Should religious wear the traditional habit?

  • Thread starter Thread starter lily628
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
šŸ‘ I echo all Augustine said and want to add another point. I have observed that all the women religious that went to secular dress also pursued secular activities and picked up some very damaging ā€œhabitsā€ - no longer serving with humility and obedience. Their numbers dwindled down to nearly extinct. Wearing of the habit adds strength to the religious life!
 
40.png
Blanka:
When I was around 18 years old I began exploring Eastern religion (having been raised Protestant and finding Western religion not very compelling). One day I happened to be riding on a city bus in Orlando and noticed a sister in full religious habit on the bus. We never spoke but as I observed her I had a very peaceful feeling and knew that the sister was someone who had dedicated her life to God. The image is still with me and that was in the 70ā€™s. That moment was a little part in the path that led me to the Catholic Church years later.:bowdown2:
Dear Blanka,

That was such a beautiful story and I am so touched that you shared it. It also scared me in a way because if I become a religious sister, that is a high reputation to live up to. I hope that with Godā€™s grace it will come naturally.

God bless you!
Lily628
 
Dear Lily628,
I pray that you will always know Godā€™s grace and that He will lead you to a vocation if that is what He desires for you. If you do enter religious life, remember that even if one day you happen not to be in the best frame of mind, the mere image of your habit might be enough to offer hope and the reassurance of Godā€™s love to someone who sees you.
I will pray that our beloved John Paul II will guide you in your spiritual life.
Blanka
:gopray:
 
I would agree with those who talked about knowing a sister by her habit. I would like to encourage my girls to religious life but have no way of knowing who is a sister and who is not.

God Bless,
Donna
 
Donna P:
I would agree with those who talked about knowing a sister by her habit. I would like to encourage my girls to religious life but have no way of knowing who is a sister and who is not.
Dear Donna P,

The Institute of Religious Life lists many communities of religious women in Minnesota. They all wear the habit and have met criteria for their orthodoxy to the Catholic faith.

I hope that at least one of them is in your area, or if not, perhaps you could schedule a day trip for you and your daughters to go visit one, if they allow that.

Some great links for religious life:
cmswr.org/index.htm
[ religiouslife.com](http://www.religiouslife.com/)
cloisters.tripod.com/

God bless,
Lily628
 
The question does not ask whether or not a nun should wear a habit, but whether or not a nun should wear a ā€œtraditional habit.ā€ I am surpised that so many people think that the only acceptable garment for a nun is the ā€œtraditional habit,ā€ regardless of where they work and in what environment they live.
 
40.png
serendipity:
The question does not ask whether or not a nun should wear a habit, but whether or not a nun should wear a ā€œtraditional habit.ā€ I am surpised that so many people think that the only acceptable garment for a nun is the ā€œtraditional habit,ā€ regardless of where they work and in what environment they live.
Hi Serendipity,

Perhaps my question was poorly worded, however I could not think of any other way to phrase it. Sisters who wear a pin or crucifix and ā€œstreet clothesā€ in the USA are considered wearing a ā€œhabitā€ in some orders. I did not want to include those types of ā€œhabitsā€ in the poll.

God bless,
Lily628
 
Hi Lily,

I voted no because I tend to be liberal in my religious views. I think it should be a choice of the convent community to wear the habit so if a community decided to do without the habit then I feel thatā€™s ok. I just got back from a ā€œcome and seeā€ retreat this weekend at a convent where the sisters are not required to wear the habit. They decided to drop the habit because of Vatican II; although it was facsinating to see that even after 35 years of it being a non-requirement to wear the habit there were still sisters present who still wore it for the same reasons stated above(in previous replys). So even in progressive convents thereā€™s still remnants of conservativism. I respect anyone who chooses to be part of a conservative faith community. I would also like to visit a conservative convent in the near future although Iā€™m not certain of which one yet. The come and see weekend I attended was with the Cenacle Sisters. Iā€™m also presently discerning Godā€™s call though Iā€™m not certain what that call is yet but I am certain that God wants me to do something with my life that at present Iā€™m not doing yet.:confused: :hmmm: I think itā€™s wonderful to give oneā€™s life completely to God, God bless you for being certain of that. My discernment with this will be going on for years to come and thats ok with me, this is something that doesnā€™t require an absolute decision on my part any time soon. Who knows, maybe fifteen or twenty years from now Iā€™ll find myself wearing a habit!šŸ™‚

God Bless,
Melanie
august0175@yahoo.com
 
Hi again Lily,

I was just reviewing what I just posted and reviewing also what you had written previously. I stated above that you were certain but youā€™re still discerning too. I got my wires crossed - :o sorry.

Melanie

P.S. I also didnā€™t realize I could edit my messages!(Iā€™m new here soā€¦:D:rolleyes:)
 
40.png
melaniem75:
So even in progressive convents thereā€™s still remnants of conservativism.
/QUOTE]

Why is wearing a traditional habit conservative?
 
Hi Buffalo,

I was told that wearing a traditional habit is conservative but I donā€™t have a specific reason why. Maybe you could help me out if you have something in mind that youā€™d like to point out to me about conservativism in general as it pertains to religious life. Iā€™m still learning and at this point still gathering as much info as possible, Iā€™ve only been to one convent so I canā€™t say much on this subject:hmmm: .

Thanks,
Melanie:thumbsup:

General Question: Why is the word religious in my above message hi-lited in red and bolded? I didnā€™t do that intentionally.:confused: Is that because the word religious appears in the subject heading? (I should spend more time by the water cooler.šŸ˜‰ )
 
40.png
melaniem75:
Hi Buffalo,

I was told that wearing a traditional habit is conservative but I donā€™t have a specific reason why. Maybe you could help me out if you have something in mind that youā€™d like to point out to me about conservativism in general as it pertains to religious life. Iā€™m still learning and at this point still gathering as much info as possible, Iā€™ve only been to one convent so I canā€™t say much on this subject:hmmm: .

Thanks,
Melanie:thumbsup:
I do not really know. But would it be fair to conclude that women religious who donā€™t wear the habit are all liberal?

To me they are either orthodox or heterodox. It seems to me that when someone uses the terms progressive, liberal or conservative one should look out for the real agenda and mission of the order. Using the word conservative implies old-fashioned and who would want to be old fashioned in todayā€™s world?
 
Hi Buffalo,

As my little brother used to say when he was in high school: ā€œTrue That!ā€. Thanks for pointing that out to me, Iā€™ll be more careful in the future.

Melanie:D
 
Dear Melanie,
I just wanted to write and thank you for your kindness in what you said, even though we may disagree. I want to give you a better answer as to why I believe the way I do about the importance of the religious habit. I hope to do that this weekend when I have more time.

Dear Catholic29,
Thank you for providing that link!

May God bless both of you in your vocational discernment.
Lily628
 
The other answers as to why one chose ā€œyesā€ are more profound than mine. I simply wish that the religious would wear traditional garb 1) for lay members of the Church to be able to identify them as members of the religious orders 2) in order to feel the respect and in some sense, distance, between their spiritual journey and mine. I look to those who have taken vows for inspiration and the fact that they dress differently symbolically represents their renunciation of material concerns 3) psychologically, wearing the same clothing binds the members of one religious order to eachother in the same way that school uniforms, scout uniforms or sports uniforms creates a togetherness mentality. It reminds them daily that they are all ā€œon the same teamā€ in the mission to serve Christ.
 
Isnā€™t not wearing one kind of like not wearing a Wedding Band?
 
I am not Catholic, but whenever I see any of the religious of your Church in traditional habits I think of them as missionaries bearing witness of their faith without saying a word.
 
Hello Melanie,
40.png
melaniem75:
I voted no because I tend to be liberal in my religious views . . . . So even in progressive convents thereā€™s still remnants of conservativism. I respect anyone who chooses to be part of a conservative faith community. I would also like to visit a conservative convent in the near future although Iā€™m not certain of which one yet.
As buffalo pointed out, in the Catholic Church there are only two ways to be: orthodox (in keeping with Church teaching and obedient to the Magisterium) or heterodox (differing in belief and/or action in one or more ways from the Magisterium).

As long as they do not disagree with the teachings of the Church, the political views of a community or its members are irrelevant to whether a community is orthodox or heterodox. The fact that some have tried to apply political terms (liberal, conservative, etc) to the Church is an indication that either (1) they are unaware of the connotations or (2) they have decided to take doctrinal matters into their own hands and have the mistaken belief that we are free to pick and choose which Catholic teachings to accept and which to reject. Here is a good article about this phenomenon:The Spectrum Virus
40.png
melaniem75:
I think itā€™s wonderful to give oneā€™s life completely to God, God bless you for being certain of that . . . . I was just reviewing what I just posted and reviewing also what you had written previously. I stated above that you were certain but youā€™re still discerning too. I got my wires crossed - sorry.
Donā€™t worry about it. You were correct in the first place. Perhaps you read this in my profile šŸ™‚ There has been a passing of time, and recently I decided for sure that this is what I want to do in the future (before I was seriously considering). God has given me many graces to confirm this in my life, and I would be lying to myself to deny it at this point.
40.png
melaniem75:
My discernment with this will be going on for years to come and thats ok with me, this is something that doesnā€™t require an absolute decision on my part any time soon. Who knows, maybe fifteen or twenty years from now Iā€™ll find myself wearing a habit!
I am glad that you are taking the time to investigate communities and discern your calling. This part of the process is vital to your search. Do not worry that you are not certain yet ā€“ continue praying and ask God for confirmations of your calling. He will be faithful to show you what you need to know in HIS timing (not necessarily your timing). (And I do hope you decide to wear a habit ;)).
40.png
melaniem75:
General Question: Why is the word religious in my above message hi-lited in red and bolded? I didnā€™t do that intentionally. Is that because the word religious appears in the subject heading? (I should spend more time by the water cooler.)
My best guess is that if you searched the forums for the word ā€œreligiousā€, that term was highlighted to show you where it appeared on the page.

I will address the religious habit in a separate post.

God bless you & I will keep your discernment process in my prayers.
Lily628
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top