we also refrain from enacting laws that limit alcohol consumption while driving since such laws infringe upon the legal rights of responsible, law-abiding citizens to drink?
Those laws already exist. In most states and cities it is illegal to serve an intoxicated person alcohol.

www.nhtsa.gov/DOT/NHTSA/…/Articles/…/811142.pdf
Perhaps we should target only those people whose medical records indicate they are alcoholics and leave the rest of the population alone to drink as much alcohol as they individually feel they are entitled to?
While it is not against the law to do so, bars are allowed to refuse service to people with medical issues without fear of legal reprisal - for instance most decent bars will not serve alcohol to an abviously pregnant woman. So a woman’s legal rights are limited by the state and can be taken advantage of by the public.
 
The old love it or leave it. Haven’t heard that golden oldie in a while.
Gun control already exists to varying degrees across the country and generally always has. Old west towns would require people to surrender their weapons for the duration of their stay, I can’t legally own an operational M-50 machine gun, or a grenade launcher or…This vote was about background checks and is far from dead.
Phase two will see who is more effective at beating their opponent over the head with their own words and proposals, or lack thereof. The Gang of 45 has to hope fervently that there isn’t another mass killing.
Agreed. But then OTOH while I may worry about many things, Commander in Chief Barack Hussein Obama sending the military after me with grenades is not something I lose much sleep over.
 
… I would really like to know if there is a reasonable argument for additional gun control and clip limits.

Lisa
sure there are. background checks for mental illness, if it doesn’t include the exercise of discretion by a non-physician; imposing civil and criminal liability on transferors for damage/crimes committed by the transferee if the transfer were illegal; required safety courses for first time possessors.

I’d be more worried about preventing accidents, the shootings are going to happen no matter what, and if not by gun, then the perp will use something else.

most gun control advocates are anti-gun, and not interested in controls that are consistent with second amendment rights.

re clips. you probably mean magazine limits. I can’t think of any reasonable arguments for limits. anyone who has used magazines knows that the bigger ones will jam more often than the smaller ones so there’s an incentive to make them bigger.

F/
 
meltzerboy I was looking forward to your response but this isn’t worthy of your usual level of argument. There is no correlation between number of bullets or number of guns owned and number of drinks consumed before one is impaired. Conceivably one could own thousands of guns and tens of thousands of bullets and be no threat to anyone. However beyond a certain limit ALL drivers are impaired.

You can do better and while you’re at it, respond to the many questions and facts posed here. I would really like to know if there is a reasonable argument for additional gun control and clip limits.

Lisa
Amendment 2.5 of the Bill of Needs:

Escapism being necessary to the functioning of a polite society, the -]right/-] need of the people to drink and operate heavy machinery, shall not be infringed.
 
meltzerboy I was looking forward to your response but this isn’t worthy of your usual level of argument. There is no correlation between number of bullets or number of guns owned and number of drinks consumed before one is impaired. Conceivably one could own thousands of guns and tens of thousands of bullets and be no threat to anyone. However beyond a certain limit ALL drivers are impaired.

You can do better and while you’re at it, respond to the many questions and facts posed here. I would really like to know if there is a reasonable argument for additional gun control and clip limits.

Lisa
And conceivably one may be able to hold one’s liquor and not be impaired enough to get into an accident on the road but still get arrested for testing over the legal limits. I was pushing Sam’s argument to its (legal) limit. Where do individual rights end and where does the general welfare of society begin: an age-old controversy? Take the case of Mayor Bloomberg’s ban on smoking in restaurants, which has worked out well (contrary to initial resentment by both restaurant owners and smokers). There are certain health effects of second-hand smoke on others, to be sure, but no greater than the deleterious effects of exhaust fumes from cars which poison the atmosphere all civilians breathe.

I agree with you, Lisa, that effective gun control is what we need. That would, of course, mean that dangerously mentally ill people should be kept from buying guns. However this too poses some problems regarding how we would activate such a policy, if not by means of background checks on all civilians. That is, should we have a national register which targets the names of all people who have suffered from mental and emotional illness by using hospital records, despite the invasion of privacy and confidentiality as well as the fact most people who fit this category are NOT dangerous? Further, people who buy guns may become dangerous due to mental illness but not be suffering from mental illness at the time of purchase. I’m not claiming that background checks are a panacea; far from it. But they may thwart some dangerous people by putting an obstacle in their path and making them think twice before attempting to purchase a weapon. It’s at least a start, together with enforcing the laws already on the books. Otherwise, what we’re doing is analogous to what you mentioned in referring to “gun-free zones”; that is, providing a free invitation to one and all to exercise their legal rights to purchase guns and ammunition of mostly any kind regardless of what their intentions may be.
 
sure there are. background checks for mental illness, if it doesn’t include the exercise of discretion by a non-physician; imposing civil and criminal liability on transferors for damage/crimes committed by the transferee if the transfer were illegal; required safety courses for first time possessors.

I’d be more worried about preventing accidents, the shootings are going to happen no matter what, and if not by gun, then the perp will use something else.

most gun control advocates are anti-gun, and not interested in controls that are consistent with second amendment rights.

re clips. you probably mean magazine limits. I can’t think of any reasonable arguments for limits. anyone who has used magazines knows that the bigger ones will jam more often than the smaller ones so there’s an incentive to make them bigger.

F/
Thanks for the response. I have mentioned mental illness and psychtropic drugs several times but so far none of the gun control advocates have addressed these issues–factors in all of the mass shootings apparently.

The mental illness restriction would be extremely difficult. Who has the power to deem a person potentially violent since most mental illness is not associated wtih violent behavior? Ditto with psychtropic drugs that also factored in the mass shootings. But the failure to address these issues demonstrates the validity of your comment above (bolded). I think most of the focus on gun control is based on political leanings and ideology rather than a sincere belief that such laws would actually make a difference in gun violence. Oh and I’m not so hypocritical to claim that those opposed to additional gun control are not similarly politically entrenched in their position. However I do believe the facts are against the effectiveness of these gun control proposals.

Lisa
 
How about EFFECTIVE gun control?

Again would you, whom I think of as a thoughtful person, please address the many facts posted regarding our current laws, that they are not being enforced, that the proposals would not have stopped any of the mass shooters, that “gun free zones” seem to be more of an attraction than a deterrent, that concealed carry laws have allowed responsible citizens to deal with or stop crime? What about the mental health issue? I believe you are a professional in mental health/psychiatry aren’t you? What about the explosion in use of psychtropic drugs to treat disturbed young men? What about DiFi’s admission that her proposals wouldn’t have stopped the Newtown Shooter?

The other element in the room is the profile of the victims. Apparently killing young people weekly in gang banger shootings doesn’t even warrent a comment. The shooters and the victims tend to be poor and members of minority groups. However should some upper class cute white kids get killed by another upper class white kid, it’s pull out all the stops to restrict gun ownership. Oddly our black President, a former resident of Chicago, can’t be bothered to address gun violence in his own city directed toward (and by) people of his own minority status. Go figure:shrug:

I just bet that 99.99% of Americans are for gun control if it means guns are not available to criminals or violent mental illness patients. I bet 99.99% of Americans are for background checks that would prevent criminals and the violent mentally ill persons from obtaining guns.

So of COURSE one can be a gun owner and for “gun control.” Let’s not reiterate the obvious but consider what would have stopped the mass shooters, knowing that we cannot prevent every single such crime but can only take reasonable measures to prevent lunatics and violent loners (the profile of such shooters generally) from getting guns.

Lisa
How about effective crime control?

Somebody sets off a bomb and kills someone, you know …
 
And conceivably one may be able to hold one’s liquor and not be impaired enough to get into an accident on the road but still get arrested for testing over the legal limits. I was pushing Sam’s argument to its (legal) limit. Where do individual rights end and where does the general welfare of society begin: an age-old controversy? Take the case of Mayor Bloomberg’s ban on smoking in restaurants, which has worked out well (contrary to initial resentment by both restaurant owners and smokers). There are certain health effects of second-hand smoke on others, to be sure, but no greater than the deleterious effects of exhaust fumes from cars which poison the atmosphere all civilians breathe. .
But again, driving IS impaired by drugs and alcohol. We can scientifically test reflexes and response times and prove that drinking/drugging and driving provides an unacceptable level of risk to both the person and society. We can look at accident reports and note the higher percentage of drivers involved in accidents who are intoxicated.

But we have no way of correlating a particular level of gun ownership and participating in violent behavior.

Further we have extensive background check requirements and some cities have very strict gun laws but they have proven to be ineffective in stopping criminals from using and obtaining guns. I just saw an article about gun violence INCREASING once Massachusetts enacted strict gun laws. Apparently it DID reduce the number of guns being registered but only because otherwise law abiding citizens were giving up their guns, rather than the criminals.
I agree with you, Lisa, that effective gun control is what we need. That would, of course, mean that dangerously mentally ill people should be kept from buying guns. However this too poses some problems regarding how we would activate such a policy, if not by means of background checks on all civilians. That is, should we have a national register which singles out the names of all people who have suffered from mental and emotional illness by using hospital records, despite the invasion of privacy and confidentiality as well as the fact most people who fit this category are NOT dangerous? Further, people who buy guns may become dangerous due to mental illness but not be suffering from mental illness at the time of purchase. I’m not claiming that background checks are a panacea; far from it. But they may thwart some dangerous people by putting an obstacle in their path and making them think twice before attempting to purchase a weapon. It’s at least a start, together with enforcing the laws already on the books. Otherwise, what we’re doing is analogous to what you mentioned in referring to “gun-free zones”; that is, providing a free invitation to one and all to exercise their legal rights to purchase guns and ammunition of mostly any kind regardless of what their intentions may be.
But again we HAVE background checks laws on the books. They DO prevent people from buying guns legally but a) those who violate the laws are not being prosecuted and b) this doesn’t stop criminals from obtaining guns illegally.

What further background check or restriction do you think would stop or even slow the level of gun violence? Remember that the guns used in Sandy Hook WERE obtained legally in a state with very strict gun laws. You can’t legislate away stupidity and poor judgment.

Agree totally on the mental health issue. I think it’s apparent this is a factor but the level of inquiry and invasion of privacy would not be possible in this country (and for that to a great extent I am glad). However in cases where officials ARE warned such as with respect to the Batman Shooter, shouldn’t they be compelled to act?
Lisa
 
How about effective crime control?

Somebody sets off a bomb and kills someone, you know …
👍

A reality check: The Boston bombers did not have any of the necessary permits (Firearms ID card) to purchase or own firearms. This card requires a background check which is on permanent file. They were also in violation of the 10 round magazine limit. Adam Lanza attempted to purchase a long gun but refused to wait 14 days for the background check so he also lacked Connecticut State firearms permit. Laws were in place and ignored. Does that mean tougher laws would have been obeyed? Kinda like well, we were only kidding about those laws, but we really mean these new ones. Right. :rolleyes:
 
Thanks for the response. I have mentioned mental illness and psychtropic drugs several times but so far none of the gun control advocates have addressed these issues–factors in all of the mass shootings apparently.

The mental illness restriction would be extremely difficult. Who has the power to deem a person potentially violent since most mental illness is not associated wtih violent behavior? Ditto with psychtropic drugs that also factored in the mass shootings. But the failure to address these issues demonstrates the validity of your comment above (bolded). I think most of the focus on gun control is based on political leanings and ideology rather than a sincere belief that such laws would actually make a difference in gun violence. Oh and I’m not so hypocritical to claim that those opposed to additional gun control are not similarly politically entrenched in their position. However I do believe the facts are against the effectiveness of these gun control proposals.

Lisa
the mental health check would be hard to implement but not impossible. its not the perfect solution but as a stopgap measure, it can work in part. the thing to avoid would be to put the power to decide who is mentally unstable in the hands of some clerk or sheriff or who isn’t a medical professional. and then only if there are medical records of some sort.

untreated mental health problems obviously slip through but there’s not much to do about it.

the mass shooting victims are now just political tools, I doubt they were ever much more than that. grabbers don’t need x deaths, they need a death, because, as the preznit says, if we can only save one, then any restriction can be justified. did you know that yesterday, 315 million Americans weren’t shot. today, another 315 won’t be shot either.

I don’t know if its been said here, but the bottom line is that this is the price for our open society. as horrific as it is, the relentless press coverage makes it magnitudes worse.

if I wanted to live in a restrictive country, I’d move to Europe or Asia.

F/
 
the mental health check would be hard to implement but not impossible. its not the perfect solution but as a stopgap measure, it can work in part. the thing to avoid would be to put the power to decide who is mentally unstable in the hands of some clerk or sheriff or who isn’t a medical professional. and then only if there are medical records of some sort.

untreated mental health problems obviously slip through but there’s not much to do about it.

the mass shooting victims are now just political tools, I doubt they were ever much more than that. grabbers don’t need x deaths, they need a death, because, as the preznit says, if we can only save one, then any restriction can be justified. did you know that yesterday, 315 million Americans weren’t shot. today, another 315 won’t be shot either.

I don’t know if its been said here, but the bottom line is that this is the price for our open society. as horrific as it is,*** the relentless press coverage makes it magnitudes worse***.

if I wanted to live in a restrictive country, I’d move to Europe or Asia.

F/
Two points in agreement with the above. The “if it only saves one” argument is applied ONLY to guns isn’t it? The obvious hypocrisy in this statement is apparent when other potentially lifesaving actions are considered.

Second your point about relentless press coverage is worthy of note. Shortly after the Sandy Hook shooting I heard several interviews with an expert on causes of these mass shootings. He said the hysteria, wall to wall press coverage, the investigation of the shooter’s background, life, and thoughts to the nth degree help to create these monsters. He noted that they are without exception “losers” who wish to leave a legacy, even if they are not alive to enjoy it. While we do support our free press, clearly the coverage bears some responsibility in inspiring if not instructing these killers. Maybe along with gun restrictions we should suggest duct tape on the mouths of the talking heads :D. Well maybe not since the media is aligned with the gun control advocates…

LIsa
 
According to this logic, should we also refrain from enacting laws that limit alcohol consumption while driving since such laws infringe upon the legal rights of responsible, law-abiding citizens to drink a legal substance? Perhaps we should target only those people whose medical records indicate they are alcoholics and leave the rest of the population alone to drink as much alcohol as they desire? After all, how do we know they might injure or kill others or themselves while driving under the influence? These are law-abiding, non-alcoholic drivers who should have a legal right to consume alcohol whenever they wish provided they are old enough to do so. Should we leave it entirely up to them to decide how much alcohol they wish to drink before driving?
Malum in se vs malum prohibitum.
 
Two points in agreement with the above. The “if it only saves one” argument is applied ONLY to guns isn’t it? The obvious hypocrisy in this statement is apparent when other potentially lifesaving actions are considered.

LIsa
Agreed. The government kills more people with CAFE limits every year than civilian owned “assault weapons”.

greenhellblog.com/2009/05/19/cafe-obama-proposed-mileage-standards-would-kill-more-americans-than-iraq-war/
The National Academy of Sciences has linked mileage standards with about 2,000 deaths per year. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration estimates that every 100-pound reduction in the weight of small cars increases annual traffic fatalities by as much as 715.
 
Two points in agreement with the above. The “if it only saves one” argument is applied ONLY to guns isn’t it? The obvious hypocrisy in this statement is apparent when other potentially lifesaving actions are considered.

Second your point about relentless press coverage is worthy of note. Shortly after the Sandy Hook shooting I heard several interviews with an expert on causes of these mass shootings. He said the hysteria, wall to wall press coverage, the investigation of the shooter’s background, life, and thoughts to the nth degree help to create these monsters. He noted that they are without exception “losers” who wish to leave a legacy, even if they are not alive to enjoy it. While we do support our free press, clearly the coverage bears some responsibility in inspiring if not instructing these killers. Maybe along with gun restrictions we should suggest duct tape on the mouths of the talking heads :D. Well maybe not since the media is aligned with the gun control advocates…

LIsa
The press coverage is extremely suspect, especially in consideration of the media treatment (or non-treatment) of other events. My favorite political writer, Mark Steyn:
In America, all atrocities are not equal: Minutes after the Senate declined to support so-called gun control in the wake of the Newtown massacre, the president rushed ill-advisedly on air to give a whiny, petulant performance predicated on the proposition that one man’s mass infanticide should call into question the constitutional right to bear arms. Simultaneously, the media remain terrified that another man’s mass infanticide might lead you gullible rubes to question the constitutional right to abortion…
nationalreview.com/article/346146/%E2%80%98co-exist%E2%80%99-bombers
 
The Boston bombers didn’t have gun permits for the four guns.

They didn’t have permits for their pressure cookers, or permits for the pipe bombs.

They didn’t have permits for the hand grenades.

Not that you can get them, but they didn’t have permits for anything.

They fired at least 80 rounds in the shoot-out where the older brother was killed.

Meanwhile, we’re told that no one needs more than 10 bullets to defend oneself nowadays.

Violent criminals do not bother with permits.

They manage to get whatever they need.

The only people who will be impacted by all the background checks and the rest of the bureaucratic paperwork will be innocent private civilians who are only looking for some way to protect themselves against nutjobs who have no inhibitions about committing violence.
 
I agree. People need to understand that when everyone buys a gun, everyone is a good citizen. After a deadly shooting, facts come up. Mental illnesses, the person being isolated, with having tougher laws it would eliminate those individuals who cause these bad things.
That sounds like you are for banning guns for everyone. To be consistent you would also have to ban guns from the military, the police, politicians, secret service, and everyone else since we can never know with absolute 100% certainty that someone who was a perfect citizen their whole life might suddenly snap. But the problem with that is that the criminals would still have the guns since they have no problem with getting their guns by illegal means. It’s like how Chicago has the strictest gun control laws in the US but has the highest rate of gun/gang related murders.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top